Khandadeva: Bhattadipika, a commentary on Jaimini's Mimamsasutra,
Adhyaya 2, Adhikarana 4,
with Sambhubhatta's Prabhavali (subcomm.)
Based on the ed. by N.S. Ananta Krishna Sastri
Bombay 1921-1922 (Reprint: Delhi 1987)
(Sri Garib Dass Oriental Series, 50-)


Input by members of the Sansknet project
(www.sansknet.org) [server down!]


This GRETIL version has been converted from a custom Devanagari encoding.
Therefore, word boundaries are usually not marked by blanks.
These and other irregularities cannot be standardized at present.


An attempt to structure the text according to sutras had to be
abandoned for want of an adequate printed edition.


THE TEXT IS NOT PROOF-READ!

#<...># = BOLD




___________________________________________________________________

THIS TEXT FILE IS FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY!
COPYRIGHT AND TERMS OF USAGE AS FOR SOURCE FILE.
            
Text converted to Ronald E. Emmerick's encoding for WordPerfect 5.1 DOS 
and related utility programmes BHELA, CARAKA etc. (DOS versions):
            
description             character  =ASCII
            
long a                  Ã             195
long A                  ù             249
long i                  Å             197
long I                  ý             253
long u                  Æ             198
long U                  ô             244
vocalic r               ­             173
vocalic R               ã             227
long vocalic r          Ì             204
vocalic l               Ê             202
long vocalic l          Ë             203
velar n                 Ç             199
velar N                 §             167
palatal n               ¤             164
palatal N               ¥             165
retroflex t             Â             194
retroflex T             è             232
retroflex d             ¬             172
retroflex D             Ö             214
retroflex n             ï             239
retroflex N             ×             215
palatal s               Ó             211
palatal S               Á             193
retroflex s             «             171
retroflex S             å             229
anusvara                æ             230
capital anusvara        õ             245
visarga                 ÷             247
capital visarga         ê             234

Other characters of the REE encoding table are not included.
Unless indicated otherwise, accents have been dropped in order 
to facilitate word search.             

For a comprehensive list of REE and other GRETIL encodings 
and formats see:
www.sub.uni-goettingen.de/ebene_1/fiindolo/gretil/gretdiac.pdf
and
www.sub.uni-goettingen.de/ebene_1/fiindolo/gretil/gretdias.pdf
___________________________________________________________________





