Fr ...u.htm-Dateien: IN WP5.1 mit FORMHTM.WPM die temporren Marken fr Textauszeichnungen in HTML-Tags umwandeln!!! Fr REE und CSX FORMTXT.WPM verwenden oder ASCII 013/014 durch o.. ERSETZEN! #<...># = BOLD %<...>% = ITALICS \<...>\ = REDLINE Kathavatthu Based on the edition by Arnold C. Taylor: Kathvatthu, Vols. I, II, London : Pali Text Society 1894 (Reprinted 1897, 1979) Input by the Dhammakaya Foundation, Thailand, 1989-1996 [GRETIL-Version vom 12.2.2015] NOTICE This file is (C) Copyright the Pali Text Society and the Dhammakaya Foundation, 2015. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. These files are provided by courtesy of the Pali Text Society for scholarly purposes only. In principle they represent a digital edition (without revision or correction) of the printed editions of the complete set of Pali canonical texts published by the PTS. While they have been subject to a process of checking, it should not be assumed that there is no divergence from the printed editions and it is strongly recommended that they are checked against the printed editions before quoting. PLAIN TEXT VERSION (In order to fascilitate word search, all annotations have been removed, and the line breaks of the printed edition have been converted into floating text.) #<...># = BOLD %<...>% = ITALICS \<...>\ = REDLINE ___________________________________________________________________ THIS TEXT FILE IS FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY! COPYRIGHT AND TERMS OF USAGE AS FOR SOURCE FILE. Text converted to Ronald E. Emmerick's encoding for WordPerfect 5.1 DOS and related utility programmes BHELA, CARAKA etc. (DOS versions): description character =ASCII long a 195 long A 249 long i 197 long I 253 long u 198 long U 244 vocalic r 173 vocalic R 227 long vocalic r 204 vocalic l 202 long vocalic l 203 velar n 199 velar N 167 palatal n 164 palatal N 165 retroflex t 194 retroflex T 232 retroflex d 172 retroflex D 214 retroflex n 239 retroflex N 215 palatal s 211 palatal S 193 retroflex s 171 retroflex S 229 anusvara 230 capital anusvara 245 visarga 247 capital visarga 234 Other characters of the REE encoding table are not included. Unless indicated otherwise, accents have been dropped in order to facilitate word search. For a comprehensive list of REE and other GRETIL encodings and formats see: http://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/gretdiac.pdf and http://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil/gretdias.pdf For further information see: http://gretil.sub.uni-goettingen.de/gretil.htm ___________________________________________________________________ Kathvatthu Vols. I & II #<[page 001]># %< 1>% Kathvatthu. NAMO TASSA BHAGAVATO ARAHATO SAMMSAMBUDDHASSA. I. 1. 1. Puggalo upalabbati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha: haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo uppalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. Anuloma-pacaka. 2. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. #<[page 002]># %<2 KATHVATTHU.>% Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma: haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. Paikamma-catukkam. 3. Tva ce pana maasi Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' tena tava tattha h' etya paiya h' eva paijnanta h' eva niggahetabbe; atha ta niggahma, suniggahto ca hoti. Haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. #<[page 003]># %< KATHVATTHU. 3>% No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' idan te micch. Niggaha-catukka. 4. Ese ce dunniggahte, h' evameva tattha dakkha; Vattabbe kho Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena," no ca vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca maya tay tattha h' etya patiya h' eva {paijnant} h' eva niggahetabb; atha ma niggahsi dunniggaht ca homa. Haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' idan te micch. Upanayana-catukka. #<[page 004]># %<4 KATHVATTHU.>% 5. Na h' eva niggahetabbe, tena hi ya niggahsi -Haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo {upalabbhati} saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' idan te micch -- tena hi ye kate niggahe se niggahe dukkate, sukate paikamme, sukat paipdan ti. Niggamana-catukka. Pahamo Niggaho. Pahamasaccikaho. 6. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha: haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' #<[page 005]># %< KATHVATTHU. 5>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. Paccanka-pacaka. 7. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma: haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. Paikamma-catukka. #<[page 006]># %<6 KATHVATTHU.>% 8. Tva ce pana maasi Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' tena tava tattha h' etya paiya h' eva paijnanta h' eva niggahetabbe; atha ta niggahma suniggahto ca hoti. Haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' idan te micch. Niggaha-catukka. 9. Ese ce dunniggahte, h' evameva tattha dakkha; Vattabbe kho Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena," no ca vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca maya tay tattha h' etya paiya h' eva paijnant h' eva niggahetabb; atha ma niggahsi dunniggaht ca homa. Haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' #<[page 007]># %< KATHVATTHU. 7>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' idan te micch. Upanayana-catukka. 10. Na h' eva niggahetabbe, tena hi ya niggahsi -Haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamatthenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `yo saccikaho paramaho tato so puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti."' idan te micch -- tena hi ye kate niggahe se niggahe dukkate, sukate paikamme, sukat paipdan ti. Niggamana-catukka. Dutiyo Niggaho. #<[page 008]># %<8 KATHVATTHU.>% 11. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,' no ca vattabbe `sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe sabbattha puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch --pe-- Tatiyo Niggaho 12. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Sabbad puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaham; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbad puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbad puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Sabbad puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbad puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' #<[page 009]># %< KATHVATTHU. 9>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ micch. Catuho Niggaho. 13. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? manta. Sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' evam vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. no ce pana vattabbe "Sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe sabbesu puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. Pacamo Niggaho. 14. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Sabbattha puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbattha puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbattha puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. #<[page 010]># %<10 KATHVATTHU.>% No ce pana vattabbe "Sabbattha puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbattha puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch --pe-- Chaho Niggaho. 15. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Sabbad puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbad puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,' no ca vattabbe `sabbad puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Sabbad puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti."' Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,' no ca vattabbe `sabbad puggalo n' upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti,}"' micch. Sattamo Niggaho. 16. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Sabbesu puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 011]># %< KATHVATTHU. 11>% jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbesu puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti."' Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbesu puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Sabbesu puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti," no ca vata re vattabbe Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `sabbesu puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,"' micch. Ahako Niggaho. 17. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Aa rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha: haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' #<[page 012]># %<12 KATHVATTHU.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch --pe-- 18.=17. reading vedan for rpa. 19.=17. reading sa for rpa. 20.=17. reading sakhr for rpa. 21.=17. reading via for rpa. 22.=17. reading cakkhyatana for rpa. 23.=17. reading sotyatana for rpa. 24.=17. reading ghnyatana for rpa. 25.=17. reading jivhyatana for rpa. 26.=17. reading kyyatana for rpa. 27.=17. reading rpyatana for rpa. 28.=17. reading saddyatana for rpa. 29.=17. reading gandhyatana for rpa. 30.=17. reading rasyatana for rpa. 31.=17. reading phohabbyatana for rpa. 32.=17. reading manyatana for rpa. 33.=17. reading dhammyatana for rpa. 34.=17. reading cakkhudhtu for rpa. 35.=17. reading sotadhtu for rpa. 36.=17. reading ghnadhtu for rpa. 37.=17. reading jivhdhtu for rpa. 38.=17. reading kyadhtu for rpa. 39.=17. reading rpadhtu for rpa. 40.=17. reading saddadhtu for rpa. 41.=17. reading gandhadhtu for rpa. 42.=17. reading rasadhtu for rpa. 43.=17. reading phohabbadhtu for rpa. 44.=17. reading cakkhuviadhtu for rpa. 45.=17. reading sotaviadhtu for rpa. 46.=17. reading ghnaviadhtu for rpa. 47.=17. reading jivhviadhtu for rpa. 48.=17. reading kyaviadhtu for rpa. 49.=17. reading manodhtu for rpa. 50.=17. reading manoviadhtu for rpa. 51.=17. reading dhammadhtu for rpa. #<[page 013]># %< KATHVATTHU. 13>% 52.=17. reading cakkhundriya for rpa. 53.=17. reading sotindriya for rpa. 54.=17. reading ghnindriya for rpa. 55.=17. reading jivhindriya for rpa. 56.=17. reading kyindriya for rpa. 57.=17. reading manindriya for rpa. 58.=17. reading ittindriya for rpa. 59.=17. reading purisindriya for rpa. 60.=17. reading jvitindriya for rpa. 61.=17. reading sukhindriya for rpa. 62.=17. reading dukkhindriya for rpa. 63.=17. reading somanassindriya for rpa. 64.=17. reading domanassindriya for rpa. 65.=17. reading upekkhindriya for rpa. 66.=17. reading saddhindriya for rpa. 67.=17. reading viriyindriya for rpa. 68.=17. reading satindriya for rpa. 69.=17. reading samdhindriya for rpa. 70.=17. reading paindriya for rpa. 71.=17. reading {anataassmtindriya} for rpa. 72.=17. reading aindriya for rpa. 73.=17. reading atvindriya for rpa. 74. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca uppalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. a rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma: haci vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi Puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `vutta Bhagavat -Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. #<[page 014]># %<14 KATHVATTHU.>% No ce pana vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe Vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi puggalo attathitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `vutta Bhagavat -Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti,' no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. 75.74. reading vedan for rpa. 76.74. reading sa for rpa. 77.74. reading sakhr for rpa. 78.74. reading via for rpa. 79.74. reading cakkhyatana for rpa --pe--. 12974. reading atvindriya for rpa. Suddhika-sasandan. 130. Rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan ti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti?} mant. Aa rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. #<[page 015]># %< KATHVATTHU. 15>% No ce pana vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe Rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, puggalo upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahena,} rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. 131.=130. reading sa for vedan. 132.=130. reading sakhr for vedan. 133.=130. reading via for vedan. 134. Vedan upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sa ca upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhanti -pe -- via ca upalabbhati --pe-- rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena -- pe; Sa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sakhr ca upalabbhanti --pe-- via ca upalabbhati --pe-rpa ca upalabbhati --pe-- vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena -- pe; Sakhr upalabbhanti saccikahaparamahena, via ca upalabbhati --pe-- rpa ca upalabbhati --pe-vedan ca upalabbhati -- pe;-- sa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena -- pe; Via upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati --pe-- vedan ca upalabbhati --pe-- sa ca upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhanti saccikahaparamahena, aa via ae sakhr ti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, via ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Aa via ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 016]># %<16 KATHVATTHU.>% jnhi niggaha; haci via upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sakhr ca upalabbhanti saccikahaparamahena, aa via ae sakhra, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena via ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa via ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe {kho} `via upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhanti saccikahaparamahena, aa viaa ae sakhr, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, via ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa via ao puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Aa via ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe" vinna upalabbhati --pe-sakhr ca upalabbhanti saccikahaparamahena, aa via ae sakhr, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, via ca upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti.}" Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `viviaa upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhanti saccikahaparamahena, aa via ae sakhr, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, via ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa via {ao} puggalo ti,"' micch. 135. Cakkhyatana upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, Sotyatana ca upalabbhati --pe--, dhammyatana ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-sotyatana upalabbhati --pe-- dhammyatana upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, cakkhyatana ca upalabbhati --pe-- manyatana ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe--, Cakkhudhtu upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sotadhtu ca upalabbhati --pe-- dhammadhtu ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-- sotadhtu upalabbhati --pe-- dhammadhtu upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, cakkhudhtu ca upalabbhati --pe-- manoviadhtu ca upalabbhati {sacciahaparamahena} -pe --, #<[page 017]># %< KATHVATTHU. 17>% Cakkhudriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena sotineriya ca upalabbhati --pe-- atvindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-- sotindriya upalabbhati --pe-- atvindriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, cakkhundriya ca upalabbhati --pe-aindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparahena, aa atvindriya aa aindriya ti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahena,} atvindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci atvindriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa atvindriya aa aindriya, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, atvindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `atvindriya upalabbhati --pe-- saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `anna atvindriya ao puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti" no ca vata re vattabbe "Anntvindriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aindriya ca upalabbhati, aa atvindriya aa aindriya, puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, atvindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `atvindriya upalabbhati --pe-- saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti,"' micch. 136. Rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan ti? mant. 3 #<[page 018]># %<18 KATHVATTHU.>% Vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti?} mant. Aa rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma: haci rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, vutta {Bhagavat} -- Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe Aa rpa ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Aa rpa ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe Rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa a vedan, vutta Bhagavat -Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, aa rpa {a} vedan, vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `Aa rpa ao puggalo ti,"' micch. 137. Rpa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sa ca upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhati -pe -- via ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena -pe --. Vedan upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, {sa} ca upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhati --pe-via ca upalabbhati --pe-- rpa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe--. Sa upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sakhr ca upalabbhanti #<[page 019]># %< KATHVATTHU. 19>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- via ca upalabbhati --pe-rpa ca upalabbhati --pe-- vedan ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe--. Sakhr upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, via ca upalabbhati --pe-- rpa ca upalabbhati --pe-vedan ca upalabbhati --pe-- sa ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe--. Via upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, rpa ca upalabbhati --pe-- vedan ca upalabbhati --pe-- sa ca upalabbhati --pe-- sakhr ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe--. Cakkhyatana upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sotyatana ca upalabbhati --pe-- dhammyatana ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-- sotyatana upalabbhati --pe-- dhammyatana upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, cakkhyatana ca upalabbhati --pe-manyatana ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena -pe --. Cakkhudhtu upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sotadhtu ca upalabbhati --pe-- dhammadhtu ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-- sotadht upalabbhati -- pe -- dhammadhtu upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, cakkhudhtu ca upalabbhati --pe-- manoviadhtu ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe--. Cakkhundriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, sotindriya ca upalabbhati --pe-- aatvindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-- sotindriya upalabbhati --pe-- atvindriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, cakkhundriya ca upalabbhati --pe-aindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena aa atvindriya aa aindriyan ti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, atvindriya ca upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 020]># %<20 KATHVATTHU.>% jnhi niggaha; haci atvindriya upalabbhati --pe-- aa aindriya, vutta Bhagavat --pe-saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `atvindriya upalabbhati --pe-- aa aindriya, vutta Bhagavat --pe-- saccikahaparamahena, no ca vattabbe `aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Atvindriya upalabbhati --pe-- aa aindriya, vutta Bhagavat --pe-- saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `atvindriya upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena --pe-- aa {aindriya,} vutta bhagavat --pe-- saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `aa atvindriya ao puggalo ti,"' micch. Opamma-sasandana. 138. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Rpa puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe Rpa puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `rpa puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe Rpa puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `rpa puggalo ti,"' micch. 139. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Rpasmi puggalo --pe-- aatra rp puggalo --pe-puggalasmi rpan ti? #<[page 021]># %< KATHVATTHU. 21>% Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalasmi rpan ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi rpan ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Puggalasmi rpan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi rpan ti,"' micch. 140. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Vedan puggalo --pe-- vedanya puggalo --pe-- aatra vedanya puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi vedan --pe-- Sa puggalo --pe-- saya puggalo --pe-- aatra saya puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi sa --pe-- Sakhr puggalo --pe-- sakhresu puggalo --pe-aatra sakhrehi puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi sakhr --pe-- Via puggalo --pe-- viasmi puggalo --pe-aatra vi puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalasmi vian ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi vian ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Puggalasmi vian ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi vian ti,"' micch. 141. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Cakkhyatana puggalo --pe-- cakkhyatanasmi puggalo --pe-- aatra cakkhyatan puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi cakkhyatana --pe-- #<[page 022]># %<22 KATHVATTHU.>% Atvindriya puggalo --pe-- atvindriyasmi puggalo --pe-- aatra atvindriy puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi atvindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha; haci puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalasmi atvindriyan ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe puggalasmi atvindriyan ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Puggalasmi atvindriyan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena," no ca vattabbe puggalasmi atvindriyan ti," micch. 142. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Rpa puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma; haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe Rpa puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `rpa puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe Rpa puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena," no ca vattabbe `r pa puggalo ti,"' micch. 143. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Rpasmi puggalo --pe-- aatra rp puggalo --pe-puggalasmi rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma; haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalasmi rpan ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi rpan ti,"' micch. #<[page 023]># %< KATHVATTHU. 23>% NO ce pana vattabbe "Puggalasmi rpan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi rpan ti,"' micch. 144. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Vedan puggalo --pe-- vedanya puggalo --pe-- aatra vedanya puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi vedan --pe-- Sa puggalo --pe-- saya puggalo --pe-- aatra saya puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi {sa} --pe-- Sakhr puggalo --pe-- sakhresu puggalo --pe-aatra sakhrehi puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi sakhr -- pe;-- Via puggalo --pe-- viasmi puggalo --pe-aatra vi puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma; {haci} puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalasmi vian ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe puggalasmi vian ti," micch. No ce pana vattabbe puggalasmi vian ti, no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe puggalasmi vian ti," micch. 145. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Cakkhyatana puggalo --pe-- cakkhyatanasmi puggalo --pe-- aatra cakkhyatan puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi cakkhyatana --pe-- Atvindriya puggalo --pe-- atvindriyasmi puggalo --pe-- aatra atvindriy puggalo --pe-- puggalasmi atvindran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jjnhi paikamma; haci puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalasmi atvindriyan ti. #<[page 024]># %<24 KATHVATTHU.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi atvindriyan ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Puggalasmi atvindriyan ti," no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahena,' no ca vattabbe `puggalasmi atvindriyan ti,"' micch. Catukkanaya -- sasandana. 146. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Puggalo sappaccayo --pe-- puggalo appaccayo, puggalo sakhato puggalo asakhato, puggalo sassato, puggalo asassato, puggalo sanimitto puggalo animitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 147. Puggalo n' upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno ti"? mant. Puggalo sappaccayo --pe-- puggalo appaccayo, puggalo sakhato puggalo asakhato, puggalo sassato, puggalo asassato, puggalo sanimitto puggalo animitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lakkhayuttikath. 148. Puggalo upalabbhati, upalabbhati puggalo ti? Puggalo upalabbhati, upalabbhati kehici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti. Puggalo kehici upalabbhati, kehici na upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 149. Puggalo saccikaho saccikaho puggalo ti? Puggalo saccikaho, saccikaho kehici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti. #<[page 025]># %< KATHVATTHU. 25>% Puggalo kehici saccikaho, kehici na saccikaho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 150. Puggalo vijjamno vijjamno puggalo ti? Puggalo vijjamno, vijjamno kehici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti? Puggalo kehici vijjamno, kehici na vijjamno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 151. Puggalo savijjamno savijjamno puggalo ti? Puggalo savijjamno, savijjamno kehici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti. Puggalo kehici savijjamno, kehici na savijjamno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 152. Puggalo atthi atthi puggalo ti? Puggalo atthi, atthi kehici puggalo, kehici na puggalo ti. Puggalo kehici atthi, kehici n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 153. Puggalo atthi, atthi na sabbo puggalo ti? mant. Puggalo n' atthi, n' atthi na sabbo puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vacanasodhana. 154. Rpadhtuy rp puggalo ti? mant. Kmadhtuy km puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpadhtuy rpino satt ti? mant. Kmadhtuy kmino satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpadhtuy arp puggalo ti? mant. #<[page 026]># %<26 KATHVATTHU.>% Kmadhtuy km puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpadhtuy arpino satt ti? mant. Kmadhtuyy kmino satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 155. Rpadhtuy rp puggalo arpadhtuy arp puggalo, atthi ca koci rpadhtuy cuto {arpadhtum} upapajjatti? mant. Rp puggalo upacchinno arp puggalo jto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpadhtuy rpino satt, {arpadhtuy} arpino satt, atthi ca koci {rpadhtuy} cuto arpadhtu upapajjatti? mant. Rp satto upacchinno arp satto jto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 156. Kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv, esese {ekahe} same samabhge tajjte ti? mant. Puggalo ti v jvo ti v jvo ti v puggalo ti v puggala appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? mant. Ao kyo ao puggalo ti? mant. Aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha: haci kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kayo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, puggalo ti v jvo ti v jvo ti v puggalo ti v puggala appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, #<[page 027]># %< KATHVATTHU. 27>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ao kyo ao puggalo, tena vata re vattabbe "Aa jva aa sarran ti." Ya {tattha} vadesi "Vattabbe kho `kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, puggalo ti v jvo ti v jvo ti v puggalo ti v puggala appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, ao kyo ao puggalo,' no ca vattabbe `aa jva aa sarran ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Aa jva aa sarran ti," no ca vata re vattabbe Kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, puggalo ti v jvo ti v jvo ti v puggalo ti v puggala appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, ao kyo ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, puggalo ti v jvo ti v jvo ti v puggalo ti v puggala appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, ao kyo ao puggalo,' no c vattabbe `aa jva aa {sarran} ti,"' micch. 157. Kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Atthi puggalo atthitya paipanno ti"? mant. Ao kyo ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi paikamma: haci kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, vutta Bhagavat "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno," tena vata re vattabbe "Ao kyo ao puggalo ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, vutta Bhagavat -- #<[page 028]># %<28 KATHVATTHU.>% "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno, no ca vattabbe `ao kyo ao puggalo ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Ao kyo ao puggalo ti," no ca vata re vattabbe Kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, vutta Bhagavat "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `kyo ti v sarran ti v sarran ti v kyo ti v kya appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte, vutta Bhagavat -"Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno' no ca vattabbe `ao kyo ao puggalo ti,"' micch. Paattnuyogo. 158. Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. So puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. Ao puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe. Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. So ca ao ca sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. N' eva so sandhvati na ao sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? #<[page 029]># %< KATHVATTHU. 29>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. So puggalo sandhvati, ao puggalo sandhvati, so ca ao ca sandhvati, n' eva so sandhvati na ao sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 159. Na vattabba "Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sa sattakkhattuparama sandhvitvna puggalo Dukkhassantakaro hoti sabbasaojanakkhy ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti. Na vattabba "Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Anamataggya Bhikkhave sasro, pubb koi na payati avijjnvarana sattna {tahsaojanna} sandhvata sasaratan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi puggalo sadhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti. 160. Puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. Atthi koci manusso hutv devo hotti? mant. Sv' eva manusso so devo ti? #<[page 030]># %<30 KATHVATTHU.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sv' eva manusso so devo ti? mant. Manusso hutv devo hoti, devo hutv manusso hoti manussabhto, ao devo ao manussabhto, sv' evya sandhvatti, micch --pe-- Sace hi sandhvati sv' eva puggalo ito cuto para loka anao, h' eva maraa na hehiti ptipto n' upalabbhati, kamma atthi, kammavipko atthi, katna kammna vipko atthi, kusalkusale vipaccamne sv' evya sandhvatti, micch. 161. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. Atthi koci manusso hutv yakkho hoti, peto hoti, nerayiko hoti, tiracchnagato hoti, oho hoti, goo hoti, {gadrabho} hoti skaro hoti, mahiso hotti? Amant. Sv' eva manusso so mahiso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sv' eva manusso so mahiso ti? mant. Manusso hutv mahiso hoti, mahiso hutv manusso hoti manussabhto, ao mahiso ao manussabhto, sv' evya sandhvatti, micch --pe-- Sace hi sandhvati sv' eva puggalo ito cuto para loka anao, h' eva maraa na hehiti ptipto n' upalabbhati, kamma atthi, kammavipko atthi, katna kammna vipko atthi, kusalkusale vipaccamne sv' evya sandhvatti, micch. 162. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? #<[page 031]># %< KATHVATTHU. 31>% mant. Atthi koci Khattiyo hutv Brhmao hotti? mant. Sv' eva Khattiyo so Brhmao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci Khattiyo hutv Vesso hoti, Suddo hotti? mant. Sv' eva Khattiyo so Suddo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci Brhmao hutv Vesso hoti Suddo hoti Khattiyo hotti? mant. Sv' eva Brhmao so Khattiyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci Vesso hutv Suddo hoti Khattiyo hoti Brhmao hotti? mant. Sv' eva Vesso so Brhmao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci Suddo hutv Khattiyo hoti Brhmao hoti Vesso hotti? mant. Sv' eva Suddo so Vesso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 163. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. Hatthacchinno hatthacchinno va hoti, pdacchinno pdacchinno va hoti, hatthapdacchinno hatthapdacchinno va hoti, kaacchinno nsacchinno kaansacchinno, agulicchinno aacchinno kaaracchinno, kuihatthako phaahatthako kuhiyo gandhiyo kilsiyo sosiyo apamriyo oho goo gadrabho skaro mahiso mahiso va hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 164. Na vattabba "Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti"? mant. #<[page 032]># %<32 KATHVATTHU.>% Nanu sotpanno puggalo manussalok cuto devaloka upapanno tattha pi sotpanno va hotti? mant. Haci sotpanno puggalo manussalok cuto devalika upapanno tattha pi sotpanno va hoti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti." Sotpanno puggalo manussalok cuto devaloka upapanno tattha pi sotpanno va hotti katv tena ca kraena sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok para loka parasm lok ima lokan ti? mant. Sotpanno puggalo manussalok cuto devaloka upapanno tattha pi manusso hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 165. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati --pe-- ima lokan ti? mant. nao avigato sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anao avigato sandhvatti? mant. Hatthacchinno hatthacchinno va hoti mahiso va hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 166. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati --pe-- ima lokan ti? mant. Sarpo sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sarpo sandhvatti? mant. Ta jva ta sarran ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- Savedano --pe-- sasao --pe-- sasakhro --pe-- savio sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savio sandhvatti? #<[page 033]># %< KATHVATTHU. 33>% mant. Ta jva ta sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 167. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok --pe-- ima lokan ti? mant. Arpo sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpo sandhvatti? mant. Aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avedano --pe-- asao --pe-- asakhro --pe-- avio sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avio sandhvatti? mant. Aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 168. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati asm lok --pe-- ima lokan ti? mant. Rpa sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa sandhvatti? mant. Ta jva ta sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Via sandhvatti? mant. Ta jva ta sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 169. Sv' eva puggalo sandhvati --pe-- ima lokan ti? mant. Rpa na sandhvatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa na sandhvatti? mant. 4 #<[page 034]># %<34 KATHVATTHU.>% Aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via na sandhvatti? na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- {Via} na sandhvatti? mant. Aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 170. Khandhesu bhijjamnesu so ce bhijjati puggalo Ucched bhavati dihi y Buddhena vivajjit. Khandhesu bhijjamnesu no ce bhijjati pubbalo Puggalo sassato hoti nibbnena samasamo ti. 171. Rpa updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Rpa anicca sakhata paiccasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma virgadhamma nirodhadhamma viparimadhamman ti? mant. Puggalo pi anicco sakhato paiccasamuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo virgadhammo nirodhadhammo viparimadhammo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 172. Vedana updya --pe-- saa updya --pe-- sakhre updya --pe-- via updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Via anicca --pe-- viparimadhamman ti? mant. Puggalo pi anicco --pe-- viparimadhammo ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 173. Rpa updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Nla rpa updya nlakassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 035]># %< KATHVATTHU. 35>% Pta rpa updya, Lohitam rpa updya, Odta rpa updya, Sanidassana rpa updya, Anidassana rpa updya, Sappaigha rpa updya, Appaigha rpa updya appaighassa pugalassa paatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 174. Vedana updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Kusala vedana updya kusalassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusala vedana updya kusalassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Kusal vedan saphal savipk ihaphal kantaphal manuaphal asecanakaphal sukhudray sukhavipk ti? mant. Kusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipko ihiphalo kantaphalo manuaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhudrayo sukhavipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 175. Vedana updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Akusala vedana updya akusalassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusala vedana updya akusalassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Akusal vedan saphal savipk anihaphal akantaphal amanuaphal secanakaphal dukkhudray dukkhavipk ti? #<[page 036]># %<36 KATHVATTHU.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ mant. Akusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipko anihaphalo akantaphalo amanuaphalo secanakaphalo dukkhudrayo {dukkhavipko} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 176. Vedana updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Abykata vedana updya abykatassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Abykata vedana updya abykattassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Abykat vedan anicc sakhat paiccasamuppann khayadhamm vayadhamm virgadhammanirodhadhamm viparimadhamm ti? mant. Abykato pi puggalo anicco sakhato --pe-- viparimadhammo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 177. Saa updya, sakhre updya, via updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Kusala via updya kusalassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Kusala via saphala savipka ihaphala, kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhudraya sukhavipkan ti? mant. Kusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipko ihaphalo kantaphalo manuaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhudrayo sukhavipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 178. Via updya puggalassa paattti? mant. #<[page 037]># %< KATHVATTHU. 37>% Akusala via updya akusalassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusala via updya akusalassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Akusala via saphala savipka anihaphala akantaphala amanuaphala secanakaphala dukkhudraya dukkhavipkan ti? mant. Akusalo pi puggalo saphalo savipko anihaphalo akantaphalo amanuaphalo secanakaphalo dukkhudrayo {dukkhavipko} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 179. Via updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Abykata via updya abykatassa puggalassa paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Abykata via updya abykatassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Abykata via anicca sakhata paiccasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma virgadhammanirodhadhamma viparimadhamman ti? mant. Abykato pi puggalo anicco sakhato --pe-- viparimadhammo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 180. Cakkhu updya cakkhum puggalo ti vattabbo ti? mant. Cakkhumhi niruddhe cakkhum puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sota updya ghna updya jivha updya #<[page 038]># %<38 KATHVATTHU.>% Kya updya mana updya manav puggalo ti vattabbo ti? mant. Manamhi niruddhe manav puggalo niruddho ti vattabho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 181. Micchdihi updya micchdihiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti? mant. Micchdihiy niruddhya micchdihiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Micchsakappa updya, Micchvca updya, Micchkammanta updya, Micch-jva updya, Micchvyma updya, Micchsati updya, Micchsamdhi updya micchsamdhiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti? mant. Micchsamdhimhi niruddhe micchsamdhiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 182. Sammdihim updya sammdihiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti? mant. Sammdihiy niruddhya {sammdihiyo} puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsakappa updya, Sammvca updya, {Sammkammanta} updya, Samm-jva updya, Sammvyma updya, Sammsati updya, Sammsamdhi updya sammsamdhiyo puggalo ti vattabbo ti? mant. #<[page 039]># %< KATHVATTHU. 39>% Sammsamdhimhi niruddhe sammsamdhiyo puggalo niruddho ti vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 183. Rpa updya vedana updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Dvinna khandna updya dvinna puggalna paattti ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Rpa updya, vedana updya, saa updya, sakhare updya, via updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Pacanna khandna updya pacanna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 184. Cakkhyatana updya, sotyatana updya puggalassa paatti? mant. Dvinna yatanna updya dvinna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhyatana updya, sotyatana updya --pe-- dhammyatana updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Dvdasanna yatanna updya dvdasanna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 185. Cakkhudhtu updya sotadhtu updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Dvinna dhtna updya dvinna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhudhtu updya {sotadhtu} updya --pe-- dhammadhtu updya puggalassa paattti? #<[page 040]># %<40 KATHVATTHU.>% mant. Ahrasanna dhtna updya ahrasanna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 186. Cakkhundriya updya sotindriya updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Dvinna indriyna updya dvinna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhundriya updya sotindriya updya --pe-- atvindriya updya puggalassa paattti? mant. Bvsatna indriyna updya bvsatna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 187. Ekavokrabhava updya ekassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Catuvokrabhava updya catunna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekavokrabhava updya ekassa puggalassa paattti? mant. Pacavokrabhava updya pacanna puggalna paattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 188. Ekavokrabhave eko va puggalo ti? mant. Catuvokrabhave cattro va puggal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekavokrabhave eko va puggalo ti? mant. Pacavokrabhave pac' eva puggal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 041]># %< KATHVATTHU. 41>% 189. Yath rukkha updya chyya paatti, evameva rpa updya puggalassa paattti, yath rukkha updya chyya paatti, rukkho pi anicco chy pi anicc, evameva rpa updya puggalassa paatti rpa anicca puggalo pi anicco ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yath rukkha updya chyya paatti ao rukkho a chy, evameva rupa updya puggalassa paattti, aa rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 190. Yath gma updya gmikassa paatti, eva eva rpa updya puggalassa paattti, yath gma updya gmikassa paatti, ao gmo ao gmiko, evameva rpa updya puggalassa paatti, aam rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 191. Yath raha updya rao paatti, evaeva {rpa} updya puggalassa paattti, yath rattha updya rao paatti, ao raho ao rj, evameva rpa updya puggalassa paatti, aam rpa ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 192. Yath na nigao negaiko, yassa nigao so negaiko, evameva na rpa rpav, yassa rpa so rpav ti, yath na nigao negaiko yassa nigao so negaiko, ao nigao ao negaiko, eva eva na rpa rpav yassa rpa so rpav, aa rpa ao rpav ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 193. Citte citte puggalassa paattti? mant. Citte citte puggalo jyati jiyyati miyyati cavati upajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 194. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba "So ti v ao ti v ti"? #<[page 042]># %<42 KATHVATTHU.>% mant Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba "Kumrako ti v kumrik ti v ti"? Vattabba. jnhi niggaha: haci dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba "So ti v ao ti v," tena vata re vattabbe "Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba kumrako ti v kumrikti v ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba so ti v ao ti v,' `dutiye citte uppanne vattabba kumrako ti v kumrik ti v ti,"' micch. Haci v pana dutiye citte uppanne vattabba "Kumrako ti v kumrik ti v," tena vata re vattabbe Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba so ti v ao ti v ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba so ti v ao ti v,' `dutiye citte uppanne vattabba kumrako ti v kumrik ti v ti,"' micch. 195. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba "So ti v ao ti v ti"? mant. Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba "Itthti v puriso ti v, gahaho ti v pabbajito ti v, devo ti v manusso ti v ti?" Vattabba. jnhi niggaha: haci dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba "So ti v ao ti v," tena vata re vattabbe Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba devo ti v manusso ti v ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba so ti v ao ti v,' `dutiye citte uppanne vattabba kumrako ti v kumrik ti v ti,"' micch. haci v pana dutiye citte uppanne vattabba Devo ti v manusso ti v ti," tena vata re vattabbe Dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba so ti v ao ti v ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho? dutiye citte uppanne na vattabba so ti v ao ti v,' `dutiye citte uppanne vattabba devo ti v manusso ti v ti,"' micch. 196. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. #<[page 043]># %< KATHVATTHU. 43>% Nanu yo passati ya passati yena passati, so passati ta passati tena passatti? mant. Haci yo passati ya passati yena passati, so passati ta passati tena passati, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu yo suti, yo ghyati, yo syati, yo phusati, yo vijnti, ya vijnti, yena vijnti, so vijnti, ta vijnti, tena vijntti? mant. Haci yo vijnti, ya vijnti, yena vijnti, so vijnti, ta vijnti, tena {vijntti,} tena vata re vattabbe, Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 197. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu yo na passati, ya na passati, yena na passati, so na passati, ta na passati, tena na passatti? mant. Haci yo na passati, ya na passati, yena na passati, so na passati, ta na passati, tena na passati, no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu yo na suti yo na ghyati yo na syati yo na phusati yo na vijnti, ya na vijnti, yena na vijnti so na vijnti, ta na vijnti, tena na vijntti? mant. Haci yo na vijnti, ya na vijnti, yena na vijnti, so na vijnti ta na vijnti tena na vijnti, no ca vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." #<[page 044]># %<44 KATHVATTHU.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ 198. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahent"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Passm' aha Bhikkhave dibbena cakkhun visuddhena atikkantamnusakena satte cavamne uppajjamne hne pate suvae dubbae sugate duggate yathkammpage satte pajnmti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti. 199. Vutta Bhagavat "Passm' aha {Bhikkhave} dibbena cakkhun visuddhena atikkantamnusakena satte cavamne uppajjamne hne pate suvae dubbae sugate duggate yathkammpage satte pajnmti" katv, ten' eva kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Bhagav dibbena cakkhun visuddhena atikkantamnusakena rpa passati puggala passatti, rpa passati, rpa puggalo, rpa cavati, rpa uppajjati, rpa yathkammpagan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Bhagav dibbena cakkhun visuddhena atikkantamnusakena rpa passati puggala passatti, puggala passati, puggalo rpa rpyatana rpadhtu nla ptaka lohitaka odta cakkhuvieyya cakkhusmi paihaati cakkhussa ptha gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Bhagav dibbena cakkhun visuddhena atikkantamnusakena rpa passati puggala passatti, ubho passati, ubho rpa rpyatana rpadhtu, ubho nl, ubho ptak, ubho lohitak, ubho odt, ubho cakkhuvieyy, ubho cakkhusmi paihaanti, #<[page 045]># %< KATHVATTHU. 45>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ubho cakkhussa ptha gacchanti, ubho cavanti, ubho uppajjanti, ubho yathkammpag ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. {Updpaattnuyogo.} 200. Kalyappakni kammni upalabbhantti? mant. Kalyappakna kammna katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 201. Kalyappakni kammni upalabbhantti kalyappakna kammna katt kret upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tassa katt kret upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni upalabbhanti kalyappakna kammna katt kret upalabbhatti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhatti, puggalassa katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni upalabbhanti kalyappakna kammna katt kret upalabbhatti? mant. Nibbna upalabbhatti, nibbnassa katt kret upalabbhatti? #<[page 046]># %<46 KATHVATTHU.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. Mahpathav upalabbhatti, mahpathaviy katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. Mahsamuddo upalabbhatti, mahsamuddassa katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabe --pe-- Kalyappakani kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. Sineru pabbatarj upalabbhatti, Sinerussa pabbatarao katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. po upalabbhatti, passa katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. Tejo upalabbhatti, tejassa katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. Vyo upalabbhatti vyassa katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni -- kret upalabbhatti? mant. Tiakahavanappatiyo uppalabbhanti, tiakahavanappatna katt kret upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- kret upalabbhatti? mant. A kalyappakni kammni ao kalyappakna kammna katt kret ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 047]># %< KATHVATTHU. 47>% 202. Kalyappakna kammna vipko upalabbhatti? mant. Kalyappakna kammna vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 203. Kalyappakna kammna vipko upalabbhatti, kalyappakna kammna vipkpaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakna kammna vipko --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhatti puggalassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakna kammna vipko upalabbhatti, kalyappakna kammna vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Nibbna upalabbhtti nibbnassa paisaved upalabbhtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakna kammna --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Mahpathav upalabbhatti, mahsamuddo upalabbhatti, Sineru pabbatarj upalabbhatti, po upalabbhatti, tejo upalabbhatti, #<[page 048]># %<48 KATHVATTHU.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ vyo upalabbhatti, tiakahavanappatiyo upalabbhantti, tiakahavanappatna paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakna kammna --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Ao kalyappakna kammna vipko, ao kalyappakna kammna vipkapaisavedti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 204. Dibba sukha upalabbhatti? mant. Dibbassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 205. Dibba sukha upalabbhatti dibbassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dibba sukha upalabbhatti, dibbassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhatti puggalassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dibba sukha upalabbhatti, dibbassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Nibbna upalabbhatti nibbnassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe. Dibba sukha upalabbhatti, dibbassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? #<[page 049]># %< KATHVATTHU. 49>% mant. Mahpathav upalabbhatti, mahsamuddo upalabbhatti, Sineru pabbatarj upalabbhatti, po upalabbhatti, tejo upalabbhatti, vyo upalabbhatti, tiakahavanappatiyo upalabbhantti, {tiakahavanappatna} paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dibba sukha upalabbhatti, dibbassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Aa dibba sukha ao dibbassa sukhassa paisavedti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 206. Mnusaka sukha upalabbhatti? mant. Mnusakassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 207. Mnusaka sukha upalabbhatti mnusakassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mnusaka sukha upalabbhatti, mnusakassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhatti puggalassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mnusaka sukha upalabbhatti, mnusakassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Nibbna upalabbhatti nibbnassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe. 5 #<[page 050]># %<50 KATHVATTHU.>% Mnusaka sukha upalabbhatti, mnusakassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Mahpathav upalabbhatti, mahsamuddo upalabbhatti, Sineru pabbatarj upalabbhatti, po upalabbhatti, tejo upalabbhatti, vyo upalabbhatti, tiakahavanappatiyo upalabbhantti, {tiakahavanappatna} paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mnusaka sukha upalabbhatti, mnusakassa sukhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Aa mnusaka sukha ao mnusakassa sukhassa paisavedti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 208. pyika dukkham upalabbhatti? mant. pyikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 209. pyika dukkha upalabbhatti pyikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- pyika dukkha upalabbhatti, pyikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhatti puggalassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- pyika dukkha upalabbhatti, pyikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Nibbna upalabbhatti nibbnassa paisaved upalabbhatti? #<[page 051]># %< KATHVATTHU. 51>% Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe. pyika dukkha upalabbhatti, pyikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Mahpathav upalabbhatti, mahsamuddo upalabbhatti, Sineru pabbatarj upalabbhatti, po upalabbhatti, tejo upalabbhatti, vyo upalabbhatti, tiakahavanappatiyo upalabbhantti, {tiakahavanappatna} paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- pyika dukkha upalabbhatti, pyikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Aa pyika dukkha ao pyikassa dukkhassa paisavedti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 210. Nerayika dukkha upalabbhatti? mant. Nerayikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 211. Nerayika dukkha upalabbhatti nerayikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Tassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nerayika dukkha upalabbhatti, nerayikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Puggalo upalabbhatti puggalassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nerayika dukkha upalabbhatti, nerayikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. #<[page 052]># %<52 KATHVATTHU.>% Nibbna upalabbhatti nibbnassa paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe. Nerayika dukkha upalabbhatti, nerayikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Mahpathav upalabbhatti, mahsamuddo upalabbhatti, Sineru pabbatarj upalabbhatti, po upalabbhatti, tejo upalabbhatti, vyo upalabbhatti, tiakahavanappatiyo upalabbhantti, {tiakahavanappatna} paisaved upalabbhatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nerayika dukkha upalabbhatti, nerayikassa dukkhassa paisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Aa nerayika dukkha ao nerayikassa dukkhassa paisavedti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 212. Kalyappakni kammni upalabbhantti, kalyappakna kammna katt kret vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. So karoti so paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- So karoti so paisavedetti? mant. Saya kata sukhadukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. Ao karoti ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ao karoti ao paisavedetti? mant. Para kata sukhadukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? #<[page 053]># %< KATHVATTHU. 53>% mant. So ca ao ca karonti, so ca ao ca {paisavedentti?} Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- So ca ao ca karonti, so ca ao ca paisavedentti? mant. Saya kata ca para kata ca sukhadukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe. Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. N' eva so karoti na so paisavedeti, na ao karoti na ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' eva so karoti na so paisavedeti, na ao karoti na ao paisavedetti? mant. Asaya kra apara kra adhiccasamuppanna sukhadukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyappakni kammni --pe-- vipkapaisaved upalabbhatti? mant. So karoti so paisavedeti, ao karoti ao paisavedeti, so ca ao ca karonti, so ca ao ca paisavedenti, n' eva so karoti na so paisavedeti, na ao karoti na ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- so karoti so paisavedeti, ao karoti ao paisavedeti, so ca ao ca karonti, so ca ao ca paisavedenti, n' eva so karoti na so paisavedeti, na ao karoti na ao paisavedetti? mant. Saya kata sukhadukkha, para kata sukhadukkha, saya kata ca para kata ca sukhadukkha, asaya kra apara kra adhiccasamuppanna sukhadukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 213. Kamma atthti? #<[page 054]># %<54 KATHVATTHU.>% mant. Kammakrako atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 214. Kamma atthti kammakrako atthti? mant. Tassa krako atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tassa krako atthti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupcchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kamma atthti kammakrako atthti? mant. Puggalo atthti, puggalassa krako atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kamma atthti kammakrako atthti? mant. Nibbna atthti, nibbnassa krako atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kamma atthti kammakrako atthti? mant. Mahpathav atthti --pe-- mahsamuddo atthti -- Sineru pabbatarj atthti --pe-- po atthti-- tejo atthti --pe-- vyo atthti -- tiakahavanappatiyo atthti, tiakahavanappatna krako atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kamma atthti kammakrako atthti? mant. Aa kamma ao kammakrako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 215. Vipko atthti? mant. Vipkapaisaved atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 216. Vipko atthti vipkapaisaved atthti? mant. Tassa paisaved atthti? #<[page 055]># %< KATHVATTHU. 55>% Na h' eva vattabbe. Tassa paisaved atthti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy n' atthi vaupacchedo n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vipko atthti vipkapaisaved atthti? mant. Puggalo atthti paggalassa paisaved atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vipko atthti vipkapaisaved atthti? mant. Nibbna atthti nibbnassa paisaved atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vipko atthti vipkapaisaved atthti? mant. Mahpathav atthti --pe-- mahsamaddo atthti --pe-- Sineru pabbatarj atthti --pe-- po atthti --pe-- tejo atthti --pe-- vyo atthti --pe-- tiakahavanappatiyo atthti, tiakahavanappatna paisaved atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vipko atthti vipkapaisaved atthti? mant. Ao vipko ao vipkapaisavedti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kalyavaggo pahamo. 217. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti?" mant. Nanu atthi koci iddhivikubbatti? mant. Haci atthi koci iddhivikubbati, tena vata re vattabbe Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." #<[page 056]># %<56 KATHVATTHU.>% Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti?" mant. Nanu atthi koci dubbya sotadhtuy sadda suti -pe -- paracitta jnti, pubbenivsa anussarati, dibbena cakkhun rpa passati, savna khaya {sacchikarotti?} mant. Haci atthi koci savna khaya {sacchikaroti,} tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 218. Atthi koci iddhividubbatti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Yo iddhivikubbati sv' eva puggalo, yo iddhi na vikubbati na so puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yo dibbya sotadhtuy sadda suti --pe-- yo paracitta jnti, yo pubbenivsa anussarati, yo dibbena cakkhun rpa passati, yo savna khaya {sacchikaroti} sv' eva puggalo, yo savna khaya na {sacchikaroti} na so puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Abhinuyogo. 219. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti?" mant. Nanu mt atthti? mant. Haci mt atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti?" mant. #<[page 057]># %< KATHVATTHU. 57>% Nanupit atthi -- pe-bht atthi, bhagin atthi, Khattiyo atthi, Brhmao atthi, Vesso atthi, Suddo atthi, gahaho atthi, pabbajito atthi, devo atthi, manusso atthti? mant. Haci manusso atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 220. Mt atthti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Atthi koci na mt hutv mt hotti? mant. Atthi koci na puggalo hutv puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci na pit hutv --pe-- na bht hutv -- na bhagin hutv, na Khattiyo hutv, na Brhmao hutv, na Vesso hutv, na Suddo hutv, na gahaho hutv, na pabbajito hutv, na devo hutv, na manusso hutv manusso hotti? mant. Atthi koci na puggalo hutv puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mt atthti katv tena {ca} kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Atthi koci mt hutv na mt hotti? mant. Atthi koci puggalo hutv na puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe -- pe- Atthi koci pit hutv, bht hutv, bhagin hutv, Khattiyo hutv, Brhmao hutv, Vesso hutv, Suddo hutv, gahaho hutv, pabbajito hutv, devo hutv, manusso hutv na manusso hotti? mant. Atthi koci puggalo hutv na puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 058]># %<58 KATHVATTHU.>% 221. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu sotpanno atthti? mant. Haci sotpanno atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu sakadgm atthi, angm atthi, Arah atthi, ubhatobhgavimutto atthi, pavimutto atthi, kyasakkh atthi, dihipatto atthi, saddhvimutto atthi, dhammnusr atthi, saddhnusr atthti? mant. Haci saddhnusr atthi tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 222. Sotpanno atthti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Atthi koci na sotpanno hutv sotpanno hotti? mant. Atthi koci na puggalo hutv puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci na sakadgm hutv --pe-- na angm hutv, na Arah hutv, na ubhatobhgavimutto hutv, na pavimutto hutv, na kyasakkh hutv, na dihippatto hutv, na saddhvimutto hutv, na dhammnusr hutv, na saddhnusr hutv saddhnusr hotti? mant. Atthi koci na puggalo hutv puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpanno atthti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahent? mant. Atthi koci sotpanno hutv na sotpanno hotti? mant. Atthi koci puggalo hutv na puggalo hotti? #<[page 059]># %< KATHVATTHU. 59>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci sakadgm hutv angm hutv na angm hotti? mant. Atthi koci puggalo hutv na puggalo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 223. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal atthti? mant. Haci cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 224. Cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal atthti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal Buddhaptubhv ptubhavantti? mant. Puggalo Buddhaptubhv ptubhavatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo Buddhaptubhv ptubhavatti? mant. Buddhassa Bhagavato parinibbute ucchinno puggalo, n' atthi puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 225. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Puggalo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo n' eva sakhato nsakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Puggalo n' eva sakhato nsakhato ti? #<[page 060]># %<60 KATHVATTHU.>% mant. Sakhata ca asakhata ca hapetv atth' a tatiy koti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhata ca asakhata ca hapetv atth' a tatiy koti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Dve, m {Bhikkhave} dhtuyo, katam dve? Sakhat ca dhtu asakhat ca dhtu. Im kho {Bhikkhave} dve dhtuyo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Sakhata ca asakhata ca hapetv atth' a tatiy {koti.}" 226. Puggalo n' eva sakhato nsakhato ti? mant. Aa sakhata aa asakhata ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Khandh sakhat nibbna asakhata puggalo n' eva sakhato nsakhato ti? mant. Ae khandh aa nibbna ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa sakhata nibbna asakhata puggalo n' eva sakhato nsakhato ti? mant. Aa rpa aa nibbna ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Vedan sa sakhr via sakhata nibbna asakhata puggalo n' eva sakhato nsakhato ti? mant. Aa vina aa nibbna ao puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 227. Puggalassa uppdo payati vayo payati hitassa aathatta payatti? mant. Puggalo sakhato ti? #<[page 061]># %< KATHVATTHU. 61>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vutta Bhagavat -- "T' imni {Bhikkhave} sakhatassa sakhatalakkhani; sakhatna {Bhikkhave} dhammna uppdo payati vayo payati hitna aathatta {payatti,}" puggalassa uppdo payati vayo payati hitassa aathatta payati, tena hi puggalo sakhato ti. Puggalassa na uppdo payati na vayo payati na hitassa aathatta payatti? mant. Puggalo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vutta Bhagavat -- "T' imni {Bhikkhave} asakhatassa asakhatalakkhani, asakhatna Bhikkhave dhamna na uppdo payati na vayo payati na hitna aathatta payatti," puggalassa na uppdo payati na vayo payati na hitassa aathatta payati, tena hi puggalo asakhato ti. 228. Parinibbuto puggalo atthatthamhi natthatthamhti? Atthatthamhti. Parinibbuto puggalo sassato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Natthatthamhti parinibbuto puggalo ucchinno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo ki nissya tihtti? Bhava nissya tihatti. Bhavo anicco sakhato paiccasamuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo virgadhammo nirodhadhammo viparimadhammo ti? mant. Puggalo pi anicco sakhato paiccasamuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo virgadhammo nirodhadhammo viparimadhammo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 229. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti pajntti? #<[page 062]># %<62 KATHVATTHU.>% mant. Haci atthi koci sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti pajnti, tena vata re vattabbe Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci dukkha vedana vediyamno --pe-- adukkhamasukha vedana vediyamno adukkhamasukha vedana vediymti pajntti? mant. Haci atthi koci adukkhamasukha vedana vediyamno adukkhamasukha vedana vedymti pajnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 230. Atthi koci sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti pajntti katv, tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Yo sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti pajnti sv' eva puggalo, yo sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti na pajnti na so puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yo dukkha vedana vediyamno --pe-- yo adukkhamasukha vedana vediyamno adukkhamasukha vedana vediymti pajnti sv' eva puggalo, yo adukkhamasukha vedana vediyamno adukkhamasukha vedana vediymti na pajnti, na so puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti pajntti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. A sukh vedan, ao sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediyamno sukha vedana vediymti pajntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 063]># %< KATHVATTHU. 63>% A dukkh vedan --pe-- a adukkhamasukh vedan, ao adukkhamasukha vedana vediyamno adukkhamasukha vedana vediymti pajntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 231. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci kye kynupass viharatti? mant. Haci atthi koci kye kynupass viharati, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamatthenti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci vedansu --pe-- citte --pe-- dhammesu dhammnupass viharatti? mant. Haci atthi koci dhammesu dhammnupass viharati, tena vata re vattabbe "Puggalo upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahanti.}" 232. Atthi koci kye kynupass viharatti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati {sacchikahaparamahenti?} mant. Yo kye kynupass viharati sv' eva puggalo, yo na kye kynupass viharati na so puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yo vedansu --pe-- citte --pe-- dhammesu dhammnupass viharati sv' eva puggalo, yo na dhammesu dhammnupass viharati na so puggalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 233. Atthi koci kye kynupass viharatti katv tena ca kraena puggalo upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti?} mant. Ao kyo ao kye kynupass {viharatti?} Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 064]># %<64 KATHVATTHU.>% A vedan aa citta ae dhamm ao dhammesu dhammnupass {viharatti?} Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 234. Puggalo upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti?} mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Suato loka avekkhassu Mogharj sad sato Attnuddihi hacca Eva maccutaro siy. Eva loka avekkhanta Maccurj na passatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati sacchikahaparamahenti." 235. Puggalo avekkhatti? mant. Saha rpena avekkhati vin rpena avekkhatti? Saha rpena avekkhatti. Tam jva ta sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vin rpena avekkhatti, aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puggalo avekkhatti? mant. Abbhantaragato avekkhati bahiddh nikkhamitv avekkhatti? Abbhantarahato avekkhatti. Ta jva ta sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bahiddh nikkhamitv avekkhatti aa jva aa sarran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 065]># %< KATHVATTHU. 65>% 236. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati {saccikahaparamahenti"?} mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd klavd bhtavd tathavd avitathavd anaathavdti? I mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Atthi puggalo attahitya paipanno ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti. 237. Na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti"? mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd klavd bhtavd tathavd avitathavd anaathavdti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Ekapuggalo Bhikkhave loke uppajjamno uppajjati bahujanahitya bahujanasukhya loknukampya atthya hitya sukhya devamanussnan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti. 238. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd --pe-- anaathavdti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Sabbe dhamm anatt ti"; atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 239. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. #<[page 066]># %<66 KATHVATTHU.>% Nanu Bhagav saccavd --pe-- anaathavdti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Dukkha eva uppajjamna uppajjati, dukkha eva nirujjhamna nirujjhatti na kakhati na vicikicchati, aparappaccayaa ev' assa ettha hoti, ettvat kho Kaccna sammdihi hotti;" atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 240. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. nanu Vajir Bhikkhun Mra ppimanta etad avoca -- Kin nu satto ti paccesi Mra dihigata nu te suddhasakhrapujo ya nayidha sattpalabbhati. Yath pi agasambhr Hoti saddo ratho iti, eva khandhesu santesu hoti satto ti sammuti. Dukkha eva hi sambhoti dukkha tihati veti ca näatra dukkh sambhoti näa dukkh nirujjhatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 241. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu {yasm} nando Bhagavanta etad avoca -- #<[page 067]># %< KATHVATTHU. 67>% Suo loko suo loko ti bhante vuccati. Kittvat nu kho bhante suo loko ti vuccatti?" Yasm kho nanda sua attena v attaniyena v, tasm suo loko ti vuccati. Ki c' nanda sua attena v attaniyena v? Cakkhu kho nanda sua attena v attaniyena v, rp su --pe-- cakkhuvia sua, cakkhusamphasso suo ya p' ida cakkhusamphassapaccay uppajjati vedayita sukha v dukkha v adukkhamasukha v, ta pi sua attena v attaniyena v, sota sua --pe-- sadd su, ghna sua, gandh su, jivh su, ras su, kyo suo, phohabb su, mano suo, dhamm su, manovia sua manosamphasso suo, ya p' ida manosamphassapaccay uppajjati vedayita sukya v dukkha v adukkhamasukha v, ta pi sua attena v attaniyena v; yasm kho nanda sua attena v attaniyena v, tasm suo loko ti vuccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 242. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd klavdi bhtavd tathavd avitathavd anaathavdti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Attani v {Bhikkhave} sati attaniya me ti assti." Eva bhante." Attaniye v {Bhikkhave} sati att me ti assti." Eva bhante." Attani ca {Bhikkhave} attaniye ca saccato thetato anupalabbhiyamne ya p' ida dihihna so loko so att so pecca bhavissmi, nicco dhuvo sassato aviparimadhammo sassati sama tath' eva hassmti. Nanvya {Bhikkhave} kevalo paripro bladhammo ti." Kici no siy bhante kevalo hi bhante paripro bladhammo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." #<[page 068]># %<68 KATHVATTHU.>% 243. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd klavd bhtavd tathavd avitathavd anaathavdti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Tayo' me Seniya satthro santo savijjamn lokasmi. Katame tayo? Idha Seniya ekacco satth dih' eva dhamme attna saccato thetato papeti, abhisamparya ca attna saccato thetato papeti; idha pana Seniya ekacco satth dih' eva hi kho dhamme attna saccato thetato papeti, no ca kho abhisamparya attna saccato thetato papeti; idha pana Seniya ekacco satth dihe c' eva dhamme attna saccato thetato na papeti, abhisamparya ca attna saccato thetato na papeti. Tatra Seniya yvya satth dihe c' eva dhamme attna saccato thetato papeti, abhisamparya ca attna saccato thetato papeti, aya vuccati Seniya satth sassatavdo. Tatra Seniya yvya dih' eva hi kho dhamme attna saccato thetato papeti, no ca kho abhisamparya attna saccato thetato papeti, aya vuccati Seniya satth ucchedavdo. Tatra Seniya yvya satth dihe c' eva dhamme attna saccato thetato na papeti, abhisamparya ca attna saccato thetato na papeti, aya vuccati Seniya satth sammsambuddho. Ime kho Seniya tayo satthro santo {savijjamn} lokasmin ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 244. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd klavd bhtavd tathavd avitathavd anaathavdti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Sappikumbho ti"? #<[page 069]># %< KATHVATTHU. 69>% mant. Atthi koci sappissa kumbha karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." 245. Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti? mant. Nanu Bhagav saccavd klavd bhtavd tathavd avitathavd anaathavadti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat "Telakumbho, madhukumbho, phitakumbho, khrakumbho, udakakumbho, pniyathlaka, pniyakosaka, pniyasarvaka, niccabhatta, dhuvaygti"? mant. Atthi koci ygu nicc dhuv sassat aviparimadhammti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi na vattabba "Puggalo upalabbhati saccikahaparamahenti." Sakhitta. Ahakaniggahapeyyla. Sandhvany updya, cittena pacama kalya, iddhi. Sutthrena ahama. Puggalakath. 1.2. 1. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sabbattha Arah arahatt parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbattha Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Sabbattha Arahato parihnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? #<[page 070]># %<70 KATHVATTHU.>% Amant. Sabbad Arah arahatt parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbad Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Sabbad Arahato parihnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sabbe 'va Arahanto arahatt parihyantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbe 'va Arahanto arahatt parihayantti? mant. Sabbesa eva Arahantna parihnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Arah arahatt parihyamno cathi phalehi parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cathi satasahassehi seh sehitta krento satasahasse parihne sehitt parihno hotti? mant. Sabbaspateyy parihno hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Cathi satasahassehi seh sehitta krento satasahasse parihne bhabbo sabbaspateyy parihyitun ti? mant. Arah arahatt parihyamno bhabbo cathi phalehi parihyitun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? #<[page 071]># %< KATHVATTHU. 71>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Amant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Amant. Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? #<[page 072]># %<72 KATHVATTHU.>% mant. Na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Arah arahatt parihyamno kattha sahtti? Angmiphale ti. Angm angmiphal parihyamno kattha sahtti? Sakadgmiphale ti. Sakadgm sakadgmiphale parihyamno kattha sahtti? Sotpaiphale ti. Sotpanno sotpattiphale parihyamno puthujjanabhmiya sahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe. {jnhi} niggaha: haci Arah arahatt parihyamno angmiphale sahti, angm angmiphal parihyamno {sakkadgmiphale} sahti, sakadgm sakadgmiphal parihyamno sotpattiphale sahti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sotpanno sotpattiphal parihyamno puthujjanabhmiya sahtti." Arah arahatt parihyamno sotpattiphale {satht ti?} mant. Sotpattiphalassa anantar arahatta eva {sacchikarot ti?} Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 073]># %< KATHVATTHU. 73>% Kassa bahutar kiles pahn Arahato v sotpannassa v ti? Arahato. haci Arahato bahutar kiles pahn parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." 9. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa bahutar kiles pahn Arahato v sakadgmissa v ti? Arahato. Haci Arahato bahutar kiles pahn, parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati {sakadgm} sakadgmiphal ti." 10. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Amant. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa bahutar kiles pahn Arahato v angmissa v ti? Arahato. Haci {Arahato} bahutar kiles pahn, parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati angm angmiphal ti." 11. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa bahutar kiles pahn angmissa v sotpannassa v ti? Angmissa. Haci angmissa bahutar kiles pahn parihyati angm {angmiphal,} tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." 12. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. #<[page 074]># %<74 KATHVATTHU.>% Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa bahutar kiles pahn angmissa v sakadgmissa v ti? Angmissa. Haci angmissa bahutar kiles pahn parihyati angm {angmiphal,} tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti." 13. Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa bahutar kiles pahn sakadgmissa v sotpannassa v ti? Sakadgmissa. Haci sakadgmissa bahutar kiles pahn parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." 14. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Kassa adhimatt maggabhvan Arahato v sotpannassa v ti? Arahato. Haci Arahato adhimatt maggabhvan parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." 15. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Pariyhyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa adhimatt satipahnabhvan, sammappadhnabhvan, iddhipdabhvan, indriyabhvan, balabhvan, bojjhagabhvan Arahato v sotpannassa v ti? Arahato. Haci Arahato adhimatt bojjhagabhvan parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." #<[page 075]># %< KATHVATTHU. 75>% 16. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati sakadgam sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Kassa adhimatt maggabhvan --pe-- bojjhagabhvan Arahato v sakadgmissa v ti? Arahato. Haci Arahato adhimatt bojjhagabhvan parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti." 17. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Kassa adhimatt maggabhvan --pe-- bojjhagabhavan Arahato v angmissa v ti? Arahato. Haci Arahato adhimatt bojjhagabhvan parihyati Arah arahatt, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati angm angmiphal ti." 18. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa adhimatt maggabhvan --pe-- bojjhagabhvan angmissa v sotpannassa v ti? Angmissa. Haci angmissa adhimatt bojjhagabhvan parihyati angm angmiphal, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." 19. Parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kassa adhimatt maggabhvan --pe-- bojjhagabhvan angmissa v sakadgmissa v ti? Angmissa. Haci angmissa adhimatt bojjhagabhvan parihyati angm angmiphal, #<[page 076]># %<76 KATHVATTHU.