DHARMAKIRTI: VADANYAYA Input by Motoi Ono Text used: M.T. MUCH, Dharmakirtis Vadanyaya Teil I. Wien 1991. 旼컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴커 � THIS TEXT FILE IS FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY! � � COPYRIGHT AND TERMS OF USAGE AS FOR SOURCE FILE. � � � � Text converted to Classical Sanskrit Extended � � (CSX) encoding: � � � � description character = ASCII � � � � long a � 224 � � long A � 226 � � long i � 227 � � long I � 228 � � long u � 229 � � long U � 230 � � vocalic r � 231 � � vocalic R � 232 � � long vocalic r � 233 � � vocalic l � 235 � � long vocalic l � 237 � � velar n � 239 � � velar N � 240 � � palatal n � 164 � � palatal N � 165 � � retroflex t � 241 � � retroflex T � 242 � � retroflex d � 243 � � retroflex D � 244 � � retroflex n � 245 � � retroflex N � 246 � � palatal s � 247 � � palatal S � 248 � � retroflex s � 249 � � retroflex S � 250 � � anusvara � 252 � � anusvara (overdot) � 167 � � capital anusvara � 253 � � visarga � 254 � � (capital visarga 255) � � � � Other characters of the CSX encoding table are � � not included. Accents have been dropped in order � � to facilitate word search. � 읕컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴켸 Explanatory Remarks A number of five figures at the left side indicates the location of the key word in the basic texts. In the case of the SV, the HB and the VN, the first three figures indicate the page number, and the last two indicate the line number (for example, SV16026=SV 160,26; HB02314=HB 23,14; VN06110=VN 61,10). In the case of the PV and the NB, the second figure indicates the chapter number and the last three figures indicate the karika or sutra number (for example, PV02232=PV, the Pramanasiddhi-chapter v.232; NB03015=NB, the Pararthanumana-chapter sutra 15. In the case of the SP, the last two figures indicate the karika number (for example, SP00015=SP, v.15). 3. In this database, sentences are artificially divided into word-units, although they involve a phonetic fusion or union in the basic texts. Further, compound words are divided into their shortest constitutive elements (we use a hyphen to indicate that hyphenated elements originally form a compound word) with the following exceptions: 3.1. The prefixes a-, dur-, nih- remain undivided, irrespective of attachment to words or compound words. 3.2. Suffixes making an adverb, for example -vat, -vasa, are divided. But suffixes making a possessive adjective, for example -vat, -mat, remain undivided, and terms such as a numeral+ -dha/-vidha/-prakara remain also undivided. 3.3. Compound words with the suffixes -ta/-tva or -bhava/-bhuta fundamentally remain undivided. For example: karyakaranabhava/-bhuta/-ta. 3.4. Compound words with evam-, tat-, tatha-, para-, yatha-, su-, sva- in the wordhead fundamentally remain undivided. For example: evamjatiya, tadutpatti, tathakrta, paratantra, yathartha, yathasvam, sujnanatva, svabhava. 3.5. Some compound words which are regarded as terminology remain also undivided. For example: agnihotra, ayogavyavaccheda, arthapatti, padartha, paramartha, prasajyapratisedha, viruddhavyabhicarin, samanantarapratyaya, samtanaparinama, samanyalaksana, svabhavapratibandha. 4. Those terms whose wordhead is subject to the Sandhi rules (for example, -d dhetu-) are cited in their original form (for example, -d *hetu-) for the sake of using this database to make an KWIC index. 1. August. 1997 / Tsukuba Motoi ONO Note: This database is quite a tentative one, and I must admit that there are a lot of errors and defects in this version. I would appreciate it very much if the user would point out any errors in this version so that we can make a better new version in the future. E-mail: ono@logos.tsukuba.ac.jp ************************************************************************* 00101 nama� samantabhadr�ya. 00102 ny�yav�dinam api v�de�u asad-vyavasth�-upany�sai� �a�h� 00103 nig�h�anti, tan-ni�edha-artham idam �rabhyate. 00104 as�dhana-a�ga-vacanam ado�a-udbh�vana� dvayo� / 00105 nigrahasth�nam, anyat tu na yuktam iti na i�yate //1// 00106 i亢asya arthasya siddhi� s�dhanam, tasya nirvartakam 00107 a�gam, tasya avacanam tasya a�gasya anucc�ra�a� v�dino 00108 nigraha-adhikara�am, tad abhyupagamya apratibhay� t余鰍�bh�v�t, 00109 s�dhana-a�gasya asamarth�d v�. 