<B1> caturtha÷ pÃda÷ /
#<(1 adhikaraïam / ) (a.2 pÃ.4 adhi.1)># 


yÃvajjÅviko 'bhyÃsa÷ karmadharma÷ prakaraïÃt  / Jaim_2,4.1 /


"yÃvajjÅvaæ darÓapÆrïamÃsÃbhyÃæ yajete" tyatra kÃmye eva svargÃdyarthe darÓapÆrïamÃsakarmaïi jÅvanaparyÃptakÃlavidhi÷ /
naca paurïamÃsyÃdikÃlavirodha÷; vyÃpyavyÃpakabhÃvena amÃvÃsyÃparÃhïÃdivadubhayorapyupapatte÷ /
ata eva vinigamanÃvirahÃtkÃladvayavidhÃvapi prayogadvayavidhi÷ /
jÅvanaparyÃptakÃlavidhisÃmarthyÃdeva ca pratipaurïamÃsyÃdyarthÃddarÓapÆrïamÃsÃv­tti÷ /
ataÓca tÃvadvyÃpyaprayogavyÃsaktavyÃpakaikaprayogÃdeva svargÃdiphalamiti prÃpte ---------- #<kÃlalak«aïÃpatternÃyaæ kÃlavidhi÷ /
ato dhÃtusaæbandhÃdhikÃravihitaïamulpratyayena jÅvanasya karmasaæbandhÃvagate÷ svÃvacchinnakÃlakatvÃdirÆpasaæbandhÃÓrayaïe ca guïabhÆtakÃlÃnurodhena
pradhÃnÃv­tternyÃyalabhyatvÃbhÃvena yÃvacchabdÃrthasyÃpi vidheyatvÃpatterlÃghavÃnnimittatvameva saæbandha÷ pratÅyate /
tadÃhi pratinimittaæ naimittikÃv­tternyÃyalabhyatvÃdyÃvacchabdÃrtho 'nuvÃda÷ /
nimittatvaæ ca svÃnvayavyatirekÃnuvidhÃyyavaÓyÃnu«ÂhÃnavattvam /
yathà rÃhÆparÃgÃnvayavyatirekÃnuvidhÃyi avaÓyÃnu«ÂhÃnaæ yasya snÃnasya tadvattvaæ rÃhÆparÃge />#
atraca vyatirekÃnuvidhÃna eva vidhestÃtparyam /
ataÓca nimittasattve naimittikasyÃvaÓyÃnu«ÂhÃnabodhanÃdakaraïe pratyavÃyo 'numÅyate /
karaïe ca 'dharmeïa pÃpamapanudati' ityÃdivÃkyaÓe«Ãt rÃtrisatranyÃyena pÃpak«aya evÃnu«aÇgiko nityanaimittikasthale phalam /
yatratu rathantarasÃmatvÃdinimittasattve naimittikasya pÃÂhÃdeva prÃptisaæbhavenÃnvayÃnuvidhÃnasya pramÃïÃntareïa prÃptistatra vyatirekÃnuvidhÃna eva vidhestÃtparyam /
ata eva rathantarÃbhÃve aindravÃyavÃgratvasyÃbhÃva÷ /
ataÓca yÃvajjÅvapade lÃghavÃdyanurodhena jÅvanasya nimittatvÃvagatestadanurodhena pÃpak«ayÃrthaæ viniyogÃntaramevedamiti siddham // 1 // #<iti prathamaæ yÃvajjÅvanimittatÃdhikaraïam
//>#
--------------- #<<B2>># (yÃvajjÅvaguïasaæyuktÃgnihotrÃdiprayogabhedÃbhedacintà vÃrtikakÃrÃïÃæ saæmateti nirÆpaïam) darÓapÆrïamÃsÃbhyÃæ svargakÃmo yajeteti kÃmyaprayogaæ vidhÃya
bahv­cabrÃhmaïe ÃmnÃtaæ vÃkyamudÃharati #<---------- yÃvajjÅvamiti >#//
yÃvajjÅvamagnihotraæ juhotÅtyetatsad­ÓavÃkyÃntarÃïÃmapyupalak«aïametat /
atra bhëyakÃreïa sÆtrÃnuguïyena karmadharmatvakart­dharmatvacintÃæ k­tÃmapi t­tÅyÃdhyÃyasaægatÃyÃstasyà bhedalak«aïe 'paryavasite sati karaïe lak«aïÃsaÇgatyÃpatterayuktÃmapi
kiæ yÃvajjÅvaguïasaæyuktÃnÃmagnihotrÃdÅnÃæ prayogà bhidyante; uta eka evÃyaæ prayoga÷ kÃmya÷ sa eva yÃvajjÅva kÃlaparimita ityevaæ lak«aïasaægataprayogabhedÃbhedaphalakatvena
vÃrtikakÃra÷ samarthayÃmÃsa //