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti." 20. Parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Kassa adhimatt maggabhvan --pe-- bojjagabhvan sakadgmissa v sotpannassa v ti? Sakadgmissa. Haci sakadgmissa adhimatt bojjhagabhvan parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal, tena vata re vattabbe "Parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti." 21. Arahat dukkha diha parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannena dukkha diha parihyati sotpanno sotpttiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat samudayo diho parihyati Arah Arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannena samudayo diho parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat nirodho diho parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannena nirodho diho parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat maggo diho parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannena maggo diho parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat cattri saccni dihni parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannena catari saccni dihni parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? #<[page 077]># %< KATHVATTHU. 77>% Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 22. Arahat dukkha diha parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sakadgmin dukkha diha parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat samudayo diho, nirodho diho, maggo diho, {cattri} saccni dihni parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sakadgmin cattari saccni dihni parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 23. Arahat dukkha diha parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Angmin dukkha diha parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat samudayo diho, nirodho diho, maggo diho, cattri saccni dihni parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Angmin cattri saccni dihni parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 24. Angmin dukkha diha parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannena dukkha diha parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmin samudayo diho, nirodho diho, maggo diho, cattri saccni dihni parihayti angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannena cattri saccni dihni parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 078]># %<78 KATHVATTHU.>% 25. Angmin dukkha diha parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sakadgmin dukkha diha parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmin samudayo duho, nirodho diho, maggo diho, cattri saccni dihni parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sakadgmin cattri saccni dihni parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 26. Sakadgmin dukkha diha parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannena dukkha diha parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmin samudayo diho, nirodho diho, maggo diho, cattri saccni dihni parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannena cattri saccni dihni parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 27. Sotpannena dukkha diha na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Arahat dukkha diha na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpannena samudayo diho, nirodho diho, naggo diho, cattri saccni dihni na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Arahat cattri saccni dihni na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? #<[page 079]># %< KATHVATTHU. 79>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 28. Sakadgmin dukkha {diha} --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Arahat cattri saccni dihni na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 29. Angmin dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Arahat cattri saccni dihni na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 30. Sotpannena dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Angmin dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 31. Sakadgmin dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Angmin dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 32. Sotpannena dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni {dihni} na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Amant. sakadgmin dukkha diha --pe-- cattri saccni dihni na parihyati sakadgmi sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 33. Arahato rgo pahno parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 080]># %<80 KATHVATTHU.>% Arahato rgo pahno parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno --pe-- apyagamanyo rgo pahno --pe-- apyagamanyo doso pahno --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno --pe-- mno pahno --pe-- dihi pahn, vicikicch pahn, thna pahna, uddhacca pahna, ahirika pahna, anottappa pahna parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato anottappa pahna parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno --pe-- apyagamanyo rgo pahno --pe-- apyagamanyo doso pahno -- apyagamanyo moho pahno parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 34. Arahato rgo pahno parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sakadgm {sakadgmiphal} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato rgo pahno parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sakadgmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno --pe-- oriko kmargo pahno, oriko bypdo pahno, parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 081]># %% Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 35. Arahato rgo pahno parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato rgo pahno pariyyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Angmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno, ausahagato kmargo pahno, ausahagato bypdo pahno parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- ausahagato bypdo pahno parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 36. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- ausahagato bypdo pahno parihyati angm angmiphal ti? 7 #<[page 082]># %<82 KATHVATTHU. [I. 2.>% mant. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 37. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sakadgmissa vicikich pahn --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno --pe-- oriko kmargo pahno --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angmissa viccikicch pahn --pe-- ausahagato bypdo pahno parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 38. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- oriko kma rgo pahno oriko bypdo pahno parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? #<[page 083]># %% mant. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 39. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Arahato rgo pahno na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Arahato rgo pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 40. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Arahato rgo pahino --pe-- anottappa {pahna} na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sakadgmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Arahato rgo pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 41. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Arahato rgo pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? #<[page 084]># %<84 KATHVATTHU. [I. 2.>% Na h' eva vattabbe. Angmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- ausahagato bypdo pahno na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? mant. Arahato rgo pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna na parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 42. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn ausahagato bypado pahno na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn ausahagato bypdo pahno na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 43. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- ausahagato bypdo pahno na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sakadgmissa vicikicch pahn --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? mant. Angmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- ausahagato bypdo pahno na parihyati angm angmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 44. Sotpannassa sakkyadihi pahn na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? mant. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sotpannassa vicikicch pahn --pe-- apyagamanyo moho pahno na parihyati sotpanno sotpattiphal ti? #<[page 085]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ mant. Sakadgmissa sakkyadihi pahn --pe-- oriko bypdo pahno na parihyati sakadgm sakadgmiphal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 45. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo, na vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno, mno pahno, dihi pahn, vicikicch pahn, thna pahna uddhacca pahna, ahirika pahna, anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamman ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." 46. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya satipahn bhvit -- pe -- sammappadhn bhvit iddhipd bhvit indriy bhvit bal bhvit bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. #<[page 086]># %<86 KATHVATTHU. [I. 2.>% Haci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." 47. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, dukkha tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita, sacchiktabba sacchikatan ti? mant. Haci Arah vtargo vtadoso --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." 48. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? Samayavimutto Arah arahatt parihyati, asamayavimutto Arah arahatt na parihyatti. Samayavimutto Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Asamayavimutto Arah arahatt na parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Asamayavimutto Arah arahatt na parihyatti? mant. Samayavimutto Arah arahatt na parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 087]># %% 49. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rgo pahno, parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rgo pahno, parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Samayavimuttassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 50. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito, parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito, parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rgappahnya satipahn bhvit --pe-- sammappadhn bhvit iddhipd bhvit indriy bhvit bal bhvit bojjhag bhvit, parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rgappahnya satipahn bhvit --pe-- bojjhag bhavit, parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Samayavimuttassa Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 51. Samayavimutto Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, #<[page 088]># %<88 KATHVATTHU. [I. 2.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ dukkha tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita, sacchiktabba sacchikata, parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Asamayavimutto Arah vtargo vtadoso --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabe. 52. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rgo pahno, na parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rgo pahno, na parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, na parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Samayavimuttassa Arahato anottappa pahna, na parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 53. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, na parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Samayavimuttassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, na parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Asamayavimuttassa Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, na parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. #<[page 089]># %% Samayavimuttassa Arahato anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhaga bhvit, na parihyati samayavi mutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 54. Asamayavimutto Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, na parihyati asamayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? mant. Samayavimutto Arah vtargo, vtadoso --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, na parihyati samayavimutto Arah arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 55. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Sriputto thero, parihyittha Arahatt ti? Na h' evam vattabbe. Mah Moggallno thero, Mah Kassapo thero, Mah Kaccyano thero, Mah Kohiko thero, Mah Panthako thero parihyittha arahatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sriputto thero na parihyittha arahatt ti? mant. Haci Sriputto thero na parihyittha arahatt, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahtt ti." Mah Mogallno thero, Mah Kassapo thero, Mah Kaccyano thero, Mah Kohiko thero, Mah Panthako thero na parihyittha arahatt ti? mant. Haci Mah Mogallno thero --pe-- Mah Panthako thero na parihyittha arahatt, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." 56. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Uccvac hi paipad samaena paksit Na pra digua yanti nayida ekagua mutan ti." #<[page 090]># %<90 KATHVATTHU. [I. 2.>% Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba. "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." 57. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Atthi chinnassa chediyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atthi chinnassa chediyan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Vtataho andno kicca yassa na vijjati Chinnassa chediya n' atthi oghapso samhato ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi chinnassa chediyan ti." 58. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Atthi katassa paticayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atthi katassa paticayo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Tassa sammvimuttassa santacittassa bhikkhuno Katassa paticayo h' atthi karaya na vijjati. Selo yath ekaghano vtena na samrati Eva rp ras sadd gandh phass ca keval Ih dhamm anih ca n' appavedhenti tdino hita citta vippamutta vaya c' assnupassatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 091]># %% Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi katassa paticayo ti." 59. Na vattabba "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' ime Bhikkhave dhamm samayavimuttassa bhikkhuno parihnya savattanti. Katame paca? Kammrmat bhassrmat niddrmat sagaikrmat yath vimutta citta na paccavekkhati. Ime kho Bhikkhave paca dhamm samayavimuttassa bhikkhuno parihnya savattantti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi parihyati Arah arahatt ti. 60. Atthi Arahato kammrmat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atthi Arahato kammrmat ti? mant. Atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmrgasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atthi Arahato bhassrmat atthi Arahato niddrmat atthi Arahato sagaikrmat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atthi Arahato sagaikrmat ti? mant. Atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmrgasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 61. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Arah arahatt parihyamno kipariyuhito pari hyatti? Rgapariyuhito parihyatti. Pariyuhna ki paicca uppajjatti? Anusaya paicca uppajjatti. Atthi Arahato anusay ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 092]># %<92 KATHVATTHU. [I. 2.>% Atthi Arahato anusay ti? mant. Atthi Arahato kmargnusayo patighnusayo mnnusayo dihnusayo vicikicchnusayo bhvargnusayo avijjnusayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Dosapariyuhito parihyatti --pe-- mohapariyuhito parihyatti. Pariyuhna ki paicca uppajjatti? Anusaya paicca uppajjatti. Atthi Arahato anusay ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato anusay ti? mant. Atthi Arahato kmargnusayo --pe-- avijjnusayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 62. Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Arahato arahatt parihyamnassa ki upacaya gacchatti? Rgo upacaya gacchatti. Sakkyadihi upacaya gacchatti, {vicikicch} upacaya gacchatti, slabbataparmso upacaya gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Doso upacaya gacchatti --pe-- moho upacaya gacchatti, sakkyadihi upacaya gacchatti, vicikicch upacaya gacchatti, slabbataparmso upacaya gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. {} Parihyati Arah arahatt ti? mant. Arah cinatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah apacinatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah updiyatti? #<[page 093]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah visinetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah ussinetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah vidhupetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah {sandhpetti?} Na h' eva vattabbe. Nanu Arah n' ev' cinati, na apacinati apacinitv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah n' ev' cinati na apacinati apacinitv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Nanu Arah n' eva pajhati na updiyati pajahitv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah n' eva pajahati na updiyati pajahitv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Nanu Arah n' eva visineti na ussineti visinitv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah n' eva visineti na ussineti visinitv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Nanu Arah n' eva vidhupeti na {sandhpeti} vidhupetv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah n' eva vidhupeti na {sandhpeti} vidhupetv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Parihyati Arah arahatt ti." Parihnikath I.3. 1. N' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. #<[page 094]># %<94 KATHVATTHU. [I. 3.>% Sabbe dev ja eamg avi {hatthasavcik} na paibal subhsitadubbhsitna attha atum, sabbe dev na Buddhe pasann na Dhamme pasann na Saghe pasann, na Buddha Bhagavanta {payirupsanti,} na Buddha Bhagavanta paha pucchanti, na Buddhena Bhagavat pahe vissajjite attaman, sabbe dev kammvaraena samanngat kilesvaraena samanngat vipkvaraena samanngat assaddh acchandik duppa abhabb niyma okkamitu kusalesu dhammesu sammatta, sabbe dev mtughtak pitughtak arahantaghtak ruhiruppdak saghabhedak, sabbe dev ptiptino adinndyino kmesu micchcrino musvdino pisuvc pharusvc samphappalpino abhijjhluno bypannacitt micchdihik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Nanu atthi dev aja aneamg vi na hatthasavcik paibal subhsitadubbhsitna attha atum, atthi dev Buddhe pasann Dhamme pasann Saghe pasann, Buddha Bhagavanta {payirupsanti,} Buddha Bhagavanta paha pucchinti, Buddhena Bhagavat pahe vissajjite attaman honti, atthi dev na kammvaraena samanngat na kilesvaraena samanngat na vipkvaraena samanngat saddh chandik paavanto bhabb niyma okkamitu kusalesu dhammesu sammatta, atthi dev na mtughtak na pitughtak na arahantaghtak na ruhiruppdak na saghabhedak, atthi dev na ptiptino na adinndyino na kmesu micchcrino na musvdino na {pisuvc} na pharusvc na {samphappalpino} na abhijjhluno abypannacitt sammdihikti? mant. Haci atthi dev aja {aneamg} vi na hatthasavcik paibal subhsitadubbhsitna attha atu #<[page 095]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- abypannacitt sammdihik, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti." 3. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Atthi tattha pabbajj muiya ksvadhra pattadhra, devesu sammsambuddh uppajjanti, paccekasambuddh uppajjanti, svakayuga uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Devesu pabbajj n' atthti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha atthi pabbajj tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi pabbajj n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha atthi pabbajj tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi pabbajj n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yo pabbajjati tass' eva brahmacariyavso, yo na pabbajjati n' atthi tassa brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Devesu muiya n' atthti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha atthi muiya tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi muiya, n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha atthi muiya tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi muiya n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yo muo hoti tass' eva brahmacariyavso, yo muo na hoti n' atthi tassa brahmacariyavso ti? #<[page 096]># %<96 KATHVATTHU. [I. 3.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Devesu ksvadhra n' atthti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha atthi ksvadhra tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi ksvadhra n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha atthi ksvadhra tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi ksvadhra n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yo ksva dhreti tass' eva brahmacariyavso, yo ksva na dhreti n' atthi tassa brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Devesu pattadhra n' atthti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha atthi pattadhra tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi pattadhra n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha atthi pattadhra tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha n' atthi pattadhra n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yo patta dhreti tass' eva brahmacariyavso, yo patta na dhreti n' atthi tassa brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Devesu sammsambuddh n' uppajjantti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha sammsambuddh uppajjanti tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha sammsambuddh n' uppajjanti n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha sammsambuddh uppajjanti tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha sammsambuddh n' uppajjanti n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? #<[page 097]># %% mant. Lumbiniy Bhagav jto Bodhiy mle abhisambuddho Brasiya Bhagavat dhammacakka pavattita tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, n' atth' aatra brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Devesu Paccekasambuddh n' uppajjantti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha Paccekasambuddh uppajjanti tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha Paccekasambuddh n' uppajjanti n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha Paccekasambuddh uppajjanti tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha Paccekasambuddh n' uppajjanti n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Majjhimesu janapadesu Paccekasambuddh uppajjanti tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, n' atth' aatra brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Devesu svakayuga n' uppajjatti, n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Yattha svakayuga uppajjati tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha svakayuga n' uppajjati n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yattha svakayuga uppajjanti tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, yattha svakayuga n' uppajjati n' atthi tattha brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Magadhesu svakayuga uppanna tatth' eva brahmacariyavso, n' atth' aatra brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? #<[page 098]># %<98 KATHVATTHU. [I. 3.>% mant. Sabbadevesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi manussesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Sabbamanussesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Asaasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi manussesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Paccantimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavso milakkhsu avitresu, yattha n' atthi gati bhikkhna bhikkhunna upsakna upsiknan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 12. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? Atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthti. Asaasattesu devesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthi brahmacariyavso, saasattesu devesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Devesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Kattha atthi kattha n' atthti? Asaasattesu devesu n' atthi brahmacariyavso, saasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti. Asaasattesu devesu n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Saasattesu devesu n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Saasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti? mant. #<[page 099]># %% Asaasattesu devesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 13. Atthi manussesu brahmacariyavso ti? Atthi yattha atthi atthi yattha n' atthti. Paccantimesu janapadesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthi brahmacariyavso milakkhsu avitresu, yattha n' atthi gati bhikkhna bhikkhunna upsakna {upsikna,} majjhimesu janapadesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Manussesu atthi yattha atthi, atthi yattha n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Kattha atthi kattha n' atthti? Paccantimesu janapadesu n' atthi brahmacariyavso milakkhsu avitresu, yattha n' atthi gati bhikkhna bhikkhunna {upsakana} upsikna, majjhimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti. Paccantimesu janapadesu n' atthi brahmacariyavso milakkhsu avitresu, yattha n' atthi gati bhikkhna bhikkhunna upsakna upsiknan ti? mant. Majjhimesu janapadesu n' atthi brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Majjhimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Paccantimesu janapadesu atthi brahmacariyavso milakkhsu avitresu, yattha n' atthi gati bhikkhna bhikkhunna upsakna upsiknan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 14. Atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti? mant. Nanu vuttam Bhagavat. "Thi Bhikkhave, hnehi Jambudpak manuss Uttarakuruke ca manusse adhigahanti deve ca Tvatise. Katamehi thi? Sur satimanto idha brahmacariyavso ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 100]># %<100 KATHVATTHU. [I. 3.>% Tena hi n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti. Svatthiya vutta Bhagavat "Idha brahmacariyavso ti"? mant. Svatthiya eva brahmacariyavso, n' atthi aatra brahmacariyavso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 15. Angmissa puggalassa pac' orambhgiyni saojanni pahnni pac' uddhambhgiyni saojanni appahnni, ito cutassa tattha uppannassa kuhi phaluppattti? Tatth' eva. Haci angmissa puggalassa pac' orambhgiyni saojanni pahnni pac' {uddhambhgiyni} saojanni appahnni ito cutassa tattha uppannassa tahi phaluppatti, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti." 16. Angmissa puggalassa pac' orambhgiyni saojanni pahnani pac' uddhambhgiyni saojanni appahnni ito cutassa tattha uppannassa kuhi bhroharaa kuhi dukkhaparita kuhi kilesappahna kuhi nirodhasacchikiriy kuhi akuppapaivedho ti? Tatth' eva. Haci angmissa puggalassa pac' orambhgiyni saojanni pahnni pac' uddhambhgiyni saojanni appahnni ito cutassa tattha uppannassa tahi akuppapaivedho, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti." Angmissa puggalassa pac' orambhgiyni saojanni pahnani pac' uddhambhgiyni saojanni appahnni ito cutassa tattha uppannassa tahi phaluppattitahi bhroharaa tahi dukkhaparita tahi kilesappahna tahi nirodhasacchikiriy tahi akuppapaivedho; ken' ahena vadesi "n' atthi devesu brahmacariyavso ti?" Handa hi angm puggalo idha bhvitena maggena tattha phala sacchikaroti. #<[page 101]># %% 17. Angm puggalo idha bhvitena maggena tattha phala sacchikarotti? mant. Sotpanno puggalo tattha bhvitena maggena idha phala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angm puggalo idha bhvitena maggena tattha phala sacchikarotti? mant. Sakadgm puggalo idha parinibby puggalo tattha bhvitena maggena idha phala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sotpanno puggalo idha bhvitena maggena idha phala sacchikarotti? mant. Angm puggalo tattha bhvitena maggena tattha phala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sakadgm puggalo idha parinibby puggalo idha bhvitena maggena idha phala sacchikarotti? mant. Angm puggalo tattha bhvitena maggena tattha phala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 18. Idha vihyanihassa puggalassa maggo ca bhvyati na ca {kiles} pahyantti? mant. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa maggo ca bhvyati na ca kiles pahyantti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Idha vihyanihassa puggalassa maggo ca bhvyati na ca kiles pahyantti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa --pe-- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa maggo ca bhvyati, na ca kiles pahyantti? #<[page 102]># %<102 KATHVATTHU. [I. 3.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa apubba acarima maggo ca bhvyati kiles ca pahyantti? mant. Idha {vihyanihassa} puggalassa apubba acarima maggo ca bhvyati kiles ca pahyantti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa --pe-- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa apubba acarima maggo ca bhvyati kiles ca pahyantti? mant. Idha vihyanihassa puggalassa apubba acarima maggo ca bhvyati kiles ca pahyantti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 19. Angm puggalo katakarayo bhvitabhvano tattha uppajjatti? mant. Arah uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arah uppajjatti? mant. Atthi Arahato punabbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atthi Arahato punabbhavo ti? mant. Arah bhavena bhava gacchati gatiy gati gacchati sasrena sasra gacchati uppattiy uppatti gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angm puggalo katakarayo bhvitabhvano anohitabhro tattha uppajjatti? mant. Bhroharaya puna magga bhvetti? Na h' evam vattabbe. #<[page 103]># %% 20. Angm puggalo katakarayo bhvitabhvano aparitadukkho appahnakileso asacchikatanirodho appaividdhkuppo tattha uppajjatti? mant. Akuppapaivedhya puna magga bhavetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angm puggalo katakarayo bhvitabhvano anohitabhro tattha uppajjati, na ca bhroharaya puna magga bhavetti? mant. Anohitabhro ca tattha parinibbyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. nagm puggalo katakarayo bhvitabhvano aparitadukkho appahnakileso asacchikatanirodho appaividhkuppo tattha uppajjati, na ca akuppapaivedhya puna magga bhvetti? mant. Apaividdhkuppo ca tattha parinibbyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 21. Yath migo sallena viddho dra pi gantv klakaroti eva eva angm puggalo idha bhvitena maggena tattha phala sacchikarotti. Yath migo sallena viddho dra pi gantv sasallo va kla karoti, eva eva angm puggalo idha bhvitena maggena tattha sasallo va {parinibbyatti?} Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Brahmacariyakath. I.4. 1. Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti? mant. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? #<[page 104]># %<104 KATHVATTHU. [I. 4.>% Sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa sotpanno, ekadesa na sotpanno, ekadesa sotpattiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj, Buddhe aveccappasdena samanngato, Dhamme --pe--, Saghe --pe--, ariyakantehi slehi samanngato, ekadesa ariyakantehi slehi na samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Samudayadassanena ki jahatti? Sakkyadihi jahati, vicikiccha slabbataparmsa tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa sotpanno, ekadesa na sotpanno --pe-- ekadesa ariyakantehi slehi na samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Nirodhadassanena ki jahatti? Vicikiccha jahati, {slabbataparmsa} tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahitti? Ekadesa sotpanno, ekadesa na sotpanno --pe-- ekadesa ariyakantehi slehi na samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Maggadassanena ki jahatti? Slabbataparmsa tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa sotpanno, ekadesa na sotpanno --pe-- ekadesa ariyakantehi slehi na samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Orika kmarga jahati, orika bypda tadekahe ca kilese ekdese jahatti. Ekadesa sakadgm, ekadesa na sakadgm, ekadesa sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharatti? #<[page 105]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Samudayadassanena ki jahatti? Orika kmarga jahati, orika bypda tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa {sakadgm} ekadesa na {sakadgm} ekadesa sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva {vattabbe} --pe--. 7. Nirodhadassanena ki jahatti? Orika bypda jahati, tad ekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa {sakadgm} ekadesa na {sakadgm} ekadesa sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Maggadassanena ki jahatti? Tadekahe kilese jahatti. Ekadesa {sakadgm} ekadesa na {sakadgm} ekadesa sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Ausahagata kmarga jahati, ausahagata bypda tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa angm, ekadesa na angm, ekadesa angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa antarparinibby, upahaccaparinibby, asakhraparinibby, sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm, ekadesa na uddhasoto akanihagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Samudayadassanena ki jahatti? #<[page 106]># %<106 KATHVATTHU. [I. 4.>% Ausahagata kmarga jahati, ausahagata bypda tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa angm, ekadesa na angm, ekadesa angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa antarparinibby, upahacaparinibby, asakhraparinibby, sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm, ekadesa na uddhasoto akanihagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Nirodhadassanena ki jahatti? Ausahagata bypdam jahati, tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa angm, ekadesa na angm, ekadesa angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa antarparinibby, upahaccaparinibby, asakhraparinibby, sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm, ekadesa na uddhasoto akanihagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Maggadassanena ki jahatti? Tadekahe kilese jahatti. Ekadesa angm, ekadesa na angm, ekadesa angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa antarparinibby, upahaccaparinibby, asakhraparinibby, sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm, ekadesa na uddhasoto akanihagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Rparga arparga mna uddhacca avijja tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa Arah, ekadesa na Arah, ekadesa arahattappatto, pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, #<[page 107]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ekadesa vtargo vtadoso vtamoho, katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho, parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, dukkha tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba na sacchikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Samudayadassanena ki jahatti? Rparga arparga mna uddhacca avijja tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa Arah, ekadesa na Arah, ekadesa arahattappatto, pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajjaviharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa vtargo vtadoso vtamoho, katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho, parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, dukkha tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita, sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba na sacchikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 15. Nirodhadassanena ki jahatti? Mna jahati, uddhacca avijja tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa Arah, ekadesa na Arah, ekadesa arahattappatto, pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa vtargo vtadoso vtamoho, katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho, parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, #<[page 108]># %<108 KATHVATTHU. [I. 4.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ dukkha tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita, sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba na sacchikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Maggadassanena ki jahatti? Uddhacca jahati, avijja tadekahe ca kilese ekadese jahatti. Ekadesa Arah, ekadesa na Arah, ekadesa arahattappatto, pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa vtargo vtadoso vtamoho, katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho, parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, dukkha tassa parita samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya {parita,} pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita, sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba na sacchikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 17. Na vattabba -- "Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat. "Anupubbena medhv thoka thoka khae khae Kammro rajatass' eva niddhame mala attano ti" Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba -- "Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti." #<[page 109]># %% 18. Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sah v' assa dassanasampadya Tayas' su dhamm jahit bhavanti Sakkyadihi vicikicchita ca Slabbata v pi yad atthi kici, Catuh' apyehi ca vippamutto, Cha cbhihnni abhabbo ktun ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba -- "Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti." 19. Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yasmi Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa viraja vtamala dhammacakkhu udapdi `ya kici samudayadhamma, sabban ta nirodhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa ti saojanni pahyanti, sakkyadihi vicikicch slabbataparmso ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba -- "Odhisodhiso kilese jahatti." Odhisokath. I.5. 1. Jahati puthujjano kmargabypdan ti? mant. Accanta jahati, anavasesa jahati, appaisandhiya jahati, samla jahati, sataha jahati, snusaya jahati, ariyena ena jahati, ariyena maggena jahati, #<[page 110]># %<110 KATHVATTHU. [I. 5.>% akuppa paivijjhanto jahati, angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Vikkhambheti puthujjano kmargabypdan ti? mant. Accanta vikkhambheti, anavasesa vikkhambheti, appaisandhiya vikkhambheti, samla vikkhambheti, sataha vikkhambheti, snusaya vikkhambheti, ariyena ena vikkhambheti, ariyena maggena vikkhambheti, akuppa paivijjhanto vikkhambheti, angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Jahati angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo kmargabypda, so ca accanta jahati, anavasesa jahati, appaisandhiya jahati, samla jahati, sataha jahati, snusaya jahati, ariyena ena jahati, ariyena maggena jahati, akuppa paivijjhanto jahati, angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? mant. Jahati puthujjano kmargabypda, so ca accanta jahati, anavasesa jahati, appaisandhiya jahati, samla jahati, sataha jahati, snusaya jahati, ariyena ena jahati, ariyena maggena jahati, akuppa paivijjhanto jahati, angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Vikkhambheti angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo kmargabypda, so ca accanta vikkhambheti, anavasesa vikkhambheti, appaisandhiya vikkhambheti, samla vikkhambheti, sataha vikkhambheti, snusaya vikkhambheti, ariyena ena vikkhambheti, ariyena maggena vikkhambheti, akuppa paivijjhanto vikkhambheti, angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? mant. Vikkhambheti puthujjano kmargabypda, so ca accanta vikkhambheti, anavasesa vikkhambheti, appaisandhiya vikkhambheti, samla vikkhambheti, sataha vikkhambheti, snusaya vikkhambheti, ariyena ena vikkhambheti, #<[page 111]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ariyena maggena vikkhambheti, akuppa paivijjhanto vikkhambheti, angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 5. Jahati puthujjano kmargabypda, so ca na accanta jahati, na anavasesa jahati --pe-- na angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? mant. Jahati angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo kmargabypda, so ca na accanta jahati --pe-- na angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 6. Vikkhambheti puthujjano kmargabypda, so ca na accanta vikkhambheti, na anavasesa vikkhambheti --pe-- na angmiphala sacchikaronto jahatti? mant. Vikkhambheti angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo kmargabypda, so ca na accanta vikkhambheti, na anavasesa vikkhambheti, --pe-- na angmiphala sacchikaronto vikkhambhetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 7. Jahati puthujjano kmargabypdan ti? mant. Katamena maggenti? Rpvacarena maggenti. Rpvacaro maggo niyyniko khayagm bodhagm apacayagm ansavo asaojanyo aganthanyo anoghanyo ayoganyo anvarayo aparamaho anupdniyo asakilesiyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 8. Nanu rpvacaro maggo aniyyniko na khayagm na bodhagm na apacayagm ssavo saojanyo --pe-- sakilesiyo ti? mant. Haci rpvacaro maggo aniyyniko na khayagm --pe-- sakilesiyo, na vata re vattabbe "Jahati puthujjano rpvacarena maggena kmargabypdan ti." #<[page 112]># %<112 KATHVATTHU. [I. 5.>% 9. Jahati angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmimaggena kmargabypda, so ca maggo niyyniko khayagm bodhagm apacayagm ansavo --pe-- asakilesiyo ti? mant. Jahati puthujjano rpvacarena maggena kmargabypda, so ca maggo niyyniko khayagm bodhagm apacayagm ansavo --pe-- asakilesiyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe--. 10. Jahati puthujjano rpvacarena maggena kmargabypda, so ca maggo aniyyniko na khayagm na bodhagm na apacayagm ssavo --pe-- sakilesiyo ti? mant. Jahati angmisacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmimaggena kmargabypda --pe-- so ca maggo aniyyniko na khayagm na bodhagm na apacayagm ssavo --pe-- sakilesiyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 11. Puthujjano kmesu vtargo saha dhammbhisamay angmiphale sahtti? mant. Arahatte sahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Puthujjano kmesu vtargo saha dhammbhisamay angmiphale sahtti? mant. Apubba acarima tayo magge bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Apubba acarima tayo magge bhvetti? mant. Apubba acarima ti smaaphalni sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Apubba acarima ti smaaphalni sacchikarotti? mant. Tia phassna tia vedanna {tia} sana tia cetanna tiam cittna tia saddhnam tia viriyna tia satna tia samdhna tia pana samodhna hotti? #<[page 113]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Na h' eva vattabbe. 12. Puthujjano kmesu vtargo saha dhammbhisamay angmiphale sahtti? mant. Sotpattimaggenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sakadgmimaggenti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Katamena maggenti? Angmimaggenti. Angmimaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. ngmimaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa jahatti? mant. Nanu tia saojanna pahn sotpattiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci tia saojanna pahn sotpattiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Angamimaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa jahatti." 13. Angmimaggena orika kmarga orika bypda jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmimaggena orika kmarga orika bypda jahatti? mant. Nanu kmargabypdna tanubhv sakadgmiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci kmargabypdna tanubhv {sakadgmiphala} vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Angmimaggena orika kmarga orika bypda jahatti." #<[page 114]># %<114 KATHVATTHU. [I. 5.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Puthujjano kmesu vtargo saha dhammbhisamay angmiphale sahtti? mant. Ye keci dhamma abhisamenti sabbe te saha dhammbhisamay angmiphale sahahantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Na vattabba "Jahati puthujjano kmargabypdan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ahesu te attase Cha Satthro yasassino, Nirmagandh karu Vimutt kmasaojan ti. Kmarga virjetv Brahmalokpag ahu. Ahesu svak tesa Anekni satni pi, Nirmagandh karu Vimutt kmasaojan ti. {Kmarga} virjetv Brahmalokpag ahti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi jahati puthujjano kmargabypdan ti. 15. Jahati puthujjano {kmargabypdan} ti? mant. #<[page 115]># %% Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "So hi nma Bhikkhave sunetto satth eva dghyuko samno eva cirahitiko aparimutto ahoti jtiy jarya maraena sokehi paridevehi dukkhehi domanassehi upysehi "aparimutto dukkhasm ti" vadmi. Ta kissa hetu? Catunna dhammna ananubodh appaivedh. Katamesa catunna? Ariyassa slassa ananubodh appaivedh, ariyassa samdhissa, ariyya paya, ariyya vimuttiy ananubodh appaivedh, tayida Bhikkhave ariya sla anubuddha paividdha, ariyo samdhi anubuddho paividdho, ariy pa anubuddh paividdh, ariy vimutti anubuddh paividdh, ucchinn bhavatah kh bhavanetti n' atth' idni punabbhavo ti. Sla samdhi pa ca Vimutti ca anuttar, Anubuddh ime dhamm Gotamena yasassin. Iti Buddho abhiya Dhamma akkhsi bhikkhna Dukkhass' antakaro Satth Cakkhum parinibbuto ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Jahati puthujjano kmargabypdan ti." Jahatikath. I.6. 1. Sabba atthti? mant. Sabbattha sabba atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sabba atthti? mant. Sabbad sabba atthti? #<[page 116]># %<116 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe. Sabba atthti? mant. Sabbena sabba atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sabba atthti? mant. Sabbesu sabba atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sabba atthti? mant. Ayogan ti katv sabba atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sabba atthti? mant. Ya pi n' atthi ta p' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Sabba atthti? mant. Sabba atthti y dihi s dihi micchdihti, y dihi s dihi sammdihti h' eva atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atta atthti? mant. Nanu atta niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Haci atta niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagata, no vata re vattabbe "Atta atthti." Angata atthti? mant. Nanu angata ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibatta aptubhtan ti? #<[page 117]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ mant. Haci angata ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibatta aptubhta, no vata re vattabbe "Angatam atthti." Paccuppanna atthi, paccuppanna aniruddha avigata avipariata na atthagata na abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Atta atthi, atta aniruddha avigata avipariata na atthagata na abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna atthi, paccuppanna jta bhtam sajta nibbatta abhinibbatta ptubhtan ti? mant. Angata atthi, angata jta bhta sajta nibbatta abhinibbatta ptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta atthi, atta niruddha vigata vipariatam atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Paccuppanna atthi, paccuppanna niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata atthi, angata ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? mant. Paccuppanna atthi, paccuppanna ajtam abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 3. Atta rpa atthti? mant. Nanu atta rpa niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Haci atta rpa niruddha --pe-- abbhatthagata, no vata re vattabbe "Atta rpa atthti." Angata rpa atthti? mant. #<[page 118]># %<118 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Nanu angata rpa ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? mant. Haci angata rpa {ajta} --pe-- aptubhta, no vata re vattabbe "Angata rpa atthti." Paccuppanna rpa atthi, paccuppanna rpa aniruddha avigata avipariata na atthagata na abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa aniruddha --pe-- na abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Paccuppanna rpa atthi, paccuppanna rpa jta bhta sajta nibbatta abhinibbatta ptubhtan ti? mant. Angata rpa atthi, angata rpa jta --pe-- ptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa atthi, paccuppanna rpa niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rpa atthi, angata rpa ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa atthi, paccuppanna rpa ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Att vedan atthi, sa atthi, sakhr atthi, via atthti? mant. Nanu atta via niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? #<[page 119]># %% mant. Haci atta via niruddha --pe-- abbhatthagata, no vata re vattabbe "Atta via atthti." Angata via atthti? mant. Nanu angata via ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? mant. Haci angata via ajta --pe-- aptubhta, no vata re vattabbe "Angata via atthti." Paccuppanna via atthi, paccuppanna via aniruddha --pe-- na abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Atta via atthi, atta via aniruddha --pe-- na abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' evam vattabbe. Paccuppanna via atthi, paccuppanna via jta --pe-- ptubhtan ti? mant. Angata via atthi, angata via jta --pe-- ptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta via atthi, atta via niruddha --pe-- abbhatthagatan ti? mant. Paccuppanna via atthi, paccuppanna via niruddha --pe-- abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata via atthi, angata via ajta --pe-- aptubhtan ti? mant. Paccuppanna via atthi, paccuppanna via ajta --pe-- aptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Paccuppannan ti v rpan ti v rpan ti v paccuppannan ti v paccuppanna rpa appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte te? mant. #<[page 120]># %<120 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Paccuppanna rpa nirujjhamna paccupannabhva jahatti? mant. Rpabhva jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Paccuppannan ti v rpan ti v rpan ti v paccuppannan ti v paccuppanna rpa appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa nirujjhamna rpabhva na jahatti? mant. Paccuppannabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Odtan ti v vatthan ti v vatthan ti v odtan ti v odta vattha appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? mant. Odta vattha rajamna odtabhva jahatti? mant. Vatthabhva jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Odtan ti v vatthan ti v vatthan ti v odtan ti v odta vattha appiya karitv esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? mant. Odta vattha rajamna vatthabhva na jahatti? mant. Odtabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Rpa rpabhva na jahatti? mant. Rpa nicca dhuva sassata aviparinmadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu rpa anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? mant. #<[page 121]># %% Haci rpa anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa rpabhva na jahatti." 8. Nibbna nibbnabhva na jahatti, nibbna nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? mant. Rpa rpabhva na jahatti, rpa nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa rpabhva na jahatti, rpa anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? mant. Nibbna nibbnabhvam na jahatti, nibbna anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti? mant. Angata atthi, angata angatabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti? mant. Paccuppanna atthi, paccuppanna paccuppannabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 10. Angata atthi, angata angatabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Paccuppanna atthi, paccuppanna paccuppannabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 11. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 122]># %<122 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Nanu atta anicca adhuva asassata {viparimadhamman} ti? mant. Haci atta anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti." 12. Nibbna atthi, nibbna nibbnabhva na jahatti, nibbna nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? mant. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti, attm nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta atthi, atta attabhva na jahatti atta anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? mant. Nibbna atthi, nibbna nibbnabhva na jahatti, nibbna anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 13. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahatti? mant. Angata rpa atthi, angata rpa angatabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahatti? mant. {Puccuppanna} rpa atthi, paccuppanna rpa paccuppannabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 14. Angata rpa atthi, angata rpa angatabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 123]># %% Paccuppanna rpa atthi, paccuppanna rpa paccuppannabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta rpa nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atta rpa anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? mant. Haci atta rpa anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahatti." 16. Nibbna atthi, nibbna nibbnabhva na jahati, {nibbna} nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? mant. Atta rpa atthi, atta rupa attabhva na jahati, atta rpa nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta rpa atthi, atta rpa attabhva na jahati, atta rpa anicca adhuva asasata viparimadhamman ti? mant. Nibbna atthi, nibbna nibbnabhva na jahati, nibbna anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Att vedan atthi, att sa atthi, att sakhr atthi, atta via atthi, atta via attabhva na jahatti? mant. #<[page 124]># %<124 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% ngata via atthi, angata via angatabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta via atthi, atta vina attabhva na jahatti? mant. Paccuppanna via atthi, paccuppanna via paccuppannabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 18. Angata {via} atthi, angata via angatabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta via atthi, atta via attabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna via atthi, paccuppanna via paccuppannabhva na jahatti? mant. tta via atthi, atta via attabhva na jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Atta via atthi, atta via attabhva na jahatti? mant. Atta via nicca dhuva sassata {aviparimadhamman} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atta via anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? mant. Haci atta via anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atta via atthi, atta via attabhva na jahatti." 20. Nibbna atthi nibbna nibbnabhva na jahati, {nibbna} nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? mant. Atta via atthi, atta via viabhva na jahati, #<[page 125]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ atta via nicca dhuva sassata aviparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta via atthi, atta via attabhva na jahati, atta via anicca adhuva asassata {viparimadhamman} ti? mant. Nibbna atthi, nibbna nibbnabhva na jahati, nibbna anicca adhuva asassata viparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 21. Atta nv' atthti? mant. Haci atta nv' atth,' atta atthti micch, haci v pana atthi nvtta, atthi attan ti micch. Angata nv' atthti? mant. Haci angata nv' atthi, angata atthti micch, haci v pana atthi nvngata, atthi angatan ti micch. 22. Angata hutv paccuppanna hotti? mant. Ta eva angata ta paccuppannan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta eva angata ta paccuppannan ti? mant. Hutv hoti hutv hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Hutv hoti hutv hotti? mant. Na hutv na hoti na hutv na hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna hutv atta hotti? mant. Ta eva paccuppanna ta attan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Ta eva paccuppanna ta attan ti? #<[page 126]># %<126 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% mant. Hutv hoti hutv hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Hutv hoti hutv hotti? mant. Na hutv na hoti na hut na hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angata hutv paccuppanna hoti, paccuppanna hutv atta hotti? mant. Ta eva angata ta paccuppanna ta attan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Ta eva angata ta paccuppanna ta attan ti? mant. Hutv hoti hutv hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Hutv hoti hutv hotti? mant. Na hutv na hoti na hutv na hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 23. Atta cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Attena cakkhun atta rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta sota atthi sadd atthi sotavia atthi kso atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Attena sotena atta sadda suotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta ghna atthi gandh atthi ghnavia atthi vyo atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Attena ghnena atta gandha ghyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att jivh atthi ras atthi jivhvia atthi po atthi manasikro atthti? #<[page 127]># %% mant. Attya jivhya atta rasa syatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atto kyo atthi phohabb atthi kyavia atthi patav atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Attena kyena atta phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atto mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Attena manena atta dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 24. Angatam cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Angatena cakkhun angatam rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angatam sota atthi sadd atthi sotavia atthi kso atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Angatena sotena angatam sadda suotti? Na h' eva vattabbe. ngatam ghna atthi gandh atthi ghnavia atthi vyo atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Angatena ghnena angatam gandha ghyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att jivh atthi ras atthi jivhvia atthi po atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Angatya jivhya angatam rasa syatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angato kyo atthi phohabb atthi kyavia atthi pathav atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Angatena kyena angata phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. #<[page 128]># %<128 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Angato mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthti? mant. Angatena manena angatam dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 25. Paccuppanna cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, {paccuppannena} cakkhun paccuppanna rpa passatti? mant. Atta cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, attena cakkhun atta rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Puccuppanna sota atthi ghna atthi jivh atthi kyo atthi mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, paccuppannena manena paccuppanna dhamma vijntti? mant. Atto mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, attena manena atta dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 26. Paccuppanna cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, {paccuppannena} cakkhun paccuppanna rpa passatti? mant. Angata cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, angatena cakkhun angata rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Paccuppanna sota atthi ghna atthi jivh atthi kyo atthi mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, paccuppannena manena paccuppanna dhama vijjntti? mant. Atto mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, angatena manena angata dhamma vijntti? #<[page 129]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 27. Atta cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, na ca attena cakkhun atta rpa passatti? mant. Paccuppanna cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, na ca {paccuppannnena} cakkhun paccuppanna rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta sota atthi ghna atthi jivh atthi kyo atthi mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, na ca attena manena atta dhamma vijntti? mant. Paccuppanno mano atthi dhmm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi maasikro atthi, na ca paccuppanena manena paccuppanna dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 28. Angata cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, na ca angatena cakkhun angata rpa passatti? mant. Paccuppanna cakkhu atthi rp atthi cakkhuvia atthi loko atthi manasikro atthi, na ca paccuppannena cakkhun paccuppanna rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angata sota atthi ghna atthi jjivh atthi kyo atthi mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, na ca angatena manena angata dhamma vijnttu? mant. Paccuppanno mano atthi dhamm atthi manovia atthi vatthu atthi manasikro atthi, na ca paccuppanena manena paccuppanna dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 29. Atta a atthti? mant. Tena ena akaraya karotti? 10 #<[page 130]># %<130 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe. Tena ena akaraya karotti? mant. Tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 30. Angata a atthti? mant. Tena ena akaraya karotti? Na h' ava vattabe. Tena ena akaraya karotti? mant. Tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 31. Paccuppanna a atthi, tena ena akaraya karotti? mant. Atta a atthi, tena ena akaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna a atthi, tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? mant. Atta a atthi, tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 32. Paccuppanna a atthi, tena ena akaraya karotti? mant. Angata a atthi, tena ena akaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna a atthi, tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? #<[page 131]># %% mant. Angata a atthi, tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhavetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 33. Atta a atthi, na ca tena ena akaraya karotti? mant. Paccuppanna a atthi, na ca tena ena {akaraya} karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta a atthi, na ca tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? mant. Paccuppanna a atthi, na ca tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 34. Angata a atthi, na ca tena ena akaraya karotti? mant. Paccuppanna a atthi, na ca tena ena akaranya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata a atthi, na ca tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? mant. Paccuppanna a atthi, na ca tena ena dukkha parijnti samudaya pajahati nirodha sacchikaroti magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 35. Arahato atto rgo atthti? mant. Arah tena rgena sargo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato atto doso atthti? #<[page 132]># %<132 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% mant. Arah tena dosena sadoso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahat atto moho atthti? mant. Arah tena mohena samoho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato atto mno atthti? mant. Arah tena mnena samno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato att dihi atthti? mant. Arah tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato att vicikicc; h atthti? mant. Arah tya vicikicchya {savicikicch} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arahato atta thna atthti? mant. Arah tena thnena sathno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato atta uddhacca atthti? mant. Arah tena uddhaccena sa-uddhaccako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato atta ahirika atthti? mant. Arah tena ahirikena sa-ahiriko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Arahato atta anottappa atthti? mant. Arah tena anottappena sa-anottp ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 36. Angmissa att sakkyadihi atthti? #<[page 133]># %% mant. Angm tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmissa att vicikicch atthi, atto slabbataparmso atthi, atto ausahagato kmargo atthi, atto ausahagato bypdo atthti? mant. Angm tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 37. Sakadgmissa att sakkyadihi atthti? mant. Sakadgm tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmissa att vicikicch atthi, atto slabbataparmso atthi, atto oriko kmargo atthi, atto oriko bypdo atthti? mant. Sakadgm tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 38. Sotpannassa att sakkyadihi atthti? mant. Sotpanno tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpannassa att vicikicch atthi, atto slabbataparmso atthi atto apyagamanyo rgo atthi, atto apyagamanyo doso atthi, atto apyagamanyo moho atthti? mant. Sotpanno {tena} mohena samoho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 39. Puthujjanassa atto rgo atthi, puthujjano tena rgena sargo ti? mant. Arahato atto rgo atthi Arah tena rgena sargo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puthujjanassa atto doso atthi --pe-- atta anottappa atthi, puthujjano tena anottappena anottp ti? mant. Arahato atta anottappa atthi, Arah tena anottappena anottp ti? #<[page 134]># %<134 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 40. Puthujjanassa att sakkyadihi atthi, puthujjano tya dihiy sadihiko ti? {mant.} Angmissa att sakkyadihi atthi, angm tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puthujjanassa att vicikicch atthi --pe-- atto ausahagato bypdo atthi, puthujjano tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? mant. Angmissa atto ausahagato bypdo atthi, angm tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 41. Puthujjanassa att sakkyadihi atthi, puthujjano tya dihiy sadihiko ti? mant. Sakadgmissa att sakkyadihi atthi, sakadgm tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puthujjanasa att viccikicch atthti --pe-- atto oriko bypdo atthi, puthujjano tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? mant. Sakadgmissa atto oriko bypdo atthi, sakadgm tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 42. Puthujjanassa att sakkyadihi atthi, puthujjano tya dihiy sadihiko ti? mant. Sotpannassa att sakkyadihi atthi, sotpanno tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puthujjanassa att vicikicch atthi --pe-- atto apyagamanyo moho atthi, puthujjano tena mohena samoho ti? mant. Sotpannassa atto apyagamanyo moho atthi, sotpanno tena mohena samoho ti? #<[page 135]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 43. Arahato atto rgo atthi, na ca Arah tena rgena sargo ti? mant. Puthujjanassa atto rgo atthi, na ca puthujjano tena rgena sargo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato atto doso atthi --pe-- atta anottappa atthi. na ca Arah tena anottappena anottp ti? mant. Puthujjanassa atta anottappa atthi, na ca puthujjano tena anottappena anottp ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 44. Angmissa att sakkyadihi atthi, na ca angm tya dihiy sadihiko ti? mant. Puthujjanassa att sakkyadihi atthi, na ca puthujjano tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmissa att vicikicch atthi --pe-- atto ausahagato bypdo atthi, na ca angam tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? mant. Puthujjanassa atto ausahagato bypdo atthi, na ca puthujjano tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 45. Sakadgmissa att sakkayadihi atthi, na ca sakadgm tya dihiy sadihiko ti? mant. Puthujjanassa att sakkyadihi atthi, na ca puthujjano tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmissa att vicikicch atthi --pe-- atto oriko bypdo atthi, na ca sakadgm tena bypdena bypannacitto ti? mant. Puthujjanassa atto oriko bypdo atthi, na ca puthujjano tena bypdena bypnnacitto ti? #<[page 136]># %<136 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 46. Sotpannassa att sakkyadihi atthi, na ca sotpanno tya dihiy sadihiko ti? mant. Puthujjanassa att sakkyadihi atthi, na ca puthujjano tya dihiy sadihiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpannassa att vicikicch atthi --pe-- atto apyagamanyo moho atthi, na ca sotpanno tena mohena samoho ti? mant. Puthujjanassa atto apyagamanyo moho atthi, na ca puthujjano tena mohena samoho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 47. Att hatth atthti? mant. Attesu hatthesu sati dnanikkhepana payatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Att pd atthti? mant. Attesu pdesu sati abhikkamapaikkamo payatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Att pabb atthti? mant. Attesu pabbesu sati {samijanapasraa} payatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atto kucchi atthti? mant. Attasmi kucchismi sati jighacchpips payat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 48. Atto kyo atthti? mant. Atto kyo paggahaniggahpago chedanabhedanpago kkehi gijjhehi kulalehi sdhrao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 137]># %% Atte kye visa kameyya, sattha kameyya, aggi kameyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh atto kyo anubandhanena bandhitu rajjubandhanena bandhitu sakhalikabandhanena bandhitu gmabandhanena bandhitu nigamabandhanena bandhitu nagarabandhanena bandhitu janapadabandhanena bandhitu kahapacamehi {bandhanehi} bandhitun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 49. Atto po atthti? mant. Tena pena pakaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atto tejo atthti? mant. Tena tejena tejakaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atto vyo atthiti? mant. Tena vyena vyakaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 50. Atto {rpakkhandho} atthi, angato {rpakkhandho} atthi, paccuppanno {rpakkhandho} atthti? mant. Tayo {rpakkhandh} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Att {pacakkhandh} atthi, angat {pacakkhandh} atthi, paccuppann {pacakkhandh} atthti? mant. {Pannarasakkhandh} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 51. Atta cakkhyatana atthi, angata cakkhyatana atthi, paccuppanna cakkhyatana atthti? mant. Ti cakkhyatannti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 138]># %<138 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% Attni dvdas' yatanni atthi, angatni dvdas' yatanni atthi, paccuppannni dvdas' yatanni atthti? mant. {Chattis' yatannti}? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 52. Att cakkhudhtu atthi, angat cakkhudhtu atthi, paccuppann cakkhudhtu atthti? mant. Tisso cakkhudhtuyo ti? Na {h' eva} vattabbe --pe-- Att ahrasa dhtuyo atthi, angat ahrasa dhtuyo atthi, paccuppann ahrasa dhtuyo atthti? mant. Catupasa dhtuyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 53. Atta cakkhundriya atthi, angata cakkhundriya atthi, paccuppanna cakkhundriya atthti? mant. Ti cakkhundriynti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attni bvsat' indriyni atthi, angatni bvsat' indriyni atthi, paccuppannni bvsat' indriyni atthti? mant. Chasah' indriynti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 54. Atto rj cakkavatt atthi, angato rj cakkavatt atthi, paccuppanno rj cakkavatt atthti? mant. Tianna rjna cakkavattna sammukhbhvo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atto Sammsambuddho atthi, angato Sammsambuddho atthi, paccuppanno Sammsambuddho atthti? mant. Tianna Sammsambuddhna sammukkhbhvo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 55. Atta atthti? #<[page 139]># %% mant. Atthi attan ti? Atthi siy atta siy nvttan ti. jnhi niggaha -- haci atta atthi, atthi siy atta siy nvtta, tentta nvtta nvtta attan ti. Ya tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho -- Atta atthi, atthi siy atta siy nvttan ti, tentta nvtta nvtta attan ti," micch. No ce pana atta nvtta nvtta attan ti, no vata re vattabbe "Atta atthi, atthi siy atta siy nvttan ti." Ya tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho -- Atta atthi, atthi siy atta siy nvtta, tentta nvtta nvtta attan ti," micch- 56. Angata atthti? mant. Atthi angatan ti? Atthi siy angata siy nvngatan ti. jnhi niggaha -- haci angata atthi, atthi siy angata siy nvngata, tenngata nvngata nvngata angatan ti. Ya tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho -- Angata atthi, atthi siy angata siy nvngatan ti, tenngata nvngata nvngata angatan ti," micch. No ce pana angata nvngata nvngata angatan ti, no vata re vattabbe "Angata atthi, atthi siy angata siy nvngatan ti." Ya tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho -- Angata atthi, atthi siy angata siy nvngata, tenngata nvngata nvngata angatan ti," micch. 57. Paccuppanna atthti? mant. Atthi paccuppannan ti? Atthi siya paccuppanna siy no paccuppannan ti. jnhi niggaha -- haci paccuppanna atthi, atthi siy paccuppanna siy no paccuppanna, tena pacuppanna no paccuppanna no paccuppanna paccuppannan ti. Ya tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho -- Paccuppanna atthi, atthi siy accuppanna siy na paccuppannan ti, tena paccuppanna no paccuppanna no paccuppanna paccuppannan ti," micch. No ce pana paccuppanna no paccuppanna no paccuppanna paccuppannan ti, #<[page 140]># %<140 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ no vata re vattabbe "Paccuppanna atthi, atthi siy paccuppanna siy no paccuppannan ti." Ya tattha vadesi, Vattabbe kho -- Paccuppanna atthi, atthi siy paccuppanna siy no paccuppanna, tena paccuppanna no paccuppanna no paccuppanna paccuppannan ti," micch. 58. Nibbna atthti? mant. Atthi attan ti? Atth siy nibbna siy no nibbnan ti. jnhi niggaha -- haci nibbna atthi, atthi siy nibbna siy no nibbna, tena nibbna no nibbna no nibbna nibbnan ti. Ya tattha vadesi, "Vattabbe kho -- {Nibbna} atthi, atthi siy nibbna siy no nibbnan ti, tena nibbna no nibbna no nibbna nibbanan ti," micch. No ce pana nibbna no nibbna no nibbna nibbnan ti, no vata re vattabbe Nibbna atthi, atthi siy nibbna siy no nibbnan ti." Ya tattha vadesi, Vattabbe kho -- Nibbna atthi, atthi siy nibbna siy no nibbnan ti, tena nibbna no nibbna no nibbna nibbnan ti," micch. 59. Na vattabba "Atta atthi angata atthti?" mant. Nanu vutta {Bhagavat} -- Ya kici Bhikkhave rpa attngatapaccuppanna ajjhatta v bahiddh v orika v sukhuma v hna v pata v ya dure santike v, aya vuccati rpakkhandho, y pci vedan, y kci sa, ye keci sakhr, ya kici via attngatapaccuppanna ajjhatta v bahiddh va orika v sukhuma v hna v paya v ya dure santike v, aya vuccati viakkhandho ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atta atthi angata atthti. 60. Atta atthi angata atthti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Tayo 'me Bhikkhave niruttipath adhivacanapath paattipath asaki asakiapubb na sakyanti na sakyissanti appaikuh samaehi {brhmaehi} vihi. #<[page 141]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Katame tayo? Ya Bhikkhave rpa atta niruddha vigata vipariata, ahosti tassa sakh, ahosti tassa sama, ahosti tassa paatti, na tassa sakh atthti na tassa sakh bhavissatti, y vedan -- pe, y sa --pe-- ye sakhr --pe-- ya via atta niruddha vigata vipariata, ahosti tassa sakh, ahosti tassa sama, ahosti tassa paatti, na tassa sakh atthti na tassa sakh ahosti. Ya Bhikkhave rpa ajta {aptubhta,} bhavissatti tassa sakh, bhavissatti tassa sama, bhavissatti tassa paatti, na tassa sakh atthti na tassa sakh ahosti, y vedan --pe-- y sa -- ye sakhr --pe-- ya via ajta aptubhta, bhvissatti tassa sakh, bhavissatti tassa sama, bhvissatti tassa paatti, na tassa sakh atthti na tassa sakh ahosti. Ya Bhikkhave rpa jta ptubhta, atthti tassa sakh, atthti tassa sama, atthti tassa paatti, na tassa sakh ahosti na tassa sakh bhavissatti, y vedan --pe-- y sa --pe-- ye sakhr --pe-- ya via jta ptubhta, atthti tassa sakh, atthti tassa sama, atthti tassa paatti, na tassa sakh ahosti na tassa sakh bhavissatti. Ime kho Bhikkhave tayo niruttipath adhivacanapath paattipath asaki asakiapubb na sakyanti na sakyissanti appaikuh samaehi brhmaehi vihi. Ye pi te Bhikkhave ahesu ukkalavassabha ahetukavd akiriyavd n' atthikavd te pi 'me tayo niruttipathe adhivacanapathe paattipathena garahitabba na paikkositabba {amaisu.} Tam kissa hetu? Nindbyrosan-uprambhabhay ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atta atthi angata atthti." #<[page 142]># %<142 KATHVATTHU. [I. 6.>% 61. Atta atthti? mant. Nanu yasm Phagguo Bhagavanta etad avoca; Atthi nu kho ta bhante cakkhu yena cakkhun atte Buddhe parinibbute chinnapapace chinnavaume pariydiavatte sabbadukkhavtivatte papayamno papeyyti, atthi nu kho s bhante jivh --pe-- atthi nu kho so bhante mano yena manena atte Buddhe parinibbute chinnapapace chinnavaume pariydiavatte sabbadukkhavtivatte papayamno papeyyti?" "N' atthi kho ta Phaggua cakkhu yena cakkhun atte Buddhe parinibbute chinnapapace chinnavaume pariydiavatte sabbadukkhavtivatte papayamno papeyyti, n' atthi kho s Phaggua jivh --pe-- n' atthi kho so Phaggua mano yena manena atte Buddhe parinibbute chinnapapace chinnavaume pariydiavatte sabbadukkhavtivatte papayamno papeyyti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atta atthti." 62. Atta atthti? mant. Nanu yasm Nandako etad avoca "Ahu pubbe lobho tad ahu akusala so etarahi n' atthi icc' eta kusala, ahu pubbe doso, ahu pubbe moho tad ahu akusala so etarahi n' atthi icc' eta kusalan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atta atthti." 63. Na vattabba "Angata atthti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Kabalikre ce Bhikkhave hre atthi rgo atthi nandi atthi tah, paihita tattha via virha, yattha patihita via virha, atthi tattha nmarpassa avakkanti, yattha atthi nmarpassa avakkanti atthi tattha sakhrna buddhi, #<[page 143]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ yattha atthi sakhrna buddhi atthi tattha yati punabbhavbhinibbatti, yattha atthi yati punabbhavbhinibbatti atthi tattha yati jtijarmaraa, yattha atthi yati jtijarmaraa sasokan ti Bhikkhave saraja sa-upysan ti vadmi, phassa ce Bhikkhave hre, manosacetanya ce Bhikkhave hre, vie ce Bhikkhave hre atthi rgo atthi nandi --pe-- saraja sa-upysan ti vadmti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Angata atthti." 64. Angata atthti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Kabalikre ce Bhikkhave hre N' atthi rgo n' atthi nandi n' atthi tah appatihita tattha via avirha, yattha appatihita via avirha n' atthi tattha nmarpassa avakkanti, yattha n' atthi nmarpassa avakkanti n' atthi tattha sakhrna buddhi, yattha n' atthi sakhrna buddhi n' atthi tattha yati punabbhavbhinibbatti, yattha n' atthi yati punabbhavbhinibbatti n' atthi tattha yati jtijarmaraa, yattha n' atthi {yati} jtijarmaraa asokanti Bhikkhave araja anupysan ti vadmi, phasse ce Bhikkhave hre, manosacetanya ce Bhikkhave hre, vie ce Bhikkhave hre n' atthi rgo n' atthi nandi --pe-- araja anupysan ti vadmti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Angata atthti." Sabbamatthtikath. I.7. 1. Atta khandh ti? mant. Atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 144]># %<144 KATHVATTHU. [I. 7.>% Atta yatanan ti? mant. Atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta dhtti? mant. Atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta khandhdhtuyatanan ti? mant. Atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Angata khandh ti? mant. Angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata yatanan ti? mant. Angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata dhtti? mant. Angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata khandhdhtuyatanan ti? mant. Angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Paccuppanna khandh paccuppanna atthti? mant. Atta khandh atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna yatana paccuppanna atthti? mant. Atta yatana atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna dhtu paccuppanna atthti? mant. #<[page 145]># %% Atta dhtu atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna khandhdhtuyatana paccuppanna atthti? mant. Atta khandhdhtuyatana atta atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Paccuppanna khandh paccuppanna atthti? mant. Angata khandh angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna yatana paccuppanna atthti? mant. Angata yatana angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna dhtu paccuppanna atthti? mant. Angata dhtu angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna khandhdhtuyatana paccuppanna atthti? mant. Angata khandhdhtuyatana angata atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atta khandh atta n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna khandh paccuppanna n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta yatana atta n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna yatana paccuppanna n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Atta dhtu atta n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna dhtu paccuppanna n' atthti? mant. Atta khandhdhtuyatana atta n' atthti? mant. 11 #<[page 146]># %<146 KATHVATTHU. [I. 7.>% Paccuppanna khandhdhtuyatana paccuppanna n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Angata khandh angata n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna khandh paccuppanna n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angata yatana angata n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna yatana paccuppanna n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angata dhtu angata n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna dhtu paccuppanna n' atthti? mant. Angata khandhdhtuyatana angata n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna khandhdhtuyatana paccuppanna n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Atta rpa khandho ti? mant. Atta rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta rpa yatanan ti? mant. Atta rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta rpa dhatti? mant. Atta rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta rpa khandhdhtuyatanan ti? mant. Atta rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Angata rpa khandho ti? mant. #<[page 147]># %% Angata rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rpa yatanan ti? mant. Angata rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rpa dhatti? mant. Angata rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rpa khandhdhtuyatanan ti? mant. Angata rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Paccuppanna rpa khandho, paccuppanna rpa atthti? mant. Atta rpa khandho, atta rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Paccuppanna rpa yatana --pe-- paccuppanna rpa dhtu --pe-- paccuppanna rpa khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna rpa atthti? mant. Atta rpa khandhdhtuyatana, atta rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Paccuppanna rpa khandho, paccuppanna rpa atthti? mant. Angata rpa khandho, angata rpa atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Paccuppanna rpa yatana --pe-- paccuppanna rpa dhtu --pe-- paccuppanna rpa khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna rpa atthti? mant. Angata rpa khandhdhtuyatana, angata rpa atthiti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 148]># %<148 KATHVATTHU. [I. 7.