00110 trividham eva hi li�gam apratyak�asya siddher a�gam, 00111 svabh�va� k�ryam anupalabdha� ca. tasya samarthana� 00112 s�dhyena vy�pti� pras�dhya dharmi�i bh�va-s�dhanam, 00113 yath� yat sat k�takam v�, tat sarvam anityam, yath� gha�a-�di�, 00114 san k�tako v� �abda iti. atra api na ka�cit krama- 00115 niyama�, i亢a-artha-siddher ubhayatra avi�e咸t. dharmi�i pr�k 00116 sattva� pras�dhya pa�c�d api vy�pti� pras�dhyata eva 00117 yath� san �abda� k�tako v�, ya� ca evam, sa sarvo anitya�, 00118 yath� gha�a-�dir iti. 00201 atra vy�pti-s�dhana� viparyaye b�dhaka-pram性a-upadar�anam. 00202 yadi na sarva� sat k�taka� v� pratik�a�a-vin成i 00203 sy�t, ak�a�ikasya kramayaugapady�bhy�m arthakriy�-ayog�d 00204 arthakriy�-s�marthya lak�a�ato niv�ttam ity asad eva sy�t. 00205 sarva-s�marthya-up�khy� viraha-lak�a�a� hi nirup�khyam iti. 00206 eva� s�dhanasya s�dhya-viparyaye b�dhaka-pram性a-anupadar�ane 00207 virodha-abh�v�d asya viparyaye v�tter adar�ane api 00208 san k�tako v� sy�n nitya� ca ity aniv�ttir eva �a�k�y筬. tato 00209 vyatirekasya sandeh�d anaik�ntika� sy�d hetv�bh�sa�. 00210 na apy adar�ana-m�tr�d vy�v�tti�, viprak敖�e�v asarva-dar�ino 00211 adar�anasya abh�va-as�dhan�t, arv�gdar�anena sat�m api ke咸�cid 00212 arth�n�m adar�an�t. 00213 b�dhaka� puna� pram性am, yatra kramayaugapadya-ayoga�, 00214 na tasya kvacit s�marthyam, asti ca ak�a�ike sa iti 00215 pravartam�nam as�marthyam asal-lak�a�am �kar�ati. tena 00216 yat sat k�taka� v� tad anityam eva iti sidhyati, t�vat� ca s�dhana 00217 dharma-m�tra-anvaya� s�dhya-dharmasya, svabh�vahetu- 00218 lak�a�a� ca siddha� bhavati. 00219 atra apy adar�anam apram性ayata� kramayaugapadya-ayogasya 00301 eva as�marthyena vy�pty-asiddhe� p�rvakasya api hetor 00302 avy�pti�. iha api puna� s�dhana-upakrame anavasth�-prasa�ga 00303 iti cet. na, abh�va s�dhanasya adar�anasya aprati�edh�t. yad 00304 adar�ana� viparyaya� s�dhayati heto� s�dhya-viparyaye, 00305 tad asya viruddha-pratyupasth�pan�d b�dhaka� pram性am 00306 ucyate. eva� hi sa hetu� s�dhya-abh�ve asan sidhyet, yadi 00307 tatra pram性avat� sva-viruddhena b�dhyeta. anyath� tatra 00308 asya b�dhaka-asiddhau sa嚆ayo durniv�ra�. na ca sarva-anupalabdhir 00309 bh�vasya b�dhik�. tatra s�marthya� krama-akrama 00310 yogena vy�pta� siddham, prak�ra-antara-abh�v�t. tena vy�paka- 00311 anupalabdhir ak�a�ike s�marthya� b�dhata iti 00312 kramayaugapadya-ayogasya s�marthya-abh�vena vy�pti-siddher 00313 na anavasth�-prasa�ga�. 00314 eva� svabh�vahetu-prayoge�u samarthita� s�dhana-a�ga� 00315 bhavati. tasya asamarthana� s�dhana-a�ga-avacana� tad-v�dina� 00316 par�jaya-sth�nam �rabdha-artha-apras�dhan�t, vastuta� 00317 samarthasya hetor up�d�ne api s�marthya-apratip�dan�t. 00318 k�ryahet�v api s�dhana-a�gasya samarthanam, yat k�rya- 00319 li�ga� k�ra�asya s�dhan�ya up�d�yate, tasya tena saha k�ryak�ra�abh�va- 00401 pras�dhana� bh�va-abh�va-s�dhana-pram性�bhy�m. 00402 yath� idam asmin sati bhavati. satsv api tad-anye�u 00403 samarthe�u tad-hetu�u tad-abh�ve na bhavati iti. eva� hy 00404 asya asandigdha� tat-k�ryatva� samarthita� bhavati. 00405 anyath� kevala� tad-abh�ve na bhavati ity upadar�ane 00406 anyasya api tatra abh�ve sandigdham asya s�marthyam. anyat 00407 tatra samartham, tad-abh�v�t tan na bh�tam. etan-niv�ttau 00408 punar niv�ttir yad�cch�-sa�v�da�, m�t�-viv�ha-ucita-de�a-janma� 00409 pi出a kharj�rasya de�a-antare�u m�t�-viv�ha-abh�ve 00410 abh�va-vat. 00411 eva� samarthita� tat tat-k�rya� sidhyati. siddha� 00412 sat sva-sambhavena tat-sambhava� s�dhayati. k�ryasya k�ra�a- 00413 avyabhic�r�t. avyabhic�re ca sva-k�ra�ai� sarva-k�ry性盛 00414 sad惡o ny�ya�. evam asamarthana� k�ryahet�v api s�dhana- 00415 a�ga-avacana� tad-v�dina� par�jaya-sth�nam, asamarthite 00416 tasmin k�ryatva-asiddher artha-antarasya tadbh�va-apratibaddha- 00417 svabh�vasya bh�ve tadbh�va-niyama-abh�v�d �rabdha-artha- 00418 asiddhe�, vastuta� k�ryasya apy up�d�ne tad-apratip�dan�t. 00420 anupalabdh�v api pratipattur upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya 00421 anupalabdhi-s�dhana� samarthanam, t�d惡y� eva anupalabdher 00422 asad-vyavah�ra-siddhe�, anupalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya 00423 pratipatt�-pratyak�a-upalabdhi-niv�tt�v apy abh�va-asiddhe�. 00501 tatra upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pti� svabh�va-vi�e�a� k�ra�a-antara- 00502 s�kalya� ca. svabh�va-vi�e�o yan na trividhena 00503 viprakar�e�a viprak敖�am, yad an�tma-r�pa-pratibh�sa-vivekena 00504 pratipatt�-pratyak�a-pratibh�sa-r�pam. t�d惡a� satsv 00505 anye�u upalambha-pratyaye�u tath� anupalabdho asad-vyavah�ra- 00506 vi�aya�. tato anyath� sati li�ge sa嚆aya�. 