#<(uktavÃrtikasiddhÃntÃparito«Ãt viniyogabhedÃbhedÃveva pÃdÃrtha iti nirÆpaïam)># vastutastu ---------- #<prayogÃÇgasyÃpi yÃvajjÅvakÃlasya pÆrvaprayoge sÃyaæprÃta÷kÃlÃvaruddhe
'varodhasaæbhavÃnna yathà pÆrvapak«e prayogabhedakatvam, tathà nimittasyÃpi pÆrvaprayoge 'saæbhavato 'pi prayogÃnaÇgatvÃt tattatpaurïamÃsyÃdikÃlÅnasiddhaprayogasya karmaïo
viniyogÃntarÃpÃdakatve 'pi prayogÃntarÃnÃpÃdakatvÃnna kÃlÃdivat prayogabhedakatvamiti prayogabhedÃbhedacintÃyà asaæbhavÃt katha¤citsaæbhave 'pi vÃve«ÂyadhikaraïaprasaÇgenaiva
vicÃrayituæ yuktatvÃdiha vicÃrÃsaægatervÃrtikakÃroktÃvaparitu«ya nimittasya viniyogÃnvayitvena tatprayuktaviniyogabhedÃbhedasya kvÃpi pÆrvamaprak­tasyeha pÃdÃrthatvena kaustubhe uktÃæ
lak«aïasaÇgatiæ tathà nimittasya guïatvena bhedakatvepyanupÃdeyaprasaÇgÃnnimittasvarÆpÃnupÃdeyasya viniyogabhedakatvavicÃreïa prÃsaÇgikÅmanantarasaÇgatiæ ca spa«ÂatvÃt, ataeva
bhëyakÃroktasaæÓayamanuktvà pÆrvapak«amevÃha># ------------ kÃmya eveti //
(kÃmye darÓapÆrïamÃsakarmaïi guïavidhÃnamiti pÆrvapak«opapÃdanam) #< uta eka evÃyaæ prayoga÷ kÃmya÷ sa eva yÃvajjÅvakÃlaparimita iti vÃrtikalekhanÃt kÃmyaprayoge 'yaæ>#
#<kÃlavidhiriti bhramaæ nivartayituæ darÓapÆrïamÃsakarmaïÅtyuktam >#//
(kÃmya evetyevakÃreïa siddhÃnte prakaraïÃnanugrahasya pÆrvapak«e tadanugrahasya ca sÆcanam) tataÓcaitadvÃkye prayogÃnvayiguïÃbhÃvena prayogavidhe÷ /
siddhÃnte 'pyanÃÓrayaïÃt paurïamÃsyÃdikÃlavidhauca tadÃÓrayaïe vinigamanÃvirahÃt atrÃpi tadÃpatterihaiva karmoddeÓena kÃlavidhÃne sati vak«yamÃïarÅtyà prayogavidhi÷, natu
prayogÃnuvÃdena kÃlavidhirityartha÷ /
siddhÃntetasyaiva karmaïo nimittasaæbandhena viniyogÃntarakaraïe 'dhikÃrÃkhyaprakaraïÃnugrahe 'pi kathaæbhÃvÃkÃÇk«Ãlak«aïaprakaraïÃnanugrahaæ pÆrvapak«e tadanugraha¤ca
sÆcayituæ kÃmya evetyevakÃra÷ prayukta÷ //
#<(yÃvajjÅvapadasya ïamulantatvaæ na nimittatvena kintu kÃlavidhitveneti nirÆpaïam)># kÃlavidhiriti //
#<yÃvajjÅvapadasya ïamulantasyÃpi yÃvaddehaæ ti«ÂhatÅtivat nirƬhalak«aïayà kÃlaparatvopapatte÷ abhikrÃmaæ juhotÅtyatra ïamulantasyÃpi nimittaparatvÃdarÓanÃdiha kÃlavidhireva yukta
ityartha÷ /
aparÃhïÃdivaditi //
piï¬apit­yaj¤avÃkye dvayoramÃvÃsyÃparÃhïakÃlayairvidhÃne 'pyekasya vyÃpyakÃlasyÃ- vacchedakatvenaikakÃlyenÃvirodhasyevehÃpyupapattirityathra÷ //>#
(atra pÆrvapak«e prÃcÅnÃpÃditayajatyabhyÃsalak«aïÃnirÃsa÷) atra prÃcÅnai÷ siddhÃnte paurïamÃsyamÃvÃsyayordarÓapÆrïamÃsÃnu«ÂhÃnena jÅvanaparyÃptakÃlÃnugrahÃsaæbhavÃt
yÃgÃbhyÃsavidhÃnÃya yajatÃvabhyÃsalak«aïà pÆrvapak«e ÃpÃditÃ, tÃæ parihartumÃha #<---------- jÅvanaparyÃpteti >#//