>% 11. Atta rpa khandho, atta rpa n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa khandho, paccuppanna rpa n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta rpa yatana --pe-- atta rpa dhtu -- pe -- atta rpa khandhdhtuyatana, atta rpa n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna rpa n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Angata rpa khandho, angata rpa n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa khandho, paccuppanna rpa n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rpa yatana --pe-- angata rpa dhtu --pe-- angata rpa khandhdhtuyatana, angata rpa n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna rpa khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna rpa n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Att vedan, att sa, att sakhr, atta via khandho ti? mant. Atta via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta {via} yatana --pe-- atta via dhtu --pe-- atta via khandhdhtuyatanan ti? mant. Atta via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Angat vedan, angat sa, angat sakhr, angata via khandho ti? mant. #<[page 149]># %% Angata via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata {via} yatana --pe-- angata via dhtu --pe-- angata via khandhdhtuyatanan ti? mant. Angata via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Paccuppanna via khandho paccuppanna via atthti? mant. Atta via khandho atta via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna via yatana --pe-- paccuppanna via dhtu --pe-- paccuppanna via khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna via atthti? mant. Atta via khandhdhtuyatana atta via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Paccuppanna via khandho, paccuppanna via atthti? mant. Angata via khandho, angata via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna via yatana --pe-- paccuppanna via dhtu --pe-- paccuppanna via khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna via atthti? mant. Angata via khandhdhtuyatana, angata via atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Atta via khandho, atta via n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna via khandho, paccuppanna via n' atthti? #<[page 150]># %<150 KATHVATTHU. [I. 7.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta via yatana --pe-- atta via dhtu --pe-- atta via khandhdhtuyatana, atta via n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna via {khandhdhtuyatana}, paccuppanna via n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 18. Angata via khandho, angata via n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna via khandho, paccuppanna via n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata via yatana --pe-- angata via dhtu --pe-- angata via khandhdhtuyatana, angata via n' atthti? mant. Paccuppanna via khandhdhtuyatana, paccuppanna via n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Na vattabba "Attngat khandhdhtuyatana n' atthi c' ete ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Tayo 'me Bhikkhave niruttipath adhivacanapath paattipath --pe-- vihti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Attngat khandhdhtuyatana n' atthi c' ete ti." 20. Attngat khandhdhtuyatana n' atthi c' ete ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ya kici Bhikkhave rpa attngatapaccuppanna ajjhatta v bahiddh v orika v sukhuma v hna v pata v ya dure santike v, aya vuccati rpakkhandho, y kci vedan, y kci sa, ye keci sakhr, ya kici via attngatapaccuppanna ajjhatta v bahiddh v orika v sukhuma v hna v pata v ya dure santike v, #<[page 151]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ aya vuccati viakkhandho ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Attngat khandhdhtuyatana n' atthi c' ete ti." Atta khandh ti kath I.8. 1. Atta atthti? Ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti. Ekacca niruddha ekacca na niruddha, ekacca vigata ekacca na vigata ekacca atthagata ekacca na atthagata, ekacca abbhatthagata ekacca na abbhatthagatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. atta ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Att avipakkavipk dhamm ekacce atthi ekacce n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Att vipakkavipk dhamm ekacce atthi ekacce n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Att avipk dhamm ekacce atthi ekacce n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atta ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Ki atthi ki n' atthti? Att avipakkavipk dhamm te atthi, att vipakkavipk dhamm te n' atthti. Att avipakkavpk dhamm te atthti? #<[page 152]># %<152 KATHVATTHU. [I. 8.>% mant. Att vipakkavipk dhamm te atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att avipakkavipk dhamm te atthti? mant. Att avipk dhamm te atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att vipakkavipk dhamm te n' atthti? mant. Att avipakkavipk dhamm te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att vipakkavipk dhamm te n' atthti? mant. Att avipk dhamm te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att avipakkavipk dhamm te atthti? mant. Nanu att avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh ti? mant. Haci att avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh, no vata re vattabbe "Att avipakkavipk dhamm te atthti. 4. Att avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te atthti? mant. Att vipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te atthti? mant. Att avipk dhamm niruddh te atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att vipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te n' atthti? mant. Att avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att vipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te n' atthti? mant. Att avipk dhamm niruddh te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Att avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te atthti? #<[page 153]># %% mant. Att vipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te n' atthti? mant. Att ekadesam vipakkavipk dhamm ekadesam avipakkavipk dhamm niruddh te ekacce atthi ekacce n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabbam "Att avipakkavipk dhamm te atthti"? mant. Nanu att avipakkavipk dhamm vipccisantti? mant. Haci att avipakkavipk dhamm vipccissanti, tena vata re vattabbe "Att avipakkavipk dhamm te atthti." Att avipakkavipk dhamm vipaccissantti katv te atthti? mant. Vipaccissantti katv paccuppann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vipaccissantti katv paccuppann ti? mant. Paccuppann dhamm nirujjhissantti katv te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Angata atthti? Ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti. Ekacca jta ekacca ajta ekacca sajta ekacca asajta, ekacca nibbatta ekacca anibbatta, ekacca ptubhta ekacca aptubhtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Angat uppdino dhamm ekacce atthi ekacce n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Angat anuppdino dhamm ekacce atthi ekacce n' atthti? #<[page 154]># %<154 KATHVATTHU. [I. 8.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Angata ekacca atthi ekacca n' atthti? mant. Ki atthi ki n' atthti? Angat uppdino dhamm te atthi, angat anuppdino dhamm te n' atthti. Angat uppdino dhamm te atthti? mant. Angat anuppdino dhamm te atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angat anuppdino dhamm te n' atthti? mant. Angat uppdino dhamm te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe. Angat uppdino dhamm te atthti? mant. Nanu angat uppdino dhamm ajt ti? Amant. Haci angat uppdino dhamm ajt, no vata re vattabbe "Angat uppdino dhamm te atthti." 8. Angat uppdino dhamm ajt te atthti? mant. Angat anuppdino dhamm ajt te atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angat anuppdino dhamm ajt te n' atthti? mant. Angat uppdino dhamm ajt te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Na vattabba "Angat uppdino dhamm te atthti"? mant. Nanu angat uppdino dhamm uppajjissantti? mant. Haci angat uppdino dhamm uppajjissanti, tena vata re vattabbe "Angat uppdino dhamm te atthti." 10. Angat uppdino dhamm uppajjissantti katv te atthti? mant. #<[page 155]># %% Uppajjissantti katv paccuppann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uppajjissantti katv paccuppann ti? mant. Paccuppann dhamm nirujjhissantti katv te n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekacca atthtikath. I.9. 1. Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Sabbe dhamm sati satindriya satibala sammsati satibojjhago, ekyanamaggo khayagm bodhagm apacayagm, ansav asaojany aganthany anoghany ayogany anvaray aparmah anuppdniy asakilesik, sabbe dhamm buddhnussati dhammnussati saghnussati slnussati cgnussati devatnussati npnasati maranussati kyagatsati upasamnussatti? Na h' eva vattabbe. 2. Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Cakkhyatana satipahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhyatana satipahnan ti? mant. Cakkhyatana sati satindriya satibala sammsati satibojjhago ekyanamaggo khayagm bodhgm apacayagm, ansava asaojanya aganthanya anoghanya ayoganya anvaraya aparmaha anupdniya asakilesika, cakkhyatana buddhnussati dhammnussati saghnussati slnussati cgnussati devatnussati npnasati maranussati kyagatsati upasamn ussatti? #<[page 156]># %<156 KATHVATTHU. [I. 9.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sotyatana ghnyatana jivhyatana kyyatana rpyatana saddyatana gandhyatana rasyatana phohabbyatana, rgo doso moho mno dihi vicikicch thna uddhacca ahirika anottappa satipahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anottappa satipahnan ti? mant. Anottappa sati satindriya satibala sammsati satibojjhago ekyanamaggo khayagm bodhagm apacayagm ansava asaojanya aganthanya anoghanya ayoganya anvaraya aparmaha anupdniya asakilesika, anottappa buddhnussati dhammnussati saghnussati slnussati cgnussati devatnussati npnasati maranussati kyagatsati upasamnussatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sati satipahn s ca satti? mant. Cakkhyatana satipahna ta ca satti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sati satipahn s ca satti? mant. Sotyatana ghnyatana jivhyatana kyyatana rpyatana saddyatana gandhyatana rasyatana phohabbyatana, rgo doso moho mno dihi vicikicch thna uddhacca ahirika anottappa satipahna ta ca satti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhyatana satipahna ta ca na satti? mant. Sati satipahn s ca na satti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotyatana ghnyatana --pe-- anottappa satipahna ta ca na satti? #<[page 157]># %% mant. Sati satipahn s ca na satti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti?" mant. Nanu sabbe dhamme rabbha sati santihatti? mant. Haci sabbe dhamme rabbha sati santihati, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti." Sabba dhamma rabbha sati santihatti, sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Sabba dhamma rabbha phasso santihatti, sabbe dhamm phassapahn ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabba dhamma rabbha sati santihatti, sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Sabba dhamma rabbha vedan santihati, sa santihati, cetan santihati, citta santihatti, sabbe dhamm cittapahn ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Sabbe satt upahitasatino satiy samanngat satiy samohit sabbesa sattna sati paccupahit ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Amatan te Bhikkhave na paribhujanti ye kyagata sati na paribhujanti, amatan te Bhikkhave paribhujanti ye kyagata sati paribhujantti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Sabbe satt {kyagata} sati paribhujanti pailabhanti sevanti bhventi bahulkarontti? #<[page 158]># %<158 KATHVATTHU. I. 9.]>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ekyano aya Bhikkhave maggo sattna visuddhiy sokaparidevna samatikkamya dukkhadomanassna ahagamya yassa adhigamya nibbnassa sacchikiriyya yadida cattro satipahn ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Sabbe dhamm ekyanamaggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Rao Bhikkhave Cakkavattissa ptubhv sattanna ratanna ptubhvo hoti. Katamesa sattanna? Cakkaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, hatthiratanassa ptubhvo hoti, assaratanassa, mairatanassa, itthiratanassa, gahapatiratanassa, pariyakaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, rao Bhikkhave Cakkavattissa ptubhv imesa sattanna ratanna ptubhvo hoti. Tathgatassa Bhikkhave ptubhv Aragato Sammsambuddhassa sattanna bojjhagaratanna ptubhvo hoti. Katamesa sattanna? {Satisambojjhagaratanassa} ptubhvo hoti, dhammavicayasambojjhagaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, viriyasambojjhagaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, ptisambojjhagaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, passaddhisambojjhagaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, samdhisambojjhagaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, upekkhsambojjhagaratanassa ptubhvo hoti, Tathgatassa Bhikkhave Arahato Sammsambuddhassa imesa sattanna bojjhagaratanna ptubhvo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tathgatassa ptubhv sammsambuddhassa sabbe dhamm satisambojjhagaratan va hontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 159]># %<[I. 10. KATHVATTHU. 159>% 9. Sabbe dhamm satipahn ti? mant. Sabbe dhamm sammappadhn, iddhipd, indriy, bal, bojjhag ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Satipahnakath. I.10. 1. Atta atthti? H' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Angata atthti? H' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti? S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Paccuppanna atthti? H' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? #<[page 160]># %<160 KATHVATTHU. I. 10.]>% mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atta h' ev' atthi h' eva 'atthti? mant. Kint' atthi kinti na' atthti? Atta attan ti h' ev' atthi, atta angatan ti h' eva n' atthi, atta paccuppannan ti h' eva n' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' attaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Angata h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti? mant. Kint' atthi kinti n' atthti? Angata angatan ti h' ev' atthi, angata attan ti h' eva n' atthi, angata paccuppannan ti h' eva h' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Paccuppanna h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti? mant. Kint' atthi kinti n' atthti? Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti h' ev' atthi, paccuppanna attan ti h' eva n' atthi, #<[page 161]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ paccuppanna angatan ti h' eva h' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Atta h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, angata h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, paccuppanna h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti"? mant. Atta angatan ti h' ev' atthi, atta paccuppannan ti h' ev' atthi, angata attan ti h' ev' atthi, angata paccuppannan ti h' ev' atthi, paccuppanna attan ti h' ev' atthi, paccuppanna angatan ti h' ev' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi atta h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, angata h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, paccuppanna h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. 8. Rpa atthti? H' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Vedan, sa, sakhr, via atthti? H' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. #<[page 162]># %<162 KATHVATTHU. [I. 10.>% S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Rpa h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti? mant. Kint' atthi kinti n' atthti? Rpa rpan ti h' ev' atthi, rpa vedan ti h' eva n' atthi --pe-- rpa sa ti h' eva n' atthi --pe-- rpa sakhr ti h' eva n' atthi, rpa vian ti h' eva n' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho n' atthaho atthaho, atthibhvo n' atthibhvo n' atthibhvo atthibhvo, atthti v n' atthti v n' atthti v atthti v, esese ekahe same samabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Vedan, sa, sakhr, via h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti? mant. Kint' atthi kinti n' atthti? Via vian ti h' ev' atthi, via rpan ti h' eva n' atthi --pe-- via vedan ti h' eva n' atthi --pe-- via sa ti h' eva n' atthi --pe-- via sakhr ti h' eva n' atthti. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe--. S' ev' atthi s' eva n' atthti? mant. Atthaho n' atthaho --pe-- tajjte ti? #<[page 163]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Na vattabbam "Rpa h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti, vedan h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti, sa h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti, sakhr h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti, via h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti?" mant. Rpa vedan ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- rpa sa ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- rpa sakhr ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- rpa vian ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- vedan, sa, sakhr, via rpan ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- via vedan ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- via sa ti h' ev' atthi --pe-- via sakhr ti h' ev' atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi rpa h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, vedan h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, sa h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, sakhr h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthi, via h' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. H' ev' atthikath. Tassa uddna Upalabbho, Parihna, Brahmacariyavso, Odhiso, {Parikmargappahna,} Sabbatthivdo, yatana, Attngatesu bhgo, Sabbe dhamm satipahn, H' ev' atthi h' eva n' atthti. Mahvaggo. II.1. 1. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. #<[page 164]># %<164 KATHVATTHU. [II. 1.>% Atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna {kmargasaojana} kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraan ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraa, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." 2. Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisahi, atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraan ti? mant. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahi, atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna --pe-- kmacchandanvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahi, n' atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna --pe-- kmacchandanvaraan ti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisahi, n' atthi tassa rgo kmargo kmargapariyuhna --pe-- kmacchandanvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Ken' atthenti? Handa hi Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti. Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti? mant. Atthi Mrakyikna devatna asucisukkavisahti? #<[page 165]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Mrakyikna devatna asucisukkavisahti? mant. Haci n' atthi Mrakyikna devatna asucisukkavisahi, no vata re vattabbe "Mrakyikna devatna Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti." 4. Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti? mant. Mrakyik devat attano asucisukkavisahi upasaharanti, aesa asucisukkavisahi upasaharanti, tassa asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mrakyik devat n' ev' attano na aesa na tassa asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti? mant. Haci Mrakyik devat n' ev' attano na aesa na tassa asucisukkavisahi upasakharanti, no vata re vattabbe "Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti." 5. Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti? mant. {Lomakpehi} upasaharantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mrakyik devat Arahato asucisukkavisahi upasaharantti? mant. Kikra ti? Handa hi vimati ghayissmti. Atthi Arahato vimatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato vimatti? mant. Atthi Arahato Satthari vimati, Dhamme vimati Saghe vimati, sikkhya vimati, pubbante vimati, aparante vimati, #<[page 166]># %<166 KATHVATTHU. [II. 1.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ pubbantparante vimati, idappaccayatpaiccasamupannesu dhammesu vimatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato Satthari vimati, Dhamme vimati, Saghe vimati, sikkhya vimati, pubbante vimati, aparante vimati, pubbantparante vimati, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu vimatti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato Satthari vimati --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu vimati, na vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato vimatti." 6. Atthi puthujjanassa vimati, atthi tassa Satthari vimati --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu vimatti? mant. Atthi Arahato vimati, atthi tassa Satthari vimati -- pe -- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu vimatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato vimati, n' atthi tassa Satthari vimati --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu vimatti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa vimati, n' atthi tassa Satthari vimati --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu vimatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Arahato asucisukkavisahi kissa nissando ti? Asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando ti. Arahato asucisukkavisahi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissanto ti? mant. Ye keci asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, sabbesa eva atthi asucisukkavisahti? #<[page 167]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ye keci asanti, pivanti khyanti, syanti, sabbesa eva atthi asucisukkavisahti? mant. Drak asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, atthi drakna asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paak asanti, pivanti khyanti, syanti atthi paakna asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dev asanti, pivanti, khyanti, syanti, atthi devatna asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Arahato asucisukkavisahi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando ti? mant. Atthi tassa sayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato uccrapassvo asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, atthi tassa sayo ti? mant. Arahato asucisukkavisahi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, atthi tassa sayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato asucisukkavisahi asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, n' atthi tassa sayo ti? mant. Arahato uccrapassvo asitapitakhyitasyitassa nissando, n' atthi tassa sayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Arah methuna dhamma paiseveyya, methuna dhamma uppdeyya, puttasambdhasayana ajjhvaseyya, ksikacandana paccanubhaveyya, mlgandhavilepana dhreyya, jtarparajata sdiyeyyti? #<[page 168]># %<168 KATHVATTHU. [II. 1.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisahi, puthujjano methuna dhamma paiseveyya, methuna dhamma uppdeyya --pe-- jtarparajata sdiyeyyti? mant. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahi, Arah methuna dhamma paiseveyya, methuna dhamma uppdeyya --pe-- jtarparajata sdiyeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahi, na ca Arah methuna dhamma paiseveyya, methuna dhamma uppdeyya --pe-- jtarparajata sdiyeyyti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa asucisukkavisahi, na ca puthujjano methuna dhamma paiseveyya, methuna dhamma uppdeyya, puttasambdhasayana ajjhvaseyya, ksikacandana paccanubhveyya, mlgandhavilepana dhreyya, jtarparajata sdiyeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgo panno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Nanu Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno, mno pahno, dihi pahn, vicikicch pahn, thna pahna, uddhacca pahna, ahirika pahna --pe-- anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamman ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamma, #<[page 169]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asuciSukkavisahti." 11. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya satipahn bhvit -- pe -- sammappadhn bhvit, iddhipd bhvit, indriy bhvit, bal bhvit --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." 12. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Nanu Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- mohappahnya -- pe -- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." 3. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? mant. Nanu Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho parikkhabhvasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggao ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, dukkha tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, #<[page 170]># %<170 KATHVATTHU. [II.1.>% pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita, sacchiktabba sacchikatan ti? mant. Haci {Arah} vtargo vtadoso vtamoho katakarayo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." 14. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisahi, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi asucisukkavisahti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisahti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi asucisukkavisahti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno, moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappa pahna, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit --pe-- dosappahnya -- pe -- mohappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? #<[page 171]># %% mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso -- pesacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 18. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit --pe-- dosappahnya --pe-- mohappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 20. Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? mant. #<[page 172]># %<172 KATHVATTHU. [II. 1.>% Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho -- pe -- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa asucisukkavisahti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 21. Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ye te Bhikkhave bhikkh puthujjan slasampann satisampajn nidda okkamanti, tesa asuci na muccati. Ye pi te Bhikkhave bhirak isayo kmesu vtarg, tesa pi asuci na muccati. Ahnam eta Bhikkhave anavakso, ya Arahato asuci mucceyyti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." 22. Na vattabba "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti"? mant. Nanu Arahato cvarapiaptasensanagilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra pare upasahareyyun ti? mant. Haci Arahato cvarapiaptasensanagilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra pare upasahareyyu, tena vata re vattabbe. "Atthi Arahato asucisukkavisahti." 23. Arahato cvarapiaptasensanagilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra pare upasahareyyun ti, atthi Arahato parpahro ti? mant. Arahato sotpattiphala v sakadgmiphala v angmiphala v arahatta v pare upasahareyyun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Parpahrakath. #<[page 173]># %% II.2. 1. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Atthi Arahato avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraan ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato avijj --pe-- avijjnvaraa, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aaan ti" 2. Atthi puthujjanassa aa, atthi tassa avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraan ti? mant. Atthi Arahato aa, atthi tassa avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjnusayo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi Arahato aa, n' atthi tassa avijj --pe-- avijjnvaraan ti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa aa, n' atthi tassa avijj --pe-- avijjnvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Arah aapakato pa haneyya, adinna diyeyya, mus bhaeyya, pisua bhaeyya, pharusa bhaeyya, samphappalapeyya, sandhi chindeyya, nillopa hareyya, ekagrika kareyya, paripanthe tiheyya, paradra gaccheyya, gmaghta kareyya, nigamaghta kareyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi puthujjanassa aa, puthujjano aapakato pa haneyya, #<[page 174]># %<174 KATHVATTHU. [II. 2.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ adinna diyeyya --pe-- nigamaghta kareyyti? mant. Atthi Arahato aa, Arah aapakato pa haneya, adinna diyeyya --pe-- nigamaghta kareyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atthi Arahato aa, na ca Arah aapakato pa haneyya, adinna diyeyya --pe-- nigamaghta kareyyti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa aa, na ca puthujjano aapakato pa haneyya, adinna diyeyya --pe-- nigamaghta kareyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Atthi Arahato Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa, sikkhya aa, pubbante aa, aparante aa, pubbantparante aa, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa, sikkhya aa, pubbante aa, aparante aa pubbantparante aa, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu aan ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu aa, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 7. Atthi puthujjanassa aa, atthi tassa Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu dhammesu aan ti? mant. Atthi Arahato aa, atthi tassa Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu aan ti? #<[page 175]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato aa, n' atthi tassa Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu aan ti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa aa, n' atthi tassa Satthari aa, Dhamme aa, Saghe aa --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." Nanu Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamman ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 9. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? #<[page 176]># %<176 KATHVATTHU. [II. 2.>% mant. Haci anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 10. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikatan ti? mant. Haci Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 11. Atthi Arahato aan ti? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi aa, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi aan ti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi aan ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi aan ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno, moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, atti tassa aan ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappa pahna, atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa aan ti? #<[page 177]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa aan ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa aan ti? 13 #<[page 178]># %<178 KATHVATTHU. [II. 2.>% mant. Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa aan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jnatvha Bhikkhave passato savna khaya vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki ca Bhikkhave jnato ki passato savna khayo hoti? Iti rpa, iti rpassa samudayo, iti rpassa atthagamo; iti vedan --pe-- iti sa --pe-- iti sakhr --pe-- iti via, iti viassa samudayo, iti viassa atthagamo ti. Eva kho Bhikkhave jnato eva passato savna khayo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 18. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jnatvha Bhikkhave passato savna khaya vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki ca Bhikkhave jnato ki passato savna khayo hoti? Ida dukkhan ti Bhikkhave jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhasamudayo ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhanirodho ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhanirodhagminpaipad ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti. Eva kho Bhikkhave jnato eva passato savna khayo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 19. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sabba Bhikkhave anabhijna aparijna avirjaya appajaha abhabbo dukkhakkhyya. Sabba ca kho Bhikkhave abhijna parijna virjaya pajaha bhabbo dukkhakkhyyti." #<[page 179]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 20. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sah v' assa dassanasampadya Tayas' su dhamm jahit bhavanti Sakkyadihi vicikicchita ca Slabbata vpi yad atthi kici, Cath' apyehi ca vippamutto Cha cbhihnni abhabbo ktun ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 21. Atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yasmi Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa viraja vtamala dhammacakkhu udapdi, `ya kici samudayadhamma sabban ta nirodhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa ti saojani pahyanti, sakkyadihi vicikicch slabbataparmso ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 22. Na vattabba "Atthi Arahato aan ti"? mant. Nanu Arah ihipurisna nmagotta na jneyya, maggmagga na jneyya, tiakahavanappatna nma na jneyyti? mant. Haci Arah ihipurisna nmagotta na jneyya, maggmagga na jneyya, #<[page 180]># %<180 KATHVATTHU. [II. 3.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tiakahavanappatna nma na jneyya, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato aan ti." 23. Arah ihipurisna nmagotta na jneyya, maggmagga na jneyya, tiakahavanappatna nma na jneyyti, atthi Arahato aan ti? mant. Arah sotpattiphala v sakadgmiphala v angmiphala v arahatta v na jneyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Aakath. II.3. 1. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Atthi Arahato vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraan ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraa, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 2. Atthi puthujjanassa kakh, atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraan ti? mant. Atthi Arahato kakh, atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi Arahato kakh, n' atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraan ti? #<[page 181]># %% mant. Atthi puthujjanassa kakh, n' atthi tassa vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Atthi Arahato Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh, Saghe kakh, sikkhya kakh, pubbante kakh, aparante kakh, pubbantparante kakh, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh, Saghe kakh, sikkhya kakh, pubbante kakh, aparante kakh, pubbantparante kakh, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh Saghe kakh --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 5. Atthi puthujjanassa kakh, atthi tassa Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh, Saghe kakh --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh ti? mant. Atthi Arahato kakh, atthi tassa Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh, Saghe kakh --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato kakh, n' atthi tassa Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh, Saghe kakh --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh ti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa kakh, n' atthi tassa Satthari kakh, Dhamme kakh, Saghe kakh --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? #<[page 182]># %<182 KATHVATTHU. [II. 3.>% mant. Nanu Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." Nanu Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamman ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 7. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 8. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikatan ti? mant. Haci Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 9. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kakh, #<[page 183]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi kakh ti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kakh ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi kakh ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno, moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappa pahna atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Paradhmmakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho #<[page 184]># %<184 KATHVATTHU. [II. 3.>% --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? mant. Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa kakh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jnatvha Bhikkhave passato savna khaya vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki ca Bhikkhave jnato ki passato savna khayo hoti? #<[page 185]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Iti rpa, iti rpassa samudayo, iti rpassa atthagamo; iti vedan --pe-- iti sa --pe-- iti sakhr --pe-- iti via, iti viassa samudayo, iti viassa atthagamo ti. Eva kho Bhikkhave jnato eva passato savna khayo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 16. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jnatvha Bhikkhave passato savna khaya vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki ca Bhikkhave jnato ki passato savna khayo {hoti?} Ida dukkhan ti Bhikkhave jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhasamudayo ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhanirodho ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhanirodhagminpaipad ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti. Eva kho Bhikkhave jnato eva passato savna khayo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 17. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sabba Bhikkhave anabhijna aparijna avirjaya appajaha abhabbo dukkhakkhyya. Sabba ca kho Bhikkhave abhijna parijna virjaya pajaha bhabbo dukkhakkhyyti.' Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 18. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sah v' assa dassanasampadya Tayas su dhamm jahit bhavanti Sakkyadihi vicikicchita ca Slabbata vpi yad atthi kici, #<[page 186]># %<186 KATHVATTHU. [II. 3.>% Cath' apyehi ca vippamutto Cha cbhihnni abhabbo ktun" ti. Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 19. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yasmi Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa viraja vtamala dhammacakkhu udapdi, `ya kici samudayadhamma sabban ta nirodhadhammanti,' saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa ti saojanni pahyanti, sakkyadihi vicikicch slabbataparmso ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 20. Atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yad have ptubhavanti dhamm tpino jhyato brhmaassa, Ath' assa kakh vapayanti sabb Yato pajnti sahetudhamman ti. Yad have ptubhavanti dhamm tpino jhyato brhmaassa, Ath' assa kakh vapayanti sabb Yato khaya paccayna avedti. Yad have ptubhavanti dhamm tpino jhyato brhmaassa Vidhpaya tihati Mrasena Suriyo va obhsaya antalikkhan ti. Ya kci kakh idha v hura v Sakavediy v paravediy v, Jhyino t pajahanti sabb #<[page 187]># %% tpino brahmacariya carant ti." "Ye kakh samatikkant kakhbhtesu pisu Asasay visayutt tesu dinna mahapphalan ti." "Etdis dhammapaksanettha Kin nu tattha kakhati koci svako, Nitia-ogha vicikicchachinna Buddha namassma jina janind ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 21. Na vattabba "Atthi Arahato kakh ti"? mant. Nanu Arah ihipurisna nmagotte kakheyya, maggmagge kakheyya, tiakahavanappatna nme kakheyyti? mant. Haci Arah ihipurisna nmagotte --pe-- tiakahavanappatna nme kakheyya, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato kakh ti." 22. Arah ihipurisna nmagotte --pe-- tiakahavanappatna nme kakheyya, atthi Arahato kakh ti? mant. Arah sotpattiphale v sakadgmiphale v angmiphale v arahatte v kakheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kakhkath. II.4. 1. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? #<[page 188]># %<188 KATHVATTHU. [II. 4.>% mant. Arah paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo {parapaibaddhabh} na jnti, na passati, sammuho asampajno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Arah na paraneyyo, na parapattiyo, na parapaccayo, na parapaibaddhabh jnti, passati, asammuho sampajno ti? mant. Haci Arah na paraneyyo, na parapattiyo, na parapaccayo, na parapaibaddhabh jnti, passati, asammuho sampajno, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 2. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitra, so ca paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapaibaddhabh na jnti, na passati, asammho sampajno ti? mant. Atthi Arahato paravitra, so ca paraneyyo parapattiyo parapaccayo parapaibaddhabh na jnti, na passati, asammuho sampajno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi Arahato paravitra, so ca na paraneyyo na parapattiyo na parapaccayo na parapaibaddhabh jnti, passati, asammho sampajno ti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitra, so ca na paraneyyo na parapattiyo na parapaccayo na parapaibaddhabh jnti, passati, asammho sampajno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Atthi Arahato Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra, sikkhya paravitra, pubbante paravitra, aparante paravitra, pubbantparante paravitra, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra ti? #<[page 189]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra, sikkhya paravitra, pubbante paravitra, aparante paravitraa, pubbantparante paravitra, idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 5. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitra, atthi tassa Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra ti? mant. Atthi Arahato paravitra, atthi tassa Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra -- pe -- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato paravitra, n' atthi {tassa} Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra ti? mant. Atthi puthujjanassa paravitra, n' atthi tassa Satthari paravitra, Dhamme paravitra, Saghe paravitra --pe-- idappaccayatpaiccasamuppannesu dhammesu paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgo pahno ucchinnamlo tlvatthukato anabhvakato yati anuppdadhammo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." #<[page 190]># %<190 KATHVATTHU. [II. 4.>% Nanu Arahato doso pahno --pe-- moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamman ti? mant. Haci Arahato anottappa pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhvakata yati anuppdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato parivitra ti." 7. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci Arahato rgappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? mant. Haci anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 8. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikatan ti? mant. Haci Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 9. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitra, paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi paravitra ti. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitra ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato atthi paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi paravitra ti? #<[page 191]># %% mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato n' atthi paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno, moho pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappa pahna, atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadhammakusalassa Arahato dosappahnya --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Sadhammakusalassa Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Paradhammakusalo Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 192]># %<192 KATHVATTHU. [II. 4.>% 13. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato rgo pahno, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato doso pahno --pe-- anottappa pahna, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Paradhammakusalassa Arahato rgappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit --pe-- anottappappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Sadhammakusalassa Arahato anottappappahnya bojjhag bhvit, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paradhammakusalassa Arah vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? mant. Sadhammakusalo Arah vtargo --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, n' atthi tassa paravitra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jnatvha Bhikkhave passato savna khaya vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki ca Bhikkhave jnato ki passato savna khayo hoti? Iti rpa, iti rpassa samudayo, iti rpassa atthagamo; iti vedan --pe-- iti sa --pe-- iti sakhr --pe-- iti via, iti viassa samudayo, iti viassa atthagamo ti. Eva kho Bhikkhave jnato eva passato savna khayo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 193]># %% mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 16. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti. mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jnatvha Bhikkhave passato savna khaya vadmi, no ajnato no apassato. Ki ca Bhikkhave jnato ki passato savna khayo hoti? Ida dukkhan ti Bhikkhave jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhasamudayo ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhanirodho ti jnto passato savna khayo hoti, aya dukkhanirodhagminpaipad ti jnato passato savna khayo hoti. Eva kho Bhikkhave jnato eva passato savna khayo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 17. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sabba Bhikkhave anabhijna aparijna avirjaya appajaha abhabbo dukkhakkhyya, Sabba ca kho Bhikkhave abhijna parijna virjaya pajaha bhabbo dukkhakkhyyti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 18. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sah v' assa dassanasampadya Tayas' su dhamm jahit bhavanti Sakkyadihi vicikicchita ca Slabbata vpi yad atthi kici, Cath' apyehi ca vippamutto Cha cbhihnni abhabbo ktun ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. 14 #<[page 194]># %<194 KATHVATTHU. [II. 4.>% Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 19. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yasmi Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa viraja vtamala dhammacakkhu udapdi, `ya kici samudayadhamma sabban ta nirodhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa ti saojanni pahyanti sakkyadihi vicikicch slabbataparmso ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 20. Atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Nha gamissmi pamocanya Kathakathi Dhotaka kaci loke, Dhamma ca sha abhijnamno Eva tuva ogha ima taresti."" Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 21. Na vattabba "Atthi Arahato paravitrati"? mant. Nanu Arahato ihipurisna nmagotta pare vitreyyu, maggmagga pare vitreyyu, tiakahavanappatna nma pare vitreyyun ti? mant. Haci Arahato ihipurisna nmagotta pare vitreyyu, maggmagga pare vitreyyu, tiakahavanappatna nma pare vitreyyu, #<[page 195]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato paravitra ti." 22. Arahato ihipurisna nmagotta pare vitreyyu, maggmagga pare vitreyyu, tiakahavanappatna nma pare vitreyyu, atthi Arahato paravitra ti? mant. Arahato sotpattiphala v sakadgmiphala v angmiphala v arahatta v pare vitreyyun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paravitraakath II.5. 1. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sabbattha sampannna atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sabbad sampannna atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- {Sampannassa} atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sabbesa sampannna atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sabbasampattsu atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sampannassa atthi kyabhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 196]># %<196 KATHVATTHU. [II. 5.>% Sampannassa n' atthi kyabhedo ti? mant. Sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sampannassa atthi vc, atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sampannassa atthi kyo, atthi kyabhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi kyo, n' atthi kyabhedo ti? mant. Sampannassa atthi vc, n' atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Dukkhan ti jnanto dukkhan ti vca bhsatti? mant. Samudayo ti jnanto samudayo ti vca bhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhan ti jnanto dukkhan ti vca bhsatti? mant. Nirodho ti jnanto nirodho ti vca bhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhan ti jnanto dukkhan ti vca bhsatti? mant. Maggo ti jnanto maggo ti vca bhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Samudayo ti jnanto na ca samudayo ti vca bhsatti? mant. Dukkhan ti jnanto na ca dukkhan ti vca bhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodho ti jnanto na ca nirodho ti vca bhsatti? mant. Dukkhan ti jnanto na ca dukkhan ti vca bhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggo ti jnanto na ca maggo ti vca bhsatti? mant. Dukkhan ti jnanto na ca dukkhan ti vca bhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? #<[page 197]># %% mant. a kigocaran ti? a saccagocaran ti. Sota saccagocaran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Sota kigocaran ti? Sota saddagocaran ti. a saddagocaran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo, a saccagocara, sota saddagocaran ti? mant. Haci a saccagocara, sota saddagocara, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo, a saccagocara, sota saddagocaran ti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna vedanna dvinna sana dvinna cetanna dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Pahavkasia sampatti sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. pokasia --pe-- tejokasia, vyokasia, nlakasia, ptakasia, lohitakasia, odtakasia sampatti --pe-- ksnacyatana, viacyatana, kicayatana --pe-- nevasansayatana sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 198]># %<198 KATHVATTHU. [II. 5.>% 9. Pahavkasia sampatti sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Haci pahavkasia sampatti sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." pokasia --pe-- odtakasia sampatti --pe-- ksnacyatana, viacyatana, kicayatana --pe-- nevasansayatana sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Haci nevasansayatana sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." 10. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokiya sampatti sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokiya pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokiya dutiya jhna --pe-- tatiya jhna --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Lokiya sampatti sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Haci lokiya sampatti sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." Lokiya pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? #<[page 199]># %% mant. Haci lokiya pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." Lokiya dutiya --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Haci lokiya dutiya --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." 12. Lokuttara pathama jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokiya pahama {jhna} sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokiya dutiya --pe-- tatiya --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokiya pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokuttara pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokiya dutiya --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokuttara pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Lokuttara pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokuttara dutiya jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? #<[page 200]># %<200 KATHVATTHU. [II. 5.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttaram pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokuttara tatiya --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara dutiya jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokuttara pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara tatiya --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Lokuttara pahama jhna sampannassa n' atthi vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Na vattabba "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti"? mant. Nanu vitakkavicr vacsakhr vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr ti? mant. Haci vitakkavicr vacsakhr vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, tena vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." 15. Vitakkavicr vacsakhr vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicra, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? mant. Pahavkasia pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vitakkavicr vacsakhr vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? #<[page 201]># %% mant. pokasia --pe-- tejokasiam, vyokasiam, nlakasia, ptakasia, lohitakasia --pe-- odtakasia pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicra, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Na vattabba "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti"? mant. Nanu vitakkasamuhn vc vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr ti? mant. Haci vitakkasamuhn vc vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicra, tena vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." 17. Vitakkasamuhn vc vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicra, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? mant. Sasamuhn vc vutt Bhagavat, dutiya jhna sampannassa atthi sa, atthi tassa vitakkavicr ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vitakkasamuhn vc vutt Bhagavat, pahama jhna sampannassa atthi vitakkavicr, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? mant. Sasamuhn vc vutt Bhagavat, ttiya jhna --pe-- catuttha jhna, ksnacyatana, viacyatana, kicayatana sampannassa atthi sa, atthi tassa vitakkavicr ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 18. Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. Nanu "pahama jhna sampannassa vc niruddh hotti," atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 202]># %<202 KATHVATTHU. II. 5.>% mant. Haci pahama jhna sampannassa vc niruddh hotti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." 19. "Pahama jhna sampannassa vc niruddh hotti," atth' eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? mant. "Dutiya jhna sampannassa vitakkavicr niruddh honti," atth' eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa vitakkavicr ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Pahama jhna sampannassa vc niruddh hotti," atth' eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa vacbhedo ti? mant. "Tatiya jhna sampannassa pti niruddh hoti --pe-- catuttha jhna sampannassa asssapasss niruddh honti, ksnacyatana sampannassa rpasa niruddh hoti, viacyatana sampannassa ksnacyatanasa niruddh hoti, kicayatana sampannassa viacyatanasa niruddh hoti -- pe -- nevasansayatana sampannassa kicayatanasa niruddh hoti, savedayitanirodha sampannassa sa ca vedan ca niruddh hontti," atth' eva suttanto ti, atthi tassa sa ca vedan cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 20. Na vattabba "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti"? mant. Nanu pahamassa jhnassa saddo kahako vutto Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci pahamassa jhnassa saddo kahako vutto Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti." 21. Pahamassa jhnassa saddo kahako vutto Bhagavat ti, sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti? mant. #<[page 203]># %% Dutiyassa jhnassa vitakkavicr kahako vutt Bhagavat --pe-- tatiyassa jhnassa pti kahako vutt Bhagavat --pe-- catutthassa jhnassa asssapasss kahako vutt Bhagavat, ksnacyatana sampannassa rpasa kahako vutt Bhagavat, viacyatana sampannassa ksnacyatanasa kahako vutt Bhagavat, kicayatana sampannassa viacyatanasa kahako vutt Bhagavat, nevasansayatana sampannassa kicayatanasa kahako vutt Bhagavat --pe-- savedayitanirodha sampannassa sa ca vedan ca kahako vutt Bhagavat, atthi tassa sa ca vedan cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 22. Na vattabba "Sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sikhissa nada Bhagavato Arahato Sammsambuddhassa abhibh nma svako brahmaloke hito sahassilokadhtu sarena vipesi. rabbhatha nikkamatha Yujatha Buddhassane, Dhuntha maccuno sena Nagra v kujaro. Yo imasmi dhammavinaye Appamatto viharissati, Pahya jtisasra Dukkhass' anta karissatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi sampannassa atthi vacbhedo ti. Vacbhedakath. II.6. 1. Dukkhhro maggaga maggapariypannan ti? #<[page 204]># %<204 KATHVATTHU. [II.7.>% mant. Ye keci "dukkhan ti" vca bhsanti, sabbe te magga bhventti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ye keci "dukkhan ti" vca bhsanti, sabbe te magga bhventti? mant. Blaputhujjan dukkhan ti" vca bhsanti, blaputhujjan magga bhventti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mtughtak --pe-- pitughtak, arahantaghtak, {rpiruppdak} --pe-- saghabhedak "dukkhan ti" vca bhsanti, saghabhedak magga bhventti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhhrakath. II.7. 1. Eka citta divasa tihatti? mant. Upahadivaso uppdakkhao, upahadivaso vayakkhao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Eka citta dve divase tihatti? mant. Divaso uppdakkhao, divaso vayakkhao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Eka citta cattro divase tihati --pe-- aha divase tihati, dasa divase tihati, vsati divase tihati, msa tihati, dve mse tihati, cattro mse tihati, aha mse tihati, dasa mse tihati, savacchara tihati, dve vassni tihati, cattri vassni tihati, aha vassni tihati, dasa vassni tihati, vsati vassni tihati, tisa vassni tihati, cattrsa vassni tihati, pasa vassni tihati, vassasata tihati, dve vassasatni tihati, #<[page 205]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ cattri vassasatni tihati, paca vassasatni tihati, vassasahassa tihati, dve vassasahassni tihati, cattri vassasahassni tihati, aha vassasahassni tihati, soasa vassasahassni tihati, kappa tihati, dve kappe tihati, aha kappe tihati, soasa kappe tihati, battisa kappe tihati, catusah kappe tihati, paca kappasatni tihati, kappasahassa tihati, dve kappasahassni tihati, aha kappasahassni tihati, soasa kappasahassni tihati, vsati kappasahassni tihati, cattrsa kappasahassni tihati, sahikappasahassni tihati, --pe-- catursti {kappasahassni} tihatti? mant. Dve cattrsa kappasahassni updakkhao, dve cattrsa kappasahassni vayakkhao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Eka citta divasa tihatti? mant. Atth' ae dhamm ekha bahu pi uppajjitv nirujjhantti? mant. Te dhamm cittena lahuparivatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Te dhamm cittena lahuparivatt ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Nha Bhikkhave aa eka dhamma pi samanupassmi eva lahuparivatta yathayida cittam. Yva c' ida Bhikkhave upam pi na sukar yva lahuparivatta cittan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Te dhamm cittena lahuparivatt ti." 3. Te dhamm cittena lahuparivatt ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Seyyathpi Bhikkhave makkao arae pavane caramno skha gahti, #<[page 206]># %<206 KATHVATTHU. [II. 7.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ta mucitv aa gahti, ta mucitv aa gahti, evameva kho Bhikkhave yadida vuccati "citta iti pi," "mano iti pi," "via iti pi," ta rattiy ca divasassa ca aad eva uppajjati, aa nirujjhatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Te dhamm cittena lahuparivatt ti." 4. Eka citta divasa tihatti? mant. Cakkhuvia divasa tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotavia --pe-- ghnavia, jivhvia, kyavia, akusala citta, rgasahagata dosasahagata mohasahagata mnasahagata dihisahagata vicikicchsahagata thnasahagata uddhaccasahagata ahirikasahagata anottappasahagata citta divasa tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Eka citta divasa tihatti? mant. Yen' eva cittena cakkhun rpa passati, ten' eva cittena sotena sadda suti --pe-- ghnena gandha ghyati, jivhya rasa syati, kyena phohabba phusati --pe-- manas dhamma vijnti --pe-- yen' eva cittena manas dhamma vijnti, ten' eva cittena cakkhun rpa passati --pe-- sotena sadda suti, ghnena gandha ghyati, jivhya rasa syati, kyena phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Eka citta divasa tihatti? mant. Yen' eva cittena abhikkamati ten' eva cittena paikkamati, yen' eva cittena paikkamati ten' eva cittena abhikkamati, yen' eva cittena loketi ten' eva cittena viloketi. #<[page 207]># %% yen' eva cittena viloketi ten' eva cittena loketi, yen' eva cittena sammijeti ten' eva cittena pasreti, yen' eva cittena pasreti ten' eva cittena sammijetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. ksnacyatanpagna devna eka citta yvatyuka tihatti? mant. Manussna eka citta yvatyuka tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- ksnacyatanpagna devna eka citta yvatyuka tihatti? mant. Ctummahrjikna devna --pe-- Tvatisna devna, Ymna devna, Tusitna devna, Nimmnaratna devna, Paranimmitavasavattna devna, Brahmaprisajjna devna, Brahmaparohitna devna, Mahbrahmna devna, Parittbhna devna, Appambhna devna, bhassarna devna, Parittasubhna devna, Appamasubhna, devna, Subhakina devna, Vehapphalna devna, Avihna devna, Atappna devna, Sudassna devna, Sudassna devna -- pe -- Akanihna devna eka citta yvatyuka tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. ksnacyatanpagna devna vsati kappasahassni yuppama, ksnacyatanpagna devna eka citta vsati kappasahassni tihatti? mant. Manussna vassasata yuppama, manussna eka citta vassasata tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- ksnacyatanpagna devna vsati kappasahassni yuppama, ksnacyatanpagna devna eka citta vsati kappasahassni tihatti? mant. #<[page 208]># %<208 KATHVATTHU. [II. 8.>% Ctummahrjikna devna paca vassasatni yuppama, ctummahrjikna devna eka citta paca vassasatni tihati --pe-- vassasahassa tihati, dve vassasahassni tihati, cattri vassasahassni tihati, aha vassasahassni tihati, soasa vassasahassni tihati, kappassa tatiyabhga tihati, upahakappa tihati, eka kappa tihati, dve kappe tihati, cattro kappe tihati, aha kappe tihati, soasa kappe tihati, battisa kappe tihati, {catusah} kappe tihati, paca kappasatni tihati, kappasahassa tihati, dve kappasahassni tihati, cattri kappasahassni tihati, aha kappasahassni tihati --pe-- Akanihagna devna soasa kappasahassni yuppama, Akanihagna devna eka citta soasa kappasahassni tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. ksnacyatanpagna devna citta muhutta muhutta uppajjati, muhutta muhutta nirujjhatti? mant. ksnacyatanpag dev muhutta muhutta cavanti, muhutta muhutta uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. ksnacyatanpagna devna eka citta yvatyuka tihatti? mant. ksnacyatanpag dev yen' eva cittena uppajjanti, ten' eva cittena cavantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cittahikath. II.8. 1. Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti? mant. Nanu atthi sukh vedan, kyika sukha, cetasika sukha, #<[page 209]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ dibba sukha, mnusaka sukha, lbhasukha, sakkrasukha, ynasukha, sayanasukha, issariyasukha, adhipaccasukha, {gihsukha,} smaasukha, ssava sukha, ansava sukha, upadhisukha, nirupadhisukha, smisa sukha, nismisa sukha, sapptika sukha, nipptika sukha, jhnasukha, vimuttasukha, kmasukha, nekkhammasukha, pavivekasukha, upasamasukha, sambodhisukhan ti? mant. Haci atthi sukh vedan --pe-- sambodhisukha, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." 2. Na vattabba "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sabba Bhikkhave ditta. Ki ca Bhikkhave sabba dia? Cakkhu Bhikkhave ditta, rp ditt, cakkhuvia ditta, cakkhusamphasso ditto, ya p' ida cakkhusamphassapaccay uppajjati vedayita sukha v dukkha v adukkhamasukha v, ta pi diha. Kena ditta? Rgaggin dosaggin mohaggin ditta, jtiy jarmaraena, sokehi paridevehi dukkhehi domanassehi upysehi dittan ti vadmi. Sota ditta, sadd ditt --pe-- ghna ditta, gandh ditt --pe-- jivh ditt, ras ditt --pe-- kyo ditto, phohabb ditt -- pe -- mano ditto, dhamm ditt, manovia ditta, manosamphasso ditto, ya p' ida manosamphassapaccay uppajjati vedayita sukha v dukkha v adukkhamasukha v, ta pi ditta. Kena ditta? Rgaggin dosaggin mohaggin ditta, jtiy jarmaraena, sokehi paridevehi dukkhehi domanassehi upysehi dittan ti vadmti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 210]># %<210 KATHVATTHU. [II. 8.>% Tena hi sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti. 3. Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' ime Bhikkhave kmagu. Katame paca? Cakkhuvieyy rp ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany, sotavieyy sadd --pe-- ghnavieyy gandh --pe-- jivhvieyy ras --pe-- kyavieyy phohabb ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany: ime kho Bhikkhave paca kmagu ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." 4. Na vattabba "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Lbh vo Bhikkhave, suladdha vo Bhikkhave, khao vo paividdho brahmacariyavsya. Dih may Bhikkhave cha phassyatanik nma niray, tattha ya kici cakkhun rpa passati, aniharpa eva passati, no iharpa; akantarpa eva passati, no kantarpa; amanparpa eva passati, no manparpa: ya kici sotena sadda suti --pe-- ghnena gandha ghyati --pe-- jivhya rasa syati --pe-- kyena phohabba phusati --pe-- manas dhamma vijnti, aniharpa eva vijnti, no iharpa; akantarpa eva vijnti, no kantarpa; amanparpa eva vijnti, no manparpan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti. 5. Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti? mant. {Nanu} vutta Bhagavat -- "Lbh vo Bhikkhave, suladdha vo Bhikkhave, khao vo paividdho brahmacariyavsya. Dih may Bhikkhave cha phassyatanik nma sagg, #<[page 211]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tattha ya kici cakkhun rpa passati, iharpa eva passati, no aniharpa; kantarpa eva passati, no akantarpa; manparpa eva passati, no amanparpa: ya kici sotena sadda suti --pe-- ghnena gandha ghyati --pe-- jivhya rasa syati --pe-- kyena phohabba phusati --pe-- manas dhamma vijnti, iharpa eva vijnti, no aniharpa; kantarpa eva passati, no akantarpa; manparpa eva passati, no amanparpan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." 6. Na vattabba "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti"? mant. Nanu yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, sabbe sakhr anicc ti? mant. Haci yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, sabbe sakhr anicc, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." 7. Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti? mant. Dna anihaphala akantaphala amanuaphala secanakaphala dukkhindriya {dukkhavipkan} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla --pe-- uposatho --pe-- bhvan --pe-- brahmacariya anihaphala akantaphala amanuaphala secanakaphala dukkhindriya dukkhavipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu dna ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipkan ti? mant. Haci dna ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipka, #<[page 212]># %<212 KATHVATTHU. [II. 9.>% no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." Nanu sla --pe-- uposatho --pe-- bhvan --pe-- brahmacariya ihaphala kantaphala manuphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipkan ti? mant. Haci brahmacariya ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipka, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." 8. Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sukho viveko tuhassa Sutadhammassa passato Abypajjha sukha loke Pnabhtesu saamo. Sukh virgat loke Kmna samatikkamo Asmimnassa yo vinayo Eta ve parama sukha. Ta sukhena sukha patta Accanta sukha eva ta Tisso vijj anuppatt Eta ve parama sukhan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Sabbe sakhr anodhikatv kukku ti." Kukkuakath. II.9. 1. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? mant. #<[page 213]># %% Anupubbena sotpattimagga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anupubbena sotpattimagga bhvetti? mant. Anupubbena sotpattiphala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? {mant.} Anupubbena sakadgmimagga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anupubbena sakadgmimagga bhvetti? mant. Anupubbena sakadgmiphala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? mant. Anupubbena angmimagga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anupubbena angmimagga bhvetti? mant. Anupubbena angmiphala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? mant. Anupubbena arahattamagga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anupubbena arahattamagga bhvetti? mant. Anupubbena arahattaphala sacchikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga sotpanno, catubhga na sotpanno; catubhga sotpattiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, #<[page 214]># %<214 KATHVATTHU. [II. 9.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharati; catubhga sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj, Buddhe aveccappasdena samanngato, Dhamme --pe-- Saghe --pe-- ariyakantehi slehi samanngato, catubhga na ariyakantehi slehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Samudayadassanena --pe-- nirodhadassanena --pe-- maggadassanena ki jahatti? Sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga sotpanno, catubhga na sotpanno; catubhga sotpattiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharati; catubhga sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj, Buddhe aveccappasdena samanngato, Dhamme --pe-- Saghe --pe-- ariyakantehi slehi samanngato, catubhga na ariyakantehi slehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Orika kmarga orika bypda tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga sakadgm, catubhga na sakadgm; catubhga sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayadassanena --pe-- nirodhadassanena --pe-- maggadassanena ki jahatti? Orika kmarga orika bypda tad ekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga sakadgm, catubhga na sakadgm; catubhga sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, #<[page 215]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga angm, catubhga na angm; catubhga angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharati; catubhga antarparinibby --pe-- upahaccaparinibby --pe-- asakhraparinibby --pe-- sasakhraparinibby -- pe uddhasoto akanihagm, catubhga na uddhasoto na akanihagm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayadassanena --pe-- nirodhadassanena --pe-- maggadassanena ki jahatti? Ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga angm, catubhga na angm; catubhga angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharati; catubhga antarparinibby --pe-- upahaccaparinibby --pe-- asakhraparinibby --pe-- sasakhraparinibby -- pe -- uddhasoto akanihagm, catubhga na uddhasoto na akanihagm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkhadassanena ki jahatti? Rparga arparga mna uddhacca avijja tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga Arah, catubhga na Arah; catubhga arahattappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharati; #<[page 216]># %<216 KATHVATTHU. [II. 9.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ catubhga vtargo vtadoso vtamoho katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visauto suvijitavijayo, dukkhan tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, catubhga sacchiktabba na sacchikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayadassanena --pe-- nirodhadassanena --pe-- maggadassanena ki jahatti? Rparga arparga mna uddhacca avijja tadekahe ca kilese catubhga jahatti. Catubhga Arah, catubhga na Arah; catubhga arahattappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, catubhga na kyena phusitv viharati; catubhga vtargo vtadoso vtamoho katakarayo ohitabhro anuppattasadattho parikkhabhavasaojano sammada vimutto ukkhittapaligho sakiaparikho abbuhesiko niraggalo ariyo pannaddhajo pannabhro visautto suvijitavijayo, dukkhan tassa parita, samudayo pahno, nirodho sacchikato, maggo bhvito, abhieyya abhita, parieyya parita, pahtabba pahna, bhvetabba bhvita --pe-- sacchiktabba sacchikata, catubhga sacchiktabba na sachikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Dukkhe dihe "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudaya dakkhanto --pe-- nirodha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo ti? #<[page 217]># %% mant. Nirodhe dihe "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo magga dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, magge dihe "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Dukkha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, dukkhe dihe "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Magga dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, magge dihe "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Samudaya dakkhanto --pe-- nirodha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, nirodhe dihe "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, dukkhe dihe na vattabba "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Magga dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, magge dihe na vattabba "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudaya dakkhanto --pe-- nirodha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, nirodhe dihe na vattabba "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Magga dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo, magge dihe na vattabba "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dukkha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo dukkhe dihe na vattabba "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Niratthiya dukkhadassanan ti? #<[page 218]># %<218 KATHVATTHU. [II. 9.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudaya dakkhanto --pe-- nirodha dakkhanto "paipannako ti" vattabbo nirodhe dihe na vattabba "phale hito ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Niratthiya nirodhadassanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Dukkhe dihe cattri saccni dihni hontti? mant. Dukkhasacca cattri saccnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpakkhandhe aniccato dihe pacakkhandh aniccato dih hontti? mant. Rpakkhandho pacakkhandh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Cakkhyatane aniccato dihe dvdasyatanni aniccato dihni hontti? mant. cakkhyatana dvdasyatannti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhudhtuy aniccato dihya ahrasa dhtuyo aniccato dih hontti? mant. Cakkhudhtu ahrasa dhtuyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhundriye aniccato dihe bvsatindriyni aniccato dihni hontti? mant. Cakkhundriya bvsatindriynti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Cathi ehi sotpattiphala sacchikarotti? mant. Cattri sotpattiphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahahi ehi sotpattiphala sacchikarotti? #<[page 219]># %% mant. Aha sotpattiphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvdasahi ehi sotpattiphala sacchikarotti? mant. Dvdasa sotpattiphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Catucattrsya ehi sotpattiphala sacchikarotti? mant. Catucattrsa sotpattiphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattasattatiy ehi sotpattiphala sacchikarotti? mant. Sattasattati sotpattiphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Na vattabba "Anupubbbhisamayo ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Seyyathpi Bhikkhave mahsamuddo anupubbaninno anupubbapoo anupubbapabbhro na yataken' eva papto, evameva kho Bhikkhave imasmi Dhammavinaye anupubbasikkh anupubbakiriy anupubbapaipad na yataken' eva apaivedho ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi anupubbbhisamayo ti. 18. Na vattabba "Anupubbbhisamayo ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Anupubbena medhv Thoka thoka khae khae Kammro rajatass' eva Niddhame mala attano ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi anupubbbhisamayo ti. #<[page 220]># %<220 KATHVATTHU. [II. 9.>% 19. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? mant. Nanvyasm Gavampat thero bhikkh etad avoca -- "Sammukh me ta vuso Bhagavato suta, sammukh paiggahta -- `Yo Bhikkhave dukkha passati, dukkhasamudaya pi so passati, dukkhanirodha pi passati, {dukkhanirodhagminpaipada} pi passati. Yo dukkhasamudaya passati, dukkha pi so passati, dukkhanirodha pi passati, {dukkhanirodhagminpaipada} pi passati. Yo dukkhanirodha passati, dukkha pi so passati, dukkhasamudaya pi passati, {dukkhanirodhagminpaipada} pi passati. Yo {dukkhanirodhagminpaipada} passati, dukkha pi so passati, dukkhasamudaya pi passati, dukkhanirodha pi passatti."' Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba, "Anupubbbhisamayo ti." 20. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sah v' assa dassanasampadya --pe-- cha cbhihnni abhabbo ktun ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Anupubbbhisamayo ti." 21. Anupubbbhisamayo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yasmi Bhikkhave samaye ariyasvakassa viraja vtamala dhammacakkhu udapdi, `ya kici samudayadhamma, sabban ta nirodhadhamman ti,' saha dassanuppd Bhikkhave ariyasvakassa ti saojanni pahyanti, sakkyadihi, vicikicch, slabbataparmso ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Anupubbbhisamayo ti." Anupubbbhisamayakath. #<[page 221]># %% II.10. 1. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Lokuttare sote paihaati no lokiye, lokuttarena viena paivijnanti no lokiyena, svak paivijnanti no puthujjan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokiye sote paihaatti? mant. Haci Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokiye sote paihaati, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." Nanu Buddhassa bhagavato vohra lokiyena viena paivijnantti? mant. Haci Buddhassa bhagavato vohra lokiyena viena paivijnanti, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." Nanu Buddhassa bhagavato vohra puthujjan paivijnantti? mant. Haci Buddhassa bhagavato vohra puthujjan paivijnanti, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." 2. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Maggo, phala, nibbna, sotpattimaggo, sotpattiphala, sakadgmimaggo, sakadgmiphala, angmimaggo, angmiphala, arahattamaggo, arahattaphala, {satipahna,} sammappadhna, iddhipd, indriya, bala, bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohra suantti? mant. #<[page 222]># %<222 KATHVATTHU. [II. 10>% Lokuttaro dhammo sotavieyyo, sotasmi paihaati, sotassa ptha gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu lokuttaro dhammo na sotavieyyo, na sotasmi paihaati, na sotassa ptha gacchatti? mant. Haci lokuttaro dhammo na sotavieyyo, na sotasmi paihaati, na sotassa ptha gacchati, no vata re vattabbe Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." 4. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohre rajjeyyun ti? mant. Lokuttaro dhammo rgahnyo, rajanyo, kamanyo, madanyo, bandhanyo, mucchanyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu lokuttaro dhammo na rgahnyo, na rajanyo, na kamanyo, na madanyo, na bandhanyo, na mucchanyo ti? mant. Haci lokuttaro dhammo na rgahnyo, na rajanyo, na kamanyo, na madanyo, na bandhanyo, na mucchanyo, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." 5. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohra dusseyyun ti? mant. Lokuttaro dhammo dosahnyo, kopahnyo, paighahnyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu lokuttaro dhammo na dosahnyo, na kopahnyo, na paighahnyo ti? mant. Haci lokuttaro dhammo na dosahnyo, na kopahnyo, #<[page 223]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ na paighahnyo, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." 6. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Atthi keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohre muyheyyun ti? mant. Lokuttaro dhammo mohahnyo, aakarao, acakkhukarao, panirodhiko, vightapakkhiko, anibbnasavattaniko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu lokuttaro dhammo na mohahnyo, na aakarao, na acakkhukarao, pavuddhiko, avightapakkhiko, nibbnasavattaniko ti? mant. Haci lokuttaro dhammo na mohahnyo, na aakarao, na acakkhukarao, pavuddhiko, avightapakkhiko, nibbnasavattaniko, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti." 7. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokuttaro ti? mant. Ye keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohra suanti, sabbe te magga bhventti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ye keci Buddhassa bhagavato vohra suanti, sabbe te magga bhventti? mant. Blaputhujjan Buddhassa bhagavato vohra suanti, blaputhujjan magga bhventti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mtughtak --pe-- pitughtak, arahantaghtak, ruhiruppdak --pe-- saghabhedak Buddhassa bhagavato vohra suanti, saghabhedak magga bhventti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 224]># %<224 KATHVATTHU. [II. 10.>% 8. Labbh sovaayya lahiy dhaapujo pi suvaapujo pi cikkhitun ti? mant. Evameva Bhagav lokuttarena vohrena lokiya pi lokuttara pi dhamma voharatti. Labbh elaiyya lahiy dhaapujo pi suvaapujo pi cikkhitun ti? mant. Evameva Bhagav lokiyena vohrena lokiya pi lokuttara pi dhamma voharatti. 