00507 atra api sarvam eva�vidham asad-vyavah�ra-vi�aya iti 00508 vy�pti�, kasyacid asato abhyupagame tal-lak�a�a-avi�e咸t; na 00509 hy eva�vidhasya asattv�n abhyupagame anyatra tasya yoga�. 00510 na hy eva�vidhasya sata� satsv anye�u upalambha-k�ra�e�v 00511 anupalabdhi�. anupalabhyam性a� tv �d惡a� na asti ity et�vanm�tra- 00512 nimitto ayam asad-vyavah�ra�, anyasya tan-nimittasya 00513 abh�v�t. 00514 sarva-s�marthya-viveko nimittam iti cet, evam etat tasya eva 00515 sarva-s�marthya-vivekina eva� prat�ti�, anyasya tat-pratipatty- 00516 up�ya-abh�v�t. tat-pratipattau ca saty�m asad-vyavah�ra 00517 iti ida� tan-nimittam ucyate. 00518 buddhi-vyapade�a-arthakriy�bhya� sad-vyavah�ro viparyaye 00519 ca asad-vyavah�ra iti cet, bhavati buddher yathokta-pratibh�s�y筬 00520 sad-vyavah�ra�, viparyaye asad-vyavah�ra�. 00521 pratyak�a-avi�aye tu sy�l li�gaj�y� api kuta�cit sad-vyavah�ra�. 00522 asad-vyavah�ras tu tad-viparyaye anaik�ntika�, viprak敖�e 00523 arthe pratipatt�-pratyak�asya anyasya v� pram性asya 00524 niv�tt�v api sa嚆ay�t. 00601 na ca sarve buddhi-vyapade妬s tad-bheda-abhedau v� vastu- 00602 satt盛 vastu-bheda-abheda-satt盛 v� s�dhayanti, asatsv api 00603 katha�cid at�ta-an�gata-�di�u n�n�-eka-arthakriy�k�ri�u v� arthe�u 00604 tad-bh�va sth�pan�ya n�n�-ek�tma-abh�ve api n�n�-eka-r�p性盛 00605 v�tte�, r�j� mah�-sammata� prabhavo r�java嚆asya, �a�kha� 00606 cakravartt� mah�-sammata-nirmitasya y�pasya utth�payit�, 00607 �a�a-vi咸�am, r�pa� sanidar�ana� sapratigham, 00608 gha�a� ca iti. na hi sanidar�ana-�di �abd� n�n�-vastu-vi�ay� ekatra 00609 upasa�h�r�t. 00610 n�n�-vi�ayatve apy ekatra upasa�h�ras tan-nimitt�n�n tatra 00611 samav�y�d iti cet, �y�se vata aya� tapasv� pad�rtha� patito 00612 aneka-sambandhinam upak�tya-aneka� �abdam �tmani tebhya� 00613 sam成a�san. sa yai� �akti-bhedair aneka� sambandhinam 00614 upakaroti tair eva aneka� �abda� ki� na utth�payati. 00615 eva� hy anena para�para-anus�ra-pari�rama� parih�to 00616 bhavati n�n�-�abda-utth�pana as�marthye n�n�-sambandhy- 00617 upak�ro api m� bh�t, anupak�re hi te咸� tat-sambandhit� 00618 api na sidhyati. 00619 gha�a ity api ca r�pa-�daya eva bahava eka-arthakriy�k�ri�a 00620 eka-�abda-v�cy� bhavantu, kim artha-antara-kalpanay�. 00621 bahavo api hy eka-artha-k�ri�o bhaveyu� cak�ur-�di-vat. tat-s�marthya- 00622 sth�pan�ya tatra eka-�abda-niyogo api sy�d iti yukta� 00623 pa�y�ma�. na ca ni�prayojan� lokasya arthe�u �abda-yojan�. 00624 tatra ye arth筬 saha p�thag v� eka-prayojan�s te咸� tadbh�va- 00625 sth�pan�ya hy eka-�abdo niyujyate yadi, ki� sy�t. tad-arthakriy�- 00701 �akti-sth�pan�ya niyuktasya samud�ya-�abdasya eka- 00702 vacana-virodho api na asty eva. sahit�n盛 s� �aktir ek� na 00703 pratyekam iti samud�ya-�abda ekasmin samud�ye v�cye 00704 eka-vacana� gha�a iti. j�ti �abde�v arth�n盛 pratyeka� 00705 sahit�n盛 ca �akter n�n�-ek� ca �aktir iti, n�n�-eka-�akti-vivak咸y盛 00706 bahu-vacanam eka-vacana� ca icch�to v�k咸 v�k�a iti 00707 sy�t, yady e�a niyamo bahu�v eva bahu-vacanam, ekasminn 00708 eka-vacanam iti. asm�kan tu s盛ketike�v arthe�u sa�keta- 00709 va妬d v�ttir ity anabhinive�a eva. 00710 n�n�-eko r�pa-�dir eka-�abda-utth�pane �akta iti cet, ki� vai 00711 puru�a-v�tter anapek咸� �abd�n arth筬 svayam utth�payanti, 00712 �hosvit puru�air �abd� vyavah�ra-artham arthe�u 00713 niyujyante. svayam utth�pane hi bh�va-�aktir a�aktir v� cintyeta, 00714 na ca tad yuktam. puru�ais te咸� niyoge yathe亢a� 00715 niyu쨓�rann iti kas tatra up�lambha�, nimitta� ca niyogasya 00716 uktam eva. api ca yadi na r�pa-�d�n�m ekena �abdena sambandha�, 00717 katham ekena e咸m 成raya-abhimatena dravye�a 00718 sambandha iti kevalam ayam asad-bh�ta-abhinive�a eva. 00719 na vayam eka-sambandha-virodh�d eka� �abda� na icch�ma�, 00720 api tv abhinn�n盛 r�pa-�d�n盛 gha�a-kambala-�di�u n�n�- 00721 arthakriy�-�abda-virodh�t ta eka-r�p筬 samud�ya-antara-asambh�vin�m 00722 arthakriy�m eva na kuryu�. tena tat-prak成an�ya ekaikena 00723 api �abdena na ucyeran. bhavatu n�ma kasyacid aya� 00724 v西cch� bhaveyur eka-r�p� r�pa-�daya� sarva-samud�ye�v iti. 00725 kim ida� paraspara-vivikta-r�pa pratibh�sa-adhiyak�a-dar�anam 00726 en�m upek�ate. ani亢a� ca ida� r�pa-�d�n盛 pratisamud�ya� 00727 svabh�va-bheda-upagam�t. 00801 yady anya eva r�pa-�dibhyo gha�a iti eka� sy�t, 00802 ki� sy�t. astu, pratyak�asya sato ar�pa-�di-r�pasya tad-vivekena buddhau 00803 svar�pe�a pratibh�sena kim �vara�am. pratibh�sam�n成 00804 ca vivekena pratyak咸 arth� d惡yante