eva¤ca nÃbhyÃsalak«aïà nataräca tasya vidheyatvamityevakÃreïa sÆcitam /
"yÃvajjÅvako 'bhyÃsa" iti sÆtramapyÃrthikÃbhyÃsaparatayà neyamiti bhÃva÷ //
#< (vyÃpyaprayogÃtiriktavyÃpakaprayogÃntaravidhipak«eïopapÃdanam)># #<eva¤ca yathaiva paurïamÃsyÃdivÃkye«u kÃlaviÓi«ÂavyÃpyaprayogavidhi÷, tathaiva yÃvajjÅvavÃkye 'pi
kÃlaviÓi«Âaprayogasya vidhÃnaæ nÃnupapannam />#
ataeva #<vidheyatÃvacchedakatayà jÅvanaparyÃpte«u tÃvatsu vyÃpyaprayoge«u tattadvidheyatÃvacchedakatayà vibhinnadharmÃntare«vapi vyÃsaktaikadharmasya
svÅkÃrÃdvyÃpyaprayogavyÃsaktavyÃpakaprayogÃdeva phalamityÃha># ---------- svargÃdÅti //
#<vyÃpyavyÃpakaprayogaviÓi«Âakarmaïa÷ phalÃpek«ÃyÃæ svargakÃmÃdivÃkyena svargÃrthatayaiva viniyogÃt svargÃdyeva># #<phalam, natu yÃvajjÅvavÃkyena pÃpak«ayÃrthatvena
viniyogÃt pÃpak«aya÷ p­thak phalamityartha÷ /
eva¤ca jÅvanaparyÃptaistÃvadbhi÷ prayogai÷ ekameva phalaæ svargÃdi bhavati, nÃntareti bhÃva÷ /
etacca vyÃpyaprayogÃpek«ayà vyÃpakaprayogÃntaravidhÃnaæ kaustubhoktarÅtyopapÃditam  >#//
(ante eva svargÃdi nÃntarÃ, nÃpi pÃpak«aya ityÃdinirÆpaïam) #<vastutastu -----------># vyÃpakaprayogeïaiva nirvÃhe tattadvyÃpyaprayogasvÅkÃre naiva ki¤cit pramÃïam /
naca vinigamanÃviraha÷; paurïamÃsyÃdivÃkye«u vyÃpakaprayogÃnuvÃdena tattatkÃlavidhÃne 'pi jÅvanakÃlÃvacchedakatvavidhayà tattatkÃlaniveÓasaæbhavasyaiva niyÃmakatvÃt /
nahi paurïamÃsyÃdikÃle«u jÅvanasyÃvyÃvartakasyÃvacchedakatvaæ saæbhavati; ato 'prÃptajÅvanakÃlaviÓi«Âaprayogavidhirayameva /
anyathà paurïamÃsyÃdikÃlÃnÃæ vyÃpyavyÃpakabhÃvena niveÓasaæbhavÃdavirodhokteranuktisahatvÃpatte÷ /
ataeva prayogabhedÃbhÃvena prak­tasaÇgatyasaæbhavena viniyogabhedamÃdÃya saÇgatyupapÃdanaæ kaustubhoktaæ saægacchate /
tÃvatÃpica paurïamÃsyÃdikÃlÃvacchinnajÅvanaparyÃptakÃlikaprayogÃdeva phalaæ svargÃdi nÃntarà navà pÃpak«aya÷ phalamityasya phalabhedasya na k«atiriti dhyeyam  //
#<(yÃvacchabdÃrthasya puru«adharmatvena kÃlavidhÃnÃyogena nyÃyalabdhÃv­ttyanuvÃdatvakathanam)># #<yÃvajjÅvaÓabde hi yÃvacchabdasya sÃmastyavacanatvÃt tasya ÓakyÃrthasya
puru«adharmatvena karmadharmatvÃyogÃt avaÓyaæ jÅvapade jÅvanakÃlalak«aïÃmeva pÆrvapak«e lak«aïÃpattirityanenÃbhipretyÃbhyÃsalak«aïÃpattiæ prÃcÅnoktÃmapahÃya
kÃlalak«aïameva pÆrvapak«e ÃpÃdayan siddhÃntamÃha>#--------- kÃlalak«aïÃpatteriti //
#<"dhÃtusaæbandhe pratyayÃ" ityanuÓÃsanÃt yasmÃddhÃtorïamutpratyayo bhavati taddhÃtvarthasya dhÃtvarthÃntareïa saæbandhasya ïamulÃbhidhÃnÃt saæbandhaviÓe«Ãpek«ÃyÃæ
yÃvacchabdatÃtparyagrÃhakavaÓÃt nimittatvarÆpatadviÓe«apratÅterna tatpratipÃdanÃya manmate lak«aïÃpattirityabhipretyÃha># ----------- ata iti #<//