9. Buddhassa {bhagavato} vohro lokiya voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttara voharantassa lokuttaro hotti? mant. Lokiya voharantassa so lokiye sote paihaati, lokuttara voharantassa lokuttare sote paihaati; lokiya voharantassa lokiyena viena paivijnanti, lokuttara voharantassa lokuttarena viena paivijnanti; lokiya voharantassa puthujjan paivijnanti lokuttara voharantassa svak paivijnantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Na vattabba "Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokiya voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttara voharantassa lokuttaro hotti"? mant. Nanu Bhagav lokiya pi lokuttara pi dhamma voharatti? mant. Haci Bhagav lokiya pi lokuttara pi dhamma voharati, tena vata re vattabbe Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokiya voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttara voharantassa lokuttaro hotti." 11. Buddhassa bhagavato vohro lokiya voharantassa lokiyo hoti, lokuttara voharantassa lokuttaro hotti? mant. Magga voharantassa maggo hoti, amagga voharantassa amaggo hoti; #<[page 225]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ phala voharantassa phala hoti, aphala voharantassa aphala hoti; nibbna voharantassa nibbna hoti, anibbna voharantassa anibbna hoti; sakhata voharantassa sakhata hoti, asakhata voharantassa asakhata hoti; rpa voharantassa rpa hoti, arpa voharantassa arpa hoti; vedana voharantassa vedan hoti, avedana voharantassa avedan hoti; saa voharantassa sa hoti, asaa voharantassa asa hoti; sakhre voharantassa sakhr honti, asakhre voharantassa asakhr honti; via voharantassa via hoti, avia voharantassa avia hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vohrakath. II.11. 1. Dve nirodh ti? mant. Dve dukkhanirodh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve dukkhanirodh ti? mant. Dve nirodhasaccnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nirodhasaccnti? mant. Dve dukkhasaccnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nirodhasaccnti? mant. Dve samudayasaccnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nirodhasaccnti? mant. #<[page 226]># %<226 KATHVATTHU. [II. 11.>% Dve maggasaccnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nirodhasaccnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- dve leni, dve sarani, dve paryanni, dve accutni, dve amatni --pe--, dve nibbnnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nibbnnti? mant. Atthi dvinna nibbnna uccancat {hinappatat} ukkasvakaso sm v bhedo v rj v antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dve nirodh ti? mant. Nanu appaisakhniruddhe sakhre paisakh nirodhentti? mant. Haci appaisakhniruddhe sakhre paisakh nirodhenti, no vata re vattabbe "Dve nirodh ti." 3. Na vattabba "Dve nirodh ti"? mant. Nanu appaisakhniruddh sakhr accantabhagg, paisakhniruddh sakhr accantabhagg ti? mant. Haci appaisakhniruddh sakhr accantabhagg, paisakhniruddh sakhr accantabhagg, tena vata re vattabbe "Dve nirodh ti." 4. Dve nirodh ti? mant. Paisakhniruddh sakhr ariyamagga gamma niruddh ti? mant. #<[page 227]># %% Appaisakhniruddh sakhr ariyamagga gamma niruddh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Dve nirodh ti? mant. Paisakhniruddh sakhr na puna uppajjantti? mant. Appaisakhniruddh sakhr na puna uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi na vattabba "Dve nirodh ti." Nirodhakath Tassa uddna Parpahro, Aa, Kakh, Paravitra, Vacbhedo, Dukkhhro, hiti, Kukku, Sakhr, Eko abhisamayo, Eko vohro, Eko nirodho ti. Dutiyo Vaggo. #<[page 228]># %<228 KATHVATTHU. [III. 1.>% III.1. 1. Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Tathgatabala svakabala, svakabala Tathgatabalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Ta eva Tathgatabala ta svakabala, ta svakabala ta Tathgatabalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Ydisa Tathgatabala, tdisa svakabala; ydisa svakabala, tdisa Tathgatabalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Ydiso Tathgatassa pubbayogo pubbacariy, dhammakkhna dhammadesan, tdiso svakassa pubbayogo pubbacariy, dhammakkhna dhammadesan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Tathgato Jino Satth Sammsambuddho Sabba Sabbadassv Dhammasm Dhammapaisarao ti? mant. Svako Jino Satth Sammsambuddho Sabba Sabbadassv Dhammasm Dhammapaisarao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Tathgato anuppannassa maggassa uppdet asajtassa maggassa sajanet anakkhtassa maggassa akkht magga maggavid maggakovido ti? #<[page 229]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ mant. Svako anuppannassa maggassa uppdet asajtassa maggassa sajanet anakkhtassa maggassa akkht magga maggavid maggakovido ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Indriyaparopariyatta yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Svako sabba sabbadassv ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Svako hnhna jntti? mant. Haci svako hnhna jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "hnhna yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 5. Svako attngatapaccuppannna kammasamdnna hnaso hetuso vipka jntti? mant. Haci svako attngatapaccuppannna kammasamdnna hnaso hetuso vipka jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Attngatapaccuppannna kammasamdnna hnaso hetuso vipka yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 6. Svako {sabbatthagminpaipada} jntti? mant. Haci svako {sabbatthagminpaipada} jnti, tena vata re vattabbe {"Sabbatthagminpaipada} yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 7. Svako anekadhtu nndhtu loka jntti? mant. Haci svako anekadhtu nndhtu loka jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Anekadhtu nndhtu loka yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." #<[page 230]># %<230 KATHVATTHU. [III. 1.>% 8. Svako sattna nndhimuttikata jntti? mant. Haci svako sattna nndhimuttikata jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sattna nndhimuttikata yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 9. Svako jhnavimokkhasamdhisampattna sakilesa vohna vuhna jntti? mant. Haci svako jhnavimokkhasamdhisampattna sakilesa vohna vuhna jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Jhnavimokkhasamdhisampattna sakilesa vohna vuhna yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 10. Svako pubbenivsnussati jntti? mant. Haci svako pubbenivsnussati jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Pubbenivsnussati yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 11. Svako sattna cutpapta jntti? mant. Haci svako sattna cutpapta jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sattna cutpapta yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 12. Nanu Tathgatasspi sav kh, svakasspi sav kh ti? mant. Atthi kici nnkaraa Tathgatassa v svakassa v savakkhayena v savakkhaya vimuttiy v vimuttti? N' atthi. Haci n' atthi kici nnkaraa Tathgatassa v svkassa v savakkhayena v savakkhaya vimuttiy v vimutti, tena vata re vattabbe "savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti." 13. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? #<[page 231]># %% mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Indriyaparopariyatta yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Indriyaparopariyatta yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svaka-asdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Indriyaparopariyatta yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? #<[page 232]># %<232 KATHVATTHU. [III. 2.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? mant. Indriyaparopariyatta yathbhta a Tathgatabala svakasdhraan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Balakath. III.2. 1. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna sotpattimaggo sotpattiphala sakadgmimaggo sakadgmiphala angmimaggo angmiphala arahattamaggo arahattaphala {satipahna} sammappadhna iddhipd indriya bala bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Suatrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Suatrammaan ti? mant. hnhna ca manasikaroti, suata ca manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- hnhna ca manasikaroti, suata ca manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? #<[page 233]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Thnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Appaihitrammaan ti? mant. hnhna ca manasikaroti, appaihita ca manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- hnhna ca manasikaroti, appaihita ca manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Satipahn ariy suatramma ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Satipahn ariy animittramma --pe-- appaihitramma ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sammappadhn, iddhipd, indriy, bal, bojjhag ariy suatramma ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bojjhag ariy animittramma --pe-- appaihitramma ti? #<[page 234]># %<234 KATHVATTHU. [III. 2.>% mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya, na vattabba "suatrammaan ti"? mant. Satipahn ariy, na vattabb "suatramma ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya, na vattabba "animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti"? mant. Satipahn ariy, na vattabb "appaihitramma ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya, na vattabba "suatrammaa --pe-- "animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti"? mant. Sammappadhn --pe-- bojjhag ariy, na vattabb appaihitramma ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna sotpattimaggo sotpattiphala sakadgmimaggo sakadgmiphala angmimaggo angmiphala arahattamaggo arahattaphala saipahna sammappadhna iddhipd indriya bala bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Suatrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 235]># %% Suatrammaan ti? mant. Sattna cutpapta ca manasikaroti, suata ca manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapta ca manasikaroti, suata ca manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Appaihitrammaan ti? mant. Sattna cutpapta ca manasikaroti, appaihita ca manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapta ca manasikaroti, appaihita ca manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Satipahn ariy suatramma ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Satipahn ariy animittramma --pe-- appaihitramma ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 236]># %<236 KATHVATTHU. [III. 2.>% 11. Sammappadhn, iddhipd, indriy, bal, bojjhag ariy suatramma ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bojjhag ariy animittramma --pe-- appaihitramma ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya, na vattabba "suatrammaan ti"? mant. Satipahn ariy, na vattabb "suatramma ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya, na vattabba "animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti"? mant. Satipahn ariy, na vattabb "appaihitramma ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya, na vattabba "suatrammaa --pe-- animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti"? mant. Sammappadhn --pe-- bojjhag ariy, na vattabb "appaihitramma ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 237]># %% savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala na vattabba "ariyan ti"? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala na vattabba "ariyan ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala na vattabba "ariyan ti"? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala na vattabba "ariyan ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaan ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaan ti? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti? mant. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya suatrammaa --pe-- animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti? mant. Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya appaihitrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 238]># %<238 KATHVATTHU. [III. 3.>% 16. hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya na vattabba "suatrammaan ti"? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya na vattabba "suatrammaan ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- hnhne yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya na vattabba "animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti"? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya na vattabba "appaihitrammaan ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sattna cutpapte yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya na vattabba "suatrammaa --pe-- animittrammaa --pe-- appaihitrammaan ti"? mant. savna khaye yathbhta a Tathgatabala ariya na vattabba "appaihitrammaan ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ariyan ti kath. III.3. 1. Sarga citta vimuccatti? mant. Rgasahagata rgasahajta rgasasaha rgasampayutta rgasahabh rgnuparivatti akusala lokiya ssava saojanya ganthanya oghanya yoganya nvaraya parmaha {updniya} sakilesika citta vimuccatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Saphassa citta vimuccati, phasso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. #<[page 239]># %% Sarga citta vimuccati rgo ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedana --pe-- sasaa --pe-- sacetana --pe-- sapaa citta vimuccati, pa ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Sarga citta vimuccati, rgo ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Saphassa sarga citta vimuccati, phasso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Rgo ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedana sarga --pe-- sasaa sarga --pe-- sacetana sarga --pe-- sapaa sarga citta vimuccati, pa ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Rgo ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sadosam citta vimuccatti? mant. Dosasahagata dosasahajta dosasasaha dosasampayutta dosasahabh dosnuparivatti akusala lokiya ssava saojanya ganthanya oghanya yoganya nvaraya parmaha updniya sakilesikam citta vimuccatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Saphassa citta vimuccati, phasso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Sadosam citta vimuccati, doso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedana --pe-- sasaa --pe-- sacetana --pe-- sapaa citta vimuccati, pa ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? #<[page 240]># %<240 KATHVATTHU. [III. 3.>% mant. Sadosam citta vimuccati, doso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Saphassa sadosam citta vimuccati, phasso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Doso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedana sadosa --pe-- sasaa sadosa --pe-- sacetana sadosa --pe-- sapaa sadosa citta vimuccati, pa ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Doso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Samoha citta vimuccatti? mant. Mohasahagata mohasahajta mohasasaha mohasampayutta mohasahabh mohnuparivatti akusala lokiya ssava saojanya ganthanya oghanya yoganya nvaraya parmaha updniya sakilesika citta vimuccatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Saphassa citta vimuccati, phasso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Samoha citta vimuccati, moho ca citta ca ubho vinuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedana --pe-- sasaa --pe-- sacetana --pe-- sapaa citta vimuccati, pa ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Samoha citta vimuccati, moho ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Saphassa samoha citta vimuccati, phasso ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? #<[page 241]># %% mant. Moho ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedana samoha --pe-- sasaa samoha --pe-- sacetana samoha --pe-- sapaa samoha citta vimuccati, pa ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? mant. Moho ca citta ca ubho vimuccantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Na vattabba "Sarga sadosa samoha citta vimuccatti"? mant. Vtarga vtadosa vtamoha nikkilesa citta vimuccatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi sarga sadosa samoha citta vimuccatti. Vimuttikath. III.4. 1. Vimutta vimuccamnan ti? mant. Ekadesa vimutta, ekadesa avimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekadesa vimutta, ekadesa avimuttan ti? mant. Ekadesa sotpanno, ekadesa na sotpanno; ekadesa sotpattiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati; ekadesa sattakkhattupasamo, kolakolo, ekabj; Buddhe aveccappasdena samanngato, Dhamme --pe-- Saghe --pe-- ariyakantehi slehi samanngato, ekadesa ariyakantehi slehi na samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ekadesa vimutta, ekadesa avimuttan ti? 17 #<[page 242]># %<242 KATHVATTHU. [III. 4.>% mant. Ekadesa sakadgm, ekadesa na sakadgm; ekadesa sakadgmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Ekadesa vimutta, ekadesa avimuttan ti? mant. Ekadesa angm, ekadesa na angm; ekadesa angmiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa na kyena phusitv viharati; ekadesa antarparinibby, upahaccaparinibby, asakhraparinibby, sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm, ekadesa na uddhasoto na akanihagm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Ekadesa vimutta, ekadesa avimuttan ti? mant. Ekadesa Arah, ekadesa na Arah; ekadesa arahattappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharati, ekadesa kyena na phusitv viharati; ekadesa vtargo vtadoso vtamoho --pe-- ekadesa sacchiktabba sacchikata, ekadesa sacchiktabba na sacchikatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Vimutta vimuccamnan ti? mant. Uppdakkhae vimutta, vayakkhae vimuccamnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Vimutta vimuccamnan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Tassa eva jnato eva passato kmsav pi citta vimuccati, bhavsav pi citta vimuccati, avijjsav pi citta vimuccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 243]># %% mant. Tena hi vimutta vimuccamnan ti. 7. Vimutta vimuccamnan ti. mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "So eva samhite citte parisuddhe pariyodte anagae vigatpakkilese mudubhte {kammaniye} hite nejappatte savna khayaya citta abhininnmetti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Vimutta vimuccamnan ti." 8. Atthi citta vimuccamnan ti? mant. Atthi citta rajjamna dussamna muyhamna kilissamnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu ratta c' eva aratta ca, duha c' eva aduha ca, mha c' eva amha ca, chinna c' eva achinna ca, bhinna c' eva abhinna ca, kata c' eva akata cti? mant. Haci ratta c' eva aratta ca, duha c' eva aduha ca, muha c' eva amuha ca, chinna c' eva achinna ca, bhinna c' eva abhinna ca, kata c' eva akata ca, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi citta vimuccamnan ti." Vimuccamnakath. III.5. 1. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo sotpanno sotpattiphalappatto pailaddho adhigato sacchikato upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. #<[page 244]># %<244 KATHVATTHU. [III. 5.>% Ahamako puggalo sotpanno sotpattiphalappatto -- pe -- kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihnusayo pahno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchnusayo --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchnusayo pahno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihnusayo --pe-- slabbataparmso pahno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihnusayo appahno ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna appahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa dihnusayo appahno ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna appahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchnusayo --pe-- slabbataparmso appahno ti? mant. #<[page 245]># %% Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna appahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa slabbataparmso appahno ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna appahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhnappahnya maggo bhvito ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhnappahnya satipahn bhvit --pe-- sammappadhn --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhnappahnya maggo bhvito --pe-- bojjhag bhvit ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhnappahnya maggo abhvito ti? mant. Anaggena pahna lokiyena ssavena --pe-- sakilesikenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhnappahnya satipahn --pe-- bojjhag abhvit ti? mant. Amaggena pahna lokiyena ssavena --pe-- sakilesikenti? #<[page 246]># %<246 KATHVATTHU. [III. 5.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhnappahnya maggo abhvito --pe-- bojjhag abhvit ti? mant. Amaggena pahna lokiyena ssavena --pe-- sakilesikenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti"? mant. Uppajjissatti? N' uppajjissatti. Haci n' uppajjissati, tena vata re vattabbe "Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahnan ti." 8. Na vattabba "Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna pahnan ti"? mant. Uppajjissatti? N' uppajjissatti. Haci n' uppajjissati, tena vata re vattabbe "Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna pahnan ti." 9. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihnusayo n' uppajjissatti katv, pahno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchnusayo --pe-- slabbataparmso n' uppajjissatti katv, pahno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchnusayo --pe-- slabbataparmso n' uppajjissatti katv, pahno ti? #<[page 247]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? mant. Gotrabhuno puggalassa dihipariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? mant. Gotrabhuno puggalassa vicikicchpariyuhna n' uppajjissatti katv, pahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakakath. III.6. 1. Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi saddhindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi saddh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi viriyindriya --pe-- n' atthi satindriya --pe-- n' atthi samdhindriya --pe-- n' atthi paindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi pa ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi viriya --pe-- atthi sati, atthi samdhi, atthi pa ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi paindriyan ti? #<[page 248]># %<248 KATHVATTHU. [III. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, atthi manindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, atthi saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, atthi manindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi pa, atthi paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi somanassa, atthi somanassindriya --pe-- atthi jvita, atthi jvitindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, atthi saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi jvita, atthi jvitindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi viriya --pe-- atthi pa, atthi paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi Saddh, n' atthi saddhindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, n' atthi manindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, n' atthi saddhindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi somanassa, n' atthi somanassindriya --pe-- atthi jvita, n' atthi jvitindriyan ti? #<[page 249]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi pa, n' atthi paindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi mano, n' atthi manindriya --pe-- atthi somanassa n' atthi somanassindriya --pe-- atthi jvita, n' atthi jvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi saddhindriyan ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo asaddho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi viriyindriyan ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo kusto hnaviriyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi satindriyan ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo muhassati asampajno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi samdhindriyan ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo asamhito vibbhantacitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi paindriyan ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo duppao eamgo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, s ca saddh niyynik ti? mant. Haci ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, s ca saddh niyynik, no vata re vattabbe "Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi saddhindriyan ti." Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi viriya, ta ca viriya niyynika --pe-- atthi sati, s ca sati niyynik --pe-- atthi samdhi, so ca samdhi niyyniko --pe-- atthi pa, s ca pa niyynik ti? #<[page 250]># %<250 KATHVATTHU. [III. 6.>% mant. Haci ahamakassa puggalassa atthi pa, s ca pa niyynik, no vata re vattabbe "Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi paindriyan ti." 9. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa atthi saddh, atthi saddhindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, atthi saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa atthi pa, atthi paindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi pa, atthi paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa --pe-- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa atthi saddh, atthi saddhindriya --pe-- atthi pa, atthi paindriyan ti? mant. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi pa, atthi paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, n' atthi saddhindriyan ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa atthi saddh, n' atthi saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi pa, n' atthi paindriyan ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa atthi pa, n' atthi paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Ahamakassa puggalassa atthi saddh, n' atthi saddhindriya --pe-- atthi pa, n' atthi paindriyan ti? #<[page 251]># %% mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa -- pe -- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa atthi pa, n' atthi paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi pac' indriynti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' imni Bhikkhave indriyni. Katamni paca? Saddhindriya, viriyindriya, satindriya, samdhindriya, paindriya. Imni kho Bhikkhave pac' indriyni. Imesa kho Bhikkhave pacanna indriyna samatt paripratt Arah hoti. Tato mudutarehi arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno hoti; tato mudutarehi angm hoti; tato mudutarehi angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno hoti; tato mudutarehi sakadgm hoti; tato mudutarehi sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno hoti; tato mudutarehi sotpanno hoti; tato mudutarehi sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno hoti. Yassa kho Bhikkhave imni pac' indriyni sabbena sabba sabbath sabba n' atthi, tam aha `bhiro puthujjanapakkhe hito ti' vadmti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Ahamako puggalo bhiro puthujjanapakkhe hito ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi ahamakassapuggalassa atthi {pac' indriynti} Ahamakassa indriyakath. III.7. 1. Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Masacakkhu dibbacakkhu, dibbacakkhu masacakkhun ti? #<[page 252]># %<252 KATHVATTHU. [III. 7.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Ydisa masacakkhu, tdisa dibbacakkhu; ydisa dibbacakkhu, tdisa masacakkhun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Ta eva masaccakkhu tam dibbacakkhu, ta dibbacakkhu ta masacakkhun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Ydiso masacakkhussa visayo nubhvo gocaro, tdiso dibbassa cakkhussa visayo nubhvo gocaro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Updinna hutv anupdinna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Updinna hutv anupdinna hotti? mant. Kmvacara hutv rpvacara hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmvacara hutv rpvacara hotti? mant. Rpvacara hutv arpvacara hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpvacara hutv arpvacara hotti? mant. Pariypanna hutv apariypanna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 253]># %% 3. Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Dibbacakkhu dhammupatthaddha masacakkhu hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Dibbacakkhu dhammupatthaddha pacakkhu hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Dibbacakkhu dhammupatthaddha masacakkhu hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Masacakkhu dhammupatthaddha dibbacakkhu hotti? mant. Dve 'va cakkhnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve 'va cakkhnti? mant. Nanu ti cakkhni vuttni Bhagavat, masacakkhu, dibbacakkhu, pacakkhun ti? mant. Haci ti cakkhni vuttni Bhagavat, masacakkhum, dibbacakkhu, pacakkhu, no vata re vattabbe "Dve 'va cakkhnti"? Dve 'va cakkhnti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "T' imni Bhikkhave cakkhni. Katamni ti? Masacakkhu, dibbacakkhu, pacakkhu. Imni kho Bhikkhave ti cakkhnti." #<[page 254]># %<254 KATHVATTHU. [III. 8.>% "Masacakkhu dibbacakkhu Pacakkhu anuttara, Etni {ti} cakkhni Akkhsi purisattamo. Masacakkhussa uppdo Maggo dibbassa cakkhuno, Yath ca a udapdi Pacakkhu anuttara. Tassa cakkhussa pailbh Sabbadukkh pamuccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Dve 'va cakkhnti." Dibbacakkhukath. III.8. 1. Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Masasota dibbasota, dibbasota masasotan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Ydisa masasota, tdisa dibbasota: ydisa dibbasota, tadisa masasotan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Ta eva masasota ta dibbasota, ta dibbasota ta masasotan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Ydiso masacakkhussa visayo nubhvo gocaro, tdiso dibbassa cakkhussa visayo nubhvo gocaro ti? #<[page 255]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Updinna hutv anupdinna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Updinna hutv anupdinna hotti? mant. Kmvacara hutv rpvacara hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmvacara hutv rpvacara hotti? mant. Rpvacara hutv arpvacara hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpvacara hutv arpvacara hotti? mant. Pariypanna hutv apariypanna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Dibbasota dhammupatthaddha masasota hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Masasota dhammupatthaddha dibbasota hotti? mant. Eka eva sotan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Eka eva sotan ti? mant. Nanu dve sotni vuttni Bhagavat, masasota dibbasotan ti? mant. Haci dve sotni vuttni Bhagavat, masasota dibbasota, no vata re vattabbe "Eka eva sotan ti." Dibbasotakath. #<[page 256]># %<256 KATHVATTHU. [III. 9.>% III.9. 1. Yathkammpagata {a} dibbacakkhun ti? mant. Yathkammpagata ca manasikaroti, dibbena cakkhun rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yathkammpagata ca manasikaroti, dibbena cakkhun rpa passatti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti? mant. Ime vata bhonto satt ti ca manasikaroti, kyaduccaritena samanngat ti ca manasikaroti, vacduccaritena samanngat ti ca manasikaroti, manoduccaritena samanngat ti ca manasikaroti, ariyna upavdak ti ca manasikaroti, micchdihik ti ca manasikaroti, micchdihikammasamdn ti ca manasikaroti, te kyassa bhed para mara apya duggati vinipta niraya upapann ti ca manasikaroti, ime v pana bhonto satt ti ca manasikaroti, kyasucaritena samanngat ti ca manasikaroti, vacsucaritena samanngat ti ca manasikaroti, manosucaritena samanngat ti ca manasikaroti, ariyna anupavdak ti ca manasikaroti, samdihik ti ca manasikaroti, sammdihikammasamdn ti ca manasikaroti, te kyassa bhed para mara sugatim sagga loka upapann ti ca manasikaroti, dibbena cakkhun rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti? mant. Ime vata bhonto satt ti ca manasikaroti, --pe--, te #<[page 257]># %% kyassa bhed para mara sugati sagga loka upapann ti ca manasikaroti, dibbena cakkhun rpa passatti? mant. Dvinna phassna dvinna cittna {samodhna} hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti? mant. Atthi koci adibbacakkhuko dibbacakkhu appailaddho anadhigato asacchikato yathkammpagata jntti? mant. Haci atthi koci adibbacakkhuko dibbacakkhu appailaddho anadhigato asacchikato yathkammpagata jnti, no vata re vattabbe "Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti." 4. Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti? mant. yasm Sriputto yathkammpagata jntti? mant. Haci yasm Sriputto yathkammpagata jnti, no vata re vattabbe "Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti." 5. yasm Sriputto yathkammpagata jntti? mant. Atth' yasmato Sriputtassa dibbacakkhun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atth' yasmato Sriputtassa dibbacakkhun ti? mant. Nanu {yasm} Sriputto etad avoca -- N' eva pubbenivsya Npi dibbassa cakkhuno Cetopariyya iddhiy Sotadhtuvisuddhiy Cutiy upapattiy Paidh me na vijjatti." #<[page 258]># %<258 KATHVATTHU. [III. 10.>% Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Yathkammpagata a dibbacakkhun ti." Yathkammpagataakath. III.10. 1. Atthi devesu savaro ti? mant. Atthi devesu asavaro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi devesu asavaro ti? mant. N' atthi devesu savaro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Nanu asavar savaro sla, atthi devesu savaro ti? mant. Atthi devesu asavaro, yamh asavar savaro slan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe. jnhi niggaha: haci asavar savaro sla, atthi devesu savaro, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi devesu asavaro, yamh asavar savaro slan ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `asavar savaro sla, atthi devesu savaro,'no ca vattabbe `atthi devesu asavaro yamh asavar savaro slan ti,"' micch. No ce pana vattabbe "Atthi devesu asavaro yamh asavar savaro slan ti," no vata re vattabbe "Asavar savaro sla, atthi devesu savaro ti." Ya tattha vadesi "Vattabbe kho `asavar savaro sla, atthi devesu savaro,' no ca vattabbe `atthi devesu asavaro yamh asavar savaro slan ti,"' micch. #<[page 259]># %% 3. Atthi manussesu savaro, atthi tattha asavaro ti? mant. Atthi devesu savaro, atthi tattha asavaro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi devesu savaro, n' atthi tattha asavaro ti? mant. Atthi manussesu savaro, n' atthi tattha asavaro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi devesu ptipt veramati? mant. Atthi devesu ptipto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi devesu surmerayamajjapamdahn veramati? mant. Atthi devesu surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. N' atthi devesu ptipto ti? mant. N' atthi devesu ptipt veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi devesu surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? mant. N' atthi devesu surmerayamajjapamdahn veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi manussesu ptipt verama, atthi tattha ptipto ti? mant. Atthi devesu ptipt verama, atthi tattha ptipto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi manussesu surmerayamajjapamdahn verama, atthi tattha surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? mant. Atthi devesu surmerayamajjapamdahn verama, atthi tattha surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 260]># %<260 KATHVATTHU. [III. 11.>% 7. Atthi devesu ptipt verama, n' atthi tattha ptipto ti? mant. Atthi manussesu ptipt verama, n' atthi tattha ptipto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi devesu surmerayamajjapamdahn verama, n' atthi tattha surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? mant. Atthi manussesu surmerayamajjapamdahn verama, n' atthi tattha surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. N' atthi devesu savaro ti? mant. Sabbe dev pniptino adinndyino kmesu micchcrino musvdino surmerayamajjapamdahyino ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi atthi devesu savaro ti. Savarakath. III.11. 1. Asaasattesu sa atthti? mant. Saabhavo saagati saasattvso saasasro saayoni saattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu asaabhavo asaagati asaasattvso asaasasro asaayoni asaattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Haci asaabhavo asaagati asaasattvso asaasasro asaayoni asaattabhvapailbho, no vata re vattabbe "Asaasattesu sa atthti." 2. Asaasattesu sa atthti? #<[page 261]># %% mant. Pacavokrabhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu ekavokrabhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Haci ekavokrabhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni attabhvapailbho, no vata re vattabbe "Asaasattesu sa atthti." 3. Asaasattesu sa atthti? mant. Tya saya saakaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manussesu sa atthi, so ca saabhavo saagati saasattvso saasasro saayoni saattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Asaasattesu sa atthi, so ca saabhavo saagati saasattvso saasasro saayoni saattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manussesu sa atthi, so ca pacavokrabhavo gati sattvso sasro yoti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Asaasattesu sa atthi, so ca pacavokrabhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manussesu sa atthi, tya saya sakaraya karotti? mant. Asaasattesu sa atthi, tya saya sakaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Asaasattesu sa atthi, so ca asaabhavo asaagati asaasattvso asaasasro asaayoni asaattabhvapailbho ti? mant. #<[page 262]># %<262 KATHVATTHU. [III. 11.>% Manussesu sa atthi, so ca asaabhavo --pe-- asaattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaasattesu sa atthi, so ca ekavokrabhavo gati -- pe -- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Manussesu sa atthi, so ca ekavokrabhavo gati -- pe -- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaasattesu sa atthi, na ca tya saya sakaraya karotti? mant. Manussesu sa atthi, na ca tya saya sakaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Asaasattesu sa atthti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Santi Bhikkhave Asaasatt nma dev, sauppd ca pana te dev tamh kya cavantti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Asaasattesu sa atthti. 6. Asaasattesu sa atthti? Kaci kle atthi kaci kle n' atthti. Kaci kle saasatt, kaci kle asaasatt; kaci kle saabhavo, kaci kle asaabhavo; kaci kle pacavokrabhavo, kaci kle ekavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Asaasattesu sa kaci kle atthi, kaci kle n' atthti? mant. Ka kla atthi, ka kla n' atthti? Cutikle uppattikle atthi, hitikle n' atthti. Cutikle ca uppattikle saasatt, hitikle asaasatt; cutikle uppattikle saabhavo, hitikle asaabhavo; cutikle uppattikle pacavokrabhavo, hitikle ekavokrabhavo ti? #<[page 263]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaakath. III.12. 1. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti"? mant. Asaabhavo asaagati asaasattvso asaasasro asaayoni asaattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Haci asaabhavo asaagati --pe-- asaattabhvapailbho, no vata re vattabbe Nevasansayatane na vattabba `Sa atthti."' 2. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti"? mant. Ekavokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu catuvokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Haci catuvokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho, no vata re vattabbe "Nevasansayatane na vattabba `Sa {atthti.}"' 3. Asaasattesu na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca asaabhavo asaagati asaasattvso asaasasro asaayoni asaattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca asaabhavo asaagati asaasattvso asaasasro asaayoni asaattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaasattesu na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca ekavokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. #<[page 264]># %<264 KATHVATTHU. [III.12.>% Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca ekavokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca saabhavo saagati --pe-- saattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Asaasattesu na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca saabhavo saagati --pe-- saattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca catuvokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Asaasattesu na vattabba "Sa atthi," so ca catuvokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti?" mant. Nanu nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo ti? mant. Haci nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Nevasansayatane na vattabba `Sa atthti."' 6. Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti? mant. ksnacyatana catuvokrabhavo, ksnacyatane na vattabba "Sa atthti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti"? mant. viacyatana --pe-- kicayatana catuvokrabhavo, kicayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 265]># %% 7. ksnacyatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? mant. Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Viacyatana --pe-- kicayatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? mant. Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti v n' atthti v ti"? mant. Nanu nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo ti? mant. Haci nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Nevasansayatane na vattabba `Sa atthti v n' atthti v ti."' 9. Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti v n' atthti v ti"? mant. ksnacyatana --pe-- viacyatana --pe-- kicayatana catuvokrabhavo, kicayatane na vattabba "Saa atthti v n' atthti v ti." 10. ksnacyatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? mant. Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Viacyatana --pe-- kicayatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? mant. Nevasansayatana catuvokrabhavo, atthi tattha sa ti? #<[page 266]># %<266 KATHVATTHU. [III. 12.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti v n' atthti v ti"? mant. Nanu nevasansayatanan ti? mant. Haci nevasansayatana, tena vata re vattabbe "Nevasansayatane na vattabba `Sa atthti v n' atthti v ti."' 12. Nevasansayatanan ti katv, nevasansayatane na vattabba "Sa atthti v n' atthti v ti"? mant. Adukkhamasukh vedan ti katv, adukkhamasukhya vedanya na vattabba "Vedan ti v, avedan ti v ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nevasansayatanakath. Tatiyo Vaggo. Bala sdhraa, Ariya, Srga citta vimuccati, Vimutta vimuccamna, Atthi citta vimuccamna, Ahamakassa puggalassa dihipariyuhna pahna, Ahamakassa puggalassa n' atthi pacindriyni, Cakkhu, Sota dhammupatthaddha, Yathkammpagataa, Devesu savaro, Asaasattesu sa, evameva bhavaggan ti. #<[page 267]># %% IV.1. 1. Gih'ssa Arah ti? mant. Atthi Arahato gihisaojanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato gihisaojanan ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato gihisaojana no vata re vattabbe "Gih 'ssa Arah ti." 2. Gih 'ssa Arah ti? mant. Nanu Arahato gihisaojana pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhva kata yati anuppdadhamman ti? mant. Haci Arahato gihisaojana pahna ucchinnamla tlvatthukata anabhva kata yati anuppdadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Gih 'ssa Arah ti." 3. Gih 'ssa Arah ti? mant. Atthi koci gih gihisaojana appahya dih' eva dhamme dukkhass' anta karotti? N' atthi. Haci n' atthi koci gih gihisaojana appahya dih' eva dhamme dukkhass' anta karoti, no vata re vattabbe "Gih 'ssa Arah ti." 4. Gih 'ssa Arah ti? mant. Nanu Vacchagotto paribbjako Bhagavanta etad avoca -- "Atthi nu kho bho Gotama koci gih gihisaojana appahya kyassa bhed dukkhass' anta karotti"? N' atthi kho Vaccha koci gih gihisaojana appahya kyassa bhed dukkhass' anta karotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 268]># %<268 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 2.>% mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Gih 'ssa Arah ti." 5. Gih 'ssa Arah ti? mant. Arah methuna dhamma paiseveyya, methuna dhamma uppdeyya, puttasambdhasayana ajjhvaseyya, ksikacandana paccanubhaveyya, mlgandhavilepana dhreyya, jtarparajata sdiyeyya, ajeaka paigaheyya, kukkuaskara paigaheyya, hatthigavassavaava paigaheyya, {tittiravaakamorakapijaa} {paigaheyya,} pitavaavlamolika dhreyya, odtni vatthni dghadasni dhreyya, yvajva agriyabhto assti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Gih 'ssa Arah ti"? mant. Nanu Yaso kulaputto, Uttiyo gahapati, Setu mnavo gihissa byajanena arahatta patt ti? mant. Haci Yaso kulaputto, Uttiyo gahapati, Setu mnavo gihissa byajanena arahatta patt, tena vata re vattabbe "Gih 'ssa Arah ti." Gih 'ssa Arah ti kath. IV.2. 1. Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Saha uppattiy sotpanno hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saha uppattiy Arah ti? #<[page 269]># %% mant. Saha uppattiy sakadgm hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Saha uppattiy angm hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Saha uppattiy sotpanno na hotti? mant. Haci saha uppattiy sotpanno na hoti, no vata re vattabbe "Saha uppatthiy Arah ti." Saha uppattiy sakadgm na hotti? mant. Haci saha uppattiy sakadgm na hoti, no vata re vattabbe "Saha uppatthiy Arah ti." Saha uppattiy angm na hotti? mant. Haci saha uppattiy angm na hoti, no vata re vattabbe "Saha uppattiy Arah ti." 3. Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Sriputto thero saha uppattiy Arah ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mah Moggallno thero --pe-- Mah Kassapo thero -- pe -- Mah Kaccyano thero --pe-- Mah Kohiko thero -- pe -- Mah Panthako thero saha uppattiy Arah ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sriputto thero na saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Haci Sriputto thero na saha uppattiy Arah, no vata re vattabbe "Saha uppattiy Arah ti." Mah Moggallno thero --pe-- Mah Kassapo thero, Mah Kaccyano thero, Mah Kohiko thero --pe-- Mah Panthako thero na saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. #<[page 270]># %<270 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 2.>% Haci Mah {Panthako} thero na saha {uppattiy} Arah, no vata re vattabbe "Saha uppattiy Arah ti." 5. Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena arahatta sacchikaroti lokiyena ssavena --pe-- sakilesikenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Uppattesiya citta niyynika khayagm bodhagm apacayagm ansava --pe-- asakilesikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu uppattesiya citta aniyynika, na khayagm, na bodhagm, na apacayagm, ssava --pe-- sakilesikan ti? mant. Haci uppattesiya citta aniyynika, na khayagm, na bodhagm, na apacayagm, ssava --pe-- sakilesika, no vata re vattabbe "Saha uppattiy Arah ti." 6. Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena rga pajahati, dosa pajahati, moha pajahati, --pe-- anottappa pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Uppattesiya citta maggo --pe-- satipahna sammappadhna iddhipdo indriya bala --pe-- bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saha uppattiy Arah ti? mant. #<[page 271]># %% Cuticitta, maggacitta, uppattesiya citta, phalacittan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uppattikath. IV.3. 1. Arahato sabbe dhamm ansav ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna sotpattimaggo sotpattiphala sakadgmimaggo sakadgmiphala angmimaggo angmiphala arahattamaggo arahataphala satipahna sammappadhna iddhipdo indriya bala bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Arahato sabbe dhamm ansav ti? mant. Arahato cakkhu ansavan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato cakkhu ansavan ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna --pe-- bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato sota --pe-- Arahato ghna --pe-- Arahato jivh --pe-- Arahato kyo ansavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato kyo ansavo ti? mant. Maggo phala --pe-- bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Arahato kyo ansavo ti? mant. Arahato kyo paggahaniggahpago chedanabhedanpago kkehi gijjhehi kulalehi sdhrao ti? mant. #<[page 272]># %<272 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 3.>% Ansavo dhammo paggahaniggahpago chedanabhedanpago kkehi gijjhehi kulalehi sdhrao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Arahato kye visa kameyya, sattha kameyya aggi kameyyti? mant. Ansave dhamme visa kameyya, sattha kameyya, aggi kameyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh Arahato kyo addubandhanena bandhitu, rajjubandhanena bandhitu, sakhalikabandhanena bandhitu, gmabandhanena bandhitu, nigamabandhanena bandhitu, nagarabandhanena bandhitu, janapadabandhanena bandhitu, kahapacamehi bandhanehi bandhitun ti? mant. Labbh ansavo dhammo addubandhanena bandhitu, rajjubandhanena bandhitu, sakhalikabandhanena bandhitu, gmabandhanena bandhitu, nigamabandhanena bandhitu, nagarabandhanena bandhitu, janapadabandhanena bandhitu, kahapacamehi bandhanehi bandhitun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Yadi Arah puthujjanassa cvara deti, ansava hutv ssava hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ansava hutv ssava hotti? mant. Ta eva ansava, ta ssavan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta eva ansava, ta ssavan ti? mant. Maggo ansavo hutv ssavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Phala, satipahna, sammappadhna, iddhipdo, indriya, bala, bojjhago ansavo hutv ssavo hotti? #<[page 273]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Yadi Arah puthujjanassa piapta deti, sensana deti, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra deti, ansavo hutv ssavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ansavo hutv ssavo hotti? mant. Ta eva ansava, ta ssavan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta eva ansava, ta ssavan ti? mant. Maggo ansavo hutv ssavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Phala, sattipahna, sammappadhna, iddhipdo, indriya, bala, bojjhago ansavo hutv ssavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Yadi puthujjano Arahato cvara deti, ssava hutv ansava hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ssava hutv ansava hotti? mant. Ta eva ssava, ta ansavan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta eva ssava, ta ansavan ti? mant. Rgo ssavo hutv ansavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Doso --pe-- moho --pe-- anottappa ssava hutv ansava hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Yadi puthujjano Arahato piapta deti, sensana deti, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra deti, ssavo hutv ansavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ssavo hutv ansavo hotti? mant. #<[page 274]># %<274 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 4.>% Ta eva ssava, ta ansavan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta eva ssava, ta ansavan ti? mant. Rgo ssavo hutv ansavo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Doso --pe-- moho --pe-- anottappa ssava hutv ansava hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Na vattabba "Arahato sabbe dhamm ansav ti"? mant. Nanu Arah ansavo ti? mant. Haci Arah ansavo, tena vata re vattabbe "Arahato sabbe dhamm ansav ti." Ansavakath. IV.4. 1. Arah cathi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Arah cathi phassehi cathi vedanhi cathi sahi cathi cetanhi cathi cittehi cathi saddhhi cathi viriyehi cathi satti cathi samdhhi cathi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Angm thi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Angm thi phassehi --pe-- thi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgm dvhi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgm dvhi phassehi --pe-- dvhi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 275]># %% 3. Arah sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Arah sotpanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arah {sakadgmiphalena} samanngato ti? mant. Arah sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arah angmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Arah angm antarparinibby, upahaccaparinibby, asakhraparinibby, sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Angm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Angm sotpanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angm sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Angm sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgm sotpanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sotpattiphalena samanngato "sotpanno ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Arah sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sve 'va Arah so sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalena samanngato, "sakadgm ti" vattabbo ti? #<[page 276]># %<276 KATHVATTHU. IV. 4.>% mant. Arah sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sve 'va Arah so sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmiphalena samanngato "angm ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Arah angmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sve 'va Arah so angm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sotpattiphalena samanngato "sotpanno ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Angm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sve 'va Angm so sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalena samanngato "sakadgm ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Angm sakadgmiphalena sammanngato ti? mant. Sotpattiphalena samanngato "sotpanno ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Sakadgm {sotpattiphalena} samanngato ti? mant. Sve 'va sakadgm so sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- {} Arah sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu Arah sotpattiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci Arah sotpattiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe Arah sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." 8. Arah sotpattiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. #<[page 277]># %% Arah sotpattimagga vtivatto, sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa apyagamanya rga apyagamanya dosa apyagamanya moha vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Arah sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu Arah sakadgmiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci Arah sakadgmiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Arah sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti." 10. Arah sakadgmiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Arah sakadgmimagga vtivatto, orika kmarga orika bypda vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Arah angmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu Arah angmiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci "Arah angmiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe Arah angmiphalena samanngato ti." 12. Arah angmiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Arah angmimagga vtivatto, ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Angm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu angm sotpattiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci angm sotpattiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Angm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." 14. Angam sotpattiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? #<[page 278]># %<278 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 4.>% mant. Angm sotpattimagga vtivatto, sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa apyagamanya rga apyagamanya dosa apyagamanya moha vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Angm sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu angm sakadgmiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci angm sakadgmiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Angm sakadgamiphalena samanngato ti." 16. Angm sakadgmiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Angm sakadgmimagga vtivatto, orika kmarga orika bypda vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Sakadgm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu sakadgm sotpattiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci sakadgm sotpattiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Sakadgm sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." 18. Sakadgm sotpattiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgm sotpattimagga vtivatto, sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa apyagamanya rga apyagamanya dosa {apyagamanya} moha vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Na vattabba "Arah cathi phalehi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu Araht cattri phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti? #<[page 279]># %% {mant.} Haci Arahat cattri phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno, tena vata re vattabbe "Arah cathi phalehi samanngato ti." 20. Na vattabba "Angm thi phalehi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu angmin ti phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti? mant. Haci angmin ti phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno, tena vata re vattabbe "Angm thi phalehi samanngato ti." 21. Na vattabba "Sakadgm dvhi phalehi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu sakadgmin dve phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti? mant. Haci sakadgmin dve phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno, tena vata re vattabbe "Sakadgm dvhi phalehi samanngato ti." 22. Arahat cattri phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti, Arah cathi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Arahat cattro magg pailaddh, tehi ca parihno ti, Arah cathi maggehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 23. {Angmin} ti phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti, angm thi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Angmin tayo magg pailaddh, tehi ca aparihno ti, angm thi maggehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 24. Sakadgmin dve phalni pailaddhni, dvhi ca aparihno ti, sakadgm dvhi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. #<[page 280]># %<280 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 5.>% Sakadgmin dve magg pailaddh, dvhi ca aparihno ti, sakadgm dvhi maggehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samanngatakath. IV.5. 1. Arah chahi upekkhhi samanngato ti? mant. Arah chahi phassehi chahi vedanhi --pe-- chahi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Arah chahi upekkhhi samanngato ti? mant. Arah cakkhun rpa passanto sotena sadda suti, ghnena gandha ghyati, jivhya rasa syati, kyena phohabba phusati, manas dhamma vijnti --pe-- manas dhamma vijnanto cakkhun rpa passati, sotena sadda suti, ghnena gandha ghyati, jivhya rasa syati, kyena phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Arah chahi upekkhhi samanngato ti? mant. Satata samita abbokia chahi upekkhhi samanngato samhito, cha upekkhyo paccuppahit ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Arah chahi upekkhhi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu Arah chaupekkho ti? mant. Haci Arah chaupekkho, tena vata re vattabbe "Arah chahi upekkhhi samanngato ti." Upekkhsamanngatakath. #<[page 281]># %% IV.6. 1. Bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Bodhiy niruddhya vigatya paipassaddhya abuddho hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Attya bodhiy buddho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attya bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? mant. Tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Angatya bodhiy buddho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angatya bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? mant. Tay bodhiy dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? mant. Attya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? #<[page 282]># %<282 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? mant. ttya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti --pe-- magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? mant. Angatya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? mant. Angatya bodhiy buddho, tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti --pe-- magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Attya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? mant. Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti --pe-- magga bhvetti? mant. Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti --pe-- magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Angatya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? mant. Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy bodhikaraya karotti? #<[page 283]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angatya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti --pe-- magga bhvetti? mant. Paccuppannya bodhiy buddho, na ca tya bodhiy dukkha parijnti --pe-- magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Attya bodhiy buddho, angatya bodhiy buddho, paccuppannya bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Thi bodhti buddho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Thi bodhti buddho ti? mant. Satata samita abbokia thi bodhti samanngato samhito, tisso bodhiyo {paccpahit} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Na vattabba "Bodhiy buddho ti"? mant. Nanu bodhipailbh buddho ti? mant. Haci bodhipailbh buddho, tena vata re vattabbe "Bodhiy buddho ti." 10. Bodhipailbh buddho ti, bodhiy buddho ti? mant. Bodhipailbh bodh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhiy buddho ti kath. IV.7. 1. Lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto ti? mant. Padesalakkhaehi samanngato padesabodhisatto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto ti? #<[page 284]># %<284 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 7.>% mant. Tibhgalakkhaehi samanngato tibhgabodhisatto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto ti? mant. Upahalakkhaehi samanngato upahabodhisatto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto ti? mant. Cakkavattisatto lakkhaasamanngato Cakkavattisatto Bodhisatto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkavattisatto lakkhaasamanngato Cakkavattisatto Bodhisatto ti? mant. Ydiso Bodhisattassa pubbayogo pubbacariy, dhammakkhna dhammadesan, tdiso Cakkavattisattassa pubbayogo pubbacariy, dhammakkhna dhammadesan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yath Bodhisattassa jyamnassa dev pahama paiggahanti, pacch manuss; evameva Cakkavattisattassa jyamnassa dev pahama paiggahanti, pacch manuss ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Yath Bodhisattassa jyamnassa cattro devaputt paiggahetv mtu purato hapenti, "Attaman dev hohi, mahesakkho tava putto uppanno ti"; evameva Cakkavattisattassa jyamnassa cattro devaputt paiggahetv mtu purato hapenti, "Attaman dev hohi, mahesakkho tava putto uppanno ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yath Bodhisattassa jyamnassa dve udakassa dhr antalikkh ptubhavanti, ek stassa, ek uhassa, yena Bodhisattassa udakakicca karonti, mtu ca; evameva Cakkavattisattassa jyamnassa dve udakassa dhr antalikkh ptubhavanti, #<[page 285]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ek stassa, ek uhassa, yena Bodhisattassa udakakicca karonti, mtu cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Yath sampatijto Bodhisatto samehi pdehi paihahitv uttarena abhimukho satta padavtihre gacchati setamhi chatte anudhriyamne, sabb ca dis viloketi, sabhi ca vca bhsati, "Aggo' ha asmi lokassa, jeho 'ha asmi lokassa, seho 'ha asmi lokassa, aya antim jti, n' atth' idni punabbhavo ti"; evameva sampatijto Cakkavattisatto samehi pdehi paihahitv uttarena abhimukho satta padavtihre gacchati setamhi chatte anudhriyamne, sabb ca dis viloketi, sabhi ca vca bhsati, Aggo 'ha asmi lokassa, jeho 'ha asmi lokassa, seho 'ha asmi lokassa, aya antim jti, n' atth' idni punabbhavo ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Yath Bodhisattassa jyamnassa mahato lokassa mahato obhsassa mahato bhmiclassa ptubhvo hoti, evameva Cakkavattisattassa jyamnassa mahato lokassa mahato obhsassa mahato bhmiclassa ptubhvo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yath Bodhisattassa pakatikyo samant byma obhsati, evameva Cakkavattisattassa pakatikyo samant byma obhsatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yath Bodhisatto mahsupina {passati,} evameva Cakkavattisatto mahsupina passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Dvattis' imni Bhikkhave mahpurisassa mahpurisalakkhani, yehi samanngatassa mahpurisassa dve 'va gatiyo bhavanti, #<[page 286]># %<286 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 8.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ana; sace agra ajjhvasati, rj hoti Cakkavatt dhammiko dhammarj cturanto vijitv janapadatthvariyappatto sattaratanasamanngato; tass' imni satta ratanni bhavanti, seyyathpda -- cakkaratana hatthiratana assaratana mairatana itthiratana gahapatiratana {pariyakaratana} eva sattama, parosahassa kho pan' assa putt bhavanti sravragarp parasenappamaddan, so ima pahavi sgarapariyanta adaena asatthena dhammena abhivijiya ajjhvasati, sace pana kho agrasm angriya pabbajjati, Araha hoti sammsambuddho loke vivaacchado ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto ti. Lakkhaakath. IV.8. 1. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti? mant. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? mant. Svako hutv buddho hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Svako hutv buddho hotti? mant. Anussaviyo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 287]># %% Anussaviyo ti? mant. Nanu Bhagav sayambh ti? mant. Haci Bhagav sayambh, no vata re vattabbe "Anussaviyo ti." 2. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo cariyabrahmacariyo ti? mant. Bhagavat Bodhiy mle t' eva smaaphalni abhisambuddhnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Bhagavat Bodhiy mle cattri smaaphalni abhisambuddhnti? mant. Haci Bhagavat Bodhiy mle cattri smaaphalni abhisambuddhni, no vata re vattabbe "Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti." 3. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti? mant. Bodhisatto dukkarakrika aksti? mant. Dassanasampanno puggalo dukkara kriya kareyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto aparantapa aksi, aa satthra {uddisiti?} mant. Dassanasampanno puggalo aa satthra uddiseyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. yasm nando bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo cariyabrahmacariyo, yasm nando bhagavato svako ti? mant. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo cariyabrahmacariyo, Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? #<[page 288]># %<288 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 8.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Citto gahapati, Hatthako avako Bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, Citto gahapati Hatthako avako bhagavato svako ti? mant. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? mant. yasm nando bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca bhagavato svako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? mant. Citto gahapati, Hatthako avako bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, na ca bhagavato svako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo cariyabrahmacariyo, na ca Kassapassa bhagavato svako ti? mant. Svako jtivtivatto asvako hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Kassape aha nanda bhagavati brahmacariya acari yati sambodhyti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 289]># %% mant. Tena hi Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti. 7. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sabbbhibh sabbavid 'ha asmi Sabbesu dhammesu anuppalitto Sabbajaho tahakkhaye vimutto, Saya abhiya ka uddiseyya. Na me cariyo atthi, Sadiso me na vijjati, Sadevakasmi lokasmi N' atthi me paipuggalo. Aha hi arah loke, Aha satth anuttaro, Eko 'mhi sammsambuddho, Stibhto 'smi nibbuto. Dhammacakka pavattetu Gacchmi ksina pura Andhabhtasmi lokasmi ha hi amatadudrabhin ti." "Yath kho tva vuso paijnsi arah 'si anantajino ti." "Mdis ve jin honti Ye patt savakkhaya, Jit me ppak dhamm Tasm 'ha Upaka jino ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 290]># %<290 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 9.>% Tena hi na vattabba "Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti." 8. Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ida dukkha ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhu udapdi, a udapdi, pa udapdi, vijj udapdi, loko udapdi; ta kho pan' ida dukkha ariyasacca parieyyan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- paritan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhu udapdi --pe-- loko udapdi; ida dukkhasamudaya ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ta kho pan' ida dukkhasamudaya ariyasacca pahtabban ti me Bhikkhave -- pe -- pahnan ti me Bhikkhave --pe--: ida dukkhanirodha ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ta kho pan' ida dukkhanirodha ariyasacca sacchiktabban ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- sacchikatan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ida dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ta kho pan' ida dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ariyasacca bhvetabban ti me Bhikkhave -- pe -- bhvitan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhu udapdi, a udapdi, pa udapdi, vijj udapdi, loko udapdti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Bodhisatto Kassapassa bhagavato pvacane okkantaniymo cariyabrahmacariyo ti." Niymokkanti kath. IV.9. 1. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo thi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo cathi phassehi cathi vedanhi cathi sahi cathi cetanhi cathi cittehi cathi saddhhi cathi viriyehi cathi sathi cathi samdhhi cathi pahi samanngato ti? #<[page 291]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. "Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dvhi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo thi phassehi thi vedanhi --pe-- thi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dvhi phassehi --pe-- dvhi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpanno sattakhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angm antarparinibby, upahaccaparinibby, {asakhraparinibby,} sasakhraparinibby, uddhasoto akanihagm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? #<[page 292]># %<292 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 9.>% mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpanno sattakkhattuparamo, kolakolo, ekabj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sotpattiphalena samanngato "sotpanno ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sv' eva arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno, so sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalena samanngato "sakadgm ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sv' eva arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno, so sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmiphalena samanngato "angmti" vattabbo ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphalena samanngato ti? #<[page 293]># %% mant. Sv' eva arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno, so angm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sotpattiphalena samanngato "sotpanno ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sv' eva angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno, so sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalena samanngato "sakadgm ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sv' eva angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno, so sakadgm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiphalena samanngato "sotpanno ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sv' eva sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno, so sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe, "Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." #<[page 294]># %<294 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 9.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ 8. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa apyagamanya rga apyagamanya dosa apyagamanya moha vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti." 10. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto, orika kmarga orika bypda vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphalena samanngato ti." #<[page 295]># %% 12. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo angmiphala vtivatto, ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto ti? Amant. Haci angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe, "Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." 14. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpaiphala vtivatto, sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa apyagamanya rga apyagamanya dosa apyagamanya moha vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphalena samanngato ti." 16. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? #<[page 296]># %<296 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 9.>% mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sakadgmiphala vtivatto, orika kmarga orika bypda vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto ti? mant. Haci sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, no vata re vattabbe "Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." 18. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphala vtivatto, sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa apyagamanya rga apyagamanya dosa apyagamanya moha vtivatto, tena samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Na vattabba "Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo thi phalehi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu arahattasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena ti phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti? mant. Haci arahattasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena ti phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno, tena vata re vattabbe "Arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo thi phalehi samanngato ti." 20. Na vattabba "Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dvhi phalehi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena dve phalni pailaddhni, #<[page 297]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tehi ca aparihno ti? mant. Haci angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena dve phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno, tena vata re vattabbe "Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dvhi phalehi samanngato ti." 21. Na vattabba "Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena sotpattiphala pailaddha, tena ca aparihno ti? mant. Haci sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena sotpattiphala pailaddha, tena ca aparihno, tena vata re vattabbe "Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti." 22. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena ti phalni pailaddhni, tehi ca aparihno ti; arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo thi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena cattro magg pailaddh, tehi ca aparihno ti; arahattasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo cathi maggehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 23. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena dve phalni pailaddhni tehi ca aparihno ti; angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dvhi phalehi samanngato ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena tayo magg pailaddh, tehi ca aparihno ti; angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo thi maggehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 24. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena sotpattiphala pailaddha, tena ca aparihno ti; #<[page 298]># %<298 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 10.>% sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo sotpattiphalena samanngato ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannena puggalena dve magg pailaddh, tehi ca aparihno ti; sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipanno puggalo dvhi maggehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Aparpi samanngatakath. IV.10. 1. Sabbasaojanna pahna arahattan ti? mant. Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti? mant. Arahattamaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa pajahatti? mant. Nanu tia saojanna pahna sotpattiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci tia saojanna pahna sotpattiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti." 2. Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti? mant. Arahattamaggena orika kmarga orika bypda pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 299]># %% Arahattamaggena orika kmarga orika bypda pajahatti? mant. Nanu kmargabypdna tanubhva sakadgmiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci kmargabypdna tanubhva sakadgmiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti." 3. Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti? mant. Arahattamaggena ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggena ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda pajahatti? mant. Nanu kmargabypdna anavasesappahna angmiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci kmargabypdna anavasesappahna angmiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti." 4. Arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti? mant. Nanu rparga-arparga-mna-uddhacca-avijjya anavasesappahna arahatta vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci rparga-arparga-mna-uddhacca-avijjya anavasesappahna "Arahatta vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe arahattamaggena sabbe saojan pahyantti." 5. Na vattabba "Sabbasaojanna pahna arahattan ti"? mant. Nanu Arahato sabbe saojan pahn ti? #<[page 300]># %<300 KATHVATTHU. [IV. 10.>% {mant.} Haci Arahato sabbe saojan pahn, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabbasaojanna pahna arahattan ti." Saojanappahnakath. Gih 'ssa Arah, Saha uppattiy Arah, Arahato sabbe dhamm ansav, Arah cathi phalehi samanngato, evameva chahi upekkhhi, Bodhiy buddho, Lakkhaasamanngato Bodhisatto, Bodhisatto okkantaniymo caritabrahmacariyo, Paipannako phalena samanngato, Sabbasaojanna pahna Arahattan ti. Catuttho Vaggo. #<[page 301]># %% V.1. 1. Vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Ya kici vimuttia sabban ta vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. {Paccavekkhanaa} vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Gotrabhuno puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Sotpannassa a sotpattiphala pattassa pailaddhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Sakadgmissa a sakadgmiphala pattassa pailaddhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. ngmissa a angmiphala pattassa pailaddhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. #<[page 302]># %<302 KATHVATTHU. [V. 1.>% Arahato a arahatta pattassa pailaddhassa adhigatassa sacchikatassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sotpattiphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmisamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmiphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattaphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sotpattiphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimutta, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? mant. Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimutta, ta ca phala paassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimuttam, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? #<[page 303]># %% mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimutta, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angmiphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttiam vimutta, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? mant. Angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimutta, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattaphalasamagissa puggalassa vimuttia vimutta, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? mant. Arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa vimuttia vimutta, ta ca phala pattassa an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vimuttikath. V.2. 1. Sekhassa asekha a atthti? mant. Sekho asekha dhamma jnti passati, diha vidita sacchikata upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu sekho asekha dhamma na jnti, na passati, adiham avidita asacchikata na upasampajja viharati, na kyena phusitv viharatti? mant. Haci sekho asekha dhamma na jnti, na passati, adiham avidita asacchikata na upasampajja viharati, na kyena phusitv viharati, no vata re vattabbe "Sekhassa asekha a atthti." #<[page 304]># %<304 KATHVATTHU. [V. 2.>% 2. Asekhassa asekha a atthi, asekho asekha dhamma jnti passati, diham vidita sacchikata upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharatti? mant. Sekhassa asekha a atthi, sekho asekha dhamma jnti passati, diham vidita sacchikata upasampajja viharati, kyena phusitv viharatti? mant. Sekhassa asekha a atthi, sekho asekha dhamma na jnti na passati, adiham avidita asacchikata na upasampajja viharati, na kyena phusitv viharatti? mant. Asekhassa asekha a atthi, asekho asekha dhamma na jnti na passati, adiha avidita asacchikata na upasampajja viharati, na kyena phusitv viharatti? mant. 3. Sekhassa asekha a atthti? mant. Gotrabhuno puggalassa sotpattimagge a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa sotpattiphale a atthti? mant. Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya --pe-- angmiphalasacchikiriyya --pe-- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa arahatte a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Sekhassa asekha a atthti"? mant. Nanu yasm nando sekho "Bhagav uro ti" jnti, "Sriputto thero, Mah Moggallno thero uro ti" jntti? mant. Haci yasm nando sekho "Bhagav uro ti" jnti, #<[page 305]># %% "Sriputto thero, Mah Moggallno thero uro ti" jnti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sekhassa asekha a atthti." Asekhaakath. V.3. 1. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti? mant. Anicce niccan ti vipariyeso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhe sukhan ti --pe-- anattani att ti --pe-- asubhe subhan ti vipariyeso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti? mant. Akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu kusalan ti? mant. Haci kusala, no vata re vattabbe "Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti." 3. Anicce niccan ti vipariyeso, so ca akusalo ti? mant. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte a, ta ca akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhe sukhan ti --pe-- anattani att ti --pe-- asubhe subhan ti vipariyeso, so ca akusalo ti? mant. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte a, ta ca akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 21 #<[page 306]># %<306 KATHVATTHU. [V. 3.>% 4. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte a, ta ca kusalan ti? mant. Anicce niccan ti vipariyeso, so ca kusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte a, ta ca kusalan ti? mant. Dukkhe sukhan ti --pe-- anattani att ti --pe-- asubhe subhan ti vipariyeso, so ca kusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti? mant. Arah pahavkasiasampatti sampajjeyyti? mant. Haci Arah pahavkasiasampatti sampajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe "Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti." 6. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte a, Arah pahavkasiasampatti sampajjeyyti? mant. Atthi Arahato vipariyeso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahato vipariyeso ti? mant. Atthi Arahato savipariyeso, cittavipariyeso, dihivipariyeso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato savipariyeso, cittavipariyeso, dihivipariyeso ti? mant. Haci n' atthi Arahato savipariyeso, cittavipariyeso, dihivipariyeso, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato vipariyeso ti." 7. Na vattabba "Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti? mant. #<[page 307]># %% Pahavti sampajjantassa sabb' eva pahav hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti. 8. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti? mant. Nanu pahav atthi, atthi ca koci pahavi pahavito sampajjatti? mant. Haci pahav atthi, atthi ca koci pahavi pahavito sampajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti." Pahav atthi, pahavi pahavito sampajjantassa viparta hotti? mant. Nibbna atthi, nibbna nibbnato sampajjantassa viparta hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi na vattabba "Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa viparte an ti." Vipartakath. V.4. 1. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? mant. Niyatassa aniymagamanya atthi an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Niyatassa aniymagamanya n' atthi an ti? mant. Aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? #<[page 308]># %<308 KATHVATTHU. [V. 4.>% mant. Niyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Niyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi an ti? mant. Aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? mant. Aniyatassa aniymagamanya atthi an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Aniyatassa aniymagamanya n' atthi an ti? mant. Aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? mant. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi niymo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? mant. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi satipahn --pe-- sammappadhn, iddhipd, indriy, bal, bojjhag ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi niymo ti? mant. Haci aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi niymo, no vata re vattabbe "Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti." Aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi satipahn --pe-- bojjhag ti? mant. Haci aniyatassa niymagamanya n' atthi bojjhag, no vata re vattabbe "Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti." 6. Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti? mant. #<[page 309]># %% Gotrabhuno puggalassa sotpattimagge a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa sotpattiphale a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya --pe-- angmiphalasacchikiriyya --pe-- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa arahatte a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti."? Nanu Bhagav jnti "Aya puggalo sammattaniyma okkamissati, bhabbo aya puggalo dhamma abhisametun ti"? mant. Haci Bhagav jnti "Aya puggalo sammattaniyma okkamissati, bhabbo aya puggalo dhamma abhisametu," tena vata re vattabbe "Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi an ti." Niymakath. V.5. 1. Sabba a paisambhid ti? mant. Sammutia paisambhid ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammutia paisambhid ti? mant. Ye keci sammuti jnanti, sabbe te paisambhidappatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabba a paisambhid ti? mant. Cetopariyye a paisambhid ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 310]># %<310 KATHVATTHU. [V. 6.>% Cetopariyye a paisambhid ti? mant. Ye keci paracitta jnanti, sabbe te paisambhidappatt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sabba a paisambhid ti? mant. Sabb pa paisambhid ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb pa paisambhid ti? mant. Pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa atthi pa, s pa paisambhid ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- pokasia --pe-- tejokasia --pe-- vyokasia -- pe -- nlakasia --pe-- ptakasia --pe-- lohitakasia -- pe -- odtakasia --pe-- ksnacyatana --pe-- viacyatana --pe-- kicayatana --pe-- nevasansayatana sampannassa --pe-- dna dadantassa --pe-- cvara dadantassa --pe-- piapta dadantassa --pe-- sensana dadantassa --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadantassa atthi pa, s pa paisambhid ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Sabba a paisambhid ti"? mant. Atthi lokuttar pa, s na paisambhid ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi sabba a paisambhid ti. Paisambhidakath. V. 6. 1. Na vattabba "Sammutia saccrammaa eva na {arammaa} ti"? mant. #<[page 311]># %% Nanu {pahavkasiasampatti} sampannassa atthi a, pahavkasia ca sammutisaccamhti? mant. Haci pahavkasiasampatti sampannassa atthi a, {pahavkasia} ca sammutisaccamhi, tena vata re vattabbe "Sammutia saccrammaa eva na arammaan ti." 2. Na vattabba "Sammutia saccrammaa eva na arammaan ti"? mant. Nanu pokasia --pe-- tejokasia --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadantassa atthi a, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro ca sammutisaccamhti? mant. Haci gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadantassa atthi a, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro ca sammutisaccamhi, tena vata re vattabbe "Sammutia saccrammaa eva na arammaan ti." 3. Sammutia saccrammaa eva na arammaan ti? mant. Tena ena dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammutiakath. V.7. 1. Cetopariyye a cittrammaa eva na arammaan ti? mant. Nanu atthi koci sarga citta "sarga cittan ti" pajntti? mant. Haci atthi koci sarga citta "sarga cittan ti" pajnti, no vata re vattabbe" Cetopariyye a cittrammaa eva na arammaan ti." #<[page 312]># %<312 KATHVATTHU. [V. 7.>% Nanu atthi koci vtarga citta "vtarga cittan ti" --pe-- sadosa citta --pe-- vtadosa citta --pe-- samoha citta --pe-- vtamoha citta, sakhitta citta, vikkhitta citta, mahaggata citta, amahaggata citta, sa-uttara citta, anuttara citta, samhita citta, asamhita citta, vimutta citta --pe-- avimutta citta "avimutta cittan ti" pajntti? mant. Haci atthi koci avimutta citta "avimutta cittan ti" pajnti, no vata re vattabbe "Cetopariyye a cittrammaa eva na arammaan ti." 2. Phassrammae a vattabba cetopariyye an ti? mant. Haci phassrammae a vattabba cetopariyye a, no vata re vattabbe "Cetopariyye a cittrammaa eva na arammaan ti." Vedanrammae a, sarammae a, cetanrammae a, cittrammae a, saddhrammae a, viriyrammae a, satrammae a, samdhrammae a, parammae a --pe-- rgrammae a --pe-- dosrammae a --pe-- anottapprammae a vattabba cetopariyye an ti? mant. Haci anottapprammae a vattabba cetopariyye a, no vata re vattabbe "Cetopariyye a cittrammaa eva na arammaan ti." 3. Phassrammae a na vattabba cetopariyye an ti? mant. Phassapariyye an ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedanrammae a --pe-- sarammae a -- pe -- anottapprammae a na vattabba cetopariyye an ti? mant. Anottappapariyye an ti? #<[page 313]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Cetopariyye a cittrammaa eva na arammaan ti"? mant. Nanu cetopariyye an ti? mant. Haci cetopariyye a, tena vata re vattabbe "Cetopariyye a {cittrammaa} eva na arammaan ti." Cittrammaakath. V.8. 1. Angate a atthti? mant. Angata mlato jnti, hetuto jnti, nidnato jnti, {sambhavato} jnti, pabhavato jnti, samuhnato jnti, hrato jnti, rammaato jnti, paccayato jnti, samudayato jntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Angate a atthti? mant. Angata hetupaccayata jnti, rammaapaccayata jnti, adhipatipaccayata jnti, anantarapaccayata jnti, samanantarapaccayata jntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Angate a atthti? mant. Gotrabhuno puggalassa sotpattimagge a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa sotpattiphale a hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa --pe-- angmiphalasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa #<[page 314]># %<314 KATHVATTHU. [V. 9.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- arahattasacchikiriyya paipannassa puggalassa arahatte a atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Angate a atthti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ptaliputtassa kho nanda tayo antary bhavissanti, aggito v udakato v mithubhed v ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi angate a atthti. Angataakath. V.9. 1. Paccuppanne a atthti? mant. Tena ena ta a jntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena ena ta a jntti? mant. Tena ena ta a an ti jntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena ena ta a an ti jntti? mant. Ta a tassa assa rammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta a tassa assa rammaan ti? mant. Tena phassena ta phassa phusati, tya vedanya ta vedana vedeti, tya saya ta saa sajnti, tya cetanya ta cetana ceteti, tena cittena ta citta cinteti, tena vitakkena ta vitakka vitakketi, tena vicrena ta vicra vicreti, tya ptiy ta pti {piyyati,} tya satiy ta sati sarati, tya paya ta paa pajnti, tena khaggena ta khagga chindati, tena pharasun ta pharusa tacchati, #<[page 315]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tya kuhriy ta kuhri tacchati, tya vsiy ta vsi tacchati, tya sciy ta sci sibbeti, tena agulaggena ta agulagga parmasati, tena nsikaggena ta nsikagga parmasati, tena matthakena ta matthaka parmasati, tena gthena ta gtha dhovati, tena muttena ta mutta dhovati, tena kheena ta khea dhovati, tena pubbena ta pubba dhovati, tena lohitena ta lohita dhovatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Paccuppanne a atthti"? mant. Nanu sabbe sakhre aniccato dihe ta pi a aniccato diha hotti? mant. Haci sabbe sakhre aniccato dihe ta pi a aniccato diha hoti, tena vata re vattabbe "Paccuppanne a atthti." Paccuppannaakath. V.10. 1. Svakassa phale a atthti? mant. Svako phalassa kata papetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Svakassa phale a papetti? mant. Atthi svakassa phalaparopariyatti, indriyaparopariyatti, puggalaparopariyattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Svakassa phale a atthti? mant. Atthi svakassa khandhapaatti, yatanapaatti, #<[page 316]># %<316 KATHVATTHU. [V. 10.>% dhtupaatti, saccapaatti, indriyapaatti, puggalapaattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Svakassa phale a atthti? mant. Svako jino satth sammsambuddho sabba sabbadassv dhammasm dhammapaisarao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Svakassa phale a atthti? mant. Svako anupannassa maggassa uppdet asajtassa maggassa sajanet anakkhtassa maggassa akkht magga maggavid maggakovido ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Svakassa phale a atthti? mant. Svako a ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi svakassa phale a atthti. Phalaakath. Vimuttia vimutta, Sekhassa asekha a, Viparte a, Aniyatassa niymagamanya atthi a, Sabba a paisambhid ti, Sammutia, Cetopariyye a, Angate a, Paccuppanne a, Svakassa phale an ti. Pacamo Vaggo. Mahpasako. #<[page 317]># %% VI.1. 1. Niymo asakhato ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Niymo asakhato, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni, dve leni, dve sarani, dve paryanni, dve accutni, dve amatni, dve nibbnnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nibbnnti? mant. Atthi dvinna nibbnna uccancat, hnappatat, ukkasvakaso, sm v bhedo v rj v antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Niymo asakhato ti? mant. Atthi keci niyma okkamanti pailabhanti, uppdenti samuppdenti, uhpenti samuhpenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sajanentti? mant. Atthi keci asakhata okkamanti pailabhanti, uppdenti samuppdenti, uhpenti samuhpenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sajanentti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Niymo asakhato ti? mant. Maggo asakhato ti? #<[page 318]># %<318 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 1.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggo sakhato ti? mant. Niymo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiniymo asakhato ti? mant. Sotpattimaggo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattimaggo sakhato ti? mant. Sotpattiniymo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgminiymo --pe-- angminiymo --pe-- arahattaniymo asakhato ti? mant. Arahattamaggo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggo sakhato ti? mant. Arahattaniymo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sotpattiniymo asakhato --pe-- arahattaniymo asakhato, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Paca asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paca asakhatnti? mant. Paca tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Niymo asakhato ti? mant. Micchattaniymo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Micchattaniymo sakhato ti? mant. Sammattaniymo sakhato ti? #<[page 319]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Niymo asakhato ti"? mant. Niyme uppajja niruddhe aniyato hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi niymo asakhato ti. Micchattaniyme uppajja niruddhe aniyato hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi micchattaniymo asakhato ti. Niymakath. VI.2. 1. Paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti? mant. {Nibbna} ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paiccasamuppdo asakhato, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni, dve leni, dve sarani, dve paryanni, dve accutni, dve amatni, dve nibbnnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve nibbnnti? mant. Atthi dvinna nibbnna uccancat, hnappatat, ukkasvakaso, sm v bhedo v rj v antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 320]># %<320 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 2.>% 2. Paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti? mant. Avijj asakhat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avijj sakhat ti? mant. Paiccasamuppdo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti? mant. Avijjpaccay sakhr asakhat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avijjpaccay sakhr sakhat ti? mant. Paiccasamuppdo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti? mant. Sakhrapaccay via asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrapaccay via sakhatan ti? mant. Paiccasamuppdo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti? mant. Viapaccay nmarpa asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Viapaccay nmarpa sakhatan ti? mant. Paiccasamuppdo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti? mant. Jtipaccay jarmaraa asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jtipaccay jarmaraa sakhatan ti? mant. #<[page 321]># %% Paiccasamuppdo sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Jtipaccay Bhikkhave jarmaraa, uppd v Tathgatna anuppd v Tathgatna hit 'va s dhtu dhammahitat dhammaniymat idappaccayat; ta Tathgato abhisambujjhati, abhisameti; abhisambujjhitv abhisametv cikkhati deseti, {papeti} pahapeti, vivarati vibhajati uttnkaroti; passathti c' ha jtipaccay Bhikkhave jarmaraa, bhavapaccay Bhikkhave jti --pe-- avijjpaccay Bhikkhave sakhr uppd v Tathgatna anuppd v Tathgatna hit 'va s dhtu --pe-- passathti c' ha avijjpaccay Bhikkhave sakhr, iti kho Bhikkhave y tatra tathat avitathat anaathat idappaccayat, aya vuccati Bhikkhave paiccasamuppdo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi paiccasamuppdo asakhato ti. 5. "Avijjpaccay sakhr ti" y tattha dhammahitat dhammaniymat asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. "Avijjpaccay sakhr ti" y tattha dhammahitat dhammaniymat asakhat, "sakhrapaccay vian ti" y tattha dhammahitat dhammaniymat asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ti asakhatnti? #<[page 322]># %<322 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 3.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ti asakhatnti? mant. Ti tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. "Avijjpaccay sakhr ti" y tattha dhammahitat dhammaniymat asakhat, "sakhrapaccay vian ti" y tattha dhammahitat dhammaniymat asakhat --pe--, "jtipaccay jarmaraan ti" y tattha dhammahitat dhammaniymat asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dvdasa asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvdasa asakhatnti? mant. Dvdasa tni --pe-- dvdasa leni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paiccasamuppdakath. VI.3. 1. Cattri saccni asakhatnti? mant. Cattri tni, cattri leni, cattri sarani, cattri paryanni, cattri accutni, cattri amatni, cattri nibbnnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cattri nibbnnti? mant. Atthi {catunna} nibbnna uccancat, hnappatat, ukkasvakaso, sm v bhedo v rj v antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dukkhasacca asakhatan ti? #<[page 323]># %% mant. Dukkha asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhasacca asakhatan ti? mant. Kyika dukkha, cetasika dukkha, sokaparidevadukkhadomanasspys asakhat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayasacca asakhatan ti? mant. Samudayo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayasacca asakhatan ti? mant. Kmatah bhavatah vibhavatah asakhat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasacca asakhatan ti? mant. Maggo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasacca asakhatan ti? mant. Sammdihi --pe-- sammsamdhi asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Dukkha sakhatan ti? mant. Dukkhasacca sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyika dukkha, cetasika dukkha, sokaparidevadukkhadomanasspys sakhat ti? mant. Dukkhasacca asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayo sakhato ti? mant. Samudayasacca sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmatah bhavatah vibhavatah sakhat ti? #<[page 324]># %<324 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 3.>% mant. Samudayasacca sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggo sakhato ti? mant. Maggasacca sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammdihi --pe-- sammsamdhi sakhato ti? mant. Maggasacca sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Nirodhasacca asakhata, nirodho asakhato ti? mant. Dukkhasacca asakhata, dukkha asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodhasacca asakhata, nirodho asakhato ti? mant. Samudayasacca asakhata, samudayo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodhasacca asakhata, nirodho asakhato ti? mant. Maggasacca asakhata, maggo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Dukkhasacca asakhata, dukkha sakhatan ti? mant. Nirodhasacca asakhata, nirodho sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samudayasacca asakhata, samudayo sakhato ti? mant. Nirodhasacca asakhata, nirodho sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasacca asakhata, maggo sakhato ti? mant. Nirodhasacca asakhata nirodho sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattaba "Cattri saccni asakhatnti"? #<[page 325]># %% mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave tathni avitathni anaathni. Katamni cattri? Ida dukkhan ti Bhikkhave tatha eta avitatha eta anaatha eta --pe-- aya dukkhasamudayo ti --pe-- aya dukkhanirodho ti --pe-- aya dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ti tatha eta avitatha eta anaatha eta: imni kho Bhikkhave cattri tathni avitathni anaathnti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi cattri saccni asakhatnti. Saccakath. VI.4. 1. ksnacyatana asakhatan ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- ksnacyatana asakhata, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. ksnacyatana asakhatan ti? mant. ksnacyatana bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. #<[page 326]># %<326 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 4.>% Asakhata bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi ksnacyatanpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi asakhatpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi ksnacyatanpag satt ti? mant. Atthi asakhatpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. ksnacyatane satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Asakhate satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- ksnacyatane atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Asakhate atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- ksnacyatana catuvokrabhavo ti? mant. Asakhata catuvokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Cattro rupp asakhat ti"? mant. Nanu cattro rupp anej vutt Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci cattro rupp anej vutt Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe "Cattro rupp asakhat ti." ruppakath. #<[page 327]># %% VI.5. 1. Nirodhasampatti asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodhasampatti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi keci nirodha sampajjanti pailabhanti, uppdenti samuppdenti, uhpenti samuhpenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sajanentti? mant. Atthi keci asakhata sampajjanti pailabhanti, uppdenti samuppdenti, uhpenti samuhpenti, nibbattenti abhinibbattenti, janenti sajanentti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Nirodh vodna vuhna payatti? mant. Asakhat vodna vuhna payatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodha sampajjantassa pahama nirujjhati vacsakhro, tato kyasakhro, tato cittasakhro ti? mant. Asakhata sampajjantassa pahama nirujjhati vacsakhro, tato kyasakhro, tato cittasakhro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodh vuhahantassa pahama uppajjati cittasakhro, tato kyasakhro, tato vacsakhro ti? #<[page 328]># %<328 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 6.>% mant. Asakhat vuhahantassa pahama uppajjati cittasakhro, tato kyasakhro, tato vacsahro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Nirodh vuhita tayo phass phusanti, suato phasso, animitto phasso, appaihito phasso ti? mant. Asakhat vuhita tayo phass phusanti, suato phasso, animitto phasso, appaihito phasso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodh vuhitassa vivekaninna citta hoti vivekapoa vivekapabbhran ti? mant. Asakhat vuhitassa vivekaninna citta hoti vivekopoa vivekapabbhran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Nirodhasampatti asakhat ti"? mant. Sakhat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi nirodhasampatti asakhat ti. Nirodhasampattikath. VI.6. 1. kso asakhato ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- kso asakhato, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? #<[page 329]># %% mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. kso asakhato ti? mant. Atthi keci anksa ksa karontti? mant. Atthi keci sakhata asakhata karontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi keci ksa anksa karontti? mant. Atthi keci asakhata {sakhata} karontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. kse pakkhiyo gacchanti, candhimasuriy gacchanti, trakarpni gacchanti, iddhi vikubbanti, bhu clenti, pi clenti, leum khipanti, lagua khipanti, iddhi khipanti, usu khipantti? mant. Asakhate pakkhiyo gacchanti, candhimasuriy gacchanti, trakarpni gacchanti, iddhi vikubbanti, bhu clenti, pi clenti, leum khipanti, lagua khipanti, iddhi khipanti, usu khipanti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. ksa parivretv gharni karonti, kohni karontti? mant. Asakhata parivretv gharni karonti, kohni karontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Udapne khaamne ankso kso hotti? mant. Sakhata asakhata hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tuccha-udapne priyamne, tucchakohe priyamne, tucchakumbhiy priyamnya, kso antaradhyatti? mant. #<[page 330]># %<330 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 7.>% Asakhata antaradhyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "kso asakhato ti"? mant. kso sakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi kso asakhato ti. ksakath. VI.7. 1. kso sanidassano ti? mant. Rpa rpyatana rpadhtu nla ptaka lohitaka odta cakkhuvieyya cakkhusmi paihaati cakkhussa ptha gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. kso sanidassano ti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca ksa ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca ksa ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca ksa ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati {cakkhuvian} ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe #<[page 331]># %% "Cakkhu ca paicca ksa ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." 3. Na vattabba "kso sanidassano ti"? mant. Nanu passati dvinna rukkhna antara, dvinna thambhna antara, tlacchidda, vtapnacchiddan ti? mant. Haci passati dvinna rukkhna antara, dvinna thambhna antara, tlacchidda, vtapnacchidda, tena vata re vattabbe "kso sanidassano ti." kso sanidassano ti kath. VI.8. 1. Pahavdhtu sanidassan ti? mant. Rpa rpyatana rpadhtu nla ptaka lohitaka odta cakkhuvieyya cakkhusmi paihaati cakkhussa ptham gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Pahavdhtu sanidassan ti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca pahavdhtu ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca pahavdhtu ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca pahavdhtu ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 332]># %<332 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 8.>% Haci "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati {cakkhuvian} ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhu ca paicca pahavdhtu ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? 3. Na vattabba "Pahavdhtu sanidassan ti"? mant. Nanu passati bhmi psa pabbatan ti? mant. Haci passati bhmi psa pabbata, tena vata re vattabbe "Pahavdhtu sanidassan ti." Na vattabba "podhtu sanidassan ti"? mant. Nanu passati udakan ti? mant. Haci passati udaka, tena vata re vattabbe "podhtu sanidassan ti." Na vattabba "Tejodhtu sanidassan ti"? mant. Nanu passati aggi jalantan ti? mant. Haci passati aggi jalanta, tena vata re vattabbe "Tejodhtu sanidassan ti." Na vattabba "Vyodhtu sanidassan ti"? mant. Nanu passati vtena rukkhe sacliyamne ti? mant. Haci passati vtena rukkhe sacliyamne, tena vata re vattabbe "Vyodhtu sanidassan ti." 4. Cakkhundriyam sanidassanan ti? mant. Rpa rpyatana rpadhtu nla ptaka lohitaka odta cakkhuvieyya cakkhusmi paihaati cakkhussa ptha gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Cakkhundriya sanidassanan ti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca cakkhundriya ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? #<[page 333]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca cakkhundriya ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca cakkhundriya ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhu ca paicca cakkhundriya ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." 6. Na vattabba "Pac' indriyni sanidassannti"? mant. Nanu passati cakkhu sota ghna jivha kyan ti? mant. Haci passati cakkhu sota ghna jivha kya, tena vata re vattabbe "Pac' indriyni sanidassannti." 7. Kyakamma sanidassanan ti? mant. Rpa rpyatana rpadhtu nla ptaka lohitaka odta cakkhuvieyya cakkhusmi paihaati cakkhussa ptha gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Kyakamma sanidassanan ti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca kyakamma ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca kyakamma ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca kyakamma ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. #<[page 334]># %<334 KATHVATTHU. [VI. 8.>% "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe {"Cakkhu} ca paicca kyakamma ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." 9. Na vattabba "Kyakamma sanidassanan ti"? mant. Nanu passati abhikkamanta paikkamanta lokenta vilokenta {samijenta} pasrentan ti? mant. Haci passati abhikkamanta paikkamanta lokenta vilokenta samijeta pasrenta, tena vata re vattabbe "Kyakamma sanidassanan ti." Pahavdhtu sanidassan ti dikath, kyakamma sanidassanan ti {pariyosnakath.} Chaho Vaggo. Niymo asakhato, Paiccasamuppdo asakhato, Cattri saccni asakhatni, Cattro rupp asakhat, Nirodhasampatti asakhat, kso asakhato, kso sanidassano, Cattro mahbht, Pac' indriyni, tatth' eva Kyakamman ti. #<[page 335]># %% VII.1. 1. N' atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sagaht ti? mant. Nanu atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi gaana gacchanti, uddesa gacchanti, pariypann ti? mant. Haci atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi gaana gacchanti, uddesa gacchanti, pariypann, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sagaht ti." 2. Cakkhyatana katama {khandhagaana} gacchatti? Rpakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci rpakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Cakkhyatana rpakkhandhena sagahtan ti." Sotyatana --pe-- ghnyatana --pe-- jivhyatana --pe-- kyyatana katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Rpakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci kyyatana rpakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Kyyatana rpakkhandhena sagahtan ti." 3. Rpyatana --pe-- saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana --pe-- rasyatana --pe-- phohabbyatana katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Rpakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci phohabbyatana rpakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Phohabbyatana rpakkhandhena sagahtan ti." 4. Sukh vedan katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Vedankkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci sukh vedan vedankkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Sukh vedan vedankkhandhena sagaht ti." Dukkh vedan --pe-- adukkhamasukh vedan katama khandhagaana gacchatti? #<[page 336]># %<336 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 1.>% Vedankkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci adukkhamasukh vedan vedankkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Adukkhamasukkh vedan vedankkhandhena sagaht ti." 5. Cakkhusamphassaj sa katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Sakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci cakkhusamphassaj sa sakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Cakkhusamphassaj sa sakkhandhena sagaht ti." Sotasamphassaj sa --pe-- manosamphassaj sa katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Sakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci manosamphassaj sa sakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Manosamphassaj sa sakkhandhena sagaht ti." 6. Cakkhusamphassaj cetan --pe-- manosamphassaj cetan katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Sakhrakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci manosamphassaj cetan sakhrakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Manosamphassaj cetan sakhrakkhandhena sagaht ti." 7. Cakkhuvia --pe-- manovia katama khandhagaana gacchatti? Viakkhandhagaana gacchatti. Haci manovia viakkhandhagaana gacchati, tena vata re vattabbe "Manovia viakkhandhena sagahtan ti." 8. Yath dmena v yottena v dve balibadd sagaht, sikkya piapto sagahto, s gaddulena sagahto; evameva te dhamm tehi dhammehi sagaht ti? mant. Haci dmena v yottena v dve balibadd sagaht, #<[page 337]># %% sikkya piapto sagahto, s gaddulena sagahto, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sagaht ti." Sagahtakath. VII.2. 1. N' atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sampayutt ti? mant. Nanu atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sahagat sahajt sasah ekuppd ekanirodh ekavatthuk ekramma ti? mant. Haci atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sahagat sahajt sasah ekuppd ekanirodh ekavatthuk ekramma, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi keci dhamm kehici dhammehi sampayutt ti." 2. Vedankkhandho sakkhandhena sahajto ti? mant. Haci vedankkhandho sakkhandhena sahajto, tena vata re vattabbe "Vedankkhandho sakkhandhena sampayutto ti." Vedankkhandho sakhrakkhandhena viakkhandhena sahajto ti? mant. Haci vedankkhando viakkhandhena sahajto, tena vata re vattabbe "Vedankkhandho viakkhandhena sampayutto ti." Sakkhandho, sakhrakkhandho, viakkhandho vedankkhandhena, sakkhandhena, sakhrakkhandhena sahajto ti? mant. Haci viakkhandho sakhrakkhandhena saha- #<[page 338]># %<338 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 3.>% Jto, tena vata re vattabbe "Viakkhandho sakhrakkhandhena sampayutto ti." Yath tilamhi tela anugata anupaviha, ucchumhi raso anugato anupaviho, evameva te dhamm tehi dhammehi anugat anupavih ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampayuttakath. VII.3. 1. N' atthi cetasiko dhammo ti? mant. Nanu atthi keci dhamm cittena sahagat sahajt sasah sampayutt ekuppd ekanirodh ekavatthuk ekramma ti? mant. Haci atthi keci dhamm cittena sahagat sahajt sasah sampayutt ekuppd ekanirodh ekavatthuk ekramma, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi cetasiko dhammo ti." 2. Phasso cittena sahajto ti? mant. Haci phasso cittena sahajto, tena vata re vattabbe "Phasso cetasiko ti." Vedan --pe-- sa, cetan --pe-- saddh viriya sati samdhi pa rgo doso moho --pe-- anottappa cittena sahajtan ti? mant. Haci anottappa cittena sahajta, tena vata re vattabbe "Anottappa cetasikan ti." 3. Cittena sahajt ti katv cetasik ti? mant. Phassena sahajt ti katv phassik ti? mant. Cittena sahajt ti katv cetasik ti? #<[page 339]># %% mant. Vedanya --pe-- saya cetanya saddhya viriyena satiy samdhiy paya rgena dosena mohena --pe-- anottappena sahajt ti katv anottappsik ti? mant. 4. N' atthi cetasiko dhammo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Citta h' ida cetasik ca dhamm Anattato {saviditassa} honti. Hnappata tadubhaye viditv Sammaddaso vedi palokadhamman ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi cetasiko dhammo ti. 5. N' atthi cetasiko dhammo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Kevaa bhikkhu parasattna parapuggalna citta pi disati, cetasika pi disati, vitakkita pi disati, vicrita pi disati `Eva pi te mano, ittha pi te mano, iti pi te cittan ti,"' Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi cetasiko dhammo ti. Cetasikakath. VII.4. 1. Cetasiko dhammo dnan ti? mant. #<[page 340]># %<340 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 4.>% Labbh cetasiko dhammo paresa dtun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh cetasiko dhammo paresa dtun ti? mant. Labbh phasso paresa dtun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh vedan --pe-- sa cetan saddh viriya sati samdhi --pe-- pa paresa dtun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Cetasiko dhammo dnan ti"? mant. Dna anihaphala akantaphala amanuaphala secanakaphala dukkhindriya dukkhavipkan ti? Nanu dna ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipkan ti? mant. Haci dna ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipka, tena vata re vattabbe "Cetasiko dhammo dnan ti." 3. Dna ihaphala vutta Bhgavat, cvara dnan ti? mant. Cvara ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dna ihaphala vutta Bhagavat, piapto, sensana, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro dnan ti? mant. Gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro ihaphalo kantaphalo manuaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhindriyo sukhavipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Cetasiko dhammo dnan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- #<[page 341]># %% "Saddh hiriya kusala ca dna Dhamm ete sappurisnuyt Eta hi magga diviya vadanti Etena hi gacchati devalokan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi cetasiko dhammo dnan ti. 5. Na vattabba "Cetasiko dhammo dnan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' imni Bhikkhave dnni mahdnni aggani rattani vasani porni asakini asakiapubbni na sakyanti, na sakyissanti, appaikuhni samaehi brhmaehi vihi. Katamni paca? Idha Bhikkhave ariyasvako ptipta pahya ptipt paivirato hoti, ptipt paivirato Bhikkhave ariyasvako aparimna sattna abhaya deti, avera deti, abypajjha deti, aparimna sattna abhaya datv, avera datv, abypajjha datv aparimassa abhayassa averassa abypajjhassa bhg hoti: ida Bhikkhave pahama dna mahdna aggaa rattaa vasaa porna asakia asakiapubba na sakyati, na sakyissati, appaikuha samaehi brhmaehi vihi. Puna ca para Bhikkhave ariyasvako adinndya pahya --pe-- kmesu micchcra pahya --pe-- musvda pahya --pe-- surmerayamajjapamdahna pahya surmerayamajjapamdahn paivirato hoti, surmerayamajjapamdahn paivirato Bhikkhave ariyasvako aparimna sattna abhaya deti, avera deti, abypajjha deti, aparimna s-ttna abhaya datv, avera datv, abypajjha datv aparimassa abhayassa averassa abypajjhassa bhg hoti: ida Bhikkhave pacama dna mhdna aggaa rattaa vasaa porna asakia asakiapubba na sakyati, #<[page 342]># %<342 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 4.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ na sakyissati, appaikuha samaehi brhmaehi vihi. Imni kho Bhikkhave paca dnni mahdnni aggani rattani vasani porni asakini asakiapubbni na sakyanti, na sakyissanti, appaikuhni samaehi brhmaehi {viuhti.}" Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi cetasiko dhammo dnan ti. 6. Na vattabba "Deyyadhammo dnan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idh' ekacco anna deti, pna deti, vattha deti, yna deti, mla deti, gandha deti, vilepana deti, seyya deti, vasatha deti, padpeyya detti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi deyyadhammo dnan ti. 7. Deyyadhammo dnan ti? mant. Deyyadhammo ihaphalo kantaphalo manuaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhindriyo sukhavipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dna ihaphala vutta Bhagavat, cvara dnan ti? mant. Cvara ihaphala kantaphala manuaphala asecanakaphala sukhindriya sukhavipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dna ihaphala vutta Bhagavat, piapto dna, sensana dna, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro dnan ti? mant. Gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro ihaphalo kantaphalo manuaphalo asecanakaphalo sukhindriyo sukhavipko ti? #<[page 343]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi na vattabba "Deyyadhammo dnan ti." Dnakath. VII.5. 1. Paribhogamaya pua vahatti? mant. Paribhogamayo phasso vahati, vedan vahati, sa vahati, cetan vahati, citta vahati, saddh vahati, viriya vahati, sati vahati, samdhi vahati, pa vahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paribhogamaya pua vaddhatti? mant. Lat viya vahati, mluv viya vahati, rukkho viya vahati, tia viya vahati, pujapujo viya vahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Paribhogamaya pua {vahatti?} mant. Dyako dna datv na samannharati, hoti puan ti? mant. Anvaantassa hoti, anbhogassa hoti, asamannharantassa hoti, amanasikarontassa hoti, acetayantassa hoti, apatthayantassa hoti, apaidahantassa hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu vahantassa hoti, bhogassa hoti, samannharantassa hoti, manasikarontassa hoti, cetayantassa hoti patthayantassa hoti, paidahantassa hotti? mant. #<[page 344]># %<344 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 5.>% Haci vaantassa hoti, bhogassa hoti, samannharantassa hoti, manasikarontassa hoti, cetayantassa hoti, patthayantassa hoti, paidahantassa hoti, no vata re vattabbe "Paribhogamaya pua vahatti." 3. Paribhogamaya pua {vahatti?} mant. Dyako dna datv kmavitakka vitakketi, bypdavitakka vitakketi, vihisvitakka vitakketi, hoti puan ti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappay kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Nabha ca Bhikkhave pahav ca ida pahama suvidravidra; orima ca Bhikkhave tra samuddassa prima ca tra ida dutiya suvidravidra; yato ca Bhikkhave verocano abbhudeti yattha ca atthameti, ida tatiya suvidravidra, sata ca Bhikkhave dhammo asata ca dhammo, ida catuttha suvidravidra: imni kho Bhikkhave cattri suvidravidrnti. Nabha ca dre pahav ca dre, Pra samuddassa tadhu dre, #<[page 345]># %% Yato ca varocano abbhudeti Pabhakaro yattha ca atthameti, Tato h' eva dratara vadanti Sata ca dhamma asata ca dhamma; Abyyiko hoti sata samgamo Yvam pi tiheyya tath' eva hoti Khippa haveti asata samgamo Tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti." 4. Na vattabba "Paribhogamaya pua vahatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "rmarop vanarop Ye jan setukrak Papa ca udapna ca Ye dadanti upassaya, Tesa div ca ratto ca Sad pua pavahati, Dhammah slasampann Te jan saggagmino ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi paribhogamaya pua vahatti. 5. Na vattabba "Paribhogamaya pua vahatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattro 'me Bhikkhave pubhisand kusalbhisand sukhass' hr sovaggik sukhavipk #<[page 346]># %<346 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 5.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ {saggasavattanik} ihya kantya manpya hitya sukhya savattanti. Katame cattro? Yassa Bhikkhave bhikkhu cvara paribhujamno appama cetosamdhi upasampajja viharati, appamo tassa pubhisando kusalbhisando sukhass' hro sovaggiko sukhavipko saggasavattaniko ihya kantya manpya hitya sukhya savattati; yassa Bhikkhave bhikkhu piapta paribhujamno --pe-- sensana paribhujamno --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra paribhujamno appama cetosamdhi upasampajja viharati, appamo tassa pubhisando kusalbhisando sukhass' hro sovaggiko sukhavipko saggasavattaniko ihya kantya manpya hitya sukhya savattati. Ime kho Bhikkhave cattro pubhisand kusalbhisand sukhass' hr sovaggik sukhavipk saggasavattanik ihya kantya manpya hitya sukhya savattantti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi paribhogamaya pua vahatti. 6. Paribhogamaya pua vahatti? mant. Dyako dna deti, paigghako paiggahetv na paribhujati chaeti vissajjeti, hoti puan ti? mant. Haci dyako dna deti, paigghako piggahetv na paribhujati chaeti vissajjeti, hoti pua, no vata re vattabbe "Paribhogamaya pua vahatti." 7. Paribhogamaya pua vahatti? mant. Dyako dna deti, paigghake paiggahte rjno v haranti, cor v haranti, aggi v ahati, udaka v vahati, appiy v dyd haranti, hoti puan ti? mant. Haci dyako dna deti, paigghake paiggahte rjno v haranti, cor v haranti, aggi v ahati, udaka v vahati, appiy v dyad haranti, hoti pua, no vata re vattabbe "Paribhogamaya pua vahatti." #<[page 347]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Paribhogamayapuakath. VII.6. 1. Ito dinnena tattha ypentti? mant. Ito cvara denti, ta cvara tattha paribhujantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ito piapta denti, ito sensana denti, ito gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra denti, ito khdanya denti, ito bhojanya denti, ito pnya denti, tattha paribhujantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ito dinnena tattha ypentti? mant. Ao aassa krako, parakata sukhadukkha ao karoti, ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Ito dinnena tattha ypentti"? mant. Nanu pet attano atthya dna denta anumodenti, citta pasdenti, pti uppdenti, somanassa pailabbhantti? mant. Haci pet attano atthya dna denta anumodenti, citta pasdenti, pti uppdenti, somanassa pailabbhanti, tena vata re vattabbe "Ito dinnena tattha ypentti." 3. Na vattabba "Ito dinnena tattha ypentti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Unname udaka vuttha Yath ninna pavattati, #<[page 348]># %<348 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 6.>% Evameva ito dinna Petna upakappati. Yath vrivah pr Pariprenti sgara, Evameva ito dinna Petna upakappati. Na hi tattha kas atthi Gorakkh' ettha na vijjati, Vaijj tdis n' atthi Hiraena kayakkaya, Ito dinnena ypenti Pet klakat tahin ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi ito dinnena tattha ypentti. 4. Na vattabba "Ito dinnena tattha ypentti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' imni Bhikkhave hni {sampassant} mtpitro putta icchanti kule jyamna. Katamni paca? Bhao v no bharissati, kicca v no karissati, kulavaso cira thassati, {dyajja} paipajjati, atha v pana petna klakatna dakkhia anuppadassati: imni kho Bhikkhave paca thni {sampassant} mtpitaro putta icchanti kule jyamnan ti Paca hni sampassa Putta icchanti pait Bhato v no bharissati, Kicca v no karissati, Kulavaso cira tihe Dyajja paipajjati, #<[page 349]># %% Atha v pana petna Dakkhia anuppadassati, hn' etni sampassa Putta icchanti pait. Tasm santo sappuris Kata katavedino Bharanti mtpitaro Pubbe kata anussara, Karonti tesa kiccni Yath ta pubbakrina, Ovdakr bhaaposi Kulavasa ahpaya Saddho slena sampanno Putto hoti pasasiyo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi ito dinnena tattha ypentti. Ito dinnakath. VII.7. 1. Pahav kammavipko ti? mant. Sukhavedany dukkhavedany adukkhamasukhavedany sukhya vedanya sampayutt dukkhya vedanya sampayutt adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutt phassena sampayutt vedanya sampayutt saya sampayutt cetanya sampayutt cittena sampayutt sramma, atthi tya vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan pathan paidhti? #<[page 350]># %<350 KATHVATTHU. [VII. 7.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sukhavedany na dukkhavedany na adukkhamasukhavedany na sukhya vedanya sampayutt na dukkhya vedanya sampayutt na adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutt na phassena sampayutt na vedanya sampayutt na saya sampayutt na cetanya sampayutt na cittena sampayutt, anramma, n' atthi tya vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? mant. Haci na sukhavedany --pe-- anramma, n' atthi tya vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Pahav kammavipko ti." 2. Phasso kammavipko phasso sukhavedanyo dukkhavedanyo adukkhamasukhavedanyo, sukhya vedanya sampayutto, dukkhya --pe-- adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutto, phassena sampayutto, vedanya sampayutto, saya sampayutto, cetanya sampayutto, cittena sampayutto, sramma, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Pahav kammavipko pahav sukhavedany dukkhavedany adukkhamasukhavedany, sukhya vedanya sampayutt, dukkhya --pe-- adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutt, phassena sampayutt, vedanya sampayutt, saya sampayutt, cetanya sampayutt, cittena sampayutt, sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahav kammavipko, pahav na sukhavedany, na dukkhavedany --pe-- anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Phasso kammavipko, phasso na sukhavedanyo, na dukkhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? 3. Pahav kammavipko ti? mant. Pahav paggahaniggahpag chedanabhedanpag ti? #<[page 351]># %% mant. Kammavipko paggahaniggahpago chedanabhedanpago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh pahav ketu {vikketu} hapetu ocinitu vicinitun ti? mant. Labbh kammavipko ketu {vikketu} hapetu ocinitu vicinitun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahav paresa sdhra ti? mant. Kammavipko paresa sdhrao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammavipko paresa sdhrao ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Asdhraam aesa Acoraharao nidhi, Kayirtha macco puni Sace sucarita careti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kammavipko paresa sdhrao ti." 4. Pahav kammavipko ti? mant. Pahama pahav sahti, pacch satt uppajjantti? mant. Pahama vipko uppajjati, pacch vipkapailbhya kamma karontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Pahav sabbasattna kammavipko ti? #<[page 352]># %<352 KATHVATTHU. [VII.7.>% mant. Sabbe satt pahavi paribhujantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbe satt pahavi paribhujantti? mant. Atthi keci pahavi aparibhujitv parinibbyantti? mant. Atthi keci kammavipka akhepetv parinibbyantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Pahav Cakkavattisattassa kammavipko ti? mant. Ae satt pahavi paribhujantti? mant. Cakkavattisattassa kammavipkam ae satt paribhujantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkavattisattassa kammavipka ae satt paribhujantti? mant. Cakkavattisattassa phassa vedana saa cetana citta saddha viriya sati samdhi paa ae satt paribhujantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Pahav kammavipko ti"? mant. Nanu atthi issariyasavattanika kamma, adhipaccasavattanika kamman ti. mant. Haci atthi issariyasavattanika kamma, adhipaccasavattanika kamma, tena vata re vattabbe "Pahav kammavipko ti." Pahav kammavipkakath. #<[page 353]># %% VII.8. 1. Jarmaraa vipko ti? mant. Sukhavedanya dukkhavedanya adukkhamasukhavedanya sukhya vedanya sampayutta dukkhya vedanya sampayutta adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutta phassena sampayutta vedanya sampayutta saya sampayutta cetanya sampayutta cittena sampayutta srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Jarmaraa vipko ti." 2. Phasso vipko, phasso sukhavedanyo --pe-- srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Jarmaraa vipko, jarmaraa sukhavedanya --pe-- srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jarmaraa vipko, jarmaraa na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Phasso vipko, phasso na sukhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Akusalna dhammna jarmaraa akusalna dhammna vipko ti? mant. Kusalna dhammna jarmaraa kusalna dhammna vipko ti? 24 #<[page 354]># %<354 KATHVATTHU. [VII.8.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalna dhammna jarmaraa na vattabba "Kusalna dhammna vipko ti"? mant. Akusalna dhammna jarmaraa na vattabba "Akusalna dhammna vipko ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Kusalna dhammna jarmaraa akusalna dhammna vipko ti? mant. Akusalna dhammna jarmaraa kusalna dhammna vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalna dhammna jarmaraa na vattabba "Kusalna dhammna vipko ti"? mant. Kusalna dhammna jarmaraa na vattabba "Akusalna dhammna vipko ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Kusalna ca akusalna ca dhammna jarmaraa akusalna dhammna vipko ti? mant. Kusalna ca akusalna ca dhammna jarmaraa kusalna dhammna vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalna ca akusalna ca dhammna jarmaraa na vattabba "Kusalna dhammna vipko ti"? mant. Kusalna ca akusalna ca dhammna jarmaraam na vattabba "Akusalna dhammna vipko ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Jarmaraa vipko ti"? mant. Nanu atthi dubbaasavattanika kamma, appyukasavattanika kamman ti? mant. Haci atthi dubbaasavattanika kamma, appyukasavattanika kamma, #<[page 355]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tena vata re vattabbe Jarmaraa vipko ti." Jarmaraa vipko ti kath. VII.9. 1. N' atthi ariyadhammavipko ti? mant. Nanu mahapphala smaa, mahapphala brahmaan ti? mant. Haci mahapphala smaa, mahapphala brahmaa, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi ariyadhammavipko ti." 2. N' atthi ariyadhammavipko ti? mant. Nanu atthi sotpattiphalan ti? mant. Haci atthi sotpattiphala, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi ariyadhammavipko ti." Nanu atthi sakadgmiphala --pe-- angmiphala -- pe -- arahattaphalan ti? mant. Haci atthi arahattaphala, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi ariyadhammavipko ti." 3. Sotpattiphala na vipko ti? mant. Dnaphala na vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattiphala na vipko ti? mant. Slaphala --pe-- bhvanphala na vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmiphala --pe-- angmiphala --pe-- arahattaphala na vipko ti? mant. #<[page 356]># %<356 KATHVATTHU. [VII.9.>% Dnaphala na vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattaphala na vipko ti? mant. Slaphala --pe-- bhvanphala na vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Dnaphala vipko ti? mant. Sotpattiphala vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dnaphala vipko ti? mant. Sakadgmiphala --pe-- angmiphala --pe-- arahattaphala vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Slaphala --pe-- bhvanphala vipko ti? mant. Sotpattiphala vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bhvanphala vipko ti? mant. Sakadgmiphala --pe-- angmiphala --pe-- arahattaphala vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Kmvacara kusala savipkan ti? mant. Lokuttara kusala savipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpvacara kusala --pe-- arpvacara kusala savipkan ti? mant. Lokuttara kusala savipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara kusala avipkan ti? mant. Kmvacara kusala avipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara kusala avipkan ti? #<[page 357]># %% mant. Rpvacara kusala --pe-- arpvacara kusala avipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Kmvacara kusala savipka cayagmti? mant. Lokuttara kusala savipka cayagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpvacara kusala --pe-- arpvacara kusala savipka cayagmti? mant. Lokuttara kusala savipka cayagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara kusala savipka apacayagmti? mant. Kmvacara kusala savipka apacayagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Lokuttara kusala savipka apacayagmti? mant. Rpvacara kusala --pe-- arpvacara kusala savipka apacayagmti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ariyadhammavipkakath. VII.10. 1. Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? mant. Tassa vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tassa vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhassa antakiriy, n' atthi vaupacchedo, n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? #<[page 358]># %<358 KATHVATTHU. [VII.10.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? mant. Vipko ti v vipkadhammadhammo ti v, vipkadhammadhammo ti v, vipko ti v, esese ekahe same sabhge tajjte ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? mant. Vipko ca vipkadhammadhammo ca, vipkadhammadhammo ca vipko ca sahagat sahajt sasah sampayutt ekuppd ekanirodh ekavatthuk ekramma ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? mant. Ta eva akusala so akusalassa vipko, ta eva kusala so kusalassa vipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti? mant. Yen' eva cittena pa hanati, ten' eva cittena niraye paccati: yen' eva cittena dna deti, ten' eva cittena sagge modatti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti"? mant. Nanu vipk cattro khandh arpino aamaapaccay ti? mant. Haci vipk cattro khandh arpino aamaapaccay, tena vata re vattabbe "Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti." Vipkadhammadhammo ti kath. #<[page 359]># %% Sattamo Vaggo. Sagaho, Sampayutto, Cetasiko dhammo, Cetasika dna, Paribhogamaya pua vahati, Ito dinnena tattha ypentti, Pahav kammavipko, Jarmaraa vipko, N' atthi ariyadhammavipko ti, Vipko vipkadhammadhammo ti. #<[page 360]># %<360 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.1.>% VIII.1. 1. Cha gatiyo ti? mant. Nanu paca gatiyo vutt Bhagavat, Nirayo, Tiracchnayoni, Pettivisayo, Manuss, Dev ti? mant. Haci paca gatiyo vutt Bhagavat, Nirayo, Tiracchnayoni, Pettivisayo, Manuss, Dev, no vata re vattabbe "Cha gatiyo ti." 2. Cha gatiyo ti? mant. Nanu Kakajak Asur petna samnava samnabhog samnhr samnyuk petehi saha vhavivha gacchantti? mant. Haci Kakajak Asur petna samnava samnabhog samnhr samnyuk petehi saha vhavivha gacchanti, no vata re vattabbe "Cha gatiyo ti." 3. Cha gatiyo ti? mant. Nanu Vepacittiparis Devna samnava samnabhog samnhr samnyuk Devehi saha vhavivha gacchantti? mant. Haci Vepacittiparis Devna samnava samnabhog samnhr samnyuk Devehi saha vhavivha gacchanti, no vata re vattabbe "Cha gatiyo ti." 4. Cha gatiyo ti? mant. Nanu Vepacittiparis pubbadev ti? mant. Haci Vepacittiparis pubbadev, no vata re vattabbe "Cha gatiyo ti." 5. Na vattabba "Cha gatiyo ti"? mant. #<[page 361]># %% Nanu atthi asurakyo ti? mant. Haci atthi asurakyo, tena vata re vattabbe "Cha gatiyo ti." Gatikath. VIII.2. 1. Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Kmabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Rpabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Arpabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Kmabhavassa ca rpabhavassa ca antare atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Rpabhavassa ca arpabhavassa ca antare atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Kmabhavassa ca rpabhavassa ca antare n' atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Haci kmabhavassa ca rpabhavassa ca antare n' atthi antarbhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarbhavo ti." Rpabhavassa ca arpabhavassa ca antare n' atthi antarbhavo ti? #<[page 362]># %<362 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.2.>% mant. Haci rpabhavassa ca arpabhavassa ca antare n' atthi antarbhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarbhavo ti." 4. Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Pacam s yoni, chaham s gati, aham s viahiti, dasamo so sattvso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Antarbhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi antarbhavpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi antarbhavpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Antarbhave satt jyanti, jyanti, myanti, cavanti, uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Antarbhave atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Antarbhavo pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atthi kmabhavo, kmabhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavo, antarbhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi kmabhavpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi kmabhavpag satt ti? mant. #<[page 363]># %% Atthi antarbhavpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmabhave satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Antarbhave satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmabhave atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Antarbhave atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmabhavo pacavokrabhavo ti? mant. Antarbhavo pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi rpabhavo, rpabhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavo, antarbhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpabhavpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpabhavpag satt ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpabhave satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Antarbhave satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 364]># %<364 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.2.>% Rpabhave atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Antarbhave atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpabhavo pacavokrabhavo ti? mant. Antarbhavo pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Atthi arpabhavo, arpabhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavo, antarbhavo bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi arpabhavpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi arpabhavpag satt ti? mant. Atthi antarbhavpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpabhave satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Antarbhave satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpabhave atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Antarbhave atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpabhavo catuvokrabhavo ti? mant. #<[page 365]># %% Antarbhavo catuvokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Sabbesa eva sattna atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbesa eva sattna n' atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Haci sabbesa eva sattna n' atthi antarbhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarbhavo ti." 9. Atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. nantarikassa puggalassa atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- nantarikassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Haci nantarikassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarbhavo ti." 10. Na-nantarikassa puggalassa atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. nantarikassa puggalassa atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- nantarikassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Na-nantarikassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Niraypagassa puggalassa --pe-- asaasattpagassa puggalassa --pe-- arppagassa puggalassa atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arppagassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Haci arppagassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarbhavo ti." 11. Na-arppagassa puggalassa atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. #<[page 366]># %<366 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.3.>% Arppagassa puggalassa atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arppagassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Na-arppagassa puggalassa n' atthi antarbhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Na vattabba "Atthi antarbhavo ti"? mant. Nanu antarparinibby puggalo atthti? mant. {Haci} antarparinibby puggalo atthi, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi antarbhavo ti." 13. Antarparinibby puggalo atthti katv atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Upahaccaparinibby puggalo atthti katv atthi upahaccabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Antarparinibby puggalo atthti katv atthi antarbhavo ti? mant. Asakhraparinibby puggalo --pe-- sasakhraparinibby puggalo atthti katv atthi sasakhrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Antarbhavakath. VIII.3. 1. Pac' eva kmagu kmadht ti? mant. Nanu atthi tappaisautto chando ti? mant. Haci atthi tappaisautto chando, no vata re vattabbe "Pac' eva kmagu kmadht ti." Nanu atthi tappaisautto rgo, tappaisautto chandargo, #<[page 367]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tappaisautto sakappo, tappaisautto rgo, tappaisautto sakappargo, tappaisautt pti, tappaisautta somanassa, tappaisautta ptisomanassan ti? mant. Haci atthi tappaisautta ptisomanassa, no vata re vattabbe "Pac' eva kmagu kmadht ti." 2. Pac' eva kmagu kmadht ti? mant. Manussna cakkhu na kmadhtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manussna sota --pe-- manussna ghna --pe-- manussna jivh --pe-- manussna kyo --pe-- manussna mano na kmadhtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manussna mano na kmadhtti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Paca kmagu loke Mano chah pavedit, Ettha chanda virjetv Eva dukkh pamuccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Manussna mano na kmadhtti." 3. Pac' eva kmagu kmadht ti? mant. Kmagu bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi kmagupaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi kmagupag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmague satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? #<[page 368]># %<368 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.3.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmague atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmagu pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmague Sammsambuddh uppajjanti, Paccekasambuddh uppajjanti, svakayuga uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Kmadhtu bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Kmagu bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni {viahiti} attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi kmadhtpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi kmagupaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi kmadhtpag satt ti? mant. Atthi kmagupag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmadhtuy satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Kmagu satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmadhtuy atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Kmagu atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmadhtu pacavokrabhavo ti? mant. Kmagu pacavokrabhavo ti? #<[page 369]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmadhtuy Sammsambuddh uppajjanti, Paccekasambuddh uppajjanti, svakayuga uppajjatti? mant. Kmagu Sammsambuddh uppajjanti, Paccekasambuddh uppajjanti, svakayuga uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Pac' eva kmagu kmadhtti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' ime Bhikkhave kmagu. Katame paca? Cakkhuvieyy rp ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany, sotavieyy sadd --pe-- ghnavieyy gandh --pe-- jivhvieyy ras --pe-- kyavieyy phohabb ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany; ime kho Bhikkhave paca kmagu ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi pac' eva kmagu kmadhtti. Kmaguakath VIII.4. 1. Pac' ev' yatan km ti? mant. Nanu atthi tappaisautto chando ti? mant. Haci atthi tappaisautto chando, no vata re vattabbe "Pac' ev' yatan km ti." Nanu atthi tappaisautto rgo, tappaisautto chandargo, tappaisautto sakappo, tappaisautto rgo, tappaisautto sakappargo, tappaisautt pti, tappaisautta somanassa, tappaisautta ptisomanassan ti? mant. Haci atthi tappaisautta ptisomanassa, no vata re vattabbe "Pac' ev' yatan km ti." 25 #<[page 370]># %<370 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.5.>% 2. Na vattabba "Pac' ev' yatan km ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' ime Bhikkhave kmagu. Katame paca? Cakkhuvieyy rp ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany, sotavieyy sadd --pe-- ghnavieyy gandh --pe-- jivhvieyy ras --pe-- kyavieyy phohabb ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany; ime kho Bhikkhave paca kmagu ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi pac' ev' yatan km ti. 3. Pac' ev' yatan km ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pac' ime Bhikkhave kmagu. Katame paca? Cakkhuvieyy rp --pe-- kyavieyy phohabb ih kant manp piyarp kmpasahit rajany; ime kho Bhikkhave paca kmagu. Api ca Bhikkhave nete kmagu nma. Te ariyassa vinaye vuccanti Sakappargo {purisassa} kmo. Na te km yni citrni loke Sakappargo purisassa kmo. Tihanti citrni tath' eva loke, Ath' ettha dhr vinayan ti chandan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Pac' ev' yatan km ti." Kmakath. VIII.5. 1. Rpino dhamm rpadhtti? mant. #<[page 371]># %% Rpa bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rppaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rppag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpe satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpe atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Rpadhtu bhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Rpa bhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpadhtpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi rppaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpadhtpag satt ti? mant. Atthi rppag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpadhtuy satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Rpe satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpadhtuy atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Rpe atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 372]># %<372 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.6.>% Rpadhtu pacavokrabhavo ti? mant. Rpa pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpino dhamm rpadhtu, kmadhtuy atthi rpan ti? mant. S va kmadhtu, s rpadhtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S va kmadhtu, s rpadhtti? mant. Kmabhavena samanngato puggalo dvhi bhavehi samanngato hoti kmabhavena ca rpabhavena cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpadhtukath. VIII.6. 1. Arpino dhamm arpadhtti? mant. Vedan bhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi vedanpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi vedanpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedanya satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedanya atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan catuvokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Arpadhtu bhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. #<[page 373]># %% Vedan bhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi arpadhtpaga kamman ti? mant. Atthi vedanpaga kamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi arpadhtpag satt ti? mant. Atthi vedanpag satt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpadhtuy satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? mant. Vedanya satt jyanti jyanti myanti cavanti uppajjantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpadhtuy atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. Vedanya atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpadhtu catuvokrabhavo ti? mant. Vedan catuvokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpino dhamm arpadhtu, kmadhtuy atthi vedan sa sakhr vian ti? mant. S va kmadhtu, s arpadhtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S va kmadhtu, s arpadhtti? mant. Kmabhavena samanngato puggalo dvhi bhavehi samanngato hoti kmabhavena ca arpabhavena cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpino dhamm rpadhtu, arpino dhamm arpadhtu, kmadhtuy atthi rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? #<[page 374]># %<374 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.7.>% mant. S va kmadhtu, s rpadhtu, s arpadhtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S va kmadhtu, s rpadhtu, s arpadhtti? mant. Kmabhavena samanngato puggalo thi bhavehi samanngato hoti kmabhavena ca rpabhavena ca arpabhavena cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpadhtukath. VIII.7. 1. Sayataniko attabhvo rpadhtuy ti? mant. Atthi tattha ghnyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha gandhyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha jivhyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha rasyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha kyyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. N' atthi tattha gandhyatanan ti? mant. N' atthi tattha ghnyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi tattha rasyatanan ti? mant. N' atthi tattha jivhyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi tattha phohabbyatanan ti? #<[page 375]># %% mant. N' atthi tattha kyyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, atthi rpyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha ghnayatana, atthi gandhyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, atthi rpyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, atthi rasyatana --pe-- atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi tattha sotyatana, atthi saddyatana -- pe -- atthi tattha manyatana, atthi dhammyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha ghnyatana, atthi gandhyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha manyatana, atthi dhammyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, atthi rasyatana --pe-- atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atthi tattha ghnyatana, n' atthi gandhyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, n' atthi rpyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha ghnyatana, n' atthi gandhyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha sotyatana, n' atthi saddyatana --pe-- atthi tattha manyatana, n' atthi dhammyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, n' atthi rasyatana -- pe -- atthi tattha kyyatana, n' atthi phohabbyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, n' atthi rpyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 376]># %<376 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.7.>% Atthi tattha kyyatana, n' atthi phohabbyatanan ti? mant. Atthi tattha sotyatana, n' atthi saddyatana --pe-- atthi tattha manyatana, n' atthi dhammyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, atthi rpyatana, tena cakkhun ta rpa passatti? mant. Atthi tattha ghnyatana, atthi gandhyatana, tena ghnena ta gandha ghyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, atthi rpyatana, tena cakkhun ta rpa passatti? mant. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, atthi rasyatana, tya jivhya ta rasa syati --pe-- atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatana, tena kyena ta phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Atthi tattha sotyatana, atthi saddyatana --pe-- atthi tattha manyatana, atthi dhammyatana, tena manena ta dhamma vijntti? mant. Atthi tattha ghnyatana, atthi gandhyatana, tena ghnena ta gandha ghyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha manyatana, atthi dhammyatana, tena manena ta dhamma vijntti? mant. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, atthi rasyatana, --pe-- atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatana, tena kyena ta phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Atthi tattha ghnyatana, atthi gandhyatana, na ca tena ghnena ta gandha ghyatti? mant. Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, atthi rpyatana, na ca tena cakkhun ta rpa passatti? #<[page 377]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha ghnyatana, atthi gandhyatana, na ca tena ghnena ta gandha ghyatti? mant. Atthi tattha sotyatana, atthi saddyatana --pe-- atthi tattha manyatana, atthi dhammyatana, na ca tena manena ta dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, atthi rasyatana -- pe -- atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatana, na ca tena kyena ta phohabba phusatti? mant. Atthi tattha cakkhyatana, atthi rpyatana, na ca tena cakkhun ta rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatana, na ca tena kyena ta phohabba phusatti? mant. Atthi tattha sotyatana, atthi saddyatana --pe-- atthi tattha manyatana, atthi dhammyatana, na ca tena manena ta dhamma vijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Atthi tattha ghnyatana, atthi gandhyatana, tena ghnena ta gandha ghyatti? mant. Atthi tattha mlagandho sragandho tacagandho pattagandho pupphagandho phalagandho magandho visagandho sugandho duggandho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Atthi tattha jivhyatana, atthi rasyatana, tya jivhya ta rasa syatti? mant. Atthi tattha mlaraso khandharaso tacaraso pattaraso puppharaso phalaraso ambila madhura tittaka kauka loiya khriya lambila kasvo sdu asdti? #<[page 378]># %<378 KATHVATTHU. [VIII. 8.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Atthi tattha kyyatana, atthi phohabbyatana, tena kyena ta phohabba phusatti? mant. Atthi tattha kakkhaa muduka saha pharusa sukhasamphassa dukkhasamphassa garuka lahukan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Na vattabba "Sayataniko attabhvo rpadhtuy ti"? mant. Nanu atthi tattha ghnanimitta jivhnimitta kyanimittan ti? mant. Haci atthi tattha ghnanimitta jivhnimitta {kyanimitta,} tena vata re vattabbe "Sayataniko attabhvo rpadhtuy ti." Rpadhtuy yatanakath. VIII.8. 1. Atthi rpa arpesti? mant. Rpabhavo rpagati rpasattvso rpasasro rpayoni rpattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu arpabhavo arpagati arpasattvso arpasasro arpayoni arpattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Haci arpabhavo arpagati arpasattvso arpasasro arpayoni arpattabhvapailbho, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi rpa arpesti." 2. Atthi rpa arpesti? mant. Pacavokrabhavo gati sattvso sasro yoni viahiti attabhvapailbho ti? #<[page 379]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu catuvokrabhavo --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Haci catuvokrabhavo --pe-- attabhvapailbho, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi rpa arpesti." 3. Atthi rpa rpadhtuy, so ca rpabhavo rpagati --pe-- rpattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi rpa arpesu, so ca rpabhavo rpagati --pe-- rpattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpa rpadhtuy, so ca pacavokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi rpa arpesu, so ca pacavokrabhavo gati -- pe -- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi rpa arpesu, so ca arpabhavo arpagati -- --pe-- arpattabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi rpa arpadhtuy, so ca arpabhavo arpagati --pe-- arpattabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpa arpesu, so ca catuvokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? mant. Atthi rpa arpadhtuy, so ca catuvokrabhavo gati --pe-- attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atthi rpa arpesti? mant. Nanu rpna nissaraa arpa vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci rpna nissaraa arpa vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi rpa arpesti." 6. Rpna nissaraa arpa vutta Bhagavat, atthi rpa arpesti? #<[page 380]># %<380 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% mant. Kmna nissaraa nekkhamma vutta Bhagavat, atthi nekkhammesu km, atthi ansavesu sav, atthi apariypannesu pariypann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- ruppe rpakath. VIII.9. 1. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusalan ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusalan ti." 2. Kusalena cittena samuhito phasso kusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, saddh, viriya, sati, samdhi --pe-- pa kusal sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. #<[page 381]># %% Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhito phasso kusalo anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, saddh, viriya, sati, samdhi --pe-- pa kusal anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusalan ti? mant. Ya kici kusalena cittena samuhita rpa, sabban ta kusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana kusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- #<[page 382]># %<382 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu kusal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana abykatan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu abykat ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa abykatan ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 6. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa kusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- {pahavdhtu,} podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu anramma kusal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa abykatan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- #<[page 383]># %% gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana -- pe -- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu anramma abykat ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa phassavippayutta kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana phasavippayutta kusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa phassavippayutta kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana -- pepahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu phassavippayutt kusal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana phassavippayutta abykatan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatanam --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhatu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu phassavippayutt abykat ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa phassavipayutta kusalan ti? mant. #<[page 384]># %<384 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa phassavippayutta kusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta kusalan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu anramma phassavippayutt kusal ti?' Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Kusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu --pe-- vyodhtu anramma phassavippayutt abykat ti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 12. Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusalan ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusalan ti." #<[page 385]># %% 13. Kusalena cittena samuhito phasso kusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, saddh, viriya, sati, samdhi --pe-- pa kusal sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhito phasso kusalo anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, saddh, viriya, sati, samdhi --pe-- pa kusal anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Kusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa kusalan ti? mant. Ya kici kusalena cittena samuhita rpa, sabban ta kusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- -- Yath kyakamma, tath vackamman ti. -- 16. Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rupa akusalan ti? 26 #<[page 386]># %<386 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% mant. {Srammaa,} atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa akusalan ti." 17. Akusalena cittena samuhito phasso akusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, rgo, doso, moho, mno, dihi, vicikicch, thna, uddhacca, ahirika --pe-- anottappa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 18. Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhito phasso akusalo anrmmao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. #<[page 387]># %% Akusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, rgo, doso, moho, mno, dihi, vicikicch, thna, uddhacca, ahirika --pe-- anottappa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Akusalena cittena samuhita kyakamma rpa akusalan ti? mant. Ya kici akusalena cittena samuhita rpa, sabban ta akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 20. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusalan ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusalan ti." 21. Akusalena cittena samuhito phasso akusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, rgo, doso, moho, mno, dihi, vicikicch, thna, uddhacca, ahirika --pe-- anottappa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? #<[page 388]># %<388 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 22. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhito phasso akusalo anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhit vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, rgo, doso, moho, mno, dihi, vicikicch, thna, uddhacca, ahirika --pe-- anottappa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 23. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusalan ti? mant. Ya kici akusalena cittena samuhita rpa, sabban ta akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 24. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana, pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 25. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana abykatan ti? #<[page 389]># %% mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo abykato ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 26. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana, pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo anrammao akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 27. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa abykatan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo anrammao abykato ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa abykatan ti? #<[page 390]># %<390 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 28. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa phassavippayutta akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana phassavippayutta akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa phassavippayutta akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana, {pahavdhtu,} podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo phassavippayutto akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 29. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana phassavippayutta abykatan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo phassavippayutto abykato ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 30. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta akusalan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa phassavippayutta akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta akusalan ti? mant. #<[page 391]># %% Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana, pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo anrammao phassavippayutto akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 31. Akusalena cittena samuhita rpyatana anrammaa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena cittena samuhita saddyatana --pe-- gandhyatana, rasyatana, phohabbyatana --pe-- pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo anrammao phassavippayutto abykato ti? mant. Akusalena cittena samuhita vackamma rpa anrammaa phassavippayutta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 32. Na vattabba "Rpa kusala pi akusala pti"? mant. Nanu kyakamma vackamma kusala pi akusala pti? mant. Haci kyakamma vackamma kusala pi akusala pi, tena vata re vattabbe "Rpa kusala pi akusala pti." 33. Rpa kusala pi {akusala} pti? mant. Cakkhyatana kusala pi akusala pti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa kusala pi akusala pti? mant. sotyatana --pe-- ghnyatana, jivhyatana, kyyatana, rpyatana, saddyatana, gandhyatana, #<[page 392]># %<392 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.9.>% rasyatana, phohabbyatana, pahavdhtu, podhtu, tejodhtu, vyodhtu, asuci, assu, lohita --pe-- sedo kusalo pi akusalo pti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 34. Kyo rpa, kyakamma rpan ti? mant. Mano rpa, manokamma rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mano arpa, manokamma arpan ti? mant. Kyo arpa, kyakamma arpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyo rpa, kyakamma arpan ti? mant. Mano rpa, manokamma arpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mano arpa, manokamma arpan ti? mant. Kyo arpa, kyokamma arpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 35. Kyo rpan ti, kyakamma rpan ti? mant. Cakkhyatana rpan ti, cakkhuvia rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyo rpan ti, kyakamma rpan ti? mant. Sotyatana rpan ti, sotavia rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyo rpan ti, kyakamma rpan ti? mant. Ghnyatana rpan ti, ghnavia rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyo rpan ti, kyakamma rpan ti? mant. Jivhyatana rpan ti, jivhvia rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyo rpan ti kyakamma rpan ti? mant. #<[page 393]># %% Kyyatana rpan ti, kyavia rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 36. Rpa kamman ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cetanha Bhikkhave kamma vadmi, cetayitv kamma karoti kyena vcya manas ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Rpa kamman ti." 37. Rpa kamman ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Kye v nanda sati kyasacetanhetu uppajjati ajjhatta sukhadukkha, vcya v nanda sati vacsacetanhetu uppajjati ajjhatta sukhadukkha, mane v nanda sati manosacetanhetu uppajjati ajjhatta sukhadukkhan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Rpa kamman ti." 38. Rpa kamman ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Tividh Bhikkhave kyasacetan akusala kyakamma dukkhindriya dukkhavipka, catubbidh Bhikkhave vacsacetan akusala vackamma dukkhindriya dukkhavipka, tividh Bhikkhave manosacetan akusala manokamma dukkhindriya dukkhavipka; tividh Bhikkhave kyasacetan kusala kyakamma sukhindriya sukhavipka, catubbidh Bhikkhave vacsacetan kusala vackamma sukhindriya sukhavipka, tividh Bhikkhave manosacetan kusala manokamma sukhindriya sukhavipkan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 394]># %<394 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.10.>% Tena hi na vattabba "Rpa kamman ti." 39. Rpa kamman ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sacya nanda samiddhi moghapuriso Ptaliputtassa paribbjakassa eva puho eva bykareyya `Sacetaniya vuso Ptaliputta kamma katv kyena vcya manas sukhavedanya sukha so vedayati, sacetaniya vuso Ptaliputta kamma katv kyena vcya manas dukkhavedanya dukkha so vedayati, sacetaniya vuso Ptaliputta kamma katv kyena vcya manas adukkhamasukhavedanya adukkhamasukha so vedayatti,'eva bykaramno kho nanda samiddhi moghapuriso Ptaliputtassa paribbjakassa sammbykaramno bykareyyti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Rpa kamman ti." Rpa kamman ti kath. VIII.10. 1. N' atthi rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. N' atthi rpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan ti? mant. Haci atthi rpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi jvitindriyan ti." #<[page 395]># %% 2. Atthi arpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan, atthi arpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Atthi rpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan, atthi rpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- Atthi rpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan, n' atthi rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Atthi arpna dhammna yuhiti yapan ypan iriyan vattan plan, n' atthi arpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Arpna dhammna yu arpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Rpna dhammna yu rpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpna dhammna yu na vattabba rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Arpna dhammna yu na vattabba arpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Rpna dhammna yu arpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Arpna dhammna yu rpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpna dhammna yu na vattabba rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Rpna dhammna yu na vattabba arpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Rpna ca arpna ca dhammna yu arpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Rpna ca arpna ca dhammna yu rpajvitindriyan ti? #<[page 396]># %<396 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.10.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpna ca arpna ca dhammna yu na vattabba rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Rpna ca arpna ca dhammna yu na vattabba arpajvitindriyan ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 6. N' atthi rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Nirodha sampannassa n' atthi jvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodha sampannassa atthi jvitindriyan ti? mant. Haci nirodha sampannassa atthi jvitindriya, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi rpajvitindriyan ti." 7. Nirodha sampannassa atthi jvitindriyan ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypannan ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypannan ti. Nirodha sampannassa atthi sakhrakkhandho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodha sampannassa atthi sakhrakkhandho ti? mant. Nirodha sampannassa atthi vedankkhandho --pe-- sakkhandho --pe-- viakkhandho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodha sampannassa atthi vedankkhandho --pe-- sakkhandho --pe-- viakkhandho ti? mant. Na nirodhasampanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. N' atthi rpajvitindriyan ti? mant. Asaasattna n' atthi jvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaasattna atthi jvitindriyan ti? mant. #<[page 397]># %% Haci asaasattna atthi jvitindriya, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi rpajvitindriyan ti." 9. Asaasattna atthi jvitindriyan ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypannan ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypannan ti. Asaasattna atthi sakhrakkhandho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaasattna atthi sakhrakkhandho ti? mant. Asaasattna atthi vedankkhandho --pe-- sakkhandho --pe-- viakkhandho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asaasattna atthi vedankkhandho --pe-- sakkhandho --pe-- viakkhandho ti? mant. Pacavokrabhavo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Uppattesiyena cittena samuhita jvitindriya uppattesiye citte bhijjamne ekadesa bhijjatti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena samuhito phasso uppattesiye citte bhijjamne ekadeso bhijjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uppattesiyena cittena samuhito phasso uppattesiye citte bhijjamne anavaseso bhijjatti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena samuhita jvitindriya uppattesiye citte bhijjamne anavasesa bhijjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Dve jvitindriynti? mant. Dvhi jvitehi jvati, dvhi maraehi myatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jvitindriyakath #<[page 398]># %<398 KATHVATTHU. [VIII.11.>% VIII.11. 1. Kammahetu Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Kammahetu sotpanno sotpattiphal parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammahetu Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Kammahetu sakadgm --pe-- angm angmiphal parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Kammahetu sotpanno sotpattiphal na parihyatti? mant. Kammahetu Arah arahatt na parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammahetu sakadgm --pe-- angm {angmiphal} na parihyatti? mant. Kammahetu Arah arahatt na parihyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Kammahetu Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Ptiptakammassa hetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adinndnakammassa hetu --pe-- kmesu micchcrakammassa hetu, musvdakammassa hetu, pisuavckammassa hetu, pharusavckammassa hetu, samphappalpakammassa hetu, mtughtakammassa hetu, pitughtakammassa hetu, arahantaghtakammassa hetu, ruhiruppdakammassa hetu, saghabhedakammassa hetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Katamassa kammassa hetti? Handa hi Arahantna abbhcikkhatti. #<[page 399]># %% Arahantna abbhcikkhanakammassa hetu Arah arahatt parihyatti? mant. Ye keci Arahantna abbhcikkhanti, sabbe te arahatta sacchikarontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammahetukath. Cha gatiyo, Antarbhavo, Pac' eva kmagu kmadhtu, Pac' ev' yatan km, Rpino dhamm rpadhtu, Arpino dhamm arpadhtu, Sayataniko attabhvo rpadhtuy, Atthi rpa arpesu, Rpa kammam, Rpajvitindriya, Kammahetu parihyatti. Ahamo Vaggo. #<[page 400]># %<400 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 1.>% IX.1. 1. nisasadassvissa saojanna pahnan ti? mant. Nanu sakhre aniccato manasikaroto saojan pahyantti? mant. Haci sakhre aniccato manasikaroto saojan pahyanti, no vata re vattabbe "nisasadassvissa saojanna pahnan ti." 2. Nanu sakhre dukkhato --pe-- rogato gaato sallato aghato bdhato parato palokato tito upaddavato bhayato upasaggato calato pabhaguto adhuvato atnato aleato asaraato asaraibhtato riccato tucchato suato anattato dnavato --pe-- viparimadhammato manasikaroto saojan pahyantti? mant. Haci sakhre viparimadhammato manasikaroto saojan {pahyanti,} no vata re vattabbe "nisasadassvissa saojanna pahnan ti." 3. Sakhre ca aniccato manasikaroti, nibbne ca nisasadassv hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhre ca aniccato manasikaroti, nibbne ca nisasadassv hotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhre ca dukkhato --pe-- rogato --pe-- viparimadhammato manasikaroti, nibbne ca nisasadassv hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhre ca viparimadhammato manasikaroti, nibbne ca nisasadassv hotti? #<[page 401]># %% mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "nisasadassvissa saojanna pahnan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu nibbne sukhnupass viharati sukhasa sukhapaisaved satata samita abbokia cetas adhimuccamno paya pariyoghamno ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi nisasadassvissa saojanna pahnan ti. nisasakath. IX.2. 1. Amatrammaa saojanan ti? mant. Amata saojanya ganthanya oghanya yoganya nvaraya parmaha updniya sakilesikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu amata asaojanya aganthanya --pe-- asakilesikan ti? mant. Haci amata asaojanya aganthanya --pe-- asakilesika, no vata re vattabbe "Amatrammaa saojanan ti." 2. Amata rabbha rgo uppajjatti? mant. Amata rgahnya rajanya kamanya madanya bandhanya mucchanyan ti? #<[page 402]># %<402 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 2.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu amata na rgahnya na rajanya na kamanya na madanya na bandhanya na mucchanyan ti? mant. Haci amata na rgahnya na rajanya na kamanya na madanya na bandhanya na mucchanya, no vata re vattabbe "Amata rabbha rgo uppajjatti." 3. Amata rabbha doso uppajjatti? mant. Amata dosahnya kopahnya paighahnyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu amata na dosahnya na kopahnya na paighahnyan ti? mant. Haci amata na dosahnya na kopahnya na paighahnya, no vata re vattabbe "Amata rabbha doso uppajjatti." 4. Amata rabbha moho uppajjatti? mant. Amata mohahnya aakaraa acakkhukaraa panirodhiya vigtapakkhiya anibbnasavattanikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu amata na mohahnya na aakaraa na acakkhukaraa pavuhiya avigtapakkhiya nibbnasavattanikan ti? mant. Haci amata na mohahniya na aakaraa --pe-- nibbnasavattanika, no vata re vattabbe "Amata rabbha moho uppajjatti." 5. Rpa rabbha saojan uppajjanti, rpa saojanya --pe-- sakilesikan ti? #<[page 403]># %% mant. Amata rabbha saojan uppajjanti, amata saojanya --pe-- sakilesikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa rabbha rgo uppajjati, rpa rgahnya --pe-- mucchanyan ti? mant. Amata rabbha rgo uppajjati, amata rgahnya --pe-- mucchanyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa rabbha doso uppajjati, rpa dosahnya --pe-- paighahnyan ti? mant. Amata rabbha doso uppajjati, amata dosahnya --pe-- paighahnyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa rabbha moho uppajjati, rpa mohahnya --pe-- anibbnasavattanikan ti? mant. Amata rabbha moho uppajjati, amata {mohahnya} --pe-- anibbnasavattanikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Amata rabbha saojan uppajjanti, amata asaojanya aganthanya anoghanya ayoganya anvaraya aparmaha anupdniya asakilesikan ti? mant. Rpa rabbha saojan uppajjanti, rpa asaojanya aganthanya --pe-- asakilesikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Amata rabbha rgo uppajjati, amata na rgahnya na rajanya na kamanya na madanya na bandhanya na mucchanyan ti? mant. Rpa rabbha rgo uppajjati, rpa na rgahnya na rajanya na kamanya na madanya na bandhanya na mucchanyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 404]># %<404 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 3.>% Amata rabbha doso uppajjati, amata na dosahnya na kopahnya na paighahnyan ti? mant. Rpa rabbha doso uppajjati, rpa na dosahnya na kopahnya na paighahnyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Amata rabbha moho uppajjati, amata na mohahnya na aakaraa --pe-- nibbnasavattanikan ti? mant. Rpa rabbha moho uppajjati, rpa na mohahnya na aakaraa --pe-- nibbnasavattanikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Amatrammaa saojanan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Nibbna nibbnato sajnti, nibbna nibbnato sajnitv nibbna maati, nibbnasmi maati, nibbnato maati, nibbna meti maati, nibbna abhinandatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi amatrammaa saojanan ti. Amatrammaakath. IX.3. 1. Rpa srammaan ti? mant. Atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa srammaan ti." 2. Phasso srammao, atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? #<[page 405]># %% mant. Rpa srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa, cetan, citta, saddh, viriya, sati, samdhi, pa, rgo, doso, moho, mno, dihi, vicikicch, thna, uddhacca, ahirika --pe-- anottappa srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Rpa srammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? mant. Phasso srammao, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa srammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? mant. Vedan, sa --pe-- anottappa srammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan bhogo --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Rpa srammaan ti"? mant. Nanu rpa sappaccayan ti? mant. Haci rpa sappaccaya, tena vata re vattabbe "Rpa srammaan ti." Rpa srammaan ti kath. IX.4. 1. Anusay anramma ti? mant. #<[page 406]># %<406 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 4.>% Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargnusayo anrammao ti? mant. Kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraa anrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraa srammaan ti? mant. Kmargnusayo srammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Kmargnusayo anrammao ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypanno ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypanno ti. Sakhrakkhandho anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho anrammao ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho, viakkhandho anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Kmargnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno anrammao ti? mant. Kmargo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno srammao ti? mant. Kmargnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno srammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 407]># %% 4. Kmargnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno anrammao, kmargo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno srammao ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho, viakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Paighnusayo, mnnusayo, dihnusayo, vicikicchnusayo, bhavargnusayo, avijjnusayo anrammao ti? mant. Avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraa anrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avijj avijjogho --pe-- avijjnvaraa srammaan ti? mant. Avijjnusayo srammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Avijjnusayo anrammao ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypanno ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypanno ti. Sakhrakkhandho anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho anrammao ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho, viakkhandho anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Avijjnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno anrammao ti? mant. #<[page 408]># %<408 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 4.>% Avijj sakhrakkhandhapariypann anramma ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avijj sakhrakkhandhapariypann sramma ti? mant. Avijjnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno srammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Avijjnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno anrammao, avijj sakhrakkhandhapariypann sramma ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho, viakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Na vattabba "Anusay anramma ti"? mant. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "snusayo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Atthi tesa anusayna rammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi anusay anramma ti. 10. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "sargo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Atthi tassa rgassa rammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi rgo anrammao ti. Anusay anramma ti kath. #<[page 409]># %% IX.5. 1. a anrammaan ti? mant. Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabhyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- a anrammaan ti? mant. Pa, paindriya, pabala, sammdihi, {dhammavicayasambojjhago} anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pa, paindriya, pabala, sammdihi, {dhammavicayasambojjhago} srammao ti? mant. a srammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. a anrammaan ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypannan ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypannan ti. Sakhrakkhandho anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho anrammao ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho, viakkhandho anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. a sakhrakkhandhapariypanna anrammaan ti? mant. Pa sakhrakkhandhapariypann anramma ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pa sakhrakkhandhapariypann sramma ti? mant. a sakhrakkhandhapariypanna srammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 410]># %<410 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 6.>% 4. a sakhrakkhandhapariypanna anrammaa, pa sakhrakkhandhapariypann sramma ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anrammao ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho, viakkhandho ekadeso srammao, ekadeso anramanao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "a anrammaan ti"? mant. Arah cakkhuviasamag "ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Atthi tassa assa rammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi a anrammaan ti. 6. Arah cakkhuviasamag "paav ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Atthi tya paya rammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi pa anramma ti. a anrammaan ti kath. IX.6. 1. Attrammaa citta anrammaan ti? mant. Nanu attrammaan ti? mant. Haci attrammaa, no vata re vattabbe "Attrammaa citta anrammaan ti." #<[page 411]># %% Attrammaa anrammaan ti, micch: haci v pana anrammaa, no vata re vattabbe "Attrammaan ti:" anrammaa attrammaan ti, micch. 2. Attrammaa citta anrammaan ti? mant. Nanu atta rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci atta rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Attrammaa citta anrammaan ti." Attrammaakath. IX.7. 1. Angatrammaa citta anrammaa ti? mant. Nanu angatrammaan ti? mant. Haci angatrammaa, no vata re vattabbe "Angatrammaa citta anrammaan ti." Angatrammaa anrammaan ti, micch: haci v pana anrammaa, no vata re vattabbe "Angatrammaan ti:" anrammaa angatrammaan ti, micch. 2. Angatrammaa citta anrammaan ti? mant. Nanu angata rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci angata rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Angatrammaa citta anrammaan ti." 3. Paccuppanna rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, paccuppannrammaa citta srammaan ti? mant. #<[page 412]># %<412 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 8.>% Atta rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, attrammaa citta srammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, paccuppannrammaa citta srammaan ti? mant. Angata rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, angatrammaa citta srammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atta rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, attrammaa citta anrammaan ti? mant. Paccuppanna rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, paccuppannrammaa citta anrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, angatrammaa citta anrammaan ti? mant. Paccuppanna rabbha atthi vaan --pe-- paidhi, paccuppannrammaa citta anrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Attrammaa citta anrammaan ti"? mant. Nanu attrammaa n' atthti? mant. Haci attrammaa n' atthi, tena vata re vattabbe Attrammaa citta anrammaan ti." Angatrammaakath. IX.8. 1. Sabba citta vitakknupaitan ti? mant. Sabba citta vicrnupatita, ptnupatita, sukhnupatita, dukkhnupatita, somanassnupatita, #<[page 413]># %% domanassnupatita, upekkhnupatita, saddhnupatita, viriynupatita, satnupatita, samdhnupatita, panupatita, rgnupatita, dosnupatita --pe-- anottappnupatitan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sabba citta vitakknupatitan ti? mant. Nanu atthi avitakko vicramatto samdhti? mant. Haci atthi avitakko vicramatto samdhi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabba citta vitakknupatitan ti." 3. Sabba citta vitakknupatitan ti? mant. Nanu atthi avitakko avicro samdhti? mant. Haci atthi avitakko avicro samdhi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabba citta vitakknupatitan ti." 4. Sabba citta vitakknupatitan ti? mant. Nanu tayo samdh vutt Bhagavat, savitakko savicro samadhi, avitakko vicramatto samdhi, avitakko avicro samdhti? mant. Haci tayo samdh vutt Bhagavat, savitakko savicro samdhi, avitakko vicramatto samdhi, avitakko avicro samdhi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabba citta vitakknupatitan ti." Vitakknupatitakath. IX.9. 1. Sabbaso vitakkayato vicrayato vitakkavipphro saddo ti? mant. Sabbaso phusayato phassavipphro saddo, sabbaso vedayato vedanvipphro saddo, #<[page 414]># %<414 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 10.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ sabbaso sajnato savipphro saddo, sabbaso cetayato cetanvipphro saddo, sabbaso cintayato cittavipphro saddo, sabbaso sarato sativipphro saddo, sabbaso pajnato pavipphro saddo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sabbaso vitakkayato vicrayato vitakkavipphro saddo ti? mant. Vitakkavipphro saddo sotavieyyo, sotasmi paihaati, sotassa ptha gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu vitakkavipphro saddo na sotavieyyo, na sotasmi paihaati, na sotassa ptha gacchatti? mant. Haci vitakkavipphro saddo na sotavieyyo, na sotasmi paihaati, na sotassa ptha gacchati, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbaso vitakkayato vicrayato vitakkavipphro saddo ti." Vitakkavipphrasaddakath. IX.10. 1. Na yath cittassa vc ti? mant. Aphassakassa vc, avedanakassa vc, asaakassa vc, acetanakassa vc, acittakassa vc ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu saphassakassa vc, savedanakassa vc, sasaakassa vc, sacetanakassa vc, sacittakassa vc ti? mant. Haci saphassakassa --pe-- sacittakassa vc, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa vc ti." #<[page 415]># %% 2. Na yath cittassa vc ti? mant. Anvaantassa vc, anbhogassa vc --pe-- apaidahantassa vc ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu vaantassa vc, bhogassa vc --pe-- paidahantassa vc ti? mant. Haci vaantassa vc, bhogassa vc --pe-- paidahantassa vc, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa vc ti." 3. Na yath cittassa vc ti? mant. Nanu vc cittasamuhn cittena saha jt cittena saha ekuppd ti? mant. Haci vc cittasamuhn cittena saha jt cittena saha ekuppd, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa vc ti." 4. Na yath cittassa vc ti? mant. Na bhaitukmo bhaati, na kathetukmo katheti, na lapitukmo lapati, na voharitukmo voharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu bhaitukmo bhaati, kathetukmo katheti, lapitukmo lapati, voharitukmo voharatti? mant. Haci bhaitukmo bhaati, kathetukmo katheti, lapitukmo lapati, voharitukmo voharati, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa vc ti." 5. Na vattabba "Na yath cittassa vc ti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci "aa bhaissmti" aa bhaati, "aa kathessmti" aa katheti, "aa lapassmti" aa lapati, "aa voharissmti" aa voharatti? mant. Haci atthi koci "aa bhaissmti" aa bhaati, #<[page 416]># %<416 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 11.>% aa kathessmti" aa katheti, aa lapassmti" aa lapati, "aa voharissmti" aa voharati, tena vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa vc ti." Na yath cittassa vc ti kath. IX.11. 1. Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti? mant. Aphassakassa kyakamma, avedanakassa kyakamma, asaakassa kyakamma, acetanakassa kyakamma, acittakassa kyakamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu saphassakassa kyakamma, savedanakassa kyakamma, sasaakassa kyakamma, sacetanakassa kyakamma, sacittakassa kyakamman ti? mant. Haci saphassakassa --pe-- sacittakassa kyakamma, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti." 2. na yath cittassa kyakamman ti? mant. Anvaantassa kyakamma, anbhogassa kyakamma --pe-- apaidahantassa kyakamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu vaantassa kyakamma, bhogassa kyakamma --pe-- paidahantassa kyakamman ti? mant. Haci vaantassa kyakamma, bhogassa kyakamma --pe-- paidahantassa kyakamma, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti." 3. Na yath {cittassa} kyakamman ti? mant. Nanu kyakamma cittasamuhna cittena saha jta cittena saha ekuppdan ti? mant. #<[page 417]># %% Haci kyakamma cittasamuhna cittena saha jta cittena saha ekuppda, no vata re vattabbe Na yath {cittassa} kyakamman ti." 4. Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti? mant. Na abhikkamitukmo abhikkamati, na paikkamitukmo paikkamati, na loketukmo loketi, na viloketukmo viloketi, na sammijitukmo sammijeti, na pasretukmo pasretti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu abhikkamitukmo abhikkamati, paikkamitukmo paikkamati, loketukmo loketi, viloketukmo viloketi, sammijitukmo sammijeti, pasretukmo pasretti? mant. Haci abhikkamitukmo abhikkamati, paikkamitukmo paikkamati, loketukmo loketi, viloketukmo viloketi, sammijitukmo sammijeti, pasretukmo pasreti, no vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti." 5. Na vattabba "Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci "aatra gacchissmti" aatra gacchati --pe-- "{aa} pasressmti" aa pasretti? mant. Haci atthi koci "aatra gacchissmti" aatra gacchati --pe-- "aa pasressmti" aa pasreti, tena vata re vattabbe "Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti." Na yath cittassa kyakamman ti kath. IX.12. 1. Attena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu atta niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagatan ti? mant. 28 #<[page 418]># %<418 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 12.>% Haci atta niruddha vigata vipariata atthagata abbhatthagata, no vata re vattabbe "Attena samanngato ti." 2. Angatena samanngato ti? mant. Nanu angata ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhtan ti? mant. Haci angata ajta abhta asajta anibbatta anabhinibbatta aptubhta, no vata re vattabbe "Angatena samanngato ti." 3. Attena rpakkhandhena samanngato, angatena rpakkhandhena samanngato, paccuppannena rpakkhandhena samanngato ti? mant. Thi rpakkhandhehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attehi pacahi khandhehi samanngato, angatehi pacahi khandhehi samanngato, paccuppannehi pacahi khandhehi samanngato ti? mant. Paarasahi khandhehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Attena cakkhyatanena samanngato, angatena cakkhyatanena samanngato, paccuppannena cakkhyatanena samanngato ti? mant. Thi cakkhyatanehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attehi dvdasahi yatanehi samanngato, angatehi dvdasahi yatanehi samanngato, paccuppannehi dvdasahi yatanehi samanngato ti? mant. Chattis' yatanehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Attya cakkhudhtuy samanngato, angatya cakkhudhtuy samanngato, paccuppannya cakkhudhtuy samanngato ti? #<[page 419]># %% mant. Thi cakkhudhthi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi ahrasahi dhthi samanngato, angathi ahrasahi dhthi samanngato, paccuppannhi ahrasahi dhthi samanngato ti? mant. Catupasadhthi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Attena cakkhundriyena samanngato, angatena cakkhundriyena samanngato, paccuppannena cakkhundriyena samanngato ti? mant. Thi cakkhundriyehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attehi bvsat' indriyehi samanngato, angatehi bvsat' indriyehi samanngato, paccuppannehi bvsat' indriyehi samanngato ti? mant. Chasah' indriyehi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Attngatehi samanngato ti"? mant. Nanu atthi ahavimokkhajhy catunna jhnna nikmalbh, catunna anupubbavihrasampattna lbh ti? mant. Haci atthi ahavimokkhajhy catunna jhnna nikmalbh, catunna anupubbavihrasampattna lbh, tena vata re vattabbe "Attngatehi samanngato ti." Attngatapaccuppannakath. nisasadassvissa saojanna pahna, Amatrammaa saojana, Rpa srammaa, #<[page 420]># %<420 KATHVATTHU. [IX. 12.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Anusay anramma, evameva a, Attngatrammaa citta, Sabba citta vitakknupatita, Sabbaso vitakkayato vicrayato vitakkavipphro saddo, Na yath cittassa vc, tath' eva kyakamma, Attngatehi samanngato ti. Navamo Vaggo. #<[page 421]># %% X.1. 1. Uppattesiye paca khandhe aniruddhe kiriy paca khandh uppajjantti? mant. Dasanna khandhna samodhna hoti, dasa khandh sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dasanna khandhna samodhna hoti, dasa khandh sammukhibhva gacchantti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Uppattesiye paca khandhe aniruddhe kiriy cattro khandh uppajjantti? mant. Navanna khandhna samodhna hoti, nava khandh sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Navanna khandhna samodhna hoti, nava khandh sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Uppattesiye paca khandhe aniruddhe kiriy a uppajjatti? mant. Channa khandhna samodhna hoti, cha khandh sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Channa khandhna samodhna hoti, cha khandh sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 422]># %<422 KATHVATTHU. [X. 2.>% 4. Uppattesiye paca khandhe niruddhe maggo uppajjatti? mant. Mato magga bhveti, klakato magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nirodhakath. x.2. 1. Maggasamagissa rpa maggo ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Maggasamagissa rpa maggo ti." 2. Samvc maggo ti? mant. Sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Sammvc maggo ti." 3. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo maggo ti? mant. Srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? #<[page 423]># %% mant. Haci anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Samm-jvo maggo ti." 4. Sammdihi maggo, s ca srammaa, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammvc maggo, s ca sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammdihi maggo, s ca sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-ajvo maggo, so ca srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi maggo, so ca srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammvc maggo, s ca sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsamdhi maggo, so ca srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo maggo, so ca srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sammvc maggo, s ca anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammdihi maggo, s ca anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammvc maggo, s ca anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati #<[page 424]># %<424 KATHVATTHU. [X. 3.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- sammsamdhi maggo, so ca anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo maggo, so ca anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Sammdihi --pe-- sammsakappo, sammvymo, sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi maggo, so ca anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Na vattabba "Maggasamagissa rpa maggo ti"? mant. Nanu sammvc sammkammanto samm-jvo maggo ti? mant. Haci sammvc sammkammanto samm-jvo maggo, tena vata re vattabbe Maggasamagissa rpa maggo ti." Rpa maggo ti kath. X.3. 1. Pacaviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti? mant. Nanu paca vi uppannavatthuk uppannramma ti? mant. Haci paca vi uppannavatthuk uppannramma, no vata re vattabbe "Pacaviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti." Nanu paca vin purejtavatthuk purejtramma, ajjhattikavatthuk bhirramma, asambhinnavatthuk asambhinnramma, nnvatthuk, nnramma, #<[page 425]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ na amaassa gocaravisaya paccanubhonti, na asamanhr uppajjanti, na amanasikr uppajjanti, na abboki uppajjanti, na apubba acarima uppajjanti, na aamaassa samanantar uppajjanti --pe-- nanu paca vi anbhog ti? mant. Haci paca vi anbhog, no vata re vattabbe "Pacaviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti." 2. Cakkhuviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti? mant. Cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci "cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." 3. Cakkhuviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti? mant. Cakkhuvia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti? mant. #<[page 426]># %<426 KATHVATTHU. [X. 3.>% Cakkhuvia phassa rabbha vedana rabbha saa rabbha cetana rabbha citta rabbha cakkhu rabbha --pe-- kya rabbha sadda rabbha -- pe -- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manoviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, manovia suata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manoviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, manovia {attngata} rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, cakkhuvia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manoviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, manovia phassa rabbha --pe-- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, cakkhuvia phassa rabbha --pe-- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattaba Pacaviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhun rpa disv na {nimittaggh} hoti nnubyajanaggh --pe-- sotena sadda sutv --pe-- ghnena gandha ghyitv --pe-- jivhya rasa syitv --pe-- kyena phohabba phusitv na nimittagh hoti nnubyajanaggh ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi pacaviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan ti. Pacaviasamagissa maggakath. #<[page 427]># %% X.4. 1. Paca vi kusal pi akusal pti? mant. Nanu paca vi uppannavatthuk uppannramma ti? mant. Haci paca vi uppannavatthuk uppannramma, no vata re vattabbe "Paca vi kusal pi akusal pti." Nanu paca vi purejtavatthuk purejtramma, ajjhattikavatthuk bhirramma, asambhinnavatthuk asambhinnramma, nnvatthuk nnramma, na {aamaassa} gocaravisaya paccanubhonti, na asamannhr uppajjanti, na amanasikr uppajjanti, na abboki uppajjanti, na apubba acarima uppajjanti, na aamaassa samanantar uppajjanti -- pe -- nanu paca vi anbhog ti? mant. Haci paca vi anbhog, no vata re vattabbe "Paca vi kusal pi akusal pti." 2. Cakkhuvia kusalan ti? mant. Cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkuvian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 428]># %<428 KATHVATTHU. [X. 4.>% mant. Haci "cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." 3. Cakkhuvia kusala pi akusala pti? mant. Cakkhuvia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuvia kusala pi akusala pti? mant. Cakkhuvia phassa rabbha vedana rabbha saa rabbha cetana rabbha citta rabbha cakkhu rabbha --pe-- kya rabbha sadda rabbha -- pe -- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manovia kusaa pi akusala pi, manovia suata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia kusala pi akusala pi, cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manovia kusala pi akusala pi, manovia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia kusala pi akusala pi, cakkhuvia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manovia kusala pi akusala pi, manovia phassa rabbha --pe-- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia kusala pi akusala pi, cakkhuvia phassa rabbha --pe-- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Paca vi kusal pi akusal pti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhun rpa disv nimittaggh hoti #<[page 429]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- na nimittaggh hoti --pe-- sotena sadda sutv --pe-- kyena phohabba phusitv nimittaggh hoti --pe-- na nimittaggh hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi {paca} vi kusal pi akusal pti. Paca vi kusal pti kath. X.5. 1. Paca vi sbhog ti? mant. Nanu paca vi uppanavatthuk uppannramma ti? mant. Haci paca vi uppannavatthuk uppannramma, no vata re vattabbe "Paca vi sbhog ti." Nanu paca vi purejtavatthuk purejtramma, ajjhattikavatthuk bhirramma, asambhinnavatthuk asambhinnramma, nnvatthuk nnramma, na aamaassa gocaravisaya paccanubhonti, na asamannhr uppajjanti, na amanasikr uppajjanti, na abboki uppajjanti, na apubba acarima uppajjanti, nanu paca vi na aamaassa samanantar uppajjantti? mant. Haci paca vi na aamaassa samanantar uppajjanti, no vata re vattabbe "Paca vi sbhog ti." 2. Cakkhuvia sbhogan ti? mant. Cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjati? mant. #<[page 430]># %<430 KATHVATTHU. [X. 5.>% Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci "cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe Cakkhu ca paicca suata ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti." 3. Cakkhuvia sbhogan ti? mant. Cakkhuvia attnagata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuvia sbhogan ti? mant. Cakkhuvia phassa rabbha vedana rabbha saa rabbha cetana rabbha citta rabbha cakkhu rabbha --pe-- kya rabbha sadda rabbha -- pe -- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manovia sbhoga, manovia suata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia sbhoga, cakkhuvia suata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manovia sbhoga, manovia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia sbhoga, cakkhuvia attngata rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 431]># %% Manovia sbhoga, manovia phassa rabbha --pe-- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia sbhoga, cakkhuvia phassa rabbha --pe-- phohabba rabbha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Paca vi sbhog ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhun rpa disv nimittaggh hoti --pe-- na nimittaggh hoti --pe-- sotena sadda sutv --pe-- kyena phohabba phusitv nimittaggh hoti --pe-- na nimittaggh hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi paca vi sbhog ti. Sbhogakath. X.6. 1. Maggasamag dvhi slehi samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag dvhi phassehi dvhi vedanhi dvhi sahi dvhi cetanhi dvhi cittehi dvhi saddhhi dvihi viriyehi dvhi sathi dvhi samdhhi dvhi pahi samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Maggasamag lokiyena slena sammanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyena phassena lokiyya vedanya lokiyya saya lokiyya cetanya lokiyena cittena lokiyya saddhya lokiyena viriyena lokiyeya satiy lokiyena samdhin lokiyya paya samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca slena samanngato ti? mant. #<[page 432]># %<432 KATHVATTHU. [X. 6.>% Maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca phassena samanngato --pe-- lokiyya ca lokuttarya ca paya samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasamag lokiyena slena samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag puthujjano ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Maggasamag lokiyya sammvcya samanngato ti? {mant.} Maggasamag lokiyya sammdihiy samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasamag lokiyya sammvcya samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyena sammsakappena --pe-- lokiyena sammvymena --pe-- lokiyya sammsatiy -- pe-- lokiyena sammsamdhin samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasamag lokiyena sammkammantena --pe-- lokiyena samm-jvena samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyya sammdihiy --pe-- lokiyena sammsamdhin samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Maggasamag lokiyya ca lokuttarya ca sammv cya samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyya ca lokuttarya ca sammdihiy samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasamag lokiyya ca lokuttarya ca {sammvcya} samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammsakappena --pe-- lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammvymena #<[page 433]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- lokiyya ca lokuttarya ca sammsatiy -- pe -- lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammsamdhin samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammkammantena --pe-- maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca samm-jvena samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyya ca lokuttraya ca sammdihiy samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammjvena samanngato ti? mant. Maggasamag lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammsakappena --pe-- lokiyena ca lokuttarena ca sammsamdhin samanngato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Maggasamag dvhi slehi samanngato ti."? mant. Lokiye sle niruddhe maggo uppajjatti? mant. Dusslo khaaslo chinnaslo magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi maggasamag dvhi slehi samanngato ti. Dvhi slehti kath. X.7. 1. Sla acetasikan ti? mant. Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- kyyatana --pe-- rpyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? #<[page 434]># %<434 KATHVATTHU. [X. 7.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla acetasikan ti? {mant.} Phasso acetasiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla acetasikan ti? mant. Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- cetan --pe-- saddh --pe-- viriya --pe-- sati --pe-- samdhi --pe-- pa acetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Phasso cetasiko ti? mant. Sla cetasikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- cetan --pe-- saddh --pe-- viriya --pe-- sati --pe-- samdhi --pe-- pa cetasik ti? mant. Sla cetasikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sla acetasikan ti? mant. Anihaphalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu ihaphalan ti? mant. Haci ihaphala, no vata re vattabbe "Sla acetasikan ti." 4. Saddh ihaphal, saddh cetasik ti? mant. Sla ihaphala, sla cetasikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Viriya, sati, samdhi --pe-- pa ihaphal, pa cetasik ti? mant. Sla ihaphala, sla cetasikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sla ihaphala, sla acetasikan ti? #<[page 435]># %% mant. Saddh ihaphal, saddh acetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla ihaphala, sla acetasikan ti? mant. Viriya, sati, samdhi --pe-- pa ihaphal, pa acetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sla acetasikan ti? mant. Aphala avipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu saphala savipkan ti? mant. Haci saphala savipka, no vata re vattabbe "Sla acetasikan ti." 7. Cakkhyatana acetasika avipkan ti? mant. Sla acetasika avipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotyatana --pe-- kyyatana --pe-- rpyatana -- pe -- phohabbyatana acetasika avipkan ti? mant. Sla acetasika avipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Sla acetasika savipkan ti? mant. Cakkhyatana acetasika savipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla acetasika savipkan ti? mant. Sotyatana --pe-- kyyatana --pe-- rpyatana -- pe -- phohabbyatana acetasika savipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Sammvc acetasik ti? mant. Sammdihi acetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 436]># %<436 KATHVATTHU. [X. 7.>% Sammvc acetasik ti? mant. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi acetasiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo acetasiko ti? mant. Sammdihi acetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samm-jvo acetasiko ti? mant. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi acetasiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 10. Sammdihi cetasik ti? mant. Sammvc cetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammdihi cetasik ti? {mant.} Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo cetasiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi cetasiko ti? mant. Sammvc cetasik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsamdhi cetasiko ti? mant. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo cetasiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Na vattabba "Sla acetasikan ti"? mant. Sle uppajjitv niruddhe dusslo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi sla acetasikan ti. Sla acetasikan ti kath. #<[page 437]># %% X.8. 1. Sla na cittnuparivattti? mant. Rpa {nibbna} cakkhyatana --pe-- kyyatana --pe-- rpyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla na cittnuparivattti? mant. Phasso na cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sla na cittnuparivattti? mant. Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- cetan --pe-- saddh --pe-- viriya --pe-- sati --pe-- samdhi --pe-- pa na cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Phasso cittnuparivattti? mant. Sla cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- cetan --pe-- saddh --pe-- viriya --pe-- sati --pe-- samdhi --pe-- pa cittnuparivattti? mant. Sla cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sammvc na cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammdihi na cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammvc na cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi na cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo na cittnuparivattti? #<[page 438]># %<438 KATHVATTHU. [X. 8.>% mant. Sammdihi na cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Samm-jvo na cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi na cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sammdihi cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammvc cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammdihi cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammvc cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsamdhi cittnuparivattti? mant. Sammkammanto --pe-- samm-jvo cittnuparivattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Sla na cittnuparivattti"? mant. Sle uppajjitv niruddhe dusslo hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi sla na cittnuparivattti. Sla na cittnuparivattti kath. #<[page 439]># %% X.9. 1. Samdnahetuka sla vahatti? mant. Samdnahetuko phasso vahati, vedan vahati, sa vahati, cetan vahati, citta vahati, saddh vahati, viriya vahati, sati vahati, samdhi vahati, pa vahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Samdnahetuka sla vahatti? mant. Lat viya vahati, mluv viya vahati, rukkho viya vahati, tia viya vahati, mujapujo viya vahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Samdnahetuka sla vahatti? mant. Sla samdiyitv kmavitakka vitakkentassa bypdavitakka vitakkentassa vihisvitakka vitakkentassa sla vahatti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' va vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappant kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukkhbhva gacchantti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Labha ca Bhikkhave pahav ca, ida pahama suvidravidra -- pe -- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 440]># %<440 KATHVATTHU. [X. 10.>% mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti." Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Samdnahetuka sla vahatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "rmarop vanarop --pe-- Dhammah slasampann Te jan saggagmino ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi samdnagetuka sla vahatti. Samdnahetukakath. X.10. 1. Viatti slan ti? mant. Ptipt veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adinndn veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmesu micchcr veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Musvd veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Surmerayamajjapamdahn veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Abhivdana sla, paccuhna sla, ajalkamma sla, smcikamma sla, sanbhihro sla, seyybhihro sla, pdodakbhihro sla, pdakathaliybhihro sla, nahne pihiparikamma slan ti? #<[page 441]># %% mant. Ptipt veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Surmerayamajjapamdahn veramati? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba Viatti slan ti." Dusslyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi viatti slan ti. Viatti slan ti kath. X.11. 1. Aviatti dussilyan ti? mant. Ptipto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adinndnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmesu micchcro ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Musvdo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Surmerayamajjapamdahnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ppakamma samdiyitv dna dadantassa pua ca apua ca ubho vahantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pua ca apua ca ubho vahantti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna citna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? mant. #<[page 442]># %<442 KATHVATTHU. [X. 11.>% Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Labha ca Bhikkhave pahav ca, ida pahama suvidravidra -- pe -- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vatabba Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnapat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti." 3. Ppakamma samdiyitv cvara dadantassa, piapta dadantassa, sensana dadantassa, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadantassa, abhivdanragassa abhivdentassa, paccuhnrahassa paccuhentassa, ajalkammrahassa ajalkamma karontassa, sammcikammrahassa sammcikamma karontassa, sanrahassa sana dadantassa, maggrahassa magga dadantassa pua ca apua ca ubho vahantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pua ca apua ca ubho vahantti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. #<[page 443]># %% Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Labha ca Bhikkhave pahav ca, ida pahama suvidravidra --pe-- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti." 4. Na vattabba "Aviatti dusslyan ti"? mant. Nanu ppakamma samdinno sti? mant. Haci ppakamma samdinno si, tena vata re vattabbe "Aviatti dusslyan ti." Aviatti dusslyan ti kath. Maggasamagissa rpa maggo, Pacaviasamagissa atthi maggabhvan, Paca vi kusal pi akusal pi, Paca vi {sbhog,} Maggasamag dvhi slehi samanngato, Sla acetasika, Sla na cittnuparivatti, Samdnahetuka sla vahati, Viatti sla, Aviatti dusslyan ti. Dasamo Vaggo. Dutiyapasako. Niymasagahagatnisasat atthi pacavokrabhavo maggasamagissa no pacavokrabhavo. #<[page 444]># %<444 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 1.>% XI.1. 1. Anusay abykat ti? mant. Vipkbykat kiriybykat rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Kmargnusayo abykato ti? mant. Kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargo --pe-- kmacchandanvaraa akusalan ti? mant. Kmargnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Paighnusayo abykato ti? mant. Paigha paighapariyuhna paighasaojana abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paigha paighapariyuhna paighasaojana akusalan ti? mant. Paighnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Mnnusayo abykato ti? mant. Mno mnapariyuhna mnasaojana abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mno mnapariyuhna mnasaojana akusalan ti? mant. Mnnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 445]># %% 5. Dihnusayo abykato ti? mant. Dihi dihogho dihiyogo {dihipariyuhna} dihisaojana abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dihi dihogho dihiyogo {dihipariyuhna} dihisaojana akusalan ti? mant. Dihnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Vicikicchnusayo abykato ti? mant. Vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vicikicch vicikicchpariyuhna vicikicchsaojana vicikicchnvaraa akusalan ti? mant. Vicikicchnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Bhavargnusayo abykato ti? mant. Bhavargo bhavargapariyuhna bhavargasaojana abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bhavargo bhavargapariyuhna bhavargasaojana akusalan ti? mant. Bhavargnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Avijjnusayo abykato ti? mant. Avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraa akusalan ti? mant. #<[page 446]># %<446 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 1.>% Avijjnusayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Na vattabba "Anusay abykat ti"? mant. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne snusayo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Kusalkusal dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi anusay abykat ti. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "sargo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Kusalkusal dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi rgo abykato ti. 10. Anusay ahetuk ti? mant. Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe--' Kmargnusayo ahetuko ti? mant. Kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana --pe-- kmraganvaraa ahetukan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana --pe-- kmraganvaraa sahetukan ti? mant. Kmargnusayo sahetuko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paighnusayo --pe-- mnnusayo, dihnusayo, vicikicchnusayo, bhavargnusayo --pe-- avijjnusayo ahetuko ti? mant. Avijj avijjogho avijjyogo avijjpariyuhna avijjsaojana avijjnvaraa ahetukan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 447]># %% Avijj avijjogho --pe-- avijjnvaraa sahetukan ti? mant. Avijjnusayo sahetuko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 11. Na vattabba "Anusay ahetuk ti"? mant. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "snusayo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Anusay tena hetun sahetuk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi anusay ahetuk ti. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "sargo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Rgo tena hetun sahetuko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi rgo ahetuko ti. 12. Anusay cittavippayutt ti? mant. Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargnusayo cittavippayutto ti? mant. Kmargo kmargapariyuhna kmargasaojana kmogho kmayogo kmacchandanvaraa cittavippayuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargo --pe-- kmacchandanvaraa cittasampayuttan ti? mant. Kmargnusayo cittasampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 13. Kmargnusayo cittavippayutto ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypanno ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypanno ti. #<[page 448]># %<448 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 1.>% Sakhrakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, viakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 14. Kmargnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittavippayutto ti? mant. Kmargo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmargo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittasampayutto ti? mant. Kmargnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittasampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 15. Kmargnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittavipayutto, kmargo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittasampayutto ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, viakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 16. Paighnusayo, mnnusayo, dihnusayo, vicikicchnusayo, bhavargnusayo, avijjnusayo cittavipayutto ti? mant. Avijj avijjogho avijjyogo --pe-- avijjnvaraa cittavippayuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 449]># %% Avijj avijjogho avijjyogo --pe-- avijjnvaraa cittasampayuttan ti? mant. Avijjnusayo cittasampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 17. Avijjnusayo cittavippayutto ti? mant. Katamakkhandhapariypanno ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypanno ti. Sakhrakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Avijjnusayo sakhrakkhadhapariypanno cittavippayutto ti? mant. Avijj sakhrakkhandhapariypann cittavippayutt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avijj sakhrakkhandhapariypann cittasampayutt ti? mant. Avijjnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittasampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 19. Avijjnusayo sakhrakkhandhapariypanno cittavippayutto, avijj sakhrakkhandhapariypann cittasampayutt ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho ekadeso citasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? 30 #<[page 450]># %<450 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 2.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 20. Na vattabba "Anusay cittavippayutt ti"? mant. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "snusayo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Anusay tena cittena sampayutt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi anusay cittavippayutt ti. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "sargo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Rgo tena cittena sampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi rgo cittavippayutto ti. Tisso pi anusayakath. XI.2. 1. Ae vigate avippayutte citte vattamne na vattabba ti"? mant. Rge vigate na vattabba "vtargo ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ae vigate avippayutte citte vattamne na vattabba ti"? mant. Dose vigate --pe-- mohe vigate --pe-- kilese vigate na vattabba "Nikkileso ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Rge vigate vattabba "vtargo ti"? mant. Ae vigate avippayutte citte vattamne vattabba ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 451]># %% Dose vigate --pe-- mohe vigate --pe-- kilese vigate vattabba "nikkileso ti"? mant. Ae vigate avippayutte citte vattamne vattabba " ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Ae vigate avippayutte citte vattamne vattabba " ti"? mant. Attena ena , niruddhena vigatena paipassaddhena ena ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- akath. XI.3. 1. a cittavippayuttan ti? mant. Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- a cittavippayuttan ti? mant. Pa paindriya pabala sammdihi dhammavicayasambojjhago cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pa paindriya pabala sammdihi dhammavicayasambojjhago cittasampayutto ti? mant. a cittasampayuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. a cittavippayuttan ti? mant. #<[page 452]># %<452 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 3.>% Katamakkhandhapariypannan ti? Sakhrakkhandhapariypannan ti. Sakhrakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. a sakhrakkhandhapariypanna cittavippayuttan ti? mant. Pa sakhrakkhandhapariypann cittavippayutt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pa sakhrakkhandhapariypann cittasampayutt ti? mant. a {sakhrakkhandhapariypanna.} cittasampayuttan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. a sakhrakkhandhapariypanna cittavippayutta, pa sakhrakkhandhapariypann cittasampayutt ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? mant. Vedankkhandho, sakkhandho ekadeso cittasampayutto, ekadeso cittavippayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "a cittavippayuttan ti"? mant. Arah cakkhuviasamag " ti" vattabbo ti? mant. a tena cittena sampayuttan ti? #<[page 453]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi a cittavippayuttan ti. Arah cakkhuviasamag "paav ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Pa tena cittena sampayutt ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi pa cittavippayutt ti. Na cittavippayuttan ti kath. XI.4. 1. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Aya samudayo ti" vca bhsato "aya samudayo ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Aya nirodho ti" vca bhsato "aya nirodho ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Aya maggo ti" vca bhsato "aya maggo ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Aya samudayo ti" vca bhsato na ca "aya samudayo ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 454]># %<454 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 4.>% "Aya nirodho ti" vca bhsato na ca "aya nirodho ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Aya maggo ti" vca bhsato na ca "aya maggo ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Rpa aniccan ti" vca bhsato "rpa aniccan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via aniccan ti" vca bhsato via aniccan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Rpa anatt ti" vca bhsato "rpa anatt ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via anatt ti" vca bhsato "via anatt ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 455]># %% 5. Rpa aniccan ti" vca bhsato na ca "rpa aniccan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via aniccan ti" vca bhsato na ca "via aniccan ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. "Rpa anatt ti" vca bhsato na ca "rpa anatt ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- "Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via anatt ti" vca bhsato na ca "via anatt ti" a pavattatti? mant. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato na ca "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. "Ida dukkhan ti" vca bhsato "ida dukkhan ti" a pavattatti? mant. ti ca danti ca ruci ca khanti ca a pavattatti? mant. Ida dukkhan ti kath. #<[page 456]># %<456 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 5.>% XI.5. 1. Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Iddhimayiko so yu, iddhimayik s gati, iddhimayiko so attabhvapailbho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Atta kappa tiheyya, angata kappa tiheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Dve kappe tiheyya, tayo kappe tiheyya, cattro kappe tiheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Sati jvite jvitvasese tiheyya, asati jvite jvitvasese tiheyyti? Sati jvite jvitvasese tiheyyti. Haci sati jvite jvitvasese tiheyya, no vata re vattabbe "Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti." Asati jvite jvitvasese tiheyyti. Mato tiheyya, klakato tiheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Uppanno phasso m nirujjhti labbh iddhiy paggahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uppann vedan --pe-- uppann sa --pe-- uppann cetan --pe-- uppanna citta --pe-- uppann saddh -- pe -- uppanna viriya --pe-- uppann sati --pe-- uppanno samdhi #<[page 457]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- uppann pa m nirujjhti labbh iddhiy paggahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Rpa nicca hotti labbh iddhiy paggahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via nicca hotti labbh iddhiy paggahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Jtidhamm satt m jyisti labbh iddhiy paggahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jardhamm satt m jirisu --pe-- bydhidhamm satt m bydhiyisu --pe-- maraadhamm satt m myisu labbh iddhiy paggahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yassa kassaci nanda cattro iddhipd bhvit bahulkat ynkat vatthukat anuhit paricit susamraddh, kakhamno so nanda kappa v tiheyya kappyasesa v ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti. 7. Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Catunna Bhikkhave dhammna n' atthi koci pibhogo samao v brhmao v devo v Mro v Brahm v koci v lokasmi. Katamesa catunna? Jardhammo m jvti n' atthi koci #<[page 458]># %<458 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 6.>% pibhogo samao v brhmao v devo v Mro v Brahm v koci v lokasmi, bydhidhammo m bydhiyti -- pe--maraadhammo m myti --pe--. Yni kho pana tni pubbe katni ppakni kammni sakilesikni ponobhavikni nissrni dukkhavipkni yati jtijarmaraiyni, tesa vipko m nibbattti n' atthi koci pibhogo samano v brhmao v devo v Mro v Brahm v koci v lokasmin ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyyti." Iddhibalakath. XI.6. 1. Cittasantati samdhti? mant. Att cittasantati samdhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cittasantati samdhti? mant. Angat cittasantati samdhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atta niruddha, angata ajtan ti? mant. Haci atta niruddha, angata ajta, no vata re vattabbe "Cittasantati samdhti." 2. Ekacittakkhaiko samdhti? mant. Cakkhuviasamag sampanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotaviasamag --pe-- {ghanviasamag} -- pe -- jivhviasamag --pe-- kyaviasamag --pe-- #<[page 459]># %% akusalacittasamag --pe-- rgasahagatacittasamag -- pe -- dosasahagatacittasamag --pe-- mohasahagatacittasamag --pe-- anottappasahagatacittasamag sampanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Cittasantati samdhti? mant. Akusalacittasantati samdhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgasahagat --pe-- dosasahagat --pe-- mohasahagat --pe-- anottappasahagat cittasantati samdhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Cittasantati samdhti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Aha kho vuso Nigaha pahomi anijamno kyena abhsamno vca satta rattindivni ekantasukhapaisaved viharitun ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi cittasantati samdhti. Samdhikath. XI.7. 1. Dhammahitat parinipphann ti? mant. Tya hitat parinipphann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya hitat {parinipphann} ti? mant. Tya ty' eva n' atthi dukkhass' antakiriy, n' atthi vapacchedo, n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 460]># %<460 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 8.>% 2. Rpassa hitat parinipphann ti? mant. Tya hitat parinipphann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya hitat parinipphann ti? mant. Tya ty' eva n' atthi dukkhass' antakiriy, n' atthi vapacchedo, n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Vedanya hitat --pe-- saya hitat --pe-- sakhrna hitat --pe-- viassa hitat parinipphann ti? mant. Tya hitat parinipphann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya ty' eva n' atthi dukkhass' anakiriy n' atthi vapacchedo n' atthi anuppdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammahitatkath. XI.8. 1. Aniccat parinipphann ti? mant. Tya aniccatya aniccat parinipphann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya aniccatya aniccat parinipphann ti? mant. Tya ty' eva n' atthi dukkhass' antakiriy, n' atthi vapacchedo, n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Jar parinipphann ti? mant. Tya jarya jar parinipphann ti? #<[page 461]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tya jarya jar parinipphann ti? mant. Tya ty' eva n' atthi dukkhass' antakiriy, n' atthi vapacchedo, n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Maraa parinipphannan ti? mant. Tassa maraassa maraa parinipphannan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tassa maraassa maraa parinipphannan ti? mant. Tassa tass' eva n' atthi dukkhass' antakiriy, n' atthi vapacchedo, n' atthi anupdparinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Rpa parinipphanna, rpassa aniccat atthti? mant. Aniccat parinipphann, aniccatya aniccat atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa parinipphannam, rpassa jar atthti? mant. Jar parinipphann, jarya jar atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa parinipphanna, rpassa bhedo atthi antaradhna atthti? mant. Maraa parinipphanna, maraassa bhedo atthi antaradhna atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via parinipphanna, viassa aniccat atthti? mant. Aniccat parinipphann, aniccatya aniccat atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Via parinipphanna, viassa jar atthti? mant. Jar parinipphann, jarya jar atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 462]># %<462 KATHVATTHU. [XI. 8.>% Via parinipphanna, viassa bhedo atthi, antaradhna atthti? mant. Maraa parinipphana, maraassa bhedo atthi, antaradhna atthti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Aniccatkath. Anusay abykat, ahetuk, cittavippayutt, Ae vigate , a cittavippayutta, Yattha sadde a pavattati, Iddhibalena samanngato kappa tiheyya, Cittasantati samdhi, Dhammahitat, Aniccat ti. Ekdasamo Vaggo. #<[page 463]># %% XII.1. 1. Savaro kamman ti? mant. Cakkhundriyasavaro cakkhukamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotindriyasavaro --pe-- ghnindriyasavaro --pe-- jivhindriyasavaro --pe-- kyindriyasavaro kyakamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyindriyasavaro kyakamman ti? mant. Cakkhundriyasavaro cakkhukamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyindriyasavaro kyakamman ti? mant. Sotindriyasavaro --pe-- ghnindriyasavaro --pe-- jivhindriyasavaro jivhkamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manindriyasavaro manokamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manindriyasavaro manokamman ti? mant. Cakkhundriyasavaro cakkhukamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manindriyasavaro manokamman ti? mant. Sotindriyasavaro --pe-- ghnindriyasavaro --pe-- jivhindriyasavaro --pe-- kyindriyasavaro kyakamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Asavaro kamman ti? mant. Cakkhundriya-asavaro cakkhukamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotindriya-asavaro --pe-- ghnindriya-asavaro --pe-- jivhindriya-asavaro --pe-- kyindriya-asavaro kyakamman ti? #<[page 464]># %<464 KATHVATTHU. [XII. 2.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyindriya-asavaro kyakamman ti? mant. Cakkhundriya-asavaro cakkhukamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyindriya-asavaro kyakamman ti? mant. Sotindriya-asavaro --pe-- ghnindriya-asavaro --pe-- {jivhindriya-asavaro} jivhkamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manindriya-asavaro manokamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manindriya-asavaro manokamman ti? mant. Cakkhundriya-asavaro cakkhukamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Manindriya-asavaro manokamman ti? mant. Sotindriya-asavaro --pe-- ghnindriya-asavaro --pe-- jivhindriya-asavaro --pe-- kyindriy-asavaro kyakamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Savaro asavaro pi kamman ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhun rpa disv nimittaggh hoti --pe-- na nimittaggh hoti, sotena sadda sutv --pe-- manas dhamma viya nimittaggh hoti --pe-- na nimittaggh hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi savaro asavaro pi kamman ti. Savaro kamman ti kath. XII.2. 1. Sabba kamma savipkan ti? mant. #<[page 465]># %% Sabb cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb cetan savipk ti? mant. Vipkbykat cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb cetan savipk ti? mant. Kiriybykat cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb cetan savipk ti? mant. Kmvacar vipkbykat cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb cetan savipk ti? mant. Rpvacar, arpvacar, apariypann vipkbykat cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb cetan savipk ti? mant. Kmvacar kiriybykat cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabb cetan savipk ti? mant. Rpvacar, arpvacar kiriybykat cetan savipk ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Vipkbykat cetan avipk ti? mant. Haci vipkbykat cetan avipk, no vata re vattabbe "Sabb cetan savipk ti." Kiriybykat cetan avipk ti? mant. Haci kiriybykat cetan avipk, no vata re vattabbe "Sabb cetan savipk ti." Kmvacar, rpvacar, arpvacar, apariypann vipkbykat cetan avipk ti? #<[page 466]># %<466 KATHVATTHU. [XII. 3.>% mant. Haci apariypann vipkbykat cetan avipk, no vata re vattabbe "Sabb cetan savipk ti." Kmvacar, rpvacar, arpvacar kiriybykat cetan avipk ti? mant. Haci arpvacar kiriybykat cetan avipk, no vata re vattabbe "Sabb cetan savipk ti." 3. Na vattabba "Sabba kamma savipkan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Nha Bhikkhave sacetanikna kammna katna upacitna appaisaveditv byantibhva vadmi ta ca kho dih' eva dhamme uppajje v apare v pariyye ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi sabba kamma savipkan ti. Kammakath. XII.3. 1. Saddo vipko ti? mant. Sukhavedanyo, dukkhavedanyo, adukkhamasukhavedanyo, sukhya vedanya sampayutto, dukkhya vedanya sampayutto, adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutto, phassena sampayutto, vedanya sampayutto, saya sampayutto, cetanya sampayutto, cittena sampayutto srammao, atthi tassa vaan bhogo samannhro manasikro cetan patthan paidhti? mant. Nanu na sukhavedanyo, na dukkhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan -- pe--paidhti? mant. #<[page 467]># %% Haci na sukhavedanyo, na dukkhavedanyo --pe-- anrammano, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Saddo vipko ti." 2. Phasso vipko, phasso sukhavedanyo --pe-- srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Saddo vipko, saddo sukhavedanyo --pe-- srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddo vipko, saddo na sukhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Phasso vipko, phasso na sukhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Saddo vipko ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "So tassa kammassa katatt upacitatt ussannat vipulatt brhmassaro hoti karavkabh ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi saddo vipko ti Saddo vipko ti kath XII.4. 1. Cakkhyatana vipko ti? mant. Sukhavedanya, dukkhavedanya --pe-- srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. #<[page 468]># %<468 KATHVATTHU. [XII. 4.>% Haci na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhyatana vipko ti." 2. Phasso vipko, phasso sukhavedanyo --pe-- srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Cakkhyatana vipko, cakkhyatana sukhavedanya --pe-- srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhyatana vipko, cakkhyatana na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? mant. Phasso vipko, phasso na sukhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sotyatana --pe-- ghnyatana --pe-- jivhyatana --pe-- kyyatana vipko ti? mant. Sukhavedanya, dukkhavedanya --pe-- sramaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Kyyatana vipko ti." Phasso vipko, phasso sukhavedanyo --pe-- srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Kyyatana vipko, kyyatana sukhavedanya -- pe -- srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyyatana vipko, kyyatana na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? #<[page 469]># %% mant. Phasso vipko, phasso na sukhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Sayatana vipko ti"? mant. Nanu sayatana kammassa katatt uppannan ti? mant. Haci sayatana kammassa katatt uppanna, tena vata re vattabbe "Sayatana vipko ti." Sayatanakatha. XII.5. 1. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Mt jvit voropit, pit jvit voropito, Arah jvit voropito, duhena cittena Tathgatassa lohita uppdita, Sagho bhinno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Abhabbo antar dhamma abhisametun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Abhabbo antar dhamma abhisametun ti? mant. Mt jvit voropit, pit jvit voropito, Arah jvit voropito, duhena cittena Tathgatassa lohita uppdita, Sagho bhinno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Atthi so niymo, yena niymena sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 470]># %<470 KATHVATTHU. [XII. 5.>% Atthi te satipahn, sammappadhn, iddhipd, indriy, bal, bojjhag, yehi bojjhagehi sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. N' atthi so niymo, yena niyamena sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Haci n' atthi so niymo, yena niymena sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato, no vata re vattabbe "Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti." N' atthi te satipahn --pe-- bojjhag, yehi bojjhagehi sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Haci n' atthi te bojjhag, yehi bojjhagehi sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato, no vata re vattabbe "Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti." 5. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Sakadgminiymenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angminiymenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattaniymenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Katamena niymenti? Sotpattiniymenti. Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti? mant. Ye keci sotpattiniyma okkamanti, sabbe te sattakkhattuparamat niyat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti"? #<[page 471]># %% mant. Nanu so sattakkhattuparamo ti? mant. Haci so sattakkhattuparamo, tena vata re vattabbe "Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato ti." Sattakkhattuparamakath. XII.6. 