ap�thagde�atve 00805 api gandha-rasa-�daya�, v�ta-�tapa-spar�a-�daya� ca eka-indriya-gr�hyatve 00806 api. idam eva ca pratyak�asya pratyak�atvam, yad 00807 an�tma-r�pa-vivekena svar�pasya buddhau samarpa�am. 00808 aya� punar gha�o am�lya-d�na-kray�, ya� svar�pa� ca na upadar�ayati 00809 pratyak�at盛 ca sv�kartum icchati. etena buddhi- 00810 �abda-�dayo api vy�khy�t� yadi tais tat-s�dhanam i�yate. na ca 00811 pratyak�asya anabhibhave r�pa-anupalak�a�am, yena tat-s�dhan�ya 00812 li�gam ucyate. apratyak�atve apy apram性asya satt�- 00813 upagamo na yukta�. tan na r�pa-�dibhyo anyo gha�a�. eva� 00814 t�van na buddhi-vyapade妬bhy盛 satt�-vyavah�ra� satt�- 00815 bheda-abheda-vyavah�ro v� ata eva na tad-viparyay�d viparyaya�. 00817 arthakriy�tas tu satt�-vyavah�ra� sy�t, na satt�-bheda-abheda- 00818 vyavah�ra�, ekasya apy aneka-arthakriy�-dar�an�t, yath� 00819 prad�pasya vijㅰna-varti-vik�ra-jv�l�-antara-utp�dan�ni, anekasya 00820 api cak�ur-�der eka-vijㅰna-kriy�-dar�an�t. 00821 na br�mo arthakriy�-bheda-m�tre�a satt�-bheda iti, ki� 00822 tarhi ad敖�a-arthakriy�-bhedena. y� arthakriy� yasminn ad敖焌 00823 punar d惡yate s� satt�-bheda� s�dhayati, yath� m�dy ad敖焌 00824 saty udaka-dh�ra�a-�dy-arthakriy� gha�e d惡yam�n�, ad敖焌 api 00825 tantu�u pr�vara�a-�dy-arthakriy� pa�e d惡yata iti satt�- 00826 bheda�. 00901 sidhyati evam artha-antaram, tath� apy avayav� na sidhyati. 00902 yath�pratyaya� sa�sk�ra-santatau svabh�va-bheda-utpatter 00903 arthakriy�-bheda�, ara�i-nirmathana-avasth�-bhed�d iva agne� 00904 sth�la-kar實a-t寤a-k晟�ha-dahana-�akti-bheda�. tath� yath�pratyaya� 00905 svabh�va-bheda-utpattes tantv-�di�v arthakriy�-bheda�. 00906 etena buddhi-vyapade�a-bheda-abhedau vy�khy�tau. 00907 tatra yad uktam arthakriy�ta� satt�-vyavah�ra-siddhi�, 00908 viparyay�d viparyaya iti satyam etat. sa eva tu viparyayo 00909 anupalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pte�u na sidhyati. tatra punar idam 00910 anicchato apy �y�tam, yasya ida� s�marthyam upalabdhi-lak�a�a- 00911 pr�pta� san na upalabhyate, so asad-vyavah�ra-vi�aya� 00912 s�marthya-lak�a�atv�t sattvasya iti. tath� api ko ati�aya� p�rvak�d 00913 asya. na hi svabh�v�d artha-antara� s�marthyam, tasya 00914 upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya yo anupalambha� sa svabh�vasya 00915 eva iti p�rvak� eva iyam anupalabdhi�. tasm�d anena kvacit 00916 ke咸�cid asad-vyavah�ram abhyupagacchat� ato anupalambh�d 00917 abhyupagantavyo na v� kvacid vi�e�a-abh�v�t. so 00918 anyatra api tath�vidhe avi�i亢a iti so api tath� astv iti vy�pti�: 00919 sarva eva�vidho anupalabdho asad-vyavah�ra-vi�aya iti. 00920 na eva ka�cit kvacit katha�cid anupalabdho apy asad-vyavah�ra- 00921 vi�aya iti cet, sarvasya sarva-r�p性盛 sarvad� aniv�tte� 00922 sarva� sarvatra sarvad� samupayujyeta. ida� ca na 00923 sy�t: idam ata�, n�ta idam, iha idam, iha na idam, id�n�m 00924 idam, id�n尋 na idam, idam evam, ida� na evam iti, kasyacid 00925 api r�pasya katha�cid kvacit kad�cid viveka-hetor abh�v�t. 00926 ananvaya-vyatireka� vi�va� sy�t, bheda-abh�v�t. 01001 avasth�-niv�tti-prav�tti-bhedebhyo vyavasth� iti cet, nanu 01002 ta eva sarva-vi�ayasya asad-vyavah�rasya abh�v�n na sambhavanti, 01003 yatas tebhyo vyavasth� sy�t. kvacid vi�aye asad-vyavah�ra- 01004 upagame sa kuta iti vaktavyam. na hy anupalambh�d 01005 anyo vyavaccheda-hetur asti, vidhi-prati�edh�bhy盛 vyavacchede 01006 sarvad� anupalambhasya eva s�dhanatv�t. anupalambh�d 01007 eva tad-abhyupagame sa yatra eva asti sarvo asad-vyavah�ra- 01008 vi�aya iti vaktavyam, vi�e�a-abh�v�t. 01009 sarva-pram性a-niv�ttir anupalabdhi�. s� yatra so asad-vi�aya 01010 i亢a iti cet, sukum�ra-praj쨚 dev�n盛priyo na sahate 01011 pram性a-cint�-vyavah�ra-parikle�a� yena na atra �dara� k�tav�n. 01012 na hy anum�na-�di-niv�ttir abh�va� gamayati vyabhic�r�t, 01013 na sarva-pratyak�a-niv�ttir asiddhe�, na �tma-pratyak�a-avi�e�a- 01014 niv�ttir api viprak敖�e�u. tasm�t svabh�va-vi�e�o yata� 01015 pram性�n niyamena sad-vyavah�ra� pratipadyate, tan-niv�ttis 01016 tasya asad-vyavah�ra� s�dhayati, tat-svabh�va-satt�y�s tat- 01017 pram性a-sattay� vy�pte�. na ca upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya arthasya 01018 pratyak咸d anya-upalabdhir yena anum�n�d asya upalabdhi� 01019 sy�t. na ca tad-r�pa-anyath�bh�vam antare�a apratyak�at�- 01020 anyath�bh�ve ca tad eva na sy�t. 01021 api ca kuta idam amantra-o�adham indraj�la� bh�vena 01022 �ik�itam, yad ayam aj�ta-ana亢a-r�pa-ati�ayo avyavadh�na-ad�ra- 01101 sth�nas tasya eva tad-avasth� indriya-�der eva puru�asya kad�cit 01102 pratyak�o apratyak�a� ca, yena kad�cit asya anum�nam upalabdhi� 01103 kad�cit pratyak�a� kad�cid �gama�, etasminn eva anati�aye 01104 am實盛 prak�r性盛 virodh�t. 01105 na anati�aya eka-ati�aya-niv�tty� apara-ati�aya-utpatty� ca vyavah�ra- 01106 bheda-upagam�t. so ati�ayas tasya �tmabh�to ananvayo nivartam�na� 01107 pravartam�na� ca katha� na svabh�va-n�n�tvam 01108 �kar�ayati sukha-du�kha-vat. s�nvayatve ca k� kasya 01109 prav�ttir niv�ttir v� iti yat ki�cid etat. 01110 athav� yadi kasyacit svabh�vasya prav�tti-niv�tt� svayam 01111 abhyanujㅰyete, tad eva paro bruv性a� kim iti na anumanyate. 