saæbandhavidhayaiva kÃlabodhopapattermamÃpi na lak«aïÃpattiriti># #<pÆrvapak«iïo lak«aïÃparihÃrÃÓaya÷ saæbandhÃÓrayaïe cetyanena sÆcita÷ /
yÃvacchabdÃrthasya vidheyatve ekapadopÃdÃnÃt viÓi«ÂaprayogavidhÃnÃdvà vÃkyabhedÃnÃpattÃvapi gauravÃpattirlÃghavÃdityanena sÆcità /
saæsargavidhayà bhÃne gauravam /
padÃrthavidhayà bhÃne lak«aïÃcetyubhayaæ nimittatvamevetyevakÃreïa vyÃvartyaæ sÆcitam >#//
nyÃyalamyatvÃditi #<//
prÃïakriyÃrÆpÃïÃæ jÅvanÃnÃæ bhedÃnnimittÃv­ttyupapatte÷ jÅvanagatasÃmastyasya naimittikasaæbandhitvena prÃptatvÃdanuvÃda ityartha÷ >#//
(jÅvane nimitte viniyogÃntaravidhÃnamevÃtretyÃdinirÆpaïam) ataeva ------ yatra vidhiÓravaïenÃnu«ÂhÃnabodhastatra anu«ÂhÃpakarÆpanimittÃpek«ayà nimittatvarÆpasaæbandhÃÓrayaïam
/
yatratu vartamÃnÃpadeÓena tacchravaïam yathà yÃvaddohamityatra tatrÃnu«ÂhÃnasyaivÃbodhanena nÃnu«ÂhÃpakatvarÆpatadapek«ayà dhÃtvarthÃntarasaæbandha÷, kintu
svÃvacchinnakÃlakatvameva sa iti vai«amyam /
#<taduktaæ vÃrtike ---------># "yuktamatra kÃlagrahaïaæ vartamÃnÃpadeÓo hyayam /
nÃtra kÃcinnimittÃpek«Ã /
tena Órutiv­tte, dohanamatikramya kÃlo g­hyate /
yaditvihÃpi yÃvaddoha÷ svapyÃdÃsÅtaveti vidhÅyeta, tata÷ kena và dohasya nimittatvaæ vÃryate" iti /
ato jÅvanasya nimittatvÃt nimittasyÃnu«ÂhÃpakatve 'pi prayogÃk«epakatve pramÃïÃbhÃvÃt svata÷siddhaprayogÃnÃmevai«Ãæ nimittasaæbandhena vividi«ÃyÃmiva viniyogÃntaramevedamiti
na vyÃpakaprayogÃnta eva svargÃdi phalam /
paurïamÃsÅpaurvÃhïÃdikÃlaÓÃstrÃntaraikavÃkyatayÃca paurvÃhïikakÃlÃvacchinnapaurïamÃsyavacchinna jÅvanasya nimittatvÃnna tithyantarasya jÅvane nimittatvasya na vaikasyÃmeva
paurïamÃsyÃæ tadavacchinnajÅvanarÆpanimittabhedÃdÃv­ttyÃpattervà prasaÇga÷ /
paurvÃhïikakÃlÃvacchinnapaurïamÃsyÃmeva pratik«aïa¤jÅvanabhedamÃdÃyÃv­ttyÃpÃdanaæ tvaÓakyatvÃdeva na saæbhavatÅti bhÃva÷ //
#<(nimittatvanirvacanam)># #<nimittatva¤ca nÃnu«ÂhÃpakatvamÃtrarÆpaæ kÃmanÃdivat, tathÃtve kÃmaÓÃstreïaiva tÃd­ÓÃnu«ÂhÃnasiddhau etadvacanavaiyarthyÃpatte÷,
yÃvacchabdÃnuvÃdÃnupapatteÓca, ato niyatÃnu«ÂhÃpakatvasyÃk«epÃttadghaÂitaæ nimittasvarÆpamÃha># ----------- nimittatvaæ ceti //
#<(nimittasamabhivyÃh­tavidherakaraïe pratyavÃyabodhakatvam)># #<niyatatvasyaca buddhipÆrvakÃriïà puru«eïa svato 'saæpÃdyamÃnatvÃt nimittasamabhivyÃh­to vidhi÷ yogyatÃbalena
vidheyÃkaraïasya pratyavÃyasÃdhanatÃæ bodhayatÅtyabhipretyÃha># ---------- ataÓceti #<//
ataÓcaitÃd­ÓanimittatvÃnurodhenÃvaÓyakartavyatÃrÆpaniyamasyÃrthasiddhasya kart­dharmatvena vidhÃnokti÷># 