1. Na vattabba "Kolakolo puggalo kolakolat niyato ti"? mant. Nanu so kolakolo ti? mant. Haci so kolakolo, tena vata re vattabbe "Kolakolo puggalo kolakolat niyato ti." 2. Na vattabba "Ekabj puggalo ekabjit niyato ti"? mant. Nanu so ekabj ti? mant. Haci so ekabj, tena vata re vattabbe "Ekabj puggalo ekabjit niyato ti." XII.7. 1. Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyyti? mant. Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca mtara jvit voropeyya --pe-- pitara jvit voropeyya, Arahanta jvit voropeyya --pe-- duhena cittena Tathgatassa lohita uppdeyya --pe-- Sagha bhindeyyti? #<[page 472]># %<472 KATHVATTHU. [XII. 7.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyyti? mant. Dihisampanno puggalo Satthari agravo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhamme --pe-- Saghe --pe-- Sikkhya agravo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Nanu dihisampanno puggalo Satthari sagravo ti? mant. Haci dihisampanno puggalo Satthari sagravo, no vata re vattabbe "Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyyti." Nanu dihisampanno puggalo Dhamme --pe-- Saghe --pe-- Sikkhya sagravo ti? mant. Haci dihisampanno puggalo Sikkhya sagravo, no vata re vattabbe "Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyyti." Dihisampanno puggalo Satthari agravo ti? mant. Dihisampanno puggalo Buddhathpe ohaneyya, omutteyya, nihubheyya, Buddhathpe apabymato kareyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe {--pe--} 5. Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyyti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Seyyathpi Bhikkhave mahsamuddo hitadhammo vela ntivattati, evameva kho Bhikkhave ya may svakna sikkhpada paatta, ta mama svak jvitahetu pi ntikkammantti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 473]># %% mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyyti." Jvit voropanakath. XII.8. 1. Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggatti? mant. Dihisampanno puggalo pyike rpe rajjeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Haci dihisampanno puggalo pyike rpe rajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe "Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggatti." 2. Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggatti? mant. Dihisampanno puggalo pyike sadde --pe-- gandhe -- pe -- rase --pe-- phohabbe --pe-- amanussitthiy, tiracchnagatitthiy, ngakaya methuna dhamma paiseveyya, ajeaka paiggaheyya, kukkuaskara paiggaheyya, hatthigavassavaava paiggaheyya --pe-- tittiravaakamorakapijaa paiggaheyyti? mant. Haci dihisampanno puggalo {tittiravaakamorakapijaa} paiggaheyya, no vata re vattabbe "Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggatti." 3. Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggati, dihisampanno puggalo pyike rpe rajjeyyti? mant. Arahato pahn duggati, Arah pyike rpe rajjeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggati, dihisampanno puggalo pyike sadde --pe-- gandhe --pe-- rase --pe-- phohabbe --pe-- tittiravaakamorakapijala paiggaheyyti? #<[page 474]># %<474 KATHVATTHU. [XII. 8.>% mant. Arahato pahn duggati, Arah {tittiravaakamorakapijaa} paiggaheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Arahato pahn duggati, na ca Arah pyike rpe rajjeyyti? mant. Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggati, na ca dihisampanno puggalo pyike rpe rajjeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahato pahn duggati, na ca Arah pyike sadde -- pe -- gandhe --pe-- rase --pe-- phohabbe --pe-- amanussitthiy, tiracchnagatitthiy, ngakaya methuna dhamma paiseveyya, ajeaka paiggaheyya, kukkuaskara paiggaheyya, hatthigavassavaava paiggaheyya --pe-- {tittiravaakamorakapijaa} paiggaheyyti? mant. Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggati, na ca dihisampanno puggalo {tittiravaakamorakapijaa} paiggaheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggatti"? mant. Dihisampanno puggalo niraya upapajjeyya --pe-- tiracchnayoni upapajjeyya --pe-- pittivisaya upapajjeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggatti. Duggatikath. #<[page 475]># %% XII.9. 1. Na vattabba "Sattamabhavikassa puggalassa pahn duggatti"? mant. Sattamabhaviko puggalo niraya upapajjeyya, tiracchnayoni upapajjeyya, pittivisaya upapajjeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi sattamabhavikassa puggalassa pahn duggatti. Sattamabhavikakath. Savaro kamma tath' eva asavaro, Sabba kamma {savipka}, Saddo vipko, Sayatana vipko, Sattakkhattuparamo puggalo sattakkhattuparamat niyato, Kolakolo puggalo kolakolat niyato, Ekabj puggalo ekabjit niyato Dihisampanno puggalo sacicca pa jvit voropeyya, Dihisampannassa puggalassa pahn duggati, Tath' eva Sattamabhavikassti. Dvdasamo Vaggo. #<[page 476]># %<476 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 1.>% XIII.1. 1. Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Kappo ca sahti Buddho ca loke uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Kappo ca sahti Sagho ca bhijjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Kappo ca sahti kappaho ca kappahiya kamma karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Kappo ca sahti kappaho ca puggalo kla karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Atta kappa tiheyya, angata kappa tiheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Dve kappe tiheyya, tayo kappe tiheyya, cattro kappe tiheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kappaho kappa tiheyyti? mant. Kappaho kappe ayhante kattha gacchatti? Aa lokadhtu gacchatti. Mato gacchati, vehsa gacchatti? Mato gacchatti. Kappahiya kamma aparpariyavepakkan ti? #<[page 477]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vehsa gacchatti? mant. Kappaho iddhim ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kappaho iddhim ti? mant. Kappahena chandiddhipdo bhvito viriyiddhipdo bhvito cittiddhipdo bhvito {vmasiddhipdo} bhvito ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Kappaho kappa tiheyyti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "pyiko nerayiko kappaho saghabhedako Vaggarato adhammaho yogakkhemato dhasati Sagha samagga bhetvna kappa nirayamhi paccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi kappaho kappa tiheyyti. Kappahakath. XIII.2. 1. Kappaho kusala citta na pailabheyyti? mant. Kappaho dna dadeyyti? mant. Haci kappaho dna dadeyya, no vata re vattabbe "Kappaho kusala citta na pailabheyyti." Kappaho kusala citta na pailabheyyti? mant. Kappaho cvara dadeyya, piapta dadeyya, sensana dadeyya, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadeyya, #<[page 478]># %<478 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 3.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ khdanya dadeyya, bhojanya dadeyya, pnya dadeyya, cetiya vandeyya, cetiye mla ropeyya, gandha ropeyya, vilepana ropeyya, cetiya padakkhia kareyyti? mant. Haci kappaho cetiya padakkhia kareyya, no vata re vattabbe "Kappaho kusala citta na pailabheyyti." 2. Kappaho kusala citta pailabheyyti? mant. Tato vuhna kusala citta pailabheyyti? mant. Rpvacara --pe-- arpvacara --pe-- lokuttara kusala citta pailabheyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalapailbhakath. XIII.3. 1. Anantarpayutto puggalo sammattaniyma okkameyyti? mant. Micchattaniyma ca sammattaniyma ca ubho okkameyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anantarpayutto puggalo sammattaniyma okkameyyti? mant. Nanu ta kamma payutta kukkucca uppdita vippaisriya janitan ti? mant. Haci ta kamma payutta kukkucca uppdita vippaisriya janita, no vata re vattabbe "Anantarpayutto puggalo sammattaniyma okkameyyti." #<[page 479]># %% 2. Anantarpayutto puggalo abhabbo sammattaniyma okkamitun ti? mant. Mt jvit voropit, pit jvit voropito, Arah jvit voropito, duhena cittena Tathgatassa lohita uppdita, Sagho bhinno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anantarpayutto puggalo ta kamma paisaharitv kukkucca paivinodetv vippaisriya paivinodetv abhabbo sammattaniyma okkamitun ti? mant. Mt jvit voropit, pit jvit voropito, Arah jvit voropito, duhena cittena Tathgatassa lohita uppdita, Sagho bhinno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Anantarpayutto puggalo ta kamma paisaharitv kukkucca paivinodetv vippaisriya paivinodetv abhabbo sammattaniyma okkamitun ti? mant. Nanu ta kamma paisahata kukkucca paivinodita vippaisriya paivintan ti? mant. Haci ta kamma paisahata kukkucca paivinodita vippaisriya paivinta, no vata re vattabbe "Anantarpayutto puggalo ta kamma paisaharitv kukkucca paivinodetv vippaisriya paivinodetv abhabbo sammattaniyma okkamitun ti." 3. Anantarpayutto puggalo sammattaniyma okkameyyti? mant. Nanu ta kamma payutto atthti? mant. Haci ta kamma payutto atthi, no vata re vattabbe "Anantarpayutto puggalo sammattaniyma okkameyyti." Anantarpayuttakath. #<[page 480]># %<480 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 5.>% XIII.4. 1. Niyato niyma okkamatti? mant. Micchattaniyato sammattaniyma okkamati, sammattaniyato micchattaniyma okkamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Niyato niyma okkamatti? mant. Pubbe magga bhvetv pacch niyma okkamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pubbe sotpattimagga bhvetv pacch sotpattiniyma okkamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pubbe sakadgmimagga --pe-- angmimagga -- arahattamagga bhvetv pacch arahattaniyma okkamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pubbe satipahna --pe-- sammappadhna --pe-- iddhipda --pe-- indriya --pe-- bala --pe-- bojjhaga bhvetv pacch niyma okkamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Niyato niyma okkamatti?" mant. Bhabbo bodhisatto tya jtiy dhamma nbhisametun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi niyato niyma okkamatti. Niyatassa niymakath. XIII.5. 1. Nivuto nvaraa jahatti? mant. Ratto rga jahati, duho dosa jahati, mho moham jahati, kiliho kilese jahatti? #<[page 481]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgena rga jahati, dosena dosa jahati, mohena moha jahati, kilesehi kilese jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgo cittasampayutto maggo cittasampayutto ti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgo akusalo maggo kusalo ti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Nabha ca Bhikkhave pathav ca ida pahama suvidravidra -- pe -- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattaba Kusalkusal --pe-- sammukhbhva gacchantti." 2. Nivuto nvaraa jahatti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "So eva samhite citte parisuddhe pariyodte anagae vigatpakkilese mudubhte kammaniye hite nejapatte savna khayaya citta abhininnmetti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Nivuto nvaraa jahatti." 3. Na vattabba "Nivuto nvaraa jahatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Tassa eva jnato eva passato kmsav pi citta vimuccati #<[page 482]># %<482 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 6.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- avijjsav pi citta vimuccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi nivuto nvaraa jahatti. Nivutakath. XIII.6. 1. Sammukhbhto saojana jahatti? mant. Ratto rga jahati, duho dosa jahati, mho moha jahati, kiliho kilese jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgena rga jahati, dosena dosa jahati, mohena moha jahati, kilesehi kelese jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgo cittasampayutto maggo cittasampayutto ti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgo akusalo maggo kusalo ti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhb dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ksalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Nabha ca Bhikkhave pathav ca ida pahama suvidravidra -- pe -- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kusalkusal --pe-- sammukhbhva gacchantti." #<[page 483]># %% 2. Sammukhbhto saojana jahatti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "So eva samhite citte parisuddhe pariyodte anagae vigatpakkilese mudubhte kammaniye hite nejapatte savna khayaya citta abhininnmetti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Sammukhbhto saojana jahatti." 3. Na vattabba "Sammukhbhto saojana jahatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Tassa eva jnato eva passato kmsav pi citta vimuccati --pe-- avijjsav pi citta vimuccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi sammukhbhto saojana jahatti. Sammukhbhtakath. XIII.7. 1. Sampanno, assdeti jhnanikanti jhnramma ti? mant. Ta jhna tassa jhnassa rammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta jhna tassa jhnassa rammaan ti? mant. Tena phassena ta phassa phusati, tya vedanya ta vedana vedeti, tya saya ta saa jnti, tya cetanya ta cetana ceteti, tena cittena ta citta cinteti, tena vitakkena ta vitakka vitakketi, tena vicrena ta vicra vicreti, tya ptiy ta pti piyyati, tya satiy ta sati sarati, tya paya ta paa pajntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 484]># %<484 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 7.>% 2. Jhnanikanti cittasampayutt jhna cittasampayuttan ti? Amant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jhnanikanti akusal jhna kusalan ti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnapat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Nabha ca Bhikkhave pathav ca ida pahama suvidravidra -- pe -- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant Tena hi na vattabba "Kusalkusal --pe-- sammukhbhna gacchantti." 3. Na vattabba "Sampanno assdeti, jhnanikanti jhnramma ti"? Amant Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu vivicc' eva kmehi vivicc' akusalehi dhammehi pahama jhna upasampajja viharati, so ta assdeti ta nikmeti tena ca vitti pajjati, vitakkavicrna vpasam --pe-- dutiyajhna --pe-- tatiyajhna --pe-- catuttha jhna upasampajja viharati, so ta assdeti ta nikmeti tena ca vitti pajjatti"? Amant. Tena hi sampanno assdeti, jhnanikanti jhnramma ti. Sampanno assdetikath. #<[page 485]># %% XIII.8. 1. Atthi astargo ti? mant. Dukkhbhinandino satt atthi keci dukkha patthenti pihenti esanti gavesanti pariyesanti dukkha ajjhosya tihantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu sukhbhinnandino satt atthi keci sukha patthenti pihenti esanti gavesanti pariyesanti sukha ajjhosya tihantti? mant. Haci sukhbhinandino --pe-- tihanti, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi astargo ti." 2. Atthi astargo ti? mant. Dukkhya vedanya rgnusayo anuseti, sukhya vedanya paighnusayo anusetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu sukhya vedanya rgnusayo anuseti, dukkhya vedanya paighnusayo anusetti? mant. Haci sukhya vedanya rgnusayo anuseti, dukkhya vedanya paighnusayo anuseti, no vata re vattabbe Atthi astargo ti." 3. Na vattabba "Atthi astargo ti"? mant. nanu vutta Bhagavat "So eva anurodhavirodha sampanno ya kici vedana vediyati, sukha v dukkha v adukkhamasukha v, so ta vedana abhinandati abhivadati ajjhosya tihatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi astargo ti." Astargakath. #<[page 486]># %<486 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 9.>% XIII.9. 1. Dhammatah abykat ti? mant. Vipkbykat kiriybykat rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammatah abykat ti? mant. Rpatah abykat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammatah abykat ti? mant. Saddatah --pe-- gandhatah --pe-- rasatah --pe-- phohabbatah abykat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpatah akusal ti? mant. Dhammatah akusal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddatah --pe-- phohabbatah akusal ti? mant. Dhammatah akusal ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dhammatah abykat ti? mant. Nanu tah akusal vutt Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci tah akusal vutt Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe Dhammatah abykat ti." Dhammatah abykat ti? mant. Nanu lobho akusalo vutto Bhagavat, dhammatah lobho ti? mant. Haci lobho akusalo vutto Bhagavat, dhammatah lobho, no vata re vattabbe Dhammatah abykat ti." 3. Dhammatah lobho abykato ti? #<[page 487]># %% mant. Rpatah lobho abykato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammatah lobho abykato ti? mant. Saddatah --pe-- gandhatah --pe-- rasatah --pe-- phohabbatah lobho abykato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpatah lobho akusalo ti? mant. Dhammatah lobho akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddatah --pe-- phohabbatah lobho akusalo ti? mant. Dhammatah lobho akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Dhammatah abykat ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Yya tah ponobhavik nandirgasahagat tatratatrbhinandin, seyyathda kmatah bhavatah vibhavatah ti" Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba Dhammatah abykat ti." 5. Na vattabba Dhammatah abykat ti"? mant. Nanu s dhammatah ti? mant. Haci s dhammatah, tena vata re vattabbe Dhammatah abykat ti." Dhammatah abykat ti kath. #<[page 488]># %<488 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 10.>% XIII.10. 1. Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Rpatah na dukkhasmudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Saddatah --pe-- phohabbatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpatah dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Dhammatah dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddatah --pe-- phohabbatah dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Dhammatah dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Nanu tah dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci tah dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti." Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Nanu labho dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavat, dhammatah lobho ti? mant. Haci lobho dukkhasamudayo vutto Bhagavat, dhammatah lobho, no vata re vattabbe "Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti." 3. Dhammatah lobho na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Rpatah lobho na dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 489]># %% Dhammatah lobho na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Saddatah --pe-- phohabbatah lobho na dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpatah lobho dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Dhammatah lobho dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddatah --pe-- phohabbatah lobho dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Dhammatah lobho dukkhasamudayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Yya tah ponobhavik nandirgasahagat tatratatrbhinandin, seyyathda kmatah bhavatah vibhavatah ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti? 5. Na vattabba "Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti?" mant. Nanu s dhammatah ti? mant. Haci s dhammatah, tena vata re vattabbe "Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti." Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti kath. #<[page 490]># %<490 KATHVATTHU. [XIII. 10.>% Kappaho kappa tiheyya, Kappaho kusala citta na pailabheyya, Anantarpayutto puggalo sammattaniyma okkameyya, Niyato niyma okkameyya, Nivuto nvaraa jahati, Sammukhbhto saojana jahati, Jhnanikanti, Astargo Dhammatah abykat, Dhammatah na dukkhasamudayo ti. Terasamo Vaggo. #<[page 491]># %% XIV.1. 1. Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamlan ti? mant. Y akusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s v kusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamla, na vattabba "Y akusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va kusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti"? mant. Kusala anvaantassa uppajjati --pe-- apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusala vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci kusala vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamlan ti." 2. Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamlan ti? mant. Akusala ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Kusala ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu kusala yoniso manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Haci kusala yoniso manasikaroto uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Akasalamla paisandahati kusalamlan ti." 3. Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamlan ti? mant. Kmasaya anantar nekkhammasa uppajjati, bypdasaya anantar abypdasa uppajjati, vihissaya anantar avihissa uppajjati, bypdassa anantar mett uppajjati, #<[page 492]># %<492 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 1.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ vihisya anantar karu uppajjati, aratiy anantar mudit uppajjati, paighassa anantar upekkh uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti? mant. "Y kusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va akusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamla, na vattabba "Y kusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va akusalassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti"? mant. Akusala anvaantassa uppajjati --pe-- apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusala vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci akusala vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti." 5. Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti? mant. Kusala yoniso manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Akusala yoniso manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu akusala ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Haci akusala ayoniso manasikaroto uppajjati, no ca vata re vattabbe "Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti." 6. Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti? mant. Nekkhamasaya anantar kmasa uppajjati, #<[page 493]># %% abypdasaya anantar bypdasa uppajjati, avihissaya anantar vihissa uppajjati, mettya anantar bypdo uppajjati, karuya anantar vihis uppajjati, muditya anantar arati uppajjati, upekhya anantar paigha uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamla, kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti"? mant. Nanu yasmi eva vatthusmi rajjati {tasmi} eva vatthusmi virajjati, yasmi eva vatthusmi virajjati tasmi eva vatthusmi rajjatti? mant. Haci yasmi eva vatthusmi rajjati tasmi eva vatthusmi virajjati, yasmi eva vatthusmi virajjati tasmi eva vatthusmi rajjati, tena vata re vattabbe "Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamla, kusalamla paisandahati akusalamlan ti." Kusalkusalapaisandahanakath. XIV.2. 1. Sayatana apubba acarima mtukucchisami sahtti? mant. Sabbagapaccag ahnindriyo mtukucchismi okkamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uppattesiyena cittena cakkhyatana sahtti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena hatth sahanti, pd sahanti, ssa sahti, kao sahti, nsik sahti, mukha sahti, dant sahantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 494]># %<494 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 2.>% Uppattesiyena cittena sotyatana --pe-- ghnyatana --pe-- jivhyatana sahtti? mant. Uppattesiyena cittena hatth sahanti, pd sahanti, ssa {sahti,} kao sahti, nsik sahti, mukha sahti, dant sahantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Mtukucchigatassa pacch cakkhyatana uppajjatti? mant. Mtukucchismi cakkhupailbhya kamma karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mtukucchigatassa pacch sotyatana --pe-- ghnyatana --pe-- jivhyatana uppajjatti? mant. Mtukucchismi {jivhpaitbhya} kamma karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mtukucchigatassa pacch kes lom nakh dant ah uppajjantti? mant. Mtukucchismi ahipailbhya kamma karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Mtukucchigatassa pacch kes lom nakh dant ah uppajjantti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pahamma kalala hoti, kalal hoti abbuda, Abbud jyate pes, pes nibbattati ghano, Ghan paskh jyanti kes lom nakh pi ca, Ya c' assa bhujati mt anna pna ca bhojana Tena so tattha ypeti mtukucchigato naro ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi mtukucchigatassa pacch kes lom nakh dant ah uppajjantti. Sayatanuppattikath. #<[page 495]># %% XIV.3. 1. Cakkhuviassa anantar sotavia uppajjatti? mant. Y cakkhuviassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va sotaviassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuviassa anantar sotavia uppajjatti, na vattabba "Y cakkhuviassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va sotaviassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti"? mant. Sotavia anvaantassa uppajjati, apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu sotavia vaantassa uppajjati, paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci sotavia vaantassa uppajjati, paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhuviassa anantar sotavia uppajjatti." 2. Cakkhuviassa anantar sotavia uppajjatti? mant. Cakkhuvia rpanimitta manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Sotavia rpanimitta manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhuvia rprammaa eva na arammaan ti? mant. Sotavia rprammaa eva na arammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti? mant. #<[page 496]># %<496 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 3.>% Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati sotavian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati sotavian ti? mant. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati sotavian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati cakkhuvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhu ca paicca rpe ca uppajjati sotavian ti." Cakkhuviassa anantar sotavia uppajjatti? mant. Ta eva cakkhuvia ta sotavian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sotaviassa anantar ghnavia uppajjati, ghnaviassa anantar jivhvia uppajjati, jivhviassa anantar kyavia uppajjatti? mant. Ya jivhviassa uppdya vaan --pe-- piidhi, s va kyaviassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jivhviassa anantar kyavia uppajjatti, na vattabba "Y jivhviassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhi, s va kyaviassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhi"? mant. Kyavia anvaantassa uppajjati, apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu kyavia vaantassa uppajjati, paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci kyavia vaantassa uppajjati, paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe Jivhviassa anantar kyavia uppajjatti." #<[page 497]># %% 4. Jivhviassa anantar kyavia uppajjatti? mant. Jivhvia rasanimitta manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Kyavia rasanimitta manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jivhvia rasrammaa eva na arammaan ti? mant. Kyavia rasrammaa eva na arammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati jivhvian ti? mant. Jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati kyavian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati kyavian ti? mant. "Jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati kyavian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? Na' atthi. "Jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati kyavian ti," atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati jivhvian ti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Jivha ca paicca rase ca uppajjati kyavian ti." Jivhviassa anantar kyavia uppajjatti? mant. Ta eva jivhvia ta kyavian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Paca vi aamaassa samanantar uppajjantti"? mant. Nanu atthi koci naccati gyati vdeti, rpa ca passati, #<[page 498]># %<498 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 4.>% sadda ca suti, gandha ca ghyati, rasa ca syati, phohabba ca phusatti? mant. Haci atthi koci --pe-- phusati, tena vata re vattabbe "Paca vi aamaassa samanantar uppajjantti." Anantarapaccayakath. XIV.4. 1. Ariyrpa mahbhtna updyti? mant. Ariyarpa kusalan ti? mant. Mahbht kusal ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mahbht abykat ti? mant. Ariyarpa abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ariyarpa mahbhtna updyti? mant. Ariyarpa ansava asaojanya aganthanya anoghanya ayoganya anvaraya aparmaha anupdniya asakilesikan ti? mant. Mahbht ansav --pe-- asakilesik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Mahbht ssav --pe-- sakilesik ti? mant. Ariyarpa ssava --pe-- sakilesikan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Ariyarpa mahbhtna updyti"? mant. #<[page 499]># %% Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ya kici Bhikkhave rpa cattri mahbhtni catunna ca mahbhtna updya rpan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi ariyrpa mahbhtna updyti. Ariyarpakath. XIV.5. 1. Ao kmargnusayo aa kmargapariyuhnan ti? mant. Ao kmargo aa kmargapariyuhna ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sv' eva kmargo ta kmargapariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva kmargnusayo ta kmargapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ao paighnusayo aa paighapariyuhnan ti? mant. Aa paigha aa paighapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta eva paigha ta paighapariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva paighnusayo ta paighapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Ao mnnusayo aa mnapariyuhnan ti? mant. Ao mno aa mnapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sv' eva mno ta mnapariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva mnnusayo ta mnapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 500]># %<500 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 5.>% 4. Ao dihnusayo aa dihipariyuhnan ti? mant. A dihi aa dihipariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S va dihi ta dihipariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva dihnusayo ta dihipariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Ao vicikicchnusayo aa vicikicchpariyuhnan ti? mant. A vicikicch aa vicikicchpariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S va vicikicch ta vicikicchpariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva vicikicchnusayo ta vicikicchpariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Ao bhavargnusayo aa bhavargapariyuhnan ti? mant. Ao bhavargo aa bhavargapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sv' eva bhavargo ta bhavargapariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva bhavargnusayo ta bhavargapariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Ao avijjnusayo aa avijjpariyuhnan ti? mant. Aa avijj aa avijjpariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- S va avijj ta avijjpariyuhnan ti? mant. Sv' eva avijjnusayo ta avijjpariyuhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Na vattabba "Ao anusayo aa pariyuhnan ti? #<[page 501]># %% mant. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne "snusayo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. "Pariyuhito ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi ao anusayo aa pariyuhnan ti. Puthujjano kusalbykate citte vattamne sargo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. Pariyuhito ti" vattabbo ti. Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi ao rgo aa pariyuhnan ti. Ao anusayo ti kath. XIV.6. 1. Pariyuhna cittavippayuttan ti? mant. Rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pariyuhna cittavippayuttan ti? mant. N' atthi sarga citta sadosa citta samoha citta --pe-- akusala citta sakiliha cittan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atthi sarga citta sadosa citta samoha citta --pe-- akusala citta sakiliha cittan ti? mant. Haci atthi sarga citta sadosa citta samoha citta --pe-- akusala citta sakiliha citta, no vata re vattabbe "Pariyuhna cittavippayuttan ti." Pariyuhna cittavippayuttan ti kath. #<[page 502]># %<502 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 7.>% XIV.7. 1. Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti rpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Sampattesiyo uppattesiyo dihadhammasukhavihro sampattesiyena cittena uppatesiyena cittena dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato sahajto sasaho sampayutto ekuppdo ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sampattesiyo na uppattesiyo na dihadhammasukhavihro na sampattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato sahajto sasaho sampayutto ekuppdo ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekrammao ti? mant. Haci na sampattesiyo --pe-- ekrammao, no vata re vattabbe Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti rpadhtupariypanno ti." 2. Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti rpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Saddargo saddadhtu anuseti saddadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti rpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Gandhargo --pe-- rasargo --pe-- phohabbargo phohabbadhtu anuseti phohabbadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddargo saddadhtu anuseti na vattabba saddadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti na vattabba rpadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 503]># %% Phohabbargo phohabbadhtu anuseti na vattabba phohabbadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti na vattabba rpadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Arpargo arpadhtu anuseti arpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Sampattesiyo uppattesiyo dihadhammasukhavihro sampattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato sahajto sasaho sampayutto ekuppdo ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sampattesiyo na uppattesiyo na dihadhammasukhavihro na sampattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato sahajto sasaho sampayutto ekuppdo ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekrammao ti? mant. Haci na sampattesiyo --pe-- ekrammao, no vata re vattabbe "Arpargo arpadhtu anuseti arpadhtupariypanno ti." 4. Arpargo arpadhtu anuseti arpadhtupariypanno ti" mant. Saddargo saddadhtu anuseti saddadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpargo arpadhtu anuseti arpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Gandhargo --pe-- rasargo --pe-- phohabbargo phohabbadhtu anuseti phohabbadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Saddargo saddadhtu anuseti na vattabba saddadhtupariypanno ti? #<[page 504]># %<504 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 8.>% mant. Arpargo arpadhtu anuseti na vattabba arpadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Phohabbargo phohabbadhtu anuseti na vattabba phohabbadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Arpargo arpadhtu anuseti na vattabba arpadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti rpadhtupariypanno, arpargo arpadhtu anuseti arpadhtupariypanno ti"? mant. Nanu kmargo kmadhtu anuseti kmadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Haci kmargo kmadhtu anuseti kmadhtupariypanno, tena vata re vattabbe Rpargo rpadhtu anuseti rpadhtupariypanno, arpargo arpadhtu anuseti arpadhtupariypanno ti." Pariypannakath. XIV.8. 1. Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. Vipkbykata kiriybykata rpa nibbna cakkhyatana --pe-- phohabbyatanan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. Dihigatasampayutto phasso abykato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. #<[page 505]># %% Dihigatasampayutt vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- cetan --pe-- citta abykatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dihigatasampayutto phasso akusalo ti? mant. Dihigata akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dihigatasampayutt vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- cetan --pe-- citta akusalan ti? mant. Dihigata akusalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. Aphala avipkan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu saphala savipkan ti? mant. Haci saphala savipka, no vata re vattabbe Dihigata abykatan ti." Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. Nanu micchdihiparamni vajjni vuttni Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci micchdihiparamni vajjni vuttni Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Dihigata abykatan ti." 3. Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Micchdihi kho Vaccha akusal, sammdihi kusal ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Dihigata abykatan ti." Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. #<[page 506]># %<506 KATHVATTHU. [XIV. 8.>% Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Micchdihissa kho aha Pua dvinna gatna aatara gati vadmi, niraya v tiracchnayoni v ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba Dihigata abykatan ti." 4. Na vattabba Dihigata abykatan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sassato loko ti kho Vaccha abykata eta, asassato loko ti kho Vaccha abykata eta, antav loko ti kho Vaccha abykata eta, anantav loko ti kho Vaccha --pe-- ta jva ta sarran ti kho Vaccha --pe-- aa jva aa sarran ti kho Vaccha --pe-- hoti Tathgato para mara ti kho Vaccha --pe-- na hoti Tathgato para mara ti kho Vaccha --pe-- hoti ca na ca hoti Tathgato para mara ti kho Vaccha --pe-- n' eva hoti na na hoti Tathgato para mara ti kho Vaccha abykata etan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi dihigata abykatan ti. 5. Dihigata abykatan ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Micchdihikassa Bhikkhave purisapuggalassa ya c' eva kyakamma yathdihisamatta samdia ya ca vackamma --pe-- ya ca manokamma y ca cetan y ca patthan yo ca paidhi ye ca sakhr, sabbe te dhamm anihya akantya amanpya ahitya dukkhya savattantti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba Dihigata abykatan ti." Abykatakath. #<[page 507]># %% XIV.9. 1. Dihigata apariypannan ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna, sotpattimaggo sotpattiphala, sakadgmimaggo sakadgmiphala, angmimaggo angmiphala, arahattamaggo arahattaphala, satipahna sammappadhna iddhipdo indriya bala bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Dihigata apariypannan ti"? mant. Puthujjano "kmesu vtargo ti" vattabbo ti? mant. "Vigatadihiyo ti" vattabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi dihigata apariypannan ti. Apariypannakath. Vaggo cuddasamo. Akusalamla paisandahati kusalamla, Kusalamla paisandahati akusalamla, Sayatna, Cha viaky, Ariyarpa mahbhtana updya, Sv' eva anusayo ta pariyuhna, Cittavippayutta, Yath dhtu ta eva anuseti, Dihigata abykata, Dihigata {apariypannan} ti. #<[page 508]># %<508 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 1.>% XV.1. 1. Paccayat vavatthit ti? mant. Nanu vmas hetu, so ca adhipatti? mant. Haci vmas hetu, so ca adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe "Hetupaccayena paccayo, adhipatipaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu chanddhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipatti? mant. Haci chanddhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, sahajtapaccayena paccayo ti." 2. Nanu viriydhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipatti? mant. Haci viriydhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, tena vata re vatabbe Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, sahajtapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu viriydhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca indriyan ti? mant. Haci viriydhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca indriya, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, indriyapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu viriydhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca maggagan ti? mant. Haci viriydhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca maggaga, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, maggapaccayena paccayo ti." 3. Nanu cittdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipatti? #<[page 509]># %% mant. Haci cittdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, sahajtapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu cittdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, so ca hro ti? mant. Haci cittdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, so ca hro, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, hrapaccayena paccayo ti." 4. Nanu cittdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca indriyan ti? mant. Haci cittdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca indriya, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, indriyapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu vimasdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipatti? mant. Haci vimasdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, sahajtapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu vimasdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca maggagan ti? mant. Haci vimasdhipati sahajtna dhammna adhipati, ta ca maggaga, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, maggapaccayena paccayo ti." Nanu ariya dhamma garu katv uppajjati paccavekkha, ta c' rammaan ti? mant. Haci ariya dhamma garu katv uppajjati paccavekkha, ta c' rammaa, tena vata re vattabbe "Adhipatipaccayena paccayo, rammaapaccayena paccayo ti." 5. Nanu purim purim kusal dhamm pacchimna pacchimna kusalna dhammna anantarpaccayena paccayo, s ca sevan ti? mant. #<[page 510]># %<510 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 2.>% Haci purim purim kusal dhamm pacchimna pacchimna kusalna dhammna anantarapaccayena paccayo, s ca sevan, tena vata re vattabbe "Anantarapaccayena paccayo, sevanapaccayena paccayo ti." 6. Nanu purim purim akusal dhamm pacchimna pacchimna akusalna dhammna anantarapaccayena paccayo, s ca sevan ti? mant. Haci purim purim akusal dhamm pacchimna pacchimna akusalna dhammna anantarpaccayena paccayo, s ca sevan, tena vata re vattabbe "Anantarapaccayo, sevanapaccayena paccayo ti." 7. Nanu purim purim kiriybykat dhamm pacchimna pacchimna kiriybykatna dhammna anantarapaccayena paccayo, s ca sevan ti? Haci purim purim kiriybykat dhamm pacchimna pacchimna kiriybykatna dhammna anantarapaccayena paccayo, s ca sevan, tena vata re vattabbe Anantarapaccayena paccayo, sevanapaccayena paccayo ti." 8. Na vattabba "Paccayat vavatthit ti"? mant. Hetupaccayena paccayo hoti, rammaapaccayena paccayo hoti, anantarapaccayena paccayo hoti, samanantarapaccayena paccayo hoti ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi paccayat vavatthit ti, Paccayakath. XV.2. 1. Avijjpaccay pi sakhr, na vattabba "Sakhrapaccay pi avijj ti"? mant. nanu avijj sakhrena sahajt ti? #<[page 511]># %% mant. Haci avijj sakhrena sahajt, tena vata re vattabbe Avijjpaccay pi sakhr sakhrapaccay pi avijj ti." 2. Tahpaccay pi updna, na vattabba updnapaccay pi tah ti"? mant. Nanu tah updnena sahajt ti? mant. Haci tah updnena sahajt, {tena} vata re vattabbe Tahpaccay pi updna updnapaccay pi tah ti." 3. Jarmaraapaccay Bhikkhave jti, jtipaccay bhavo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. Tena hi avijjpaccay pi sakhr, na vattabba sakhrapaccay pi avijj," tahpaccay pi updna, na vattabba updnapaccay pi tah ti." 4. Viapaccay Bhikkhave nmarpa, nmarpapaccay pi vian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi avijjpaccay pi sakhr sakhrapaccay pi avij, tahpaccay pi updna updnapaccay pi tah ti. Aamaapaccayakath. XV.3. 1. Addh parinipphanno ti? mant. Rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atto addh parinipphanno ti? #<[page 512]># %<512 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 3.>% Rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Angato addh parinipphanno ti? mant. Rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- mant. Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanno addh parinipphanno ti? mant. Rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atta rpa vedan sa sakhr via, atto addh ti? mant. Att pac' addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata rpa vedan sa sakhr via, angato addh ti? mant. Angat pac' addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- {Paccuppanna} rpa vedan sa sakhr via, paccuppanno addh ti? mant. Paccuppann pac' addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Att pacakkhandh atto addh, angat pacakkhandh angato addh, paccuppann pacakkhandh paccuppanno addh ti? mant. #<[page 513]># %% Pannaras' addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attni dvdas' yatanni atto addh, angatni dvdas' yatanni angato addh, paccuppannni dvdas' yatanni paccuppanno addh ti? mant. Chattis' addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Att ahrasa dhtuyo atto addh, angat ahrasa dhtuyo angato addh, paccuppann ahrasa dhtuyo paccuppanno addh ti? mant. Catupas' addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Attni bvsat' indriyni atto addh, angatni bvsat' indriyni angato addh, paccuppannni bvsat' indriyni paccuppanno addh ti? mant. Chasah addh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Addh parinipphanno ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "T' imni Bhikkhave kathvatthni. Katamni ti? Atta v Bhikkhave addhna rabbha katha katheyya `eva ahosi atta addhnan ti,' angata v Bhikkhave addhna rabbha katha katheyya `eva bhavissati angata addhnan ti,' etarahi v Bhikkhave paccuppanna addhna rabbha katha katheyya `eva hoti etarahi paccuppannan ti.' Imni kho Bhikkhave ti kathvatthnti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi addh parinipphanno ti. Addhkath. #<[page 514]># %<514 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 5.>% XV.4. 1. Khao parinipphanno, layo parinipphanno, muhutta parinipphannan ti? mant. Rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Muhutta parinipphannan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "T' imni Bhikkhave kathvatthni. Katamni ti? Atta v Bhikkhave addhna rabbha katha katheyya `eva ahosi atta addhnan ti,' angata v Bhikkhave addhna rabbha katha katheyya `eva bhavissati angata addhnan ti,' etarahi v Bhikkhave paccuppanna addhna rabbha katha katheyya `eva hoti etarahi paccuppanna ti.' Imni kho Bhikkhave {ti} kathvatthnti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi muhutta parinipphannan ti. Khaalayamuhuttakath. XV.5. 1. Cattro sav ansav ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna sotpattimaggo sotpattiphala --pe-- bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Cattro sav ansav ti"? mant. Atth' a' eva sav yehi savehi te sav ssav hontti? #<[page 515]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi cattro sav ansav ti. savakath. XV.6. 1. Lokuttarna dhammna jarmaraa lokuttaran ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna --pe-- bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattimaggassa jarmaraa sotpattimaggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattimaggassa jarmaraa sotpattimaggo ti? mant. Sotpattiphalassa jarmaraa sotpattiphalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmimaggassa --pe-- sakadgmiphalassa --pe-- angmimaggassa --pe-- angmiphalassa --pe-- arahattamaggassa jarmaraa arahattamaggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggassa jarmaraa arahattamaggo ti? mant. Arahattaphalassa jarmaraa arahattaphalan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Satipahnna sammappadhnna iddhipdna indriyna balna bojjhagna jarmaraa bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Lokuttarna dhammna jarmaraa lokuttaran ti"? mant. Lokiyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi lokuttaran ti. Jarmaraakath. #<[page 516]># %<516 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 8.>% XV.7. 1. Savedayitanirodhasampatti lokuttar ti? mant. Maggo phala nibbna --pe-- bojjhago ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Savedayitanirodhasampatti lokuttar ti"? mant. Lokiy ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi lokuttar ti. Savedayitakath. XV.8. 1. Savedayitanirodhasampatti lokiy ti? mant. Rpan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kmvacar ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpvacar ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpvacar ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Savedayitanirodhasampatti lokiy ti"? mant. Lokuttar ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi lokiy ti. Dutiyasavedayitakath. #<[page 517]># %% XV.9. 1. Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyyti? mant. Atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa maraantiyo phasso, maraantiy vedan, maraantiy sa, maraantiy cetan, maraantiya cittan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa marantiyo phasso --pe-- maraantiya cittan ti? mant. Haci n' atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa maraantiya citta, no vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyyti." 2. Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyyti? mant. Atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa phasso vedan sa cetan cittan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa phasso vedan sa cetan cittan ti? mant. Aphassakassa klakiriy, avedanakassa klakiriy -- pe -- acittakassa klakiriy ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu saphassakassa klakiriy --pe-- sacittakassa klakiriy ti? mant. Haci saphassakassa klakiriy --pe-- sacittakassa klakiriy, no vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyyti." 3. Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyyti? mant. Savedayitanirodhasampannassa kye visa kameyya, sattha kameyya, aggi kameyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 518]># %<518 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 10.>% Savedayitanirodhasampannassa kye visa na kameyya, sattha na kameyya, aggi na kameyyti? mant. Haci aggi na kameyya, no vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyyti." 4. Savedayitanirodhasampannassa kye visa kameyya, sattha kameyya, aggi kameyyti? mant. Na nirodhasampanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Savedayitanirodhasampanno na kla kareyyti? mant. Atthi so niymo yena niymena niyato savedayitanirodhasampanno na kla kareyyti? N' atthi Haci n' atthi so niymo yena niymena niyato savedayitanirodhasampanno na kla kareyya, no vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampanno na kla kareyyti." 5. Cakkhuviasamag na kla kareyyti? mant. Atthi so niymo yena niymena niyato cakkhuviasamag na kla kareyyti? N' atthi Haci n' atthi so niymo yena niymena niyato cakkhuviasamag na kla kareyya, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhuviasamag na kla kareyyti." Tatiyasavedayitakath. XV.10. 1. Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti? mant. Atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa alobho kusalamla, #<[page 519]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ adoso kusalamla, amoho kusalamla, saddh viriya sati samdhi pa ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa alobho kusalamla --pe-- pa ti? mant. Haci n' atthi pa, no vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti." 2. Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti? mant. Atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa phasso vedan sa cetan cittan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi savedayitanirodhasampannassa phasso vedan sa cetan cittan ti? mant. Aphassakassa maggabhvan, avedanakassa maggabhvan --pe-- acittakassa maggabhvan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu saphassakassa maggabhvan --pe-- sacittakassa maggabhvan ti? mant. Haci saphassakassa maggabhvan --pe-- sacittakassa maggabhvan, no vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti." 3. Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti? mant. ye keci savedayitanirodha sampajjanti, sabbe te asaasattpik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti"? mant. Nanu idhpi asa tatrpi asa ti? mant. Haci idhpi asa tatrpi asa, tena vata re vattabbe "Savedayitanirodhasampatti asaasattpik ti." Asaasattpikakath. #<[page 520]># %<520 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 11.>% XV.11. 1. Aa kamma ao kammpacayo ti? mant. Ao phasso ao phasspacayo, a vedan ao vedanpacayo, a sa ao sapacayo, a cetan ao cetanpacayo, aa citta ao cittpacayo, a saddh ao saddhpacayo, aa viriya ao viriypacayo, a sati ao satpacayo, ao samdhi ao samdhpacayo, a pa ao papacayo, ao rgo ao rgpacayo --pe-- aa anottappa ao anottapppacayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Aa kamma ao kammpacayo ti? mant. Kammpacayo kammena sahajto ti? Na h' {eva} vattabbe --pe-- Kammpacayo kammena sahajto ti? mant. Kusalena kammena sahajto kammpacayo kusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalena kammena sahajto kammpacayo kusalo ti? mant. Sukhya vedanya sampayuttena kammena sahajto kammpacayo sukhya vedanya sampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhya --pe-- adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayuttena kammena sahajto kammpacayo adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Kammpacayo kammena sahajto ti? mant. Akusalena kammena sahajto kammpacayo akusalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Akusalena kammena sahajto kammpacayo akusalo ti? mant. #<[page 521]># %% Sukhya vedanya sampayuttena kammena sahajto kammpacayo sukhya vedanya sampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhya --pe-- adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayuttena kammena sahajto kammpacayo adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Kamma cittena sahajta, kamma srammaan ti? mant. Kammpacayo cittena sahajto, kammpacayo srammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammpacayo cittena sahajto, kammpacayo anrammao ti? mant. Kamma cittena sahajta, kamma anrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kamma cittena sahajta, citta bhijjamna, kamma bhijjatti? mant. Kammpacayo cittena sahajto, citta bhijjamna kammpacayo bhijjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammpacayo cittena sahajto, citta bhijjamna, kammpacayo na bhijjatti? mant. Kamma cittena sahajta, citta bhijjamna, kamma na bhijjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Kammamhi kammpacayo ti? mant. Ta eva kamma, so kammpacayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammamhi kammpacayo, kammpacayato vipko nibbattatti? mant. #<[page 522]># %<522 KATHVATTHU. [XV. 11.>% Ta eva kamma, so kammpacayo, so kammavipko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammamhi kammpacayo, kammpacayato vipko nibbattati, vipko srammao ti? mant. Kammpacayo srammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammpacayo anrammao ti? mant. Vipko anrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Aa kamma ao kammpacayo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Pua ekacco sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi kyasakhra abhisakharoti, sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi vacsakhra --pe-- manosakhra abhisakharoti, so sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi kyasakhra abhisakharitv, sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi vacsakhra --pe-- manosakhra abhisakharitv sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi loka upapajjati, tam ena sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi loka upapanna samna sabypajjh pi abypajjh pi phass phusanti; so sabypajjhehi pi abypajjhehi pi phassehi phuho samno sabypajjha pi abypajjha pi vedana vedeti vokiasukhadukkha, seyyathpi manuss, ekacce ca dev, ekacce ca viniptik; iti kho Pua bhtbhtassa upapatti hoti, ya karoti, tena upapajjati; upapanna eta phass phusanti. Eva pha Pua kammadyd satt ti vadmti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Aa kamma ao kammpacayo ti." Kammpacayakath. #<[page 523]># %% Vaggo paarasamo. Paccayat vavatthit, Paiccasamuppdo, Addh ca khao layo muhutta, Cattro sav ansav, {Lokuttarna} dhammna jarmaraa lokuttara, Savedayitanirodhasampatti lokuttar, Savedayitanirodhasampatti lokiy, Savedayitanirodhasampanno kla kareyya, Sv' eva maggo asaasattpapattiy, Aa kamma ao kammpacayo ti. Anusay, Savaro, Kappo, Mla, Vavatthit. Tatiyo Pasako. #<[page 524]># %<524 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 1.>% XVI.1. 1. Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. Paro parassa citta m rajji m dussi m muyhi m kilissti niggahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. Paro parassa uppanno phasso m nirujjhti niggahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa uppann vedan --pe-- uppann sa -- pe -- uppann cetan --pe-- uppanna citta --pe-- uppann saddh --pe-- uppanna viriya --pe-- uppann sati -- pe--uppanno samdhi --pe-- uppann pa m nirujjhti niggahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. Paro parassa atthya rga pajahati, dosa pajahati --pe-- anottappa pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. Paro parassa atthya magga bhveti, satipahna bhveti --pe-- bojjhaga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. Paro parassa atthya dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. #<[page 525]># %% Ao aassa krako, para kata sukha dukkha ao karoti ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Paro parassa citta niggahtti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Attan va kata ppa, attan sakilissati, Attan akata ppa, attan va visujjhati, Suddhi asuddhi paccatta ao aa visodhaye ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Paro parassa citta niggahtti." 4. Na vattabba "Paro parassa citta niggahtti"? mant. Nanu atthi balappatt atthi vasbht ti? mant. Haci atthi balappatt atthi vasbht, tena vata re vattabbe "Paro parassa citta niggahtti." Niggahakath. XVI.2. 1. Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Paro parassa citta m rajji m dussi m muyhi m kilissti paggahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Paro parassa alobha kusalamla janeti, adosa kusalamla janeti, #<[page 526]># %<526 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 2.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ amoha kusalamla janeti, saddha janeti, viriya janeti, sati janeti, samdhi janeti, paa janetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Paro parassa uppanno phasso m nirujjhti paggahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa uppann vedan --pe-- uppann sa -- pe -- uppann cetan --pe-- uppanna citta --pe-- uppann saddh --pe-- uppanna viriya --pe-- uppann sati --pe-- uppanno samdhi --pe-- uppann pa m nirujjhti paggahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Paro parassa atthya rga pajahati, dosa pajahati --pe-- anottappa pajahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Paro parassa atthya magga bhveti, satipahna bhveti --pe-- bojjhaga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Paro parassa atthya dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Ao aassa krako, para kata sukha dukkha ao karoti ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Paro parassa citta paggahtti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- #<[page 527]># %% "Attan va kata ppa, attan sakilissati, Attan akata ppa, attan va visujjhati, Suddhi asuddhi paccatta näo aa visodhaye ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Paro parassa citta paggahtti." 4. Na vattabba "Paro parassa citta paggahtti"? mant. Nanu atthi balappatt atthi vasbht ti? mant Haci atthi balappatt atthi vasbht, tena vata re vattabbe "Paro parassa citta paggahtti." Paggahakath. XVI.3. 1. Paro parassa sukha anuppadetti? mant. Paro parassa dukkha anuppadetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa dukkha na anuppadetti? mant. Paro parassa sukha na anuppadetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Paro parassa sukha anuppadetti? mant. Paro parassa attano sukha anuppadeti, aesa sukha anuppadeti, tassa sukha anuppadetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paro parassa n' ev' attano na aesa na tassa sukha anuppadetti? mant. Haci paro parassa n' ev' attano na aesa na tassa sukha anuppadeti, #<[page 528]># %<528 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 4.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ no vata re vattabbe "Paro parassa sukha anuppadetti." Paro parassa sukha anuppadetti? mant. Ao aassa krako, para kata sukha dukkha ao karoti ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Paro parassa sukha anuppadetti"? mant. Nanu yasm Udy etad avoca -- "Bahna vata no Bhagav dukkhadhammna apahatt, bahna vata no Bhagav sukhadhammna upahatt, bahna vata no Bhagav akusalna dhammna apahatt, bahna vata no Bhagav kusalna dhammna upahatt ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi paro parassa sukha anuppadetti. Sukhnuppadnakath. XVI.4. 1. Adhigayha manasikarotti? mant. Tena cittena ta citta pajntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena cittena ta citta pajntti? mant. Tena cittena ta citta cittan ti pajntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena cittena ta citta citan ti pajntti? mant. Ta citta tassa cittassa rammaan ti? #<[page 529]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ta citta tassa cittassa rammaan ti? mant. Tena phassena ta phassa phusati, tya vedanya, tya saya, tya cetanya, tena cittena, tena vitakkena, tena vicrena, tya ptiy, tya satiy, tya paya ta paa pajntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atta attan ti manasikaronto angata angatan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta attan ti manasikaronto angata angatan ti manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta attan ti manasikaronto paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta attan ti manasikaronto paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta attan ti manasikaronto angata angatan ti manasikaroti, paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atta attan ti manasikaronto angata angatan ti manasikaroti, paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? mant. Tia phassna --pe-- tia cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Angata angatan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikarotti? 35 #<[page 530]># %<530 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 4.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata angatan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata angatan ti manasikaronto paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata angatan ti manasikaronto paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata angatan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikaroti, paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angata angatan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikaroti, paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikarotti? mant. Tia phassna --pe-- tia cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikaronto angata angatan ti manasikarotti? #<[page 531]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikaronto angata angatan ti manasikarotti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikaroti, angata angatan ti manasikarotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paccuppanna paccuppannan ti manasikaronto atta attan ti manasikaroti, angata angatan ti manasikarotti? mant. Tia phassna --pe-- tia cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Adhigayha manasikarotti"? mant. Nanu vutta bhagavat -- "`Sabbe sakhr anicc ti" yad paya passati, Atha nibbindati dukkhe esamaggo visuddhiy. `Sabbe sakhr dukkh ti' yad paya passati, Atha nibbindati dukkhe esamaggo visuddhiy. `Sabbe dhamm anatt ti' yad paya passati, Atha nibbindati dukkhe esamaggo visuddhiy ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi adhigayha manasikarotti. Adhigayhamanasikrakath. #<[page 532]># %<532 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 5.>% XVI.5. 1. Rpa hetti? mant. Alobho hetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adoso hetu --pe-- amoho hetu, lobho hetu, doso hetu, moho hetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa hetti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa hetti." 2. Alobho hetu srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa hetu srammaa, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adoso hetu, amoho hetu, lobho hetu doso hetu moho hetu srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa hetu srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Rpa hetu srammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? mant. Alobho hetu anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa hetu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- panidhti? #<[page 533]># %% mant. Adoso hetu --pe-- moho hetu anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Rpa hetti"? mant. Nanu mahbht upd rpna updya hetti? mant Haci mahbht upd rpna updya hetu, tena vata re vattabbe "Rpa hetti." Rpa hetti kath. XVI.6. 1. Rpa sahetukan ti? mant. Alobhahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adosahetun ti --pe-- amohahetun ti, lobhahetun ti, dosalhetun ti, mohahetun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa sahetukan ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe Rpa sahetukan ti." 2. Alobho sahetuko srammao, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? mant. Rpa sahetuka srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 534]># %<534 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 7.>% Adoso sahetuko --pe-- amoho saddh viriya sati samdhi pa lobho doso moho mno dihi vicikicch thna uddhacca ahirika anottappa sahetuka srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa sahetuka srammaa, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Rpa sahetuka anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Alobho sahetuko anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa sahetuka anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Adoso sahetuko --pe-- anottappa sahetuka anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Rpa sahetukan ti"? mant. Nanu rpa sappaccayan ti? mant. Haci rpa sappaccaya, tena vata re vattabbe "Rpa sahetukan ti." Rpa sahetukan ti kath. XVI.7. 1. Rpa kusalan ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. #<[page 535]># %% Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa kusalan ti." 2. Alobho kusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? mant. Rpa kusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adoso kusalo, amoho kusalo, saddh viriya sati samdhi --pe-- pa kusal sramma, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa kusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Rpa kusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Alobho kusalo anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa kusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Adoso kusalo, pa kusal anramma, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Rpa akusalan ti? mant. Srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa akusalan ti." 5. Lobho akusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? #<[page 536]># %<536 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 8.>% mant. Rpa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Doso moho mno --pe-- anottappa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa akusala srammaa, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Rpa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Lobho akusalo anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Doso, moho, anottappa akusala anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Rpa kusala pi akusala pti"? mant. Nanu kyakamma vackamma kusala pi akusala pti? mant. Haci kyakamma vackamma kusala pi akusala pi, tena vata re vattabbe "Rpa kusala pi akusala pti." Rpa kusalkusalan ti kath. XVI.8. 1. Rpa vipko ti? mant. Rpa sukhavedanya dukkhavedanya adukkhamasukhavedanya, #<[page 537]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ sukhya vedanya sampayutta, dukkhya vedanya sampayutta, adukkhamasukhya vedanya sampayutta, phassena sampayutta --pe-- cittena sampayutta srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sukhavedanya --pe-- na dukkhavedanya --pe-- {anrammaa,} n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci na sukhavedanya --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa vipko ti." 2. Phasso vipko phasso sukhavedanyo --pe-- srammao, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Rpa vipko rpa sukhavedanya --pe-- srammaa, atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpa vipko rpa na sukhavedanya --pe-- anrammaa, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Phasso vipko phasso na sukhavedanyo --pe-- anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Rpa vipko ti"? mant. Nanu kammassa katatt uppann cittacetasik dhamm vipko ti? mant. Haci kammassa katatt uppann cittacetasik dhamm vipko, tena vata re vattabbe "Kammassa katatt uppanna rpa vipko ti." Rpa vipko ti kath. #<[page 538]># %<538 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 9.>% XVI.9. 1. Atthi rpa rpvacaran ti? mant. Sampattesiya uppattesiya dihadhammasukhavihra sampattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagata sahajta sasaham {sampayutta} ekuppda ekanirodha ekavatthuka ekrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sampattesiya na uppattesiya na dihadhammasukhavihra na sampattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagata --pe-- ekrammaan ti? mant. Haci na sampattesiya --pe-- ekrammaa, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi rpa. rpvacaran ti." 2. Atthi rpa arpvacaran ti? mant. Sampattesiya uppattesiya dihadhammasukhavihra sampattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagata sahajta sasaham sampayutta ekuppda ekanirodha ekavatthuka ekrammaan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sampattesiya na uppattesiya na dihadhammasukhavihra na sampattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagata --pe-- ekrammaan ti? mant. Haci na sampattesiya --pe-- ekrammaa, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi rpa arpvacaran ti." 3. Na vattabba "Atthi rpa rpvacara, atthi rpa arpvacaran ti"? mant. Nanu kmvacarakammassa katatt rpa kmvacaran ti? mant. Haci kmvacarakammassa katatt rpa kmvacara, #<[page 539]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tena vata re vattabbe "Rpvacarakammassa katatt rpa rpvacara, arpvacarakammassa katatt rpa arpvacaran ti." Rpa rpvacarrpvacaran ti kath. XVI.10. 1. Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Sampattesiyo uppattesiyo dihadhammasukhavihro sampattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato sahajto sasaho sampayutto ekuppdo ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sampattesiyo na uppattesiyo na dihadhammasukhavihro na sampattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato --pe-- ekrammao ti? mant. Haci na sampattesiyo --pe-- ekrammao, no vata re vattabbe "Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno ti." 2. Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Saddargo saddadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Gandhargo --pe-- rasargo --pe-- phohabbargo phohabbadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Saddargo na vattabba "saddadhtupariypanno ti"? mant. Rpargo na vattabba "rpadhtupariypanno ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Gandhargo --pe-- rasargo --pe-- phohabbargo na vattabba "phohabbadhtupariypanno ti"? #<[page 540]># %<540 KATHVATTHU. [XVI. 10.>% mant. Rpargo na vattabba "rpadhtupariypanno ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Sampattesiyo uppattesiyo dihadhammasukhavihro sampattesiyena cittena uppattesiyena cittena dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato sahajto sasaho sampayutto ekuppdo ekanirodho ekavatthuko ekrammao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu na sampattesiyo na uppattesiyo na dihadhammasukhavihro na sampattesiyena cittena na uppattesiyena cittena na dihadhammasukhavihrena cittena sahagato --pe-- ekrammao ti? mant. Haci na sampattesiyo --pe-- ekrammao, no vata re vattabbe "Arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti." 5. Arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Saddargo saddadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Gandhargo --pe-- rasargo --pe-- phohabbargo phohabbadhtupariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Saddargo na vattabba "Saddadhtupariypanno ti"? mant. Arpargo na vattabba "arpadhtupariypanno ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Gandhargo --pe-- rasargo -- Pe -- phohabbargo na vattabba "phohabbadhtupariypanno ti"? mant. Arpargo na vattabba "arpadhtupariypanno ti"? #<[page 541]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno, arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti"? mant. Nanu kmargo kmadhtupariypanno ti? mant. Haci kmargo kmadhtupariypanno, tena vata re vattabbe "Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno, arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti." Rpargo rpadhtupariypanno, arpargo arpadhtupariypanno ti kath. Vaggo soasamo. Cittaniggaho, Cittapaggaho, Sukhnuppadna, Adhigayha manasikro, Rpa hetu, Rpa sahetuka, Rpa kusala pi akusala pi, Rpa vipko, Atthi rpa rpvacara, Atthi rpa arpvacara, Sabbe kiles kmadhtupariypann ti. #<[page 542]># %<542 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 1.>% XVII.. 1. Atthi Arahato pupacayo ti? mant. Atthi Arahato apupacayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Arahato apupacayo ti? mant. N' atthi Arahato pupacayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi Arahato pupacayo ti? mant. Arah pubhisakhra abhisakharoti, nejbhisakhra abhisakharoti, gatisavattanika kamma karoti, bhavasavattanika kamma karoti, issariyasavattanika kamma karoti, adhipaccasavattanika kamma karoti, mahbhogasavattanika kamma karoti, mahparivrasavattanika kamma karoti, devasobhagyasavatanika kamma karoti, manussasobhagyasavattanika kamma karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi Arahato pupacayo ti? mant. Arah cintti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arah apacintti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arah pajahatti --pe-- Arah updiyatti --pe-- Arah visinetti --pe-- Arah ussinetti --pe-- Arah vidhpetti --pe-- Arah sandhpetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 543]># %% Nanu Arah nev' cinti na apacinti apacinitv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah nev' cinti na apacinti apacinitv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato pupacayo ti." Nanu Arah neva pajahati na updiyati pajahitv hito, n' eva visineti na ussineti visinetv hito, n' eva vidhpeti na sandhpeti vidhpetv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah neva vidhpeti na sandhpeti vidhpetv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi Arahato pupacayo ti." 4. N' atthi Arahato pupacayo ti? mant. Arah dna dadeyyti? mant. Haci Arah dna dadeyya, no vata re vattabe "N' atthi Arahato pupacayo ti." Arah cvara dadeyya --pe-- piapta dadeyya, sensana dadeyya, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadeyya, khdanya dadeyya, bhojanya dadeyya, pnya dadeyya, cetiya vandeyya, cetiye mla ropeyya, gandha ropeyya, vilepana ropeyya --pe-- cetiya abhidakkhia kareyyti? mant. {Haci} Arah cetiya abhidakkhia kareyya, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi Arahato pupacayo ti." Atthi Arahato pupacayo ti kath. XVII.2. 1. N' atthi Arahato aklamaccti? mant. N' atthi Arahantaghtako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Arahantaghtako ti? mant. #<[page 544]># %<544 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 2.>% Atthi Arahato aklamaccti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. N' atthi Arahato aklamaccti? mant. Yo Arahanta jvit voropeti, sati jvite jvitvasese jvit voropeti, asati jvite jvitvasese jvit voropetti? Sati jvite jvitvasese jvit voropetti. Haci sati jvite jvitvasese jvit voropeti, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi Arahato aklamaccti." Asati jvite jvitvasese jvit voropetti, n' atthi Arahantaghtako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. N' atthi Arahato aklamaccti? mant. Arahato kye visa na kameyya, sattha na kameyya, aggi na kameyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Arahato kye visa kameyya, sattha kameyya, aggi kameyyti? mant. Haci Arahato kye visa kameyya, sattha kameyya, aggi kameyya, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi Arahato aklamaccti." 4. Arahato kye visa na kameyya, sattha na kameyya, aggi na kameyyti? mant. N' atthi Arahantaghtako ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atthi Arahato aklamaccti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Nha Bhikkhave sacetanikna kammna katna upacitna appaisaveditv byantibhva vadmi, ta ca kho dih' eva dhamme uppajje v apare v pariyye ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? #<[page 545]># %% mant. {Teha} hi n' atthi Arahato aklamaccti. N' atthi Arahato aklamaccti kath. XVII.3. 1. Sabba ida kammato ti? mant. Kamma pi kammato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabba ida kammato ti? mant. Sabba ida pubbekatahetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Sabba ida kammato ti? mant. Sabba ida kammavipkato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabba ida kammavipkato ti? mant. Kammavipkena pa haneyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ptipto saphalo ti? mant. Kammavipko saphalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammavipko aphalo ti? mant. Ptipto aphalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Kammavipkena adinna diyeyya --pe-- mus bhaeyya, pisua bhaeyya, pharusa bhaeyya, {samphappalapeyya}, sandhi chindeyya, nillopa hareyya, ekgrika kareyya, paripanthe tiheyya, paradra gaccheyya, gmaghta kareyya, nigamaghta kareyya, kammavipkena dna dadeyya, cvara dadeyya, #<[page 546]># %<546 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 4.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ piapta dadeyya, sensana dadeyya, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadeyyti? mant. Gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro saphalo ti? mant. Kammavipko saphalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kammavipko aphalo ti? mant. Gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhro aphalo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Sabba ida kammato ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Kammun vattati loko kammun vattati paj Kammanibandhan satt rathassnva yyato. Kammena kitti labhate pasasa, Kammena jni ca vadha ca bandha, Ta kamma nnkaraa viditv Kasm vade n' atthi kamman ti loke ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi sabba ida kammato ti. Sabba ida kammato ti kath. XVII.4. 1. Indriyabaddha eva dukkhan ti? mant. Indriyabaddha eva anicca sakhata paiccasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma virgadhamma nirodhamma viparimadhamman ti? #<[page 547]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anindriyabaddha anicca sakhata paiccasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma virgadhmma nirodhadhamma viparimadhamman ti? mant. Haci anindriyabaddha --pe-- viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Indriyabadha eva dukkhan ti." 2. Anindriyabaddha anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, ta ca na dukkhan ti? mant. Indriyabaddha anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, ta ca na dukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Indriyabaddha anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, ta ca dukkhan ti? mant. Anindriyabaddha anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, ta ca dukkhan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Indriyabaddha eva dukkhan ti? mant. Nanu yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, anindriyabaddha aniccan ti? mant. Haci yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, anindriyabaddha anicca, no vata re vattabbe "Indriyabaddha eva dukkhan ti." 4. Na vattabba "Indriyabaddha eva dukkhan ti"? mant. Yath indriyabaddhassa dukkhassa pariya Bhagavati brahmacariya vussati, evameva anindriyabaddhassa dukkhassa pariya Bhagavati brahmacariya vussatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yath indriyabaddha dukkha parita na puna uppajjati, #<[page 548]># %<548 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 5.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ evameva anindriyabaddha dukkha parita na puna uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi indriyabaddha eva dukkhan ti. Indriyabaddhakath. XVII.5. 1. hapetv ariyamagga avases sakhr dukkh ti? mant. Dukkhasamudayo pi dukkho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhasamudayo pi dukkho ti? mant. T' eva ariyasaccnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- T' eva ariyasaccnti? mant. Nanu cattri ariyasaccni vuttni Bhagavat -- Dukkha, Dukkhasamudayo, Dukkhanirodho, Dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ti? mant. Haci cattri ariyasaccni vuttni Bhagavat -- Dukkha, Dukkhasamudayo, Dukkhanirodho, Dukkhanirodhagmin paipad, no vata re vattabbe "T' eva ariyasaccnti." 2. Dukkhasamudayo pi dukkho ti? mant. Ken' ahenti? Aniccahenti. Ariyamaggo anicco ti? mant. Ariyamaggo dukkho ti? #<[page 549]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ariyamaggo anicco so ca na dukkho ti? mant. Dukkhasamudayo anicco so ca na dukkho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dukkhasamudayo anicco so ca dukkho ti? mant. Ariyamaggo anicco so ca dukkho ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "hapetv ariyamagga avases sakhr dukkh ti"? mant. Nanu s dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ti? mant. Haci s dukkhanirodhagmin paipad, tena vata re vattabbe "hapetv ariyamagga avases sakhr dukkh ti." hapetv ariyamaggan ti kath. XVII.6. 1. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti"? mant. Nanu Sagho huneyyo phuneyyo dakkhieyyo ajalkarayo anuttara puakkhetta lokassti? mant. Haci Sagho huneyyo --pe-- lokassa, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti." 2. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti"? mant. Nanu cattro purisayug, aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci cattro purisayug, aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat, #<[page 550]># %<550 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 6.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti." 3. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti"? mant. Nanu atthi keci Saghassa dna dentti? mant. Haci atthi keci Saghassa dna denti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti." Nanu atthi keci Saghassa cvara denti, piapta denti, sensana denti, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra denti, khdanya denti, bhojanya denti --pe-- pnya dentti? mant. Haci atthi keci Saghassa cvara denti, piapta denti, sensana denti, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra denti, khdanya denti, bhojanya denti --pe-- pnya denti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti." 4. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia paigahtti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "huti jtavedo va mahmegha va medin sagho samdhisampanno paigahti dakkhian ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Sagho dakkhia paigahtti. 5. Sagho dakkhia paigahtti? mant. Maggo {paigahti,} phala paigahtti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia pai- gahtti" kath. #<[page 551]># %% XVII.7. 1. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti"? mant. Nanu Sagho huneyyo phuneyyo dakkhieyyo ajalkarayo anuttara puakkhetta lokassti? mant. Haci Sagho huneyyo --pe-- lokassa, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti." 2. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti"? mant. Nanu cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci cattro purisayug, aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti." 3. Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti"? mant. Nanu atthi keci Saghassa dna datv dakkhia rdhentti? mant. Haci atthi keci Saghassa dna datv dakkhia rdhenti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti." Nanu atthi keci Saghassa cvara datv --pe-- {piapta} datv --pe-- sensana datv --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra datv --pe-- khdanya datv --pe-- bhojanya datv --pe-- pnya datv dakkhia radhentti? mant. Haci atthi keci Saghassa pnya datv dakkhia rdhenti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti." 4. Sagho dakkhia visodhetti? mant. #<[page 552]># %<552 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 8.>% Maggo visodheti, phala visodhetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na vattabba "Sagho dakkhia visodhetti" kath. XVII.8. 1. Na vattabba "Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti"? mant. Nanu atthi keci saghabhattni karonti, uddesabhattni karonti, ygupnni karontti? mant. Haci atthi keci saghabhattni karonti, uddesabhattni karonti, ygupnni karonti, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti." 2. Na vattabba "Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat gaabhojana paramparabhojana atirittabhojana anatirittabhojanan ti? mant. Haci vutta Bhagavat gaabhojana paramparabhojana atirittabhojana anatirittabhojana, tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti." 3. Na vattabba "Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti"? mant. Nanu aha pnni vuttni Bhagavat -- ambapna jambupna cocapna mocapna madhupna muddikapna sukapna phrusakapnan ti? mant. Haci aha pnni vuttni Bhagavat -- ambapna jambupna cocapna mocapna madhupna muddikapna sukapna phrusakapna, #<[page 553]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ tena vata re vattabbe "Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti." 4. Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syatti? mant. Maggo bhujati pivati khdati syati, phala bhujati pivati khdati syatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Na vattabba "Sagho bhujatti" kath. XVII.9. 1. Na vattabba "Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Nanu Sagho huneyyo phuneyyo dakkhieyyo ajalkarayo anuttara puakkhetta lokassti? mant. Haci Sagho huneyyo --pe-- lokassa, tena vata re vattabbe "Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti." 2. Na vattabba "Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Nanu cattro purisayug, aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci cattro purisayug, aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe "Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti." 3. Na vattabba "Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Saghe Gotam dehi, Saghe te dinne aha c' eva pjito bhavissmi Sagho cti." #<[page 554]># %<554 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 9.>% Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti. 4. Na vattabba "Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Nanu Sakko devna indo Bhagavanta etad avoca -- "Yajamnna manussna puapekhnapina Karota opadhika pua kath dinna mahapphalan ti." "Cattro ca paipann cattro ca phale hit Esasagho ujubhto paslasamhito. Yajamnna manussna puapekhnapina Karota opadhika pua Saghe dinna mahapphalan ti." "Eso hi Sagho vipulo mahaggato Esappameyyo udadhva sgaro Ete hi seh naravrasvak Pabhakar dhamma udrayan ti. Tesam sudinna suhuta suyiha Ye sagha uddissa dadanti dna S dakkhi Saghagat paihit Mahapphal lokavidna vait Etdisa yaa anussarant Ye vedajt viharanti loke Vineyya macchera ala samla Anindit sagga upenti hnan ti." #<[page 555]># %% Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Saghassa dinna mahapphalan ti. Na vattabba "Saghassa dinna mahap- phalan ti" kath. XVII.10. 1. Na vattabba "Buddhassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Nanu Bhagav dipadna aggo, dipadna seho, dipadna pamokkho, dipadna uttamo, dipadna pavaro asamo asamasamo appaisamo appaibhgo appaipuggalo ti? mant. Haci Bhagav {dipadna} aggo, dipadna seho, dipadna pamokkho, dipadna uttamo, dipadna pavaro asamo asamasamo appaisamo {appaibhgo} appaipuggalo, tena vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa dinna mahapphalan ti." 2. Na vattabba "Buddhassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Atthi keci Buddhena samasamo slena samdhin payti? N' atthi. Haci n' atthi keci Buddhena samasamo slena samdhin paya, tena vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa dinna mahapphalan ti." 3. Na vattabba "Buddhassa dinna mahapphalan ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Nayimasmi v loke parasmi v pana Buddhena seho ca samo ca vijjati, #<[page 556]># %<556 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 11.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ yamhuneyyna aggata gato, {puatthikna} vipulaphalesinan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Buddhassa dinna mahapphalan ti. Na vattabba "Buddhassa dinna mahap- phalan ti" kath. XVII.11. 1. Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti? mant. Nanu atthi keci paigghak huneyy phuneyy dakkhieyy ajalkaray anuttara puakkhetta lokassti? mant. Haci atthi keci paigghak hueyy phueyy dakkhieyy ajalkaray anuttara puakkhetta lokassa, no vata re vattabbe "Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti." 2. Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti? mant. Nanu cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal dakkhieyy vutt Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci cattro purisayug aha purisapuggal {dakkhieyy} vutt Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti." 3. Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti? mant. #<[page 557]># %% Nanu atthi keci sotpanne dna datv dakkhia rdhentti? mant. Haci atthi keci sotpanne dna datv dakkhia rdhenti, no vata re vattabbe "Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti." Nanu atthi keci sakadgmissa --pe-- angmissa --pe-- Arahato dna datv dakkhia rdhentti? mant. Haci atthi keci Arahato dna datv dakkhia rdhenti, no vata re vattabbe "Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti." 4. Paigghakato dna visujjhatti? mant. Ao aassa krako, parakata sukhadukkha, ao karoti ao paisavedetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dyakato va dna visujjhati, na paigghakato ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Catasso kho im' nanda dakkhi visuddhiyo, Katam catasso? Atth' nanda dakkhi dyakato visujjhati no paigghakato, atth' nanda dakkhi paigghakato visujjhati no dyakato, atth' nanda dakkhi dyakato c' eva visujjhati paigghakato ca, atth' nanda dakkhi n' eva dyakato visujjhati no paigghakato. Im kho nanda catasso dakkhi visuddhiyo ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Dyakato va dna visujjhati, no paigghakato ti." Dakkhi visuddhikath. #<[page 558]># %<558 KATHVATTHU. [XVII. 11.>% Vaggo sattarasamo. Atthi Arahato pupacayo, N' atthi Arahato aklamaccu, Sabba ida kammato, Indriyabaddha eva dukkha, hapetv ariyamagga avases sakhr dukkh, Sagho dakkhia paigahti, Sagho dakkhia Visodheti, Sagho bhujati pivati khdati syati, Saghassa dinna mahapphala, Atthi dna visuddhiy ti. #<[page 559]># %% XVIII.1. 1. Na vattabba "Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti"? mant. Nanu atthi Buddhavuttni cetiyni rmavihragmanigamanagarni rahni janapadnti? mant. Haci atthi Buddhavuttni cetiyni rmavihragmanigamanagarni rahni janapadni, tena vata re vattabbe "Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti." 2. Na vattabba "Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti"? mant. Nanu Bhagav umbiniy jto, Bodhiy mle abhisambuddho, Brasiya Bhagavat Dhammacakka pavattita, Cple cetiye yusakhro ossaho, Kusinrya Bhagav parinibbuto ti? mant. Haci Bhagav umbiniy jto, Bodhiy mle abhisambuddho, Brasiya Bhagavat Dhammacakka pavattita, Cple cetiye yusakhro ossaho, Kusinrya Bhagav parinibbuto, tena vata re vattabbe "Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti." 3. Na vattabba "Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Eka idha Bhikkhave samaya Ukkahya viharmi Subhagavane slarjamle ti, eka idha Bhikkhave samaya Uruvelya viharmi Ajaplanigrodhe {pahambhisambuddho} ti, eka idha Bhikkhave samaya Rjagahe viharmi Veuvane Kalandakanivpe ti, eka idha Bhikkhave samaya Svatthiya viharmi Jetavane Anthapiikassa rme ti, #<[page 560]># %<560 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 2.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ eka idha Bhikkhave samaya Vesliya viharmi Mahvane kugraslyan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti. 4. Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti? mant. Nanu Bhagav loke jto loke sambuddho loka abhibhuyya viharati anupalitto lokenti? mant. Haci Bhagav loke jto loke sambuddho loka abhibhuyya viharati anupalitto lokena, no vata re vattabbe "Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsti." Manussalokakath. XVIII.2. 1. Na vattabba "Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito ti"? mant. Kena desito ti? Abhinimmitena desito ti. Abhinimmito Jino Satth Sammsambuddho Sabba Sabbadassv Dhammasm Dhammapaisarao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vattabba "Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito ti"? mant. Kena desito ti? yasmat nandena desito ti. yasm nando Jino Satth --pe-- Dhammapaisarao ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito ti"? mant. #<[page 561]># %% Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sakhittena pi kho aha Sriputta dhamma deseyya, vitthrena pi kho aha Sriputta dhamma deseyya, sakhittavitthrena pi kho aha Sriputta dhamma deseyya, atro va dullabh ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito ti. 4. Na vattabba "Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Abhiyha Bhikkhave Dhamma desemi no anabhiya, sanidnha Bhikkhave Dhamma desemi no anidna, sappihriyha Bhikkhave Dhamma desemi no appihriya, ya c' assa mayha Bhikkhave abhiya Dhamma desayato no anabhiya, sanidna Dhamma desayato no anidna, sapihriya Dhamma desayato no {appihriya} karayo ovdo karayo anussan, ala ca pana vo Bhikkhave tuhiy, ala attamanatya, ala somanassya Sammsambuddho Bhagav, svkhyto Dhammo suppaipanno Sagho ti. Imasmi ca pana veyykaraasmi bhaamne dasasahass lokadhtu akampitth ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito ti Dhammadesankath. XVIII.3. 1. N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? mant. N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato mett ti? #<[page 562]># %<562 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 3.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? mant. N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato mudit --pe-- upekkh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato mett ti? mant. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato mudit --pe-- upekkh ti? mant. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? mant. Bhagav akruiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Bhagav kruiko lokahito loknukampako lokatthacaro ti? mant. Haci Bhagav kruiko lokahito loknukampako lokatthacaro, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti." 4. N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? mant. Nanu Bhagav mahkaru sampatti sampajjti? mant. Haci Bhagav mahkaru sampatti sampajji, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti." 5. Atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti? mant. Bhagav sargo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi n' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu ti. Karukath. #<[page 563]># %% XVIII.4. 1. Buddhassa Bhagavato uccrapassvo ativiya ae gandhajte adhigahtti? mant. Bhagav gandhabhoj ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Bhagav odanakummsa bhujatti? mant. Haci Bhagav odanakummsa bhujati, no vata re vattabbe "Buddhassa Bhagavato uccrapassvo ativiya ae gandhajte adhigahtti." 2. Buddhassa Bhagavato uccrapassvo ativiya ae gandhajte adhigahtti? mant. Atthi keci Buddhassa Bhagavato uccrapassva nahyanti vilimpenti uccrenti, peya patismenti, karaya nikkhipenti, pae pasrenti, tena ca gandhena gandhakaraya karontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Gandhajtikath. XVIII.5. 1. Ekena ariyamaggena cattri smaaphalni sacchikarotti? mant. Catunna phassna --pe-- catunna saa samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekena ariyamaggena cattri smaaphalni sacchikarotti? mant. #<[page 564]># %<564 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 5.>% Sotpattimaggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmi --pe-- angmimaggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Katamena maggenti? Arahattamaggenti. Arahattamaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa jahatti? mant. Nanu tiam saojanna pahna sotpattiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci tiam saojanna pahna sotpattiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena sakkyadihi vicikiccha slabbataparmsa jahatti." 2. Arahattamaggena orika kmarga orika bypda jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggena orika kmarga orika bypda jahatti? mant. Nanu kmargabypdna tanubhva sakadgmiphala vutta Bhagavt ti? mant. Haci kmargabypdna tanubhva sakadgmiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena orika kmarga orika bypda jahatti." 3. Arahattamaggena ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggena ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda jahatti? #<[page 565]># %% mant. Nanu kmargabypdna anavasesappahna angmiphala vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci kmargabypdna anavasesappahna angmiphala vutta Bhagavat, no vata re vattabbe "Arahattamaggena ausahagata kmarga ausahagata bypda jahatti." 4. Na vattabba "Ekena ariyamaggena cattri smaaphalni sacchikarotti"? mant. Bhagavat sotpattimaggo bhvito ti? mant. Bhagav sotpanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bhagavat sakadgmi --pe-- angmimaggo bhvito ti? mant. Bhagav angm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Bhagav ekena ariyamaggena cattri smaaphalni sacchikaroti, svak cathi ariyamaggehi cattri smaaphalni sacchikarontti? mant. Svak Buddhassa Bhagavato adiha dakkhinti, anadhigata adhigacchanti, asacchikata sacchikarontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekamaggakath. XVIII.6. 1. Jhn jhna sakamatti? mant. #<[page 566]># %<566 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 6.>% Paham jhn tatiya jhna sakamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Jhn jhna sakamatti? mant. Dutiy jhn catuttha jhna sakamatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Paham jhn dutiya jhna sakamatti? mant. Y pahamassa jhnassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va dutiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paham jhn dutiya jhna sakamati, na vattabba "Y pahamassa jhnassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhi, s va dutiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti"? mant. Dutiya jhna anvaantassa uppajjati --pe-- apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu dutiya jhna vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci dutiya jhna vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Paham jhn dutiya jhna sakamatti." 3. Paham jhn dutiya jhna sakamatti? mant. Pahama jhna kme dnavato manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Dutiya jhna kme dnavato manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahama jhna savitakka savicran ti? #<[page 567]># %% mant. Dutiya jhna savitakka savicran ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paham jhn dutiya jhna sakamatti? mant. Ta eva pahama jhna ta dutiya jhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Dutiy jhn tatiya jhna sakamatti? mant. Y dutiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va tatiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dutiy jhn tatiya jhna sakamati, na vattabba "Y dutiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhi, s va tatiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhti"? mant. Tatiya jhna anvaantassa uppajjati --pe-- apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu tatiya jhna vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci tatiya jhna vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Dutiy jhn tatiya jhna sakamatti? 5. Dutiy jhn tatiya jhna sakamatti? mant. Dutiya jhna vitakkavicre dnavato manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Tatiya jhna vitakkavicre dnavato manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dutiya jhna sapptikan ti? mant. Tatiya jhna sapptikan ti? #<[page 568]># %<568 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 6.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dutiy jhn tatiya jhna sakamatti? mant. Ta eva dutiya jhna ta tatiya jhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Tatiy jhn catuttha jhna sakamatti? mant. Y tatiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va catutthassa jhnassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tatiy jhn catuttha jhna sakamati, na vattabba "Y tatiyassa jhnassa uppdya vaan --pe-- paidhi, s va catutthassa jhnassa uppdya vaan -- pe -- paidhti"? mant. Catuttha jhna anvaantassa uppajjati --pe-- apaidahantassa uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu catuttha jhna vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjatti? mant. Haci catuttha jhna vaantassa uppajjati --pe-- paidahantassa uppajjati, no vata re vattabbe "Tatiy jhn catuttha jhna sakamatti," 7. Tatiy jhn catuttha jhna sakamatti? mant. Tatiya jhna pti dnavato manasikaroto uppajjatti? mant. Catuttha jhna pti dnavato manasikaroto uppajjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tatiya jhna sukhasahagatan ti? mant. Catuttha jhna sukhasahagatan ti? #<[page 569]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tatiy jhn catuttha jhna sakamatti? mant. Ta eva tatiya jhna ta catuttha jhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 8. Na vattabba "Jhn jhna sakamatti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu vivicc' eva kmehi --pe-- catuttha jhna upasampajja viharatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi jhn jhna sakamatti. Jhnasakantikath. XVIII.7. 1. Atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Atthi phassantarik --pe-- atthi saantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Dutiyassa ca jhnassa tatiyassa ca jhnassa antare atthi jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Tatiyassa ca jhnassa catutthassa ca jhnassa antare atthi jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dutiyassa ca jhnassa tatiyassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Haci dutiyassa ca jhnassa tatiyassa ca jhnassa antare #<[page 570]># %<570 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 7.>% n' atthi jhnantarik, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi jhnantarik ti." Tatiyassa ca jhnassa catutthassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Haci tatiyassa ca jhnassa catutthassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi jhnantarik ti." 3. Pahammassa ca jhnassa dutiyassa ca jhnassa antare atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Dutiyassa ca jhnassa tatiyassa ca jhnassa antare atthi jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahamassa ca jhnassa dutiyassa ca jhnassa antare atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Tatiyassa ca jhnassa catutthassa ca jhnassa antare atthi jhnatarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Dutiyassa ca jhnassa tatiyassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Pahamassa ca jhnassa dutiyassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tatiyassa ca jhnassa catutthassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik ti? mant. Pahamassa ca jhnassa dutiyassa ca jhnassa antare n' atthi jhnantarik ti? Na h' evam vattabbe --pe-- 5. Avitakko vicramatto samdhi jhnantarik ti? mant. Savitakko savicro samdhi jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avitakko vicramatto samdhi jhnantarik ti? mant. #<[page 571]># %% Avitakko avicro samdhi jhnanatarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Savitakko savicro samdhi na jhnantarik ti? mant. Avitakko vicramatto samdhi na jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Avitakko avicro samdhi na jhnantarik ti? mant. Avitakko vicramatto samdhi na jhnantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Dvinna jhnna paupannna antare avitakko vicramatto samdhti? mant. Nanu avitakke vicramatte samdhimhi vattamne pahama jhna niruddha, dutiya jhna anupannan ti? mant. Haci avitakke vicramatte samdhimhi vattamne pahama jhna niruddha, dutiya jhna anupannam, no vata re vattabbe "Dvinna jhnna pauppannna antare avitakko vicramatto samdhti." 8. Avitakko vicramatto samdhi na jhnantarik ti? mant. Avitakko vicramatto samdhi pahama jhna --pe-- dutiya jhna --pe-- tatiya jhna --pe-- catuttha jhnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi avitakko vicramatto samdhi jhnantarik ti. 9. Avitakko vicramatto samdhi jhnantarik ti? mant. Nanu tayo samdh vutt Bhagavat -- "savitakko savicro samdhi, avitakko vicramatto samdhi, avitakko avicro samdhti? mant. Haci tayo samdh --pe-- avicro samdhi, no vata re vattabbe "Avitakko vicramatto samdhi jhnantarik ti." #<[page 572]># %<572 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 8.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Jhnantarikakath. XVIII.8. 1. Sampanno sadda sutti? mant. Sampanno cakkhuv rpa passati --pe-- sotena --pe-- ghnena --pe-- jivhya --pe-- kyena phohabba phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sampanno sadda sutti? mant. Sotaviasamag sampanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu samdhi manoviasamagissti? mant. Haci samdhi manoviasamagissa, no vata re vattabbe "Sampanno sadda sutti." 2. Samdhi manoviasamagissa sotaviasamag sadda sutti? mant Haci samdhi manoviasamagissa sotaviasamag sadda suti, no vata re vattabbe "Sampanno sadda sutti." Samdhi manoviasamagissa sotaviasamag sadda sutti? mant. Dvina phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodh. na hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Sampanno sadda sutti"? mant. Nanu pahamassa jhnassa saddo kaako vutto Bhagavat ti? #<[page 573]># %% mant. Haci pahamassa jhnassa saddo kaako vutto Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe "Sampanno sadda sutti." Pahamassa jhnassa saddo kaako vutto Bhagavat ti, sampanno sadda sutti? mant. Dutiyassa jhnassa vitakko vicro kaako vutto Bhagavat, atthi tassa vitakkavicr ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahamassa jhnassa saddo kaako vutto Bhagavat ti, sampanno sadda sutti? mant. Tatiyassa jhnassa pti kaako, catutthassa jhnassa asssapassso kaako, ksnacyatana sampannassa rpasa kaako, viacyatana sampannassa ksnacyatanasa kaako, kicayatana sampannassa viacyatanasa kaako, nevasansayatana sampannassa kicayatanasa kaako, savedayitanirodha sampannassa sa ca vedan ca kaako vutto Bhagavat, atthi tassa sa ca vedan cti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sadda sutti kath. XVIII.9. 1. Cakkhun rpa passatti? mant. Rpena rpa passatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpena rpa passatti? mant. Rpena rpa paivijntti? #<[page 574]># %<574 KATHVATTHU. [XVIII. 9.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpena rpa paivijntti? mant. Rpa manovian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Cakkhun rpa passatti? mant. Atthi cakkhussa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu n' atthi cakkhussa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci n' atthi cakkhussa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Cakkhun rpa pasatti." 3. Sotena sadda sutti --pe-- ghnena gandha ghyatti --pe-- jivhya rasa syatti --pe-- kyena phohabba phusatti? mant. Rpena rpa phusatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpena rpam phusatti? mant. Rpena rpam paivijntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpena rpa paivijntti? mant. Rpa manovian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Kyena phohabba phusatti? mant. Atthi kyassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu n' atthi kyassa vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci n' atthi kyassa vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Kyena phohabba phusatti." 5. Na vattabba "Cakkhun rpa passatti --pe-- kyena phohabba phusatti"? mant. #<[page 575]># %% Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave bhikkhu cakkhun rpa passati --pe-- kyena phohabba phusatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi cakkhun rpa passatti --pe-- kyena phohabba phusatti. Cakkhun rpa passatti kath. Vaggo ahrasamo. Buddho Bhagav manussaloke ahsi, Buddhena Bhagavat Dhammo desito, N' atthi Buddhassa Bhagavato karu, Buddhassa Bhagavato uccrapassvo ativiya ae gandhajte adhigahti, Ekena ariyamaggena cattri smaaphalni sacchikaroti, Jhn jhna sakamati, Atthi jhnantarik, Sampanno sadda suti, Cakkhun rpam passati, Kyena phohabba phusatti. #<[page 576]># %<576 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 1.>% XIX.1. 1. Atte kilese jahatti? mant. Niruddha nirodheti, vigata vigameti, ka khepeti, atthagata atthagameti, abbhatthagata abbhatthagametti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atte kilese jahatti? mant. Nanu atta niruddhan ti? mant. Haci atta niruddha, no vata re vattabbe "Atte kilese jahatti." Atte kilese jahatti? mant. Nanu atta n' atthti? mant. Haci atta n' atthi, no vata re vattabbe "Atte kilese jahatti." 2. Angate kilese jahatti? mant. Ajta ajaneti, asajta asajaneti, anibbatta anibbattati, aptubhta aptubhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Angate kilese jahatti? mant. Nanu angata ajtan ti? mant. Haci angata ajta, no vata re vattabbe "Angate kilese jahatti." Angate kilese jahatti? mant. Nanu angata n' atthti? mant. Haci angata n' atthi, no vata re vattabbe "Angate kilese jahatti." #<[page 577]># %% 3. Paccuppanne kilese jahatti? mant. Ratto rga jahati, duho dosa jahati, mho moha jahati, kiliho kilese jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgena rga jahati, dosena dosa jahati, mohena moha jahati, kilesehi kilese jahatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgo cittasampayutto, maggo cittasampayutto ti? mant. Dvinna phassna --pe-- dvinna cittna samodhna hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rgo akusalo, maggo kusalo ti? mant. Kusalkusal svajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kusalkusal savajjnavajj hnappat kahasukkasappaibhg dhamm sammukhbhva gacchantti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Cattr' imni Bhikkhave suvidravidrni. Katamni cattri? Nabha ca Bhikkhave pathav ca, ida pahama suvidravidra --pe-- tasm sata dhammo asabbhi rak ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kusalkusal --pe-- gacchantti." 4. Na vattabba "Atte angate paccuppanne kilese jahatti." mant. N' atthi kilesajahan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi atte angate paccuppanne kilese jahatti. Kilesajahanakath. #<[page 578]># %<578 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 2.>% XIX.2. 1. Suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti? mant. Animitta sakhrakkhandhapariypannan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti? mant. Appaihito sakhrakkhandhapariypanno ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Animitta na vattabba "sakhrakkhandhapariypannan ti"? mant. Suat na vattabb "sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Appaihito na vattabbo "sakhrakkhandhapariypanno ti"? mant. Suat na vattabb "sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandho na anicco na sakhato na paiccasamuppanno na khayadhammo na vayadhammo na virgadhammo na nirodhadhammo na viparimadhammo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu sakhrakkhandho anicco sakhato paiccasamuppanno khayadhammo vayadhammo virgadhammo nirodhadhammo viparimadhammo ti? mant. Haci {sakhrakkhandho} anicco --pe-- viparimadhammo, no vata re vattabbe "Suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti." 4. Rpakkhandhassa suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti? mant. #<[page 579]># %% Sakhrakkhandhassa suat rpakkhandhapariypann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- viakkhandhassa suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti? mant. Sakhrakkhandhassa suat viakkhandhapariypann ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. {Sakharakkhandhassa} suat na vattabb "rpakkhandhapariypann ti"? mant. Rpakkhandhassa suat na vattabb "sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakhrakkhandhassa suat na vattabb "vi akkhandhapariypann ti"? mant. Viakkhandhassa suat na vattabb "sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti"? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Na vattabba "Suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sua ida Bhikkhave sakhr attena v attaniyena v ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann ti. Suat kath. XIX.3. 1. Smaaphala asakhatan ti? mant. #<[page 580]># %<580 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 3.>% Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Smaaphala asakhata, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Smaaphala asakhatan ti? mant. Smaa asakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Smaa sakhatan ti? mant. Smaaphala sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Sotpattiphala asakhatan ti? mant. Sotpattimaggo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sotpattimaggo sakhato ti? mant. Sotpattiphala sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sakadgmi --pe-- angmi --pe-- arahattaphala asakhatan ti? mant. Arahattamaggo asakhato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattamaggo sakhato ti? mant. Arahattaphala sakhatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Sotpattiphala asakhata, sakadgmi --pe-- #<[page 581]># %% angmi --pe-- arahattaphala asakhata, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Paca asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paca asakhatnti? mant. Paca tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Smaaphalakath. XIX.4. 1. Patti asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Patti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Cvarassa patti asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna --pe-- amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cvarassa patti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? #<[page 582]># %<582 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 4.>% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Piaptassa --pe-- sensanassa --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhrassa patti asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna --pe-- amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhrassa patti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Cvarassa patti asakhat -- piaptassa --pe-- sensanassa --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhrassa patti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Paca asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Paca asakhatnti? mant. Paca tni --pe-- antark {v} ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Pahamassa jhnassa patti asakhat -- eva sabba vitthretabba -- dutiyassa tatiyassa catutthassa jhnassa ksnacyatanassa viacyatanassa kicayatanassa nevasansayatanassa --pe-- sotpattimaggassa sotpattiphalassa, sakadgmi angmi -- arahattamaggassa arahattaphalassa patti asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna --pe-- accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahattaphalassa patti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? #<[page 583]># %% mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Sotpattimaggassa patti asakhat, sotpattiphalassa patti asakhat --pe-- arahattamaggassa patti asakhat, arahattaphalassa patti asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Nava asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nava asakhatnti? mant. Nava tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. Na vattabba "Patti asakhat ti"? mant. Patti rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi patti asakhat ti. Pattikath. XIX.5. 1. Sabbadhammna tathat asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbadhammna tathat asakhat, nibbna asakhatan ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 584]># %<584 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 5.>% Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Rpassa rpat, nanu rpat asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna ta lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Rpassa rpat, nanu rpat asakhat ti? mant. Dve asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dve asakhatnti? mant. Dve tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Vedanya vedanta, nanu vedanat --pe-- saya saat, nanu saat --pe-- sakhrna sakhrat, nanu sakhrat --pe-- viassa viat, nanu viat asakhat ti? mant. Nibbna tam lea saraa paryana accuta amatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Viassa viat, nanu rpat asakhat ti? mant. Cha asakhatnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cha asakhatnti? mant. Cha tni --pe-- antark v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Sabbadhammna tathat asakhat ti"? mant. Sabbadhammna tathat rpa vedan sa sakhr vian ti? #<[page 585]># %% mant. Tena hi sabbadhammna tathat asakhat ti. Tathat kath. XIX.6. 1. Nibbnadhtu kusal ti? mant. Sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Haci anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhi, no vata re vattabbe "Nibbnadhtu kusal ti." 2. Alobho kusalo srammao, atthi tassa vaan -- pe -- paidhti? mant. Nibbnadhtu kusal sramma, atthi tya vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Adoso kusalo --pe-- amoho kusalo --pe-- saddh viriya sati samdhi --pe-- pa kusal sramma, atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Nibbnadhtu kusal sramma, atthi tya vaan -- pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nibbnadhtu kusal anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? mant. Alobho kusalo anrammao, n' atthi tassa vaan --pe -- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nibbnadhtu kusal anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? #<[page 586]># %<586 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 7.>% mant. Adoso --pe-- pa kusal anramma, n' atthi tya vaan --pe-- paidhti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Nibbnadhtu kusal ti"? mant. Nanu nibbnadhtu anavajj ti? mant. Haci nibbnadhtu anavajj, tena vata re vattabbe "Nibbnadhtu kusal ti." Kusalakath. XIX.7. 1. Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti? mant. Mtughtako accantaniyato, pitughtako, Arahantaghtako --pe-- ruhiruppdako --pe-- Saghabhedako accantaniyato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti? mant. Accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikicch uppajjeyyti? mant. Haci accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikicch uppajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti." 2. Accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikicch n' uppajjeyyti? mant. Pahn ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahn ti? mant. Sotpattimaggenti? #<[page 587]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmi -- angmi -- arahattamaggenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Katamena maggenti? Akusalena maggenti. Akusalo maggo nyniko khayagm bodhagm ansavo --pe-- asakilesiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu akusalo maggo anyniko sakilesiko ti? mant. Haci akusalo maggo anyniko sakilesiko, no vata re vattabbe "Accantaniyatassa puggalassa vicikicch akusalena maggena pahn ti." 3. Sassatadihiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedadihi uppajjeyyti? mant. Haci sassatadihiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedadihi uppajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti." 4. Sassatadihiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedadihi n' uppajjeyyti? mant. Pahn ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahn ti? mant. Sotpattimaggenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmi -- angmi -- arahattamaggenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Katamena maggenti? Akusalena maggenti. Akusalo maggo nyniko khayagm bodhagm ansavo --pe-- asakilesiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu akusalo maggo anyniko sakilesiko ti? mant. Haci akusalo maggo anyniko sakilesiko, no vata re vattabbe "Sassatadihiniyatassa puggalassa ucchedadihi akusalena maggena pahn ti." #<[page 588]># %<588 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 7.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ 5. Ucchedadihiniyatassa puggalassa sassatadihi uppajjeyyti? mant. Haci ucchedadihiniyatassa puggalassa sassatadihi uppajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti." 6. Ucchedadihiniyatassa puggalassa sassatadihi n' uppajjeyyti? mant. Pahn ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pahn ti? mant. Sotpattimaggenti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sakadgmi -- angmi -- {arahattamaggenti?} Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Katamena maggenti? Akusalena maggenti. Akusalo maggo nyniko khayagm bodhagm ansavo --pe-- asakilesiko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu akusalo maggo anyniko --pe-- sakilesiko ti? mant. Haci akusalo maggo anyniko --pe-- sakilesiko, no vata re vattabbe "Ucchedadihiniyatassa puggalassa sassatadihi akusalena maggena pahn ti." 7. Na vattabba "Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti"? Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo samanngato hoti ekantakakehi akusalehi dhammehi, so saki nimuggo nimuggo va hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. #<[page 589]># %% Tena hi atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti. 8. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo samanngato hoti ekantakakehi akusalehi dhammehi, so saki nimuggo nimuggo va hotti" katv tena ca kraena atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo ummujjitv nimujjatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Sabbakla ummujjitv nimujjatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 9. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo samanngato hoti ekantakakehi akusalehi dhammehi, so saki nimuggo nimuggo va hotti" katv tena ca kraena atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat ti? mant. Vutta Bhagavat -- "Idha Bhikkhave ekacco puggalo ummujjitv hito hoti, ummujjitv vipassati viloketi, ummujjitv patarati, ummujjitv paigdhappatto hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Sabbakla ummujjitv paigdhappatto hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Accantaniymakath. XIX.8. 1. N' atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? mant. N' atthi lokiy saddh ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi lokiya viriyindriya --pe-- satindriya --pe-- samdhindriya --pe-- paindriyan ti? #<[page 590]># %<590 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 8.>% mant. N' atthi lokiy pa ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi lokiy saddh ti? mant. Atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiya viriya --pe-- pa ti? mant. Atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi lokiyo mano, atthi lokiya manindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiy saddh, atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiyo mano, atthi lokiya manindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiy pa, atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiya somanassa, atthi lokiya somanassindriya, atthi lokiya jvita, atthi lokiya jvitindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiy saddh, atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiya jvita, atthi lokiya jvitindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiy pa, atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi lokiy saddh, n' atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiyo mano, n' atthi lokiya manindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiy pa, n' atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiyo mano, n' atthi lokiya manindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiy saddh, n' atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? #<[page 591]># %% mant. Atthi lokiya somanassa, n' atthi lokiya somanassindriya, atthi lokiya jvita, n' atthi lokiya jvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiy pa, n' atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiya jvita, n' atthi lokiya jvitindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Atthi lokuttar saddh, atthi lokuttara saddhindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiy saddh, atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokuttar pa, atthi lokuttara paindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokiy pa, atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 6. Atthi lokiy saddh, n' atthi lokiya saddhindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokuttar saddh, n' atthi lokuttara saddhindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi lokiy pa, n' atthi lokiya paindriyan ti? mant. Atthi lokuttar pa, n' atthi lokuttara paindriyan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 7. N' atthi lokiyni pac' indriynti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat "Addasa kho aha Bhikkhave Buddhacakkhun loka volokento satte apparajakkhe mahrajakkhe tikkhindriye mudindriye {devakre} suvipaye appekacce paralokavajjabhayadassvino viharante ti." #<[page 592]># %<592 KATHVATTHU. [XIX. 8.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi lokiyni pac' indriynti. Indriyakath. Vaggo eknavsatimo. Atte kilese jahati, Angate kilese jahati, Paccuppanne kilese jahati, Suat sakhrakkhandhapariypann, Smaaphala asakhata, Patti asakhat, Sabbadhammna tathat asakhat, Nibbnadhtu kusal, Atthi puthujjanassa accantaniymat, N' atthi lokiyni pac' indriynti. #<[page 593]># %% XX.1. 1. Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti? mant. Asacicca pa hantv ptipt hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti? mant. Asacicca adinna diyitv --pe-- musbhaitv musvd hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Asacicca pa hantv ptipt na hotti? mant. Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko na hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Asacicca adinna diyitv --pe-- musbhaitv musvd na hotti? mant. Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko na hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti? mant. "Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti," atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. "Sacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti," atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Haci "sacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti," atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Asacicca mtara jvit voropetv nantariko hotti." 4. Na vattabba "Mtughtako nantariko ti"? mant. Nanu mt jvit voropit ti? mant. Haci mt jvit voropit, tena vata re vattabbe Mtughtako nantariko ti." 5. Na vattabba "Pitughtako nantariko ti"? 39 #<[page 594]># %<594 KATHVATTHU. [XX. 1.>% mant. Nanu pit jvit voropito ti? mant. Haci pit jvit voropito, tena vata re vattabbe "Pitughtako nantariko ti." 6. Na vattabba "Arahantaghtako nantariko ti"? mant. Nanu Arah jvit voropito ti? mant. Haci Arah jvit voropito, tena vata re vattabbe "Arahantaghtako nantariko ti." 7. Na vattabba "Lohituppdako nantariko ti"? mant. Nanu Tathgatassa lohita uppditan ti? mant. Haci Tathgatassa lohita {uppditan,} tena vata re vattabbe "Lohituppdako nantariko ti." 8. Saghabhedako nantariko ti? mant. Sabbe Saghabhedak nantarik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbe Saghabhedak nantarik ti? mant. Dhammasa Saghabhedako nantariko ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammasa Saghabhedako nantariko ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Atth' Upli Saghabhedako pyiko nerayiko kappaho atekiccho, atth' Upli Saghabhedako na pyiko na nerayiko na kappaho na atekiccho ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Dhammasa Saghabhedako nantariko ti." 9. Na vattabba "Dhammasa Saghabhedako nantariko ti"? #<[page 595]># %% mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "pyiko nerayiko kappaho Saghabhedako Vaggarato adhammaho yogakkhemato dhasati Sagha samagga bhetvna kappa nirayamhi paccatti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi Sagabhedako nantariko ti. Asaciccakath. XX.2. 1. N' atthi puthujjanassa an ti? mant. N' atthi puthujjanassa pa pajnan vicayo pavicayo dhammavicayo sallakkha upalakkha paccupalakkha ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atthi puthujjanassa pa --pe-- paccupalakkha ti? mant. Haci atthi puthujjanassa pa --pe-- paccupalakkha, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi puthujjanassa an ti." 2. N' atthi puthujjanassa an ti? mant. Puthujjano pahama jhna sampajjeyyti? mant. Haci puthujjano pahama jhna sampajjeyya, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi puthujjanassa an ti." Puthujjano dutiya jhna --pe-- tatiya jhna -- pe -- catuttha jhna --pe-- ksnacyatana sampajjeyya, viacyatana kicayatana nevasansayatana sampajjeyya, puthujjano dna dadeyya #<[page 596]># %<596 KATHVATTHU. [XX. 3.>% --pe-- cvara, piapta, sensana, gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadeyyti? mant. Haci puthujjano gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadeyya, no vata re vattabbe "N' atthi puthujjanassa an ti." 3. Atthi puthujjanassa an ti? mant. Puthujjano tena ena dukkha parijnti, samudaya pajahati, nirodha sacchikaroti, magga bhvetti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- akath. XX.3. 1. N' atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti? mant. N' atthi nirayesu kammakra ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi nirayesu kammakra ti? mant. Atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi manussesu kammakra, atthi ca kraik ti? mant. Atthi nirayesu kammakra, atthi ca kraik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi nirayesu kammakra, n' atthi ca kraik ti? mant. Atthi manussesu kammakra, n' atthi ca kraik ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- #<[page 597]># %% "Na Vessabh no pi ca Pettirj Somo Yamo Vessavao ca rj Sakni kammni hananti tattha Ito paunna paralokapattan ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi n' atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti. 4. N' atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ta ena Bhikkhave nirayapl pacavidhabandhana nma kraa krenti, tatta ayokhla hatthe gamenti, tatta ayokhla dutiye hatthe gamenti, tatta {ayokhla} pde gamenti, tatta ayokhla dutiye pde gamenti, tatta ayokhla majjhe urasmi gamenti; so tattha dukkh tibb kauk vedan vedeti, na ca tva kla karoti yva na ta ppakamma byanti hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti. 5. N' atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti? mant. Nanu vutta {Bhagavat} -- "Ta ena Bhikkhave nirayapl savesitv kudhrhi tacchanti, ta ena Bhikkhave nirayapl uddha pda adhosira hapetv vshi tacchanti, ta ena Bhikkhave nirayapl rathe yojetv diya pahaviy sampajjalitya sajotibhtya srenti pi pacc srenti pi, ta ena Bhikkhave nirayapl mahanta Agrapabbata ditta sampajjalita sajotibhta ropenti pi oropenti pi, #<[page 598]># %<598 KATHVATTHU. [XX. 4.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ ta ena Bhikkhave nirayapl uddha pda adhosira gahetv tattya lohakumbhiy pakkhipanti diya sampajjalitya sajotibhtya, so tattha pheuddehaka paccati, so tattha pheuddehaka paccamno saki pi uddha gacchati saki pi adho gacchati, saki pi tiriya gacchati, so tattha dukkh tibb kauk vedan vedayati na ca tva kla karoti yva ca na ta ppakamma byanti hoti, tam ena Bhikkhave nirayapl mahniraye pakkhipanti. So kho pana Bhikkhave Mahnirayo Catukkao catudvro Vibhatto bhgaso mito Ayopkrapariyanto Ayas paikujjito, Tassa ayamay bhmi Alit tejas yutt. Samant yojanasata Pharitv tihati sabbad ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi nirayesu nirayapl ti. Nirayaplakath. XX.4. 1. Atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti? mant. Atthi tiracchnagatesu dev ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti? #<[page 599]># %% mant. Devaloko tiracchnayonti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti? mant. Atthi tattha k paag makas makkhik ah vicchik satapad gaupd ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. N' atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti? mant. Nanu atthi tattha Ervao nma hatthingo sahassayutta dibbam ynan ti? mant. Haci atthi tattha Ervao nma hatthingo sahassayutta dibba yna, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti." 3. Atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti? mant. Atthi tattha hatthibandh assabandh yvasik kraik bhattakrak ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi n' atthi devesu tiracchnagat ti. Tiracchnakath. XX.5. 1. Pacagiko maggo ti? mant. Nanu ahagiko maggo vutto Bhagavat, seyyathda sammdihi --pe-- sammsamdhti? mant. Haci ahagiko maggo vutto Bhagavat, seyyathda sammdihi #<[page 600]># %<600 KATHVATTHU. XX. 5.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- sammsamdhi, no vata re vattabbe "Pacagiko maggo ti." 2. Pacagiko maggo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Maggna ahagiko seho saccna caturo pad Virgo seho dhammna dvipadna ca cakkhum ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi ahagiko maggo ti. 3. Sammvc maggaga, s ca na maggo ti? mant. Sammdihi maggaga, s ca na maggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammvc maggaga, s ca na maggo ti? mant. Sammsakappo --pe-- sammvymo --pe-- sammsati --pe-- sammsamdhi maggaga, so ca na maggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammkammanto --pe-- sammjvo maggaga, so ca na maggo ti? mant. Sammdihi --pe-- sammsamdhi maggaga, so ca na maggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Sammdihi maggaga, s ca maggo ti? mant. sammvc maggaga, s ca maggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammdihi maggaga, s ca maggo ti? mant. Sammkammanto --pe-- sammjvo maggaga, so ca maggo ti? #<[page 601]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammsakappo --pe-- sammsamdhi maggaga, so ca maggo ti? mant. Sammvc --pe-- sammjvo maggaga, so ca maggo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Ahagiko maggo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Pubbe va kho pan' assa kyakamma vackamma jvo suparisuddho hoti, eva assya ariyo ahagiko maggo bhvanpripri gacchatti."? Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi pacagiko maggo ti. 6. Pacagiko maggo ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Yasmi kho Subhadda Dhammavinaye ariyo ahagiko maggo na upalabbhati, samao pi tattha na upalabbhati, dutiyo pi tattha samao na upalabbhati, tatiyo pi tattha samao na upalabbhati, catuttho pi tattha samao na upalabbhati, yasmi ca kho Subhadda Dhammavinaye ariyo ahagiko maggo upalabbhati samao pi tattha upalabbhati, dutiyo pi --pe-- tatiyo pi --pe-- catuttho pi tattha samao upalabbhati; imasmi kho Subhadda Dhammavinaye ariyo ahagiko maggo upalabbhati, idh' eva Subhadda samao idha dutiyo samao idha tatiyo samao idha catuttho samao, su parappavd samaehi aehti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi ahagiko maggo ti. Maggakath. #<[page 602]># %<602 KATHVATTHU. [XX. 6.>% XX.6. 1. Dvdasavatthuka a lokuttaran ti? mant. Dvdasa lokuttaranti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvdasa lokuttaranti? mant. Dvdasa sotpattimagg ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvdasa sotpattimagg ti? mant. Dvdasa sotpattiphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvdasa sakadgmi --pe-- angmi --pe-- arahattamagg ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dvdasa arahattamagg ti? mant. Dvdasa arahattaphalnti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Na vatabba "Dvdasavatthuka a lokuttaran ti"? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ida dukkha ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhu udapdi a udapdi vijj udapdi pa udapdi loko udapdi, ta kho pan' ida dukkha ariyasacca parieyyan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- paritan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ida dukkhasamudayo ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ta kho pan' ida dukkhasamudayo ariyasacca pahtabban ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- pahnan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ida dukkhanirodho ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ta kho pan' ida dukkhanirodho ariyasacca sacchiktabban ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- sacchikatan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ida dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ariyasaccan ti me Bhikkhave --pe-- ta kho pan' ida dukkhanirodhagmin paipad ariyasacca bhvetabban ti me Bhikkhave #<[page 603]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ --pe-- bhvitan ti me Bhikkhave pubbe ananussutesu dhammesu cakkhu udapdi --pe-- loko udapdti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi dvdasavatthuka a lokuttaran ti. akath. Vaggo vsatimo. Mtughtako nantariko, Pitughtako nantariko, Arahantaghtako nantariko, Ruhiruppdako nantariko, Saghabhedako nantariko, N' atthi puthujjanassa a, N' atthi nirayesu nirayapl, Atthi devesu tiracchnagat, Pacagiko maggo, dvdasavatthuka a lokuttaran ti. Catuttho pasako. Niggaho, puasacayo, ahsi, attena ca mtughtako ti. #<[page 604]># %<604 KATHVATTHU. [XXI. 1.>% XXI.1. 1. Ssana navakatan ti? mant. Satipahn navakat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ssana navakatan ti? mant. Sammappadhn --pe-- iddhipd --pe-- indriy --pe-- bal --pe-- bojjhag navakat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pubbe akusala pacch kusala katan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pubbe ssava --pe-- saojanya gandhanya oghanya yoganya nvaraya parmaha updniya sakilesika pacch asakilesika katan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi koci Tathgatassa ssana nava karotti? mant. Atthi koci satipahne nava karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci sammappadhne --pe-- bojjhage nava karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci pubbe akusala pacch kusala karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Atthi koci pubbe ssava --pe-- sakilesika pacch asakilesika karotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Labbh Tathgatassa ssana puna nava ktun ti? mant. Labbh satipahn puna nava ktun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh sammappadhn --pe-- bojjhag nava ktun ti? #<[page 605]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh pubbe akusala pacch kusala ktun ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Labbh pubbe ssava --pe-- sakilesika pacch asakilesika ktun ti? Ssanakath. XXI.2. 1. Puthujjano tedhtukehi dhammehi avivitto ti? mant. Puthujjano tedhtukehi phassehi --pe-- vedanhi sahi cetanhi cittehi saddhhi viriyehi sathi samdhhi -- pe -- tedhtukhi pahi avivitto ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Puthujjano tedhtukehi dhammehi avivitto ti? mant. Yasmi khae puthujjano cvara deti, tasmi khae pahama jhna upasampajja viharati --pe-- ksnacyatana upasampajja viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Yasmi khae puthujjano piapta deti --pe-- sensana deti --pe-- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra deti, tasmi khae catuttha jhna upasampajja viharati, nevasansayatana upasampajja viharatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Na vattabba "Puthujjano tedhtukehi dhammehi avivitto ti"? mant. Puthujjanassa rpadhtu -- arpadhtpaga kamma paritan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi puthujjano tedhtukehi kammehi avivitto ti. Avivittakath. #<[page 606]># %<606 KATHVATTHU. [XXI. 4.>% XXI.3. 1. Atthi kici saojana appahya arahattappattti? mant. Atthi kici sakkyadihi appahya --pe-- vicikiccha slabbataparmsa rga dosa moha anottappa appahya arahattappattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi kici saojana appahya arahattappattti? mant. Arah sargo sadoso samoho samno samakkho sapaso sa-upyso sakileso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Arah nirgo niddoso nimmoho nimmno nimmakkho nippaso nirpyso nikkileso ti? mant. Haci Arah nirgo niddoso nimmoho nimmno nimmakkho nippaso nirpyso nikkileso, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi kici saojana appahya arahattappattti." 3. Na vattabba "Atthi kici saojana appahya Arahattapattti"? mant. Arah sabba Buddhavisaya jntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi atthi kici saojana appahya Arahattappattti. Saojanakath. XXI.4. 1. Atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? mant. #<[page 607]># %% Niccapa rukkh hontti atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Niccapupph rukkh hontu --pe-- niccaphalik rukkh hontu, nicca juha hotu, nicca khema hotu nicca subhikkha hotu, nicca suvatthi hotti, atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi adhippya- iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? mant. Uppanno phasso m nirujjhti atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uppann vedan --pe-- pa m nirujjhti atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 3. Atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? mant. Rpa nicca hotti --pe-- vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via nicca hotti, atthi adhippyaiddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna {v} svakna v ti? mant. Jtidhamm satt m jyisti, atthi --pe-- jardhamm satt m jaristi --pe-- bydhidhamm satt m bydhiyisti -- pe-maraadhamm satt m myisti, atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 5. Na vattabba "Atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti? #<[page 608]># %<608 KATHVATTHU. [XXI. 6.>% mant. Nanu yasm Pilindavaccho rao Mgadhassa Seniyassa Bimbisrassa psda suvaan t' eva adhimucci, suvao ca pana sti? mant. Haci yasm Palindavaccho rao Mgadhassa Seniyassa Bimbisrassa psda suvaan t' eva adhimucci, suvao ca pana si, tena vata re vattabbe "Atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v ti." Iddhikath. XXI.5. 1. Atthi Buddhna Buddhehi hntirekat ti? mant. Satipahnato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammappadhnato --pe-- iddhipdato --pe-- indriyato -- pe-- balato --pe-- bojjhagato --pe-- vasbhvato --pe-- sabbautaadassanato ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Buddhakath. XXI.6. 1. Sabb dis Buddh tihantti? mant. Puratthimya disya Buddh tihantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Puratthimya disya Buddh tihantti? mant. Kinnmo so Bhagav, kijacco, kigotto, kinnm tassa Bhagavato mtpitaro, #<[page 609]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ kinnma tassa Bhagavato svakayuga, ko nmo tassa Bhagavato upahko, kdisa cvara dhreti, kdisa patta dhreti, katarasmi gme v nigame v nagare v rahe {v} janapade v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Dakkhiya disya --pe-- pacchimya disya --pe-- uttarya disya --pe-- hehimya disya Buddho tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Hehimya disya Buddho tihatti? mant. Kinnmo so Bhagav --pe-- janapade v ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uparimya disya Buddho tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Uparimya disya Buddho tihatti? mant. Ctummahrjike tihati --pe-- Tvatise tihati -- pe -- Yme tihati --pe-- Tusite tihati --pe-- nimmnaratiy tihati --pe-- paranimmitavasavattiy tihati --pe-- Brahmaloke tihatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sabbadis kath. XXI.7. 1. Sabbe dhamm niyat ti? mant. Micchattaniyat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammattaniyat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi aniyato rsti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atthi aniyato rsti? #<[page 610]># %<610 KATHVATTHU. [XXI. 7.>% mant. Haci atthi aniyato rsi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe dhamm niyat ti." 2. Sabbe dhamm niyat ti? mant. Nanu tayo rs vutt Bhagavat -- micchattaniyato rsi, sammattaniyato rsi, aniyato rsti? mant. Haci tayo rs vutt Bhagavat -- micchattaniyato rsi, sammattaniyato rsi, aniyato rsi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe dhamm niyat ti." 3. Rpa rpahena niyatan ti? mant. Micchattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via viahena niyatan ti? mant. Micchattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Rpa rpahena niyata --pe-- vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via vinahena niyatan ti"? mant. Rpa hoti, vedan hoti, sa hoti, sakhr honti, via hoti, vedan, sa, sakhr, via rpa hoti, vedan hoti, sa hoti, sakhr hontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi rpa rpahena niyata, vedan, sa, sakhr, via viahena niyatan ti. Dhammakath. #<[page 611]># %% XXI.8. 1. Sabbe kamm niyat ti? mant. Micchattaniyat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammattaniyat ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi aniyato rsti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atthi aniyato rsti? mant. Haci atthi aniyato rsi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe kamm niyat ti." 2. Sabbe kamm niyat ti? mant. Nanu tayo rs vutt Bhagavat -- micchattaniyato rsi, sammattaniyato rsi, aniyato rsti? Haci tayo rs vutt Bhagavat -- micchattaniyato rsi, sammattaniyato rsi, aniyato rsi, no vata re vattabbe "Sabbe kamm niyat ti." 3. Dihadhammavedanya kamma dihadhammavedanyahena niyatan ti? mant. Micchattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Upapajjavedanya kamma --pe-- aparpariyavedanya kamma aparpariyavedanyahena niyatan ti? mant. Micchattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Sammattaniyatan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 4. Na vattabba "Dihadhammavedanya kamma dihadhammavedanyahena niyata, #<[page 612]># %<612 KATHVATTHU. [XXI. 8.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ upapajjavedanya kamma --pe-- aparpariyavedanya kamma aparpariyavedanyahena niyatan ti"? mant. Dihadhammavedanya kamma upapajjavedanya hoti, aparpariyavedanya hoti --pe-- upapajjavedanya kamma dihadhammavedanya hoti, aparpariyavedanya hoti, aparpariyavedanya kamma dihadhammavedanya hoti upapajjavedanya hotti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi dihadhammavedanya kamma dihadhammavedanyahena niyata, upapajjavedanya kamma --pe-- aparpariyavedanya kamma aparpariyavedanyahena niyatan ti. Kammakath. Vaggo ekavsatimo. Ssana navakata, Atthi koci Tathgatassa ssana nava karoti, Labbh Tathgatassa ssana puna nava ktu, Puthujjano tedhtukehi dhammehi avivitto, Atthi kici saojana appahya arahattappatti, Atthi adhippya-iddhi Buddhna v svakna v, Atthi Buddhna Buddhehi hntirekat, Sabb dis Buddh tihanti, Sabbe dhamm niyat, Sabbe kamm niyat ti. #<[page 613]># %% XXII.1. 1. Atthi kici saojana appahya parinibbnan ti? mant. Atthi kici sakkyadihi appahya --pe-- vicikiccha slabbataparmsa rga dosa moha anottappa appahya parinibbnan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi kici saojana appahya parinibbnan ti? mant. Arah sargo sadoso samoho samno samakkho sapaso sa-upyso sakileso ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Arah nirgo niddoso nimmoho nimmno nimmakkho nippaso nirpyso nikkileso ti? mant. Haci Arah nirgo niddoso nimmoho nimmno nimmakkho nippaso nirpyso nikkileso, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi kici saojana appahya parinibbnan ti." 3. Na vattabba "Atthi kici sannojana appahya parinibbnan ti"? mant. Arah sabba Buddhavisaya jntti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi atthi kici saojana appahya parinibbnan ti? Parinibbnakath. XXII.2. 1. Arah kusalacitto parinibbyatti? mant. Arah pubhisakhra abhisakharonto, nejbhisakhra abhisakharonto, gatisavattanika kamma karonto, #<[page 614]># %<614 KATHVATTHU. [XXII. 2.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ bhavasavattanika kamma karonto, issariyasavattanika kamma karonto, adhipaccasavattanika kamma karonto, mahbhogasavattanika kamma karonto, mahparivrasavattanika kamma karonto, devasobhagyasavattanika kamma karonto, manussasobhagyasavattanika kamma karonto parinibbyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Arah kusalacitto parinibbyatti? mant. Arah cinanto, apacinanto, pajahanto, updiyanto visinento, ussinento, vidhpento, sandhpento parinibbyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu {Arah} nev' cinti na apacinti apacinitv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah nev' cinti na apacinti apacinitv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Arah kusalacitto parinibbyatti." Nanu Arah neva pajahati na updiyati pajahitv hito, neva visineti na ussineti visinetv hito, nanu Arah neva vidhpeti na sandhpeti vidhpetv hito ti? mant. Haci Arah neva pajahati na upditati pajahitv hito, neva visineti na ussineti visinetv hito, haci Arah neva vidhpeti na sandhpeti vidhpetv hito, no vata re vattabbe "Arah kusalacitto parinibbyatti." 3. Na vattabba "Arah kusalacitto parinibbyatti"? mant. Nanu Arah upahitasati sato sampajno parinibbyatti? mant. Haci Arah upahitasati sato sampajno parinibbyati, tena vata re vattabbe "Arah kusalacitto parinibbyatti." Kusalacittakath. #<[page 615]># %% XXII.3. 1. Arah neje hito parinibbyatti? mant. Nanu Arah pakaticitte hito parinibbyatti? mant. Haci Arah pakaticitte hito parinibbyati, no vata re vattabbe "Arah neje hito parinibbyatti." 2. Arah neje hito parinibbyatti? mant. Arah kiriyamaye citte hito parinibbyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Arah vipkacitte hito parinibbyatti? mant. Haci Arah vipkacitte hito parinibbyati, no vata re vattabbe "Arah neje hito parinibbyatti." 3. Arah neje hito parinibbyatti? mant. Arah kiriybykate citte hito parinibbyatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu Arah vipkbykate citte hito parinibbyatti? mant. Haci Arah vipkbykate citte hito parinibbyati, no vata re vattabbe "Arah neje hito parinibbyatti." 4. Arah neje hito parinibbyatti? mant. Nanu Bhagav catutthajjhn vuhahitv samanantar parinibbuto ti? mant. Haci Bhagav catutthajjhn vuhahitv samanantar parinibbuto, no vata re vattabbe "Arah neje hito parinibbyatti." nejakath. #<[page 616]># %<616 KATHVATTHU. [XXII. 5.>% XXII.4. 1. Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammbhisamayo ti? mant. Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammadesan, dhammasavana, dhammaskacch, paripucch, slasamdna, indriyesu guttadvrat, bhojane mattaut, pubbarattpararatta jgariynuyogo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- N' atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammadesan --pe-- jgariynuyogo ti? mant. Haci n' atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammadesan --pe-- jgariynuyogo, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammbhisamayo ti." 2. Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammbhisamayo ti? mant. Nanu dve paccay sammdihiy updya, parato ca ghoso, yoniso ca manasikro ti? mant. Haci dve paccay sammdihiy updya, parato ca ghoso, yoniso ca manasikro, no vata re vattabbe "Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammbhisamayo ti." 3. Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammbhisamayo ti? mant. Suttassa pamattassa muhasatissa asampajnassa dhammbhisamayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Dhammbhisamayakath. XXII.5. 1. (a) Atthi gabbhaseyyya arahattappattti? mant. #<[page 617]># %% Suttassa pamattassa muhasatissa asampajnassa arahattappattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- (b) Atthi supinagatassa dhammbhisamayo ti? mant. Suttassa pamattassa muhasatissa asampajnassa dhammbhisamayo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- (c) Atthi supinagatassa arahattappattti? mant. Suttassa pamattassa muhasatissa asampajnassa arahattappattti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tisso pi kath. XXII.6. 1. Sabba supinagatassa citta abykatan ti? mant. Supinantena pa haneyyti? mant. Haci supinantena pa haneyya, no vata re vattabbe "Sabba supinagatassa citta abykatan ti." Supinantena dinna diyeyya --pe-- mus bhaeyya -- pe -- pisuna bhaeyya -- pharusa bhaeyya -- {samphappalpeyya} -- sandhi chindeyya -- nillopa kareyya -- ekgrika kareyya -- paripanthe tiheyya -- paradra gaccheyya -- gmaghta kareyya -- nigamaghta kareyya -- supinantena methuna dhamma paiseveyya -- supinagatassa asucimucceyya -- supinantena dna dadeyya -- cvara dadeyya -- piapta dadeyya -- sensana dadeyya -- gilnapaccayabhesajjaparikkhra dadeyya -- khdanya dadeyya -- bhojanya dadeyya -- pya dadeyya -- cetiya dadeyya -- cetiye mla ropeyya -- gandha ropeyya -- vilepana ropeyya -- pe -- cetiya abhidakkhia kareyyti? #<[page 618]># %<618 KATHVATTHU. [XXII. 7.>% mant. Haci supinantena cetiya abhidakkhia kareyya, no vata re vattabbe "Sabba supinagatassa citta abykatan ti." 2. Na vattabba "Sabba supinagatassa citta abykatan ti"? mant. Nanu supinagatassa citta abbohriya vutta Bhagavat ti? mant. Haci supinagatassa citta abbohriya vutta Bhagavat, tena vata re vattabbe "Sabba supinagatassa citta abykatan ti." Abykatakath. XXII.7. 1. N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Ptipto Bhikkhave sevito bhvito bahulkato nirayasavattaniko tiracchnayonisavattaniko pittivisayasavattaniko, yo sabbalahu so ptiptassa vipko manussabhtassa appyukasavattaniko hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? 2. N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Adinndna Bhikkhave sevita bhvita bahulkata nirayasavattanika tiracchnayonisavattanika pittivisayasavattanika, yo sabbalahu so adinndnassa vipko manussabhtassa bhogabyasanasavattaniko hoti --pe-- yo sabbalahu so kmesu micchcrassa vipko manussabhtassa sapattaverasavattaniko hoti --pe-- yo sabbalahu so musvdassa vipko, #<[page 619]># %% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ manussabhtassa abbhtabbhakkhnasavattaniko hoti --pe-- yo sabbalahu so pisuya vcya vipko, manussabhtassa mittehibhedanasavattaniko hoti -- pe -- yo sabbalahu so pharusya vcya vipko, manussabhtassa amanpasaddasavattaniko hoti --pe-- yo sabbalahu so samphappalpassa vipko, manussabhtassa andeyyavcasavattaniko hoti, surmerayapna Bhikkhave sevita --pe-- yo sabbalahu so surmerayapnassa vipko manussabhtassa ummattakasavattaniko hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti. 3. N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Micchdihi Bhikkhave sevit bhvit bahulkat nirayasavattanik tiracchnayonisavattanik pittivisayasavattanik ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti. 4. N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Micchsakappo --pe-- micchsamdhi Bhikkhave sevito --pe-- pittivisayasavattaniko ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti. 5. N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? mant. nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sammdihi Bhikkhave sevit bhvit bahulkat amatogadh hoti amataparyan amatapariyosn ti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? 6. N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti? mant. Nanu vutta Bhagavat -- "Sammsakappo -- pe sammsamdhi Bhikkhave sevito bhvito bahulkato amatogadho hoti amataparyano amatapariyosno ti." #<[page 620]># %<620 KATHVATTHU. [XXII. 8.>% \<[... content straddling page break has been moved to the page above ...]>/ Atth' eva suttanto ti? Tena hi atthi kci sevanapaccayat ti. sevanapaccayakath. XXII.8. 1. Ekacittakkhaik sabbe dhamm ti? mant. Citte mahpahav sahti, mahsamuddo sahti, Sineru pabbatarj sahti, po sahti, tejo sahti, vyo sahti, tiakahavanappatiyo sahantti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Ekacittakkhaik sabbe dhamm ti? mant. Cakkhyatana cakkhuviena sahajtan ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Cakkhyatana cakkhuviena sahajtan ti? mant. Nanu yasm Sriputto etad avoca -- "Ajjhattika c' eva vuso cakkhu aparibhinna hoti, bhir ca rp na ptha gacchanti, no ca tajjo samannhro hoti, n' eva tva tajjassa viabhvassa ptubhvo hoti; ajjhattika c' eva vuso cakkhu aparibhinna hoti, bhir ca rp ptha gacchanti, no ca tajjo samannhro hoti, n' eva tva tajjassa viabhvassa ptubhvo hoti; yato ca kho vuso ajjhattika c' eva cakkhu aparibhinna hoti, bhir ca rp ptha gacchanti, tajjo ca samannhro hoti, eva tajjassa viabhvassa ptubhvo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Cakkhyatana cakkhuviena sahajtan ti." 3. Sotyatana --pe-- ghnyatana --pe-- jivhyatana --pe-- kyyatana kyaviena sahajtan ti? #<[page 621]># %% Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Kyyatana kyaviena sahajtan ti? mant. Nanu yasm Sriputto etad avoca -- "Ajjhattiko c' eva vuso kyo aparibhinno hoti bhir ca phohabb na ptha gacchanti no ca --pe-- ajjhattiko c' eva vuso kyo aparibhinno hoti bhir ca phohabb ptha gacchanti no ca --pe-- yato ca kho vuso ajjhattiko c' eva kyo aparibhinno hoti bhir ca rp phohabb ptha gacchanti tajjo ca samannhro hoti, eva tajjassa viabhvassa ptubhvo hotti." Atth' eva suttanto ti? mant. Tena hi na vattabba "Kyyatana kyaviena sahajtan ti." 4. Na vattabba "Ekacittakkhaik sabbe dhamm ti"? mant. Sabbe dhamm nicc dhuv sassat aviparimadhamm ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Tena hi ekacittakkhaik sabbe dhamm ti. Khaikakath. Vaggo bvsatimo. Atthi kici saojana appahya {parinibbna,} Arah kusalacitto parinibbyati, Arah neje hito parinibbyati, Atthi gabbhaseyyya dhammbhisamayo, Atthi gabbhaseyyya arahattappatti, Atthi supinagatassa dhammbhisamayo, Atthi supinagatassa arahattappatti, Sabba supinagatassa citta abykata, N' atthi kci sevanapaccayat, Ekacittakkhaik sabbe dhamm ti. #<[page 622]># %<622 KATHVATTHU. [XXIII. 2.>% XXIII.1. 1. Ekdhippyo methuno dhammo paisevitabbo ti? mant. Ekdhippyena asamaena hotabba, abhikkhun hotabba, chinnamlena hotabba, prjikena hotabban ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Ekdhippyena methuno dhammo paisevitabbo ti? mant. Ekdhippyena po hantabbo, adinna diyitabba, mus bhaitabb, pisua bhaitabba, pharusa bhaitabba, samphappalpitabba, sandhi cheditabb, nillopa htabba, ekgrika ktabba, paripanthe htabba, paradro gantabbo, gmaghto ktabbo, nigamaghto ktabbo ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- {Ekdhippyakath.} XXIII.2. 1. Arahantna vaena amanuss methuna dhamma paisevantti? mant. Arahantna vaena amanuss pa hananti --pe-- {adinna} diyanti, mus bhaanti, pisua bhaanti, pharusa bhaanti, {samphappalpanti}, sandhi chindanti, nillopa haranti, ekgrika karonti, paripanthe tihanti, paradra gacchanti, gmaghta karonti, nigamaghta karontti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Arahantavaakath. #<[page 623]># %% XXIII.3. 1. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu vinipta gacchatti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu niraya gacchati, sajva gacchati, klasutta gacchati, tpana gacchati, patpana gacchati, saghtaka gacchati, roruva gacchati, avci gacchatti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu vinipta gacchatti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu vinipta gacchatti, atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. Haci Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu vinipta gacchatti, n' atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu vinipta gacchatti." 2. Bodhisatto issariykmakrikhetu gabbhaseyya okkamatti? Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu niraya upapajjeyya, tiracchnayoni upapajjeyyti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu gabbhaseyya okkamatti? mant. Bodhisatto iddhim ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto iddhim ti? mant. Bodhisattena chandiddhipdo bhvito --pe-- viriyiddhipdo --pe-- cittiddhipdo --pe-- vmasiddhipdo bhvito ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- #<[page 624]># %<624 KATHVATTHU. [XXIII. 3.>% Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu gabbhaseyya okkamatti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu gabbhaseyya okkamatti, atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi Haci Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu gabbhaseyya okkamatti, n' atthi' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu gabbhaseyya okkamatti." 3. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu dukkarakrika aksti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu sassato loko ti pacchgacchi, asassato loko ti --pe-- antav loko ti --pe-- anantav loko ti --pe-- ta jva ta sarran ti, aa jva aa sarran ti, hoti Tathgato para mara ti, na hoti Tathgato para mara ti, hoti ca na ca hoti Tathgato para mara ti, n' eva hoti na na hoti Tathgato para mara ti pacchgacchti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu dukkarakrika aksti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu dukkarakrika aksti, atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. Haci Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu dukkarakrika aksti, n' atthi' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu dukkarakrika aksti." 4. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu aparantapa aksi, aa satthra uddisti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu sassato loko ti pacchgacchi, asassato loko ti --pe-- anatav loko ti --pe-- #<[page 625]># %% anantav loko ti --pe-- ta jva ta sarran ti, aa jva aa sarran ti, hoti Tathgato para mara ti, na hoti Tathgato para mara ti, hoti ca na ca hoti Tathgato para mara ti, n' eva hoti na na hoti Tathgato para mara ti pacchgacchti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu aa satthra uddisti? mant. Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu aa satthra uddisti, atth' eva suttanto ti? N' atthi. Haci Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu aa satthra uddisti, n' atth' eva suttanto, no vata re vattabbe "Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu aa satthra uddisti." Issariyakmakrikkath. XXIII.4. 1. Atthi na rgo rgapairpako ti? mant. Atthi na phasso phassapairpako, atthi na vedan vedanpairpak, atthi na sa sapairpak, atthi na cetan cetanpairpak, atthi na citta cittapairpaka, atthi na saddh saddhpairpak, atthi na viriya viriyapairpaka, atthi na sati satipairpak, atthi na samdhi {samdhipairpako}, atthi na pa papairpak ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- 2. Atthi na doso dosapairpako, atthi na moho mohapairpako, atthi na kileso kilesapairpak ti? mant. #<[page 626]># %<626 KATHVATTHU. [XXIII. 5.>% Atthi na phasso phassapairpako --pe-- atthi na pa papairpak ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Pairpakath. XXIII.5. 1. Rpa aparinipphannan ti? mant. Rpa na anicca na sakhata na {paiccasamuppanna} na khayadhamma na vayadhamma na {virgadhamma} na nirodhadhamma na viparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu rpa anicca sakhata paiccasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma virgadhamma nirodhadhamma viparimadhamman ti? mant. Haci rpa anicca sakhata paiccasamuppanna khayadhamma vayadhamma virgadhamma nirodhadhamma viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Rpa aparinipphannan ti." 2. Dukkha eva parinipphannan ti? mant. Nanu yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, rpa aniccan ti? mant. Haci yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, rpa anicca, no vata re vattabbe "Dukkha eva parinipphannan ti." 3. Vedan --pe-- sa --pe-- sakhr --pe-- via --pe-- cakkhyatana --pe-- cakkhudhtu --pe-- cakkhundriya --pe-- atvindriya aparinipphannan ti? mant. #<[page 627]># %% Aatvindriya na anicca --pe-- na viparimadhamman ti? Na h' eva vattabbe --pe-- Nanu atvindriya anicca --pe-- viparimadhamman ti? mant. Haci atvindriya anicca --pe-- viparimadhamma, no vata re vattabbe "Atvindriya aparinipphannan ti." 4. Dukkha eva parinipphannan ti? mant. Nanu yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, atvindriya aniccan ti? mant. Haci yad anicca ta dukkha vutta Bhagavat, atvindriya anicca, no vata re vattabbe "Dukkha eva parinipphannan ti." Aparinipphannakath. Vaggo tevsatimo. Ekdhippyena methuno dhammo paisevitabbo, Arahantna vaena amanuss methuna dhamma paisevanti, Bodhisatto issariyakmakrikhetu vinipta gacchati, gabbhaseyya okkamati, dukkarakrika aksi, aparantapa aksi, aa satthra uddisi, Atthi na rgo rgapairpako, atthi na doso dosapairpako, atthi na moho mohapairpako, atthi na kileso kilesapairpako, Rpa parinipphanna, atvindriya aparinipphannan ti. #<[page 628]># %<628 KATHVATTHU. [XXIII. 6.>% Mahniymo anusay niggaho khuddakapacamo, Parappavdamaddano suttamlasamhit Ujjotan satthusamaye ti. Kathvatthuppakarae pacatisa bhavra nihita.