01112 tasya niranvaya-upajanana-vin成a-upagam�d iti cet, ko 01113 ayam anvayo n�ma bh�vasya janma-vin成ayo�. �akti�, s� asty 01114 eva pr�g api janmano nirodh�d apy �rdhvam. tena aya� na ap�rva� 01115 sarvath� j�yate, na p�rvo vin成yati iti. yadi s� sarvad� anati�ay� 01116 kim id�n�m ati�ayavat yat k�to aya� vyavah�ra-vibh�ga�. 01117 t� avasth� ati�ayavatya iti cet t� avasth筬 s� ca 01118 �akti�, kim eko bh�va �hosvin n�n�. eka� cet, katham id�n�m 01119 idam ekatra avibhakta-�tmani ni�pary�ya� paraspara-vy�hata� 01120 yok�yate: janma-ajanma niv�ttir aniv�ttir ekatva� n�n�tva� 01121 pratyak�at�-apratyak�at� arthakriy�-upayogo anupayoga� 01122 ca ity �di. 01201 asti pary�yo avasth� �aktir iti tena avirodha iti cet, vismara�a- 01202 鬪lo dev�n盛priya� prakara�a� na lak�ayati. �aktir 01203 avasth� ity eko bh�vo avibh�ga iti pak�e aya� virodha ukta�. 01204 atha asty anayor vibh�go na ka�cid virodha�, kevala� 01205 s�nvayau bh�vasya janma-vin成�v iti na sy�t, yasm�d yasya anvayo 01206 na tasya janma-vin成au yasya ca tau na tasya anvaya�. 01207 tayor abhed�d ado�a iti cet, anuttara� bata, do�a-sa�ka�am 01208 atrabhav�n d敖�i-r�ge�a prave�yam�no api na �tm�na� 01209 cetayati. abhedo hi n�ma-aikya� t�v iti ca bheda-adhi亢h�no 01210 bh�viko vyavah�ra�. niv�tti-pr�durbh�vayor aniv�tti-pr�durbh�vau 01211 sthit�v, asthitir ity �dika� n�n�tva-lak�a�a� ca 01212 katha� yojyate. e�a hi bh�v�n盛 bheda etad-viraha� ca abhedo 01213 yath� sukha-�di�u �akty- avasthayo� ca ek�tmani. anyath� 01214 bheda-abheda-lak�a�a-abh�v�d bheda-abhedayor avyavasth� sy�t 01215 sarvatra. 01216 tad�tmani pr�durbh�vo abheda�, viparyaye bheda�, yath� 01217 m�d-�tmani pr�durbhavato gha�asya tasm�d abheda�. 01218 bheda� ca viparyaye sukha-du�khayor iti, ida� bheda- 01219 abheda-lak�a�am, tena avirodha iti cet, na vai m�d�tmani 01220 gha�asya pr�durbh�va�, ki� tarhi m�d�tm� eva ka�cit 01221 gha�a�. na hy ekas trailokye m�d-�tm�, prativij쨅pti-pratibh�sa- 01222 bhed�t dravya-svabh�va-bhed�t. eva� hy asya api sukha-�di�u 01223 caitanye�u ca bheda-avagama� samartho bhavati, yady 01224 eva� bheda� sy�t. 01301 saty apy etasmin kasyacid �tmano anvay�d aikyam iti 01302 cet, sukha-�di�v apy aya� prasa�ga� caitanye�u ca. na ca gha�a- 01303 �di�v api sarva-�tman� anvayo avai�var�pya-sahotpatty-�di-prasa�g�t. 01304 na ca gha�a� m�d-�tm�na� ca ka�cid vivekena upalak�ayati. 01305 yena eva� sy�d idam iha pr�durbh�tam iti. na hy 01306 adhi亢h�na-adhi亢h�ninor vivekena anupalak�a�e eva� bhavati. 01307 na ca �akte� �akty-�tmani pr�durbh�va iti tasy筬 sv�tmano 01308 abhedo na sy�t. 01309 etena pari鎚ma� pratyukta�, yo api hi kalpayet, yo yasya 01310 pari鎚ma�, sa tasm�d abhinna iti, na hi �akter �tma-apari鎚ma 01311 iti, ki� ca idam ukta� bhavati pari鎚ma iti. avasthitasya 01312 dravyasya dharma-antara-niv�ttir dharma-antara-pr�durbh�va� 01313 ca pari鎚ma� yat tad dharma-antara� nivartate 01314 pr�durbhavati ca, ki� tat tad eva avasthita� dravya� sy�t. 01315 tato artha-antara� v� anya-vikalpa-abh�v�t. 01316 yadi tat tad eva, tasya avasth�na� na niv�tti-pr�durbh�v�v 01317 iti kasya t�v iti vaktavyam. avasthitasya dharma-antaram iti 01318 ca na sidhyati. na hi tad eva tasya anap成rita-vyapek�a-abheda� 01319 dharma-antara� bhavati. 01320 atha dravy�d artha-antara� dharma�, tad� tasya niv�tti- 01321 pr�durbh�v�bhy盛 na dravyasya pari�ati�. na hy artha-antaragat�bhy盛 01322 niv�tti-pr�durbh�v�bhy�m artha-antarasya pari�ati�, 01323 caitanye api prasa�g�t. 01401 dravyasya dharma iti ca vyapade�o na sidhyati sambandha- 01402 abh�v�t. na hi k�ryak�ra�abh�v�d anyo vastu-sambandho 01403 asti. na ca anayo� k�ryak�ra�abh�va�, svayam atad�tmano 01404 atat-k�ra�atv�t, dharmasya dravy�d artha-antara-bh�tatv�t. 01406 arth�ntaratve api dharma-k�ra�atve dharma-antarasya 01407 k�ryasya utp�dan�d dravyasya pari鎚ma iti i亢a� sy�t. tad aviruddham 01408 anyasya api, hetu-phala-sant�ne m�d-dravya-�khye p�rvak�n 01409 m�t-pi出a-dravy�t k�ra鎚d uttarasya gha�a-dravyasya 01410 k�ryasya utpattau m�d-dravya� pari�atam iti vyavah�rasya upagam�t. 01411 na ca dharmasya dravy�t tattv�nyatv�bhy�m anyo 01412 vikalpa� sambhavati, ubhayath� api na pari鎚ma�. 