kartur và ÓrutisaæyogÃt  / Jaim_2,4.2 /


iti sÆtra iti bhÃva÷ //
(viÓvajinnyÃyÃprav­ttyà vÃkyaÓe«agatapÃpak«ayÃrthatvopapÃdanam) atra prÃbhÃkarairvidheyÃkaraïasya vidhinà pratyavÃyajanakatvabodhane 'pi karaïasya naiva ki¤citphalamityaÇgÅkriyate
/
nyÃyasudhÃk­tà tu pratyayavÃcyabhÃvanÃyà bhÃvyasÃkÃÇk«atvaniyamÃt karaïÃtphalÃÇgÅkÃrepyakaraïanimittapratyavÃyaprÃgabhÃvaparipÃlanasya phalatvamityuktam, tadubhayanirÃsÃyÃha
#<--------- karaïe ceti >#//
kÃmyamÃnena svargÃdiphalenÃvaÓyakatvÃnirvÃhÃt viÓvajinnyÃyena svargaphalakalpanÃyogÃt phalaviÓe«Ãpek«ÃyÃæ "dharmeïa pÃpamapanudati," "pÆrvÃæ sandhyÃæ japan vipro naiÓameno
vyapohati," "yadrÃtryà pÃpamakÃr«aæ yadahnà pÃpamakÃr«aæ manasà vÃcà hastÃbhyÃæ" ityÃdivÃkyaÓe«ebhyo ni«iddhÃcaraïajanyapratyavÃyak«ayasya phalatvamavasÅyate ityartha÷ /
yadyapi dharmeïetyasya na ki¤cidvÃkyaÓe«atvam, apitu vÃkyatvameva; tathÃpi Ãdipadasaæg­hÅtÃnÃæ pÆrvoktÃnÃæ saædhyÃvandanavidhivÃkyaÓe«atvÃdvÃkyaÓe«etyuktam /
akaraïe pratyavÃyabhiyà prav­ttasya pÃpak«ayÃrthaæ prav­ttyabhÃvamapek«ya pÃpak«ayasyÃnu«aÇgikatvokti÷ /
nyÃyasudhÃk­nmatanirÃsa÷ kaustubhe dra«Âavya÷ /
nimittalak«aïaprasaÇgÃt rathantarasÃmÃdhikaraïoktamevÃrthaæ punarviÓadayati #<------------ yatra tviti >#//
siddhÃntamupasaæharatiïae.#< -------------># #<ataÓceti >#//
(pÆrvottarakalpaprayojananirÆpaïam) prayojanaæ pÆrvapak«e yÃvajjÅvamabhyastarÆpaka eka÷ kÃmya eva proyaga÷ jÅvanakÃlasya vik­tau sauryÃdÃvatideÓÃdyÃvajjÅviko 'bhyÃsa÷, siddhÃnte
tvaphalakÃmasyÃpi sÃyaæprÃta÷kÃlayorabhyastarÆpastatraivaca parisamÃpta eka÷ prayoga÷ /
sÃyaæprÃta÷kÃlÃntare tathaivÃpara÷ sauryeca nimittasyÃnatideÓÃnna yÃvajjÅvaæ prayoga iti spa«ÂatvÃnnoktam //
#<
iti prathamaæ yÃvajjÅvanimittatvÃdhikaraïam //>#
---------------- #<<B1>># (2 adhikaraïam / ) (a.2 pÃ.4 adhi.2) #<nÃma /
agnihotrÃdau satsvapi bhedakapramÃïe«u na karmabheda÷ /
bhedakapramÃïairhi svavÃkyasya karmotpattiparatvÃvagaterutpannasyotpattyayogÃtkarmÃntaratvasiddhi÷ /
prak­te tÆktapramÃïairutpattiparatvÃvagame 'pi puru«abhedÃttattacchÃkhÃdhyÃyipuru«Ãn pratyekasyaiva karmaïa÷ sarvatrotpattisaæbhavÃnna karmabheda÷ /
nahi sarvaÓÃkhÃ÷ sarvapuru«airadhyeyÃ÷, svÃdhyÃyavidhau 'adhvaryuæ v­ïÅte' itivatsvÅyatvaikatvayorvivak«itatvenÃnekaÓÃkhÃdhyayanÃnupapatte÷ /
nacaivaæ vedÃntarasthaÓÃkhÃdhyayanasyÃpyanÃpatti÷ 'vedÃnadhÅtya' ityÃdivacanÃntarÃnurodhena vedatrayagataikaikaÓÃkhÃdhyayanasyaivÃvaÓyakatvÃvagate÷ /
ata eva vedabhede puru«ÃbhedÃdekatraivotpattiraparatra guïÃrthaæ Óravaïabhityatra niyÃmakaæ vak«yate /
vedaikatve tu pratiÓÃkhaæ puru«abhedÃt satyapi sarve«Ãmutpattiparatve na karmabheda÷ /
ata evaikasmin karmaïi viruddhÃnÃæ nÃnÃÓÃkhÃgatÃÇgÃnÃæ vikalpa÷ /
sa ca na tattatpuru«abhedena vyavasthita÷ /
tattadaÇgÃnÃæ tattadadhyetrarthatve pramÃïÃbhÃvena prakaraïÃcchruddhakratvarthatvÃvagate÷ /
aviruddhÃÇge«u samuccaya÷ /
ÓÃkhÃntarÅyÃÇgaj¤Ãnaæ ca kalpasÆtrÃdibhi÷ sulabham /
yattu 'bahnalpaæ và svag­hyoktaæ' ityÃdivacanantat sarvÃÇgopasaæhÃrÃsaæbhave 'nukalpavidhÃnÃrthamiti kaustubhe dra«Âavyam />#
tadevaæ ÓabdÃntarÃbhyÃsasaÇkhyÃsaæj¤ÃguïaprakaraïÃntarairnirÆpita÷ karmaïÃæ bheda÷ /
ata÷ paraæ te«Ãæ viniyogo nirÆpayi«yate // 2 // #<iti dvitÅyaæ ÓÃkhÃntarÃdhikaraïam //>#
iti ÓrÅkhaï¬adevaviracitÃyÃæ bhÃÂÂadÅpikÃyÃæ dvitÅyÃdhyÃyasya caturtha÷ pÃda÷ //
#<adhyÃyaÓca samÃpta÷ /># // / #<<B2>># (lak«aïÃnantarasaægatinirÆpaïam) pÆrvamutpattiprayogaviniyogabhedakatvenoktÃnÃæ «aïïÃæ pramÃïÃnÃæ nirÆpaïe k­te
saæpratyekavedagatanÃnÃÓÃkhÃgatakarmavidhi«u ÓabdÃntarasaæj¤ÃsaækhyÃnÃæ pramÃïÃnÃæ bhedakatvÃyoge 'pi saæbhavadbhedakatvÃnÃæ guïÃbhyÃsaprakaraïÃntarÃïÃæ
bhedakatvavicÃrÃllak«aïasaÇgatiæ tathÃnantarÃdhikaraïopanyastaviniyogabhedakatvasyÃpya- pavÃdÃdÃpavÃdikÅæ cÃnantarasaÇgatiæ spa«ÂatvÃttathà pÆrvapak«aæ
cÃtiphalgutvÃdanuktvodÃharaïapÆrvakaæ siddhÃntamevÃha #<---------- ÓÃkhÃbhedeneti >#//
ekavedagateti Óe«a÷ /
ataeva -------- vedÃntaragate "bhÆyastvenobhayaÓrutÅ"titÃrtÅyanyÃyena yatra vede dravyadevatÃÓravaïÃt rÆpalÃbhastatraivotpatti÷, netaratra, tatra guïÃrthaæ puna÷Óravaïamityarthasya
siddhÃntayi«yamÃïatvÃttatra bhedaÓaÇkÃnupapatternodÃharaïatvam /
ato yatrobhayatra rÆpalÃbhenotpattividhibhedasaæbhava÷, tatraiva bhedaÓaÇkotthÃnÃt te«ÃmevodÃharaïatvamityartha÷ /#<
satsvapÅti >#//
(saæj¤ÃÓabdÃntasaÇkhyÃnÃmabhedakatvepi abhyÃsaguïÃde÷ bhedakatvasaæbhavena pÆrvapak«a÷) yadapi kÃÂhakaæ kÃlÃpakamityÃdisaæj¤ÃyÃ÷ karmabhedakatvaæ sÆtrakÃreïoktam /
tatra tasyà granthaparatvena karmaparatvÃbhÃvÃt, vede 'nÃmnÃnenotpattigatatvÃbhÃvÃcca na bhedakatvasaæbhava÷, sÆtre tadupapÃdanantvabhyuccayamÃtreïa j¤eyam /
tathà ÓabdÃntarasyÃpi samÃnadhÃtvarthakatvÃt itaradhÃtvarthÃpek«ayà bhedakatvasya siddhÃnte 'pÅ«ÂatvÃnnabhedakatvam /
tathà saÇkhyÃyÃ÷ svasamavÃyibhedakatvÃccÃsaæbhava÷, evaæ saæj¤ÃÓabdÃntarasaÇkhyÃnÃmasaæbhave 'pyananyaparavidhipuna÷ÓravaïarÆpÃbhyÃsasya
aindrÃgnaikÃdaÓakapÃlatvÃdiguïÃvarodhe vacanÃntarÃmnÃtadvÃdaÓakapÃlatvÃdiguïÃntarasya niveÓÃyogÃt guïasya dÆrasthatvenÃsannidherupÃdeya- guïasÃmÃnyÃbhÃvÃcca
prakaraïÃntarasyaca bhedakatvasaæbhavÃbhiprÃyeïa bhedakapramÃïe«viti bahuvacanopÃdÃnaæ k­tam /
tadevopapÃdayati#< --------- bhedakapramÃïairhÅti >#//
(svÃdhyÃyasyÃdhyayanavidhyuddeÓyatvepi kalpyavidhÃvupÃdeyatvÃtsvÅyatvaikatvayorvivak«aïam) #<adhvaryuæ v­ïÅta itivaditi //
anenaca ----------># svÃdhyÃyasyÃdhyayanaæ pratyuddeÓyatvÃduddeÓyasvÃdhyÃyagataikatvÃvivak«ÃÓaÇkÃyÃ÷ yathaivÃdhvaryuæ v­ïÅte ityatra satyapyadhvaryoruddeÓyatve v­tenÃdhvaryuïÃ
svakÃryaæ kuryÃditi kalpyavidhÃvupÃdeyatayà ÓravaïÃdekatvavivak«Ã, tathehÃpyadhÅtena svÃdhyÃyenÃrthaj¤Ãnaæ bhÃvayediti kalpyaviniyogavidhau upÃdeyatvaÓravaïÃt tadvivak«eti
nirÃsa÷ sÆcita÷ /
svairadhÅyate 'sau svÃdhyÃya iti vyutpattyÃdhyÃyagatasvaparaæparÃgatapuru«aparigraharÆpasvÅyatvokte÷ svÅyatvetyuktam //
#<(svÃdhyÃya ityadhyÃyasya vedatvavyÃpyaÓÃkhÃparatvavyavasthÃpanam //)>#//
#<"anayà trayyà vidyayà lokaæ jayati" "vedÃnadhÅtya vedau và vedaæ vÃpi yathÃkrama" mityÃdiÓrutism­tibhirvedÃntaragataÓÃkhÃdhyayanasyÃbhyanuj¤ÃnÃt tadanurodhenÃdhyÃyapadamapi
­gvedatvÃdivyÃpyaÓÃkhÃ- parameva; tatraivaca svÅyatvaikatvayorviÓe«aïatvÃt /
­gvedatvÃdivyÃpyÃyà ekaikapitryÃdiparamparÃgatÃyÃ÷ ÓÃkhÃyà adhyayananiyamakaraïena tadvyÃpyaÓÃkhÃntarasyaivÃdhyayanavidhÃne 'pi na vedÃntaragatÃyÃstanniv­ttirityabhipretya
samÃdhatte>#---------- vedÃniti //
#<(vedabhede karmabheda÷ na ÓÃkhÃbheda ityupapÃdanam)># puru«ÃbhedÃditi //
#<vedabhedena tadadhyayanasya sarvapuru«Ãn pratyavirodhÃt tadgatavidhipuna÷ ÓravaïasyÃdhyet­bhedapuraskÃreïa j¤ÃnÃrthatvena parihÃrÃsaæbhavÃt ubhayotpattau prÃptÃyÃæ