01413 na nirviveka� dravyam eva dharma�, na api dravy�d 01414 artha-antaram, ki� tarhi, dravyasya sa�nive�o avasth�-antaram, 01415 yath� a�gul�n盛 mu亢i�. na hy a�guly eva nirvivek� mu亢i�, 01416 pras�rit�n�m amu亢itv�t, na apy artha-antaram, p�thak-svabh�vena 01417 anupalabdher iti cet, na, mu亢er a�guli-vi�e�atv�t. a�gulya 01418 eva hi k成cin mu亢i�, na sarv筬. na hi pras�rit� a�gulyo 01419 nirviveka-svabh�v� mu亢y-a�gulya�, avasth�-dvaye api ubhaya- 01420 pratipatti-prasa�g�t. ya eva hi khalu viveka� svabh�vabh�ta�, 01421 sa eva vastu-bheda-lak�a�a� sukha-du�kha-vat. parabh�te 01501 ca viveka-utp�de a�gulya� pras�rit� eva upalabhyeran, na hi 01502 svaya� svabh�v�d acyutasya artha-antara-utp�de anyath�-upalabdhi�, 01503 atiprasa�g�t 01504 nanu ukta� na dravyam eva nirvivekam avasth�, na api 01505 dravy�d artha-antaram iti. uktam idam, na punar yuktam, na 01506 hi sato vastunas tattv�nyatve muktv� anya� prak�ra� sambhavanti, 01507 tayor vastuni paraspara-parih�ra-sthita-lak�a�atvena 01508 eka-ty�gasya apara-up�d�na-n�ntar�yakatv�t. a�gul實u puna� 01509 pratik�a�a-vin成in實v any� eva pras�rit筬, any� mu亢i�. 01510 tatra mu亢y-�di-�abd� vi�e�a-vi�ay筬, a�gul�-�abda� s�m�nya- 01511 vi�aya�, b�ja-a�kura-�di-�abda-vat vr�hy-�di-�abda-vac ca. tena a�gulya� 01512 pras�rit� na mu亢i�. 01513 tad yadi pr�g asad eva k�ra�e k�rya� bhavet, ki� na 01514 sarva� sarvasm�d bhavati. na hy asattve ka�cid vi�e�a iti. 01515 nanu sarvatra sarvasya sattve apy aya� tulyo do�a�. na hi 01516 sattve ka�cid vi�e�a�. vi�e�e v� sa vi�e�as traigu�y�d 01517 bhinna� sy�t, tadbh�ve vi�e�asya ananvay�t. sata� ca sarv�tman� 01518 ni�panna-avasth�y�m iva ki� j�yate. s�dhana-vaiphalya� 01519 ca, s�dhyasya kasyacid abh�v�t yasya kasyacid ati�ayasya 01520 tatra katha�cid asata utpattau, so ati�ayas tatra asan 01521 katha� j�yate. j�tau v� sarva� sarvasm�j j�yeta iti tulya� paryanuyoga�. 01601 na ati�ayas tatra sarvath� na asti, katha�cit sata eva bh�v�d 01602 iti cet, yath� na asti, sa prak�ras tatra asan katha� j�yeta. 01603 na ca sarvath� sata� ka�cij janma-artha ity uktam. 01604 asato api k�ryasya k�ra鎚d utp�de, yo yaj-janana-svabh�va�, 01605 tata eva tasya janma, na anyasm�d iti niyama�. 01606 tasya api sa svabh�va-niyama� sva-hetor ity an�di-bh�va-svabh�va- 01607 niyama�. 01608 api ca, yadi m�t-pi出e gha�o asti, katha� tad-avasth�y盛 01609 na pa�c�d-vad upalabdhi�, tad-arthakriy� v�. vyakter apr�durbh�v�d 01610 iti cet, tasya eva tad-arthakriy�-�di-bh�ve gha�atv�t, 01611 tad-r�pasya ca pr�g asattv�t, katha� gha�o asti. na hi r�pa-antarasya 01612 sattve r�pa-antaram asti. na ca r�pa-pratibh�sa-bhede vastv- 01613 abhedo yukta�, atiprasa�g�t. 01614 tasm�d ya upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pta-svabh�vo anupalabdha�, 01615 sa na asty eva. na hi tasya tat-svabh�va-sthit�v anupalabdhi�. 01616 tad-asthiti� ca atattva�. paraspara-svabh�va-asthitayor 01617 iva du�kha-sukhayor iti vy�ptir asad-vyavah�ra-ni�cayena 01618 anupalabdhi-vi�e�asya. 01619 tena anupalabdhy� kasyacid vyavaccheda� pras�dhayat� 01620 tasya yathokta-upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptir upadar�aniy�. upadar�ya- 01621 anupalabdhi-nirde�a� samarthana� svabh�va-anupalabdhau. 01622 vy�paka-anupalabdh�v api dharmayor vy�pyavy�pakabh�va� 01623 pras�dhya vy�pakasya niv�tti-pras�dhana� samarthanam. 01624 k�ra�a-anupalabdh�v api k�ryak�ra�abh�va� 01625 pras�dhya k�ra�asya niv�tti-pras�dhana� samarthanam. tad- 01626 viruddha-upalabdhi�v api dvayor viruddhayor ekasya viruddhasya 01627 upadar�ana� samarthanam. 01701 evam anupalabdhau s�dhana-a�gasya asamarthana� s�dhana- 01702 a�ga-avacana� tad v�dino nigrahasth�nam, asamarthane 01703 tasmin s�dhya-asiddhe�. 01704 athav� s�dhyate tena pare咸m aprat�to artha iti s�dhana� 01705 trir�pa-hetu-vacana-samud�ya�. tasya a�ga� pak�a-dharma- 01706 �di-vacanam. tasya ekasya apy avacanam as�dhana-a�ga-vacanam. 01707 tad api v�dino nigrahasth�nam tad-avacane hetu-r�pasya 01708 eva avacanena siddher abh�v�t. 01709 athav� tasya eva s�dhanasya yan na a�ga� pratijㅰ-upanaya- 01710 nigamana-�di, tasya as�dhana-a�gasya s�dhana-v�kye up�d�na� 01711 v�dino nigrahasth�nam, vyartha-abhidh�n�t. 01712 anvaya-vyatirekayor v� s�dharmyavati vaidharmyavati 01713 ca s�dhana-prayoga ekasya eva abhidh�nena siddher bh�v�t, 01714 dvit�yasya as�marthyam iti tasya apy as�dhana-a�gasya abhidh�na� 01715 nigrahasth�nam vyartha-abhidh�n�d eva. 01716 nanu ca vi�aya-upadar�an�ya pratijㅰ-vacanam as�dhana-a�gam 01717 apy upadeyam eva. na, vaiyarthy�t. asaty api pratijㅰ- 01718 vacane yathokt�t s�dhana-v�ky�d bhavaty eva i亢a-artha-siddhir 01719 ity ap�rthaka� tasya up�d�nam. yadi ca vi�aya-upadar�anam 01720 antare�a prat�ter anutpatti�, katha� na pratijㅰ s�dhana- 01721 avayava�. na hi pak�a-dharma-�di-vacanasya api prat�ti-hetu- 01722 bh�v�d anya� s�dhana-artha�. sa pratijㅰ-vacane api tulya iti 01723 katha� na s�dhanam. 01801 kevalasya as�marthy�d as�dhanatvam iti cet, tat tulya� 01802 pak�a-dharma-vacanasya api iti tad api na s�dhana-avayava� sy�t. 01803 na hi pak�a-dharma-vacan�t keval�t pratipatter utpatti�. 01804 etena sa嚆aya-utpatti� pratyukt�, pak�a-dharma-vacan�d api 01805 keval�d apradar�ite sambandhe sa嚆aya-utpatte�. tasm�d 01806 vyartham eva s�dhana-v�kye pratijㅰ-vacana-up�d�na� v�dino 01807 nigrahasth�nam. 01808 athav� s�dhanasya siddher yan na a�gam asiddho viruddho 01809 anaik�ntiko v� hetv�bh�sa�. tasya api vacana� v�dino 01810 nigrahasth�nam asamartha-up�d�n�t. 01811 tath� s�dhya-�di-vikalasya ananvaya-apradar�ita-anvaya-�der api 01812 d敖焌nt�bh�sasya as�dhana-a�gasya vacanam api v�dino nigrahasth�nam, 01813 asamartha-up�d�n�d eva. na hi tair heto� sambandha� 01814 �akyate pradar�ayitum, apradar�an�d as�marthyam. 01816 athav� siddhi� s�dhanam tad-a�ga� dharmo yasya arthasya 01817 viv�da-成rayasya v�da-prast�va-heto�, sa s�dhana-a�ga�. 01818 tad-vyatireke�a aparasya apy ajijㅰsitasya vi�e�asya 妬stra-成raya- 01819 vy�ja-�dibhi� prak�epo gho�a�a� ca para-vy�mohana-anubh晟a�a- 01820 �akti-vigh�ta-�di-heto�. tad apy as�dhana-a�ga-vacana� 01901 v�dino nigrahasth�nam, aprastuta-abhidh�n�t, tath� vi�e�a-sahitasya 01902 arthasya prativ�dino ajijㅰsitatv�t. jijㅰs�y�m ado�a�. 01903 jijㅰsita� punar arthasya anyasya prasa�ga-para�paray� 01904 ye�a panna-�din� bahi� prativ�dina� pr成nik�n盛 ca 01905 ny�yadar�in�m iti. ebhi� kath�-viccheda eva kara鰍ya�, na 01906 hi ka�cid artha� kvacit kriyam性a-prasa�ge na prayujyate, 01907 nair�tmyav�dinas tu tat-s�dhane n�tya-g�ty-�der api tatra 01908 prasa�g�t. 01909 yath� pratijㅰ-abhidh�na-p�rvaka� ka�cit kury�t. na asty 01910 �tm� iti vaya� bauddh� br�ma�. ke bauddh筬. ye buddhasya 01911 bhagavata� 妬sanam abhyupagat筬. ko buddho bhagav�n. 01912 yasya 妬sane bhadanta-a�vagho�a� pravrajita�. ka� punar 01913 bhadanta-a�vagho�a�. yasya r晟�ra-p�la� n�ma n葉akam. 01914 k�d惡a� r晟�ra-p�la� n�ma n葉akam iti prasa�ga� k�tv� 01915 n�ndyante tata� pravi�ati s�tradh�ra iti pa�hen n�tyed 01916 g�yec ca. prativ�d� ta� ca sarva-prasa�ga� na anukartu� 01917 samartha iti par�jita� sy�d iti. 01918 sabhya� s�dhu-sammat�n盛 vidu咸� tattva-cint�-prak�ra�. 01919 na ca eva� prastutasya paryavas�na� sambhavati, ani�caya- 01920 phalatv�d an�rambha eva v�dasya. 02001 katha� ca eva� jaya-par�jayau, prativ�dino apy ananubh晟a�asya 02002 eva�prak�rasya prasa�gasya vistare�a anubh晟a�a- 02003 vy�jena sambhav�d ani�citatv�c ca. tasm�t pratijㅰ-vacanam 02004 eva t�van na ny�yyam. kuta� punar tatra ajijㅰsita- 02005 vi�e�a-prasa�ga-upany�sas tad-vy�khy�-prasa�ga-vitatha-pral�pa� 02006 ca. sarva� ca aya� prak�ro durmatibhi� �a�hair ny�ya-s�marthyena 02007 artha-pratip�dane asamarthai� pravartita�. yath� 02008 puru�a-ati�aya-p�rvak�ni tanu-kara�a-bhuvana-�d�ni iti pratijㅰya 02009 tanu-kara�a-bhuvana-vy�khy�-vy�jena sakala-vai�e�ika-妬stra-artha- 02010 gho�a�am, nitya� �abdo anityo v� iti v�de dv�da�a-lak�a�a- 02011 prapa쨇a-prak成ana-妬stra-pra�etur jaimini-pratij쨅ta-tattva- 02012 nityat�-adhikara�a-�abda-gha�a-anyatara-sadvit�yo gha�a iti 02013 pratijㅰm uparacayya dv�da�a-lak�a�a-artha-vy�khy�nam. sarvo 02014 aya� durmat�n�m as�marthya-pracch�dana-up�ya�, na tu 02015 satyair asty upeta�, tattva-par�k咸y盛 phala-�di-pratisara�a- 02016 da出a-prayoga-�d�n�m ayuktatv�t. 02017 bhavaty eva n葉aka-�di-gho�a�e artha-antara-gaman�t par�jaya 02018 iti cet, anyasya apy ajijㅰsitasya ki� na bhavati. na hi 02019 asya api k�cid vivak�ita-s�dhya-dharma-siddhau n�ntar�yakat�. 02020 yath� hetu-pratyaya-p�ratantrya-lak�a�a-sa�sk�ra-du�khat�- 02021 �di-siddhim antare�a na anityat�-siddhi�, tath�vidhas tu 02022 dharma� p�thag anukto api s�dhya-dharme antarbh�v�t pak檻k�ta 02023 eva iti na p�thag asya upany�so vy�khy�na� v�. tasm�d 02101 eva�vidhasya api tad�n尋 prativ�din� ajijㅰsitasya arthasya 02102 pratijㅰy�m anyatra v� upany�so vy�khy�na� v� artha-antara- 02103 gaman�n nigrahasth�nam eva. tena jijㅰsita-dharma-m�tram 02104 eva s�dhana-a�ga� v�cyam. na prasa�ga upak�eptavya�, 02105 tad-upak�epe atiprasa�g�t. 02106 evam as�dhana-a�ga-vacana� v�dino nigrahasth�na� prativ�din� 02107 tath�bh�ve pratip�dite, anyath� dvayor ekasya api 02108 na jaya-par�jay�v iti. 02109 ado�a-udbh�vana� prativ�dino nigrahasth�nam. v�din� 02110 s�dhane prayukte abhyupagata-uttara-pak�o yatra vi�aye prativ�d� 02111 yad� na do�am udbh�vayati tad� par�jito vaktavya�. 02112 s�dhana-do咸� punar ny�natvam asiddhir anaik�ntikat� 02113 v�dina� s�dhayitum i亢asya arthasya viparyaya-s�dhanam 02114 a亢�da�a d敖焌nta-do�a� ca. te咸m anudbh�vanam apraty�yanam 02115 apratip�dana� prativ�dina� par�jaya-adhikara�am. 02116 tat puna� s�dhanasya nirdo�atv�t, sado�atve api prativ�dino 02117 ajㅰn�t pratip�dana-as�marthy�d v�. na hi du亢a-s�dhana-abhidh�ne 02118 api v�dina� prativ�dino apratip�dite do�e par�jaya- 02119 vyavasth�pan� yukt�, tayor eva paraspara-s�marthya-upagh�ta- 02120 apek�ay� jaya-par�jaya-vyavasth�pan�t. kevala� hetv�bh�s�d 02121 bh�ta-pratipatter abh�v�d apratip�dakasya jayo api na asty 02122 eva. na hi tattva-cint�y盛 ka�cic chala-vyavah�ra�. 02201 yady eva� ki� na par�jaya�, tattva-siddhi-bhra嚆�t. 02202 na anir�kara鎚t. nir�kara�a� hi tasya anyena par�jaya�, na 02203 siddhy-abh�va�, pratiyogy-anapek�a鎚t siddhy-abh�vasya, 02204 s�dhana-abh�ve asaty api pratiyogini bh�v�t. pratiyogina� ca 02205 tan-nir�kara�e as�marthy�t par�jayasya anutpatter apar�jaya�. 02206 tasm�d ayam asamartha-s�dhana-abhidh�yy api pare�a 02207 tath�bh�ve apratip�dite apar�jito vaktavya�. 02208 chala-vyavah�re api vijig實嶪盛 v�da iti cet, na, durjana- 02209 vipratipatty-adhik�re sat盛 妬stra-prav�tte�. na hi para-anugraha- 02210 prav�tt� mithy�-pral�pa-�rambha-�tma-utkar�a-para-pa�sana- 02211 �d�n asad-vyavah�r�n upadi�anti. na ca para-vipa�sanena 02212 l�bha-satk�ra-�loka-up�rjana� sat�m �c�ra�. na api tath�-prav�ttebhya� 02213 sva-hasta-d�nena pr性in�m upat�pana� sat-sammat�n盛 02214 妬strak�ra-sabh�sad盛 yuktam. na ca ny�ya-妬str性i 02215 sadbhir l�bha-�dy-up�rjan�ya pra鰍yante. tasm�n na yoga-vihita� 02216 ka�cid vijig實u-v�do n�ma. para-anugraha-prav�tt�s tu santo 02217 vipratipanna� pratip�dayanto ny�yam anusareyu� sat- 02218 s�dhana-abhidh�nena bh�ta-do�a-udbh�vanena v�, s�k�i-pratyak�a� 02219 tasya eva anuprabodh�ya. tad eva ny�ya-anusara�a� sat盛 02220 v�da�, ukta-ny�ye tattva-arth� cet pratipadyeta, tad-apratipatt�v 02221 apy anyo na pratipadyeta iti. 02222 tattva-rak�a�a-artha� sadbhir upahartavyam eva chala-�di 02223 vijig實ubhir iti cet, na, nakha-cape�a-�astra-prah�ra-�d�pana-�dibhir 02224 api iti vaktavyam. tasm�n na jy�y�n aya� tattva-rak�a�a- 02301 up�ya�. s�dhana-prakhy�pana� sat盛 tattva-rak�a�a-up�ya� 02302 s�dhana-�bh�sa-d余a�a� ca, tad-abh�ve mithy�-pral�p�d atra 02303 para-upat�pa-vidh�ne api tattva-aprati亢h�pan�t. anyath� api ny�ya- 02304 upavar�ane vidvat-prati亢h�n�t. tasm�t para-anugrah�ya 02305 tattva-khy�pana� v�dino vijaya�, bh�ta-do�a-dar�anena mithy�- 02306 pratipatti-nivartana� prativ�dina�. 02307 athav� yo na do�a� s�dhanasya tad-bh�ve api v�din� s�dhayitum 02308 i亢asya arthasya siddher vigh�ta-abh�v�t, tasya udbh�vana� 02309 prativ�dino nigraha-adhikara�am, mithy�-uttara-abhidh�n�t. 02311 yath� s�dhyatay� ani亢o api v�dino dharma�, 妬stra-upagam�t 02312 s�dhya iti tad-vipary�sena virodha-udbh�vanam. na asty 02313 �tm� iti tava pratijㅰ-padayor virodha iti pratijㅰ-do�a-udbh�vanam. 02314 prayatn�nantar�yaka� �abdo anitya� prayatn�nantar�yakatv�d 02315 iti hetor dharma-vi�e�atv�t pratijㅰrthaikade�a ity 02316 asiddha-udbh�vanam, sarv性i s�dharmya-vaidharmya-sama-�d�ni 02317 j�ty-uttar性i ity evam-�der do�asya udbh�vanam ado�a-udbh�vanam. 02319 tasya v�din� do�a-�bh�satve prakhy�pite prativ�d� par�jito 02320 vaktavya�, p�rvapak�e s�dhanasya nirdo�atv�t. do�avati 02321 puna� s�dhane na dvayor ekasya api jaya-par�jayau, tattva- 02322 aprakhy�pan�t ado�a-udbh�van�c ca. apratipak咸y盛 ca 02323 pak�a-siddhau k�t�y盛 jet� bhavati. 02401 tasm�j jig實at� sva-pak�a� ca sth�pan�ya� para-pak�a� ca 02402 nir�kartavya�. nirdo�e s�dhana-abhidh�ne api v�dina� prativ�din� 02403 do�a-�bh�sa udbh�vite, d余a�a-�bh�satva-khy�pana eva 02404 jaya-par�jayau, na anyath�, bh�vatas tattva-abhidh�ne api pratipak�a- 02405 nir�kara�ena tattvasya prakhy�pana-as