bhÆyodharmÃmnÃnaæ yatra tatrotpattiritaratra guïÃrthaæ ÓravaïamityarthabhÆyastvaæ niyÃmakaæ t­tÅye vak«yata ityartha÷ /
evaæ yatra sÃmavede ekasyÃmeva ÓÃkhÃyÃæ pa¤caviæÓa«aÇviæÓÃkhyabrÃhmaïabhedastatrÃpyadhyet­bhedÃbhÃvÃdekatra vidhiraparatrÃnuvÃdo bÃdhakÃsattve, tadabhÃvetu
karmÃntaramevÃbhyÃsÃdityapi j¤eyam />#
utpattiparatveneti //
#<tattadadhyetÌn prati># #<aj¤Ãtotpattij¤Ãpakatayà vidhipuna÷Óravaïopapatterna karmabheda ityartha÷ //
evaæ vidhipuna÷ ÓravaïasyÃnyaparatvÃdabhyÃsasya bhedakatve niraste tenaivÃnupasthitirÆpaprakaraïÃntarasya pramÃt­bhedenotpattyÃk«epakatve 'pi bhedÃk«epakatvÃbhÃvÃt
bhedakatvÃsiddhimabhipretyÃvaÓi«Âaæ guïak­tabhedaæ nirasitumÃha># -------- ataeveti //
#<yato 'dhyet­bhedena dvayorapyutpattiparatvÃt naikatarasyotpattiÓi«ÂatvamutpannaÓi«Âatvaæ vÃ, ata eva ekatareïaikatarasya bÃdhÃyogÃdekÃrthatve sati vrÅhiyavayoriva vikalpa ityartha÷
/
kÃÂhakÃdisamÃkhyÃnÃæ ÓÃkhÃsviva karmaïyapi prayogÃt tÃbhirÃdhvaryavÃdisamÃkhyÃvat puru«aviÓe«aniyamopapattyÃÓaÇkÃmabhipretya pariharati># ---------- saceti //
#<karmaïi prayogasya kaÂhaproktagranthavihitasaæbandhanimittakasya kart­tÃsaæbandhena kaÂhÃdiniyÃmakatvÃyogÃt na tena vyavasthÃsiddhirityartha÷ >#//
(ÓÃkhÃntarÅyÃÇgÃnu«ÂhÃnopÃyanirÆpaïam) #<nanu ---------># ÓÃkhÃntarÅyÃÇgÃnÃæ pradhÃnÃnÃæ vÃdhyayanavidhisiddhaj¤ÃnÃbhÃvÃt kathamanu«ÂhÃnopapattirityÃÓaÇkÃæ kratuvidhÅnÃæ
svakart­ÓÃkhÃrthavi«aye 'dhyayanavidhisiddhaj¤ÃnalÃbhena tadupÃyÃnÃk«epakatve 'pi ÓÃkhÃntarav­ttisvÃnu«ÂheyÃrthavi«aye tadvidhisiddhaj¤ÃnÃbhÃve sati tadupÃyÃk«epakatvopapatte÷
kalpasÆtrÃdhyayanena tajj¤ÃnasaæbhavenÃnu«ÂhÃnopapattyà nirasyati#< -------- ÓÃkhÃntarÅyeti >#//
(kratuvidhÅnÃæ ÓÆdrÃdhikÃrÃk«epakatvanirÃsa÷) ÓÆdrasya tadÃk«epasaæbhave 'pi tadupÃyÃdhyayanani«edhÃnna taditi vai«amyamiti bhÃva÷  //
#<(bahvalpaæ vetivacanavirodhaparihÃra÷)># nanu -------- #<ÓÃkhÃntarÅyÃÇgopasaæhÃre># #<"bahvalpaæ và svag­hyoktaæ yasya yÃvat prakÅrttitaæ /
tasya tÃvati ÓÃstrÃrthe k­te sarva÷ k­to bhave" diti vacanena svag­hyapadasyopalak«aïatayà svag­hyoktasya svaÓÃkhÃvagatasya># #<vÃnu«ÂhÃnaniyamavidhÃnÃt tena virodha
ityÃÓaÇkÃnirÃsÃyÃha># ---------- yattviti //
#<(pÆrvottarapak«aprayojananirÆpaïam)># #<prayojanaæ ÓÃkhÃntaragatÃÇgÃnÃæ na vikalpasamuccayau pÆrvapak«e /
siddhÃnte tÃviti pÆrvamevoktaprÃyatvÃnnoktam >#//
(adhyÃyÃrthopasaæhÃra÷ /
uttarÃdhyÃyÃrthasaægrahaÓca) ete«Ã¤ca pramÃïÃnÃmekavi«ayopanipÃte 'nadhigatÃrthagant­tvatadabhÃvarÆpaprÃmÃïyÃprÃmÃïyaviÓe«e 'pi virodhÃbhÃvÃnna balÃbalÃnve«aïaæ
kÃryamityabhipretya tadavaÓi«Âasya vicÃraïÅyasyÃbhÃvÃt adhyÃyÃrthamupasaæharati #<--------- tadevamiti >#//
ÓrotÌïÃmaudÃsÅnyavÃraïena sukhagrahaïÃrthamuttarÃdhyÃyÃrthaæ saæg­hïÃti #<-------- ata÷paramiti >#//
te«Ãmiti bahuvacanena ata÷ paramityanenaca sÆcitottarÃdhyÃyÃrthanirÆpaïaæ pratyetadadhyÃyÃrthanirÆpaïasya hetuhetumadbhÃvarÆpà saÇgatiruttaratra spa«ÂÅbhavi«yati //
#< // iti dvitÅyaæ ÓÃkhÃntarÃdhikaraïam //>#
iti kavimaï¬ana-khaï¬adevaÓi«ya-ÓuæbhubhaÂÂaviracitÃyÃæ bhÃÂÂadÅpikÃvyÃkhyÃyÃæ prabhÃvalyÃæ dvitÅyÃdhyÃyasya caturtha÷ pÃda÷ //
#<atra dvitÅyÃdhyÃyassamÃpta÷ //

adhyÃya÷ pÃda÷ adhikaraïasaækhyà Ãdito 'dhikaraïasaækhyÃ># 2 4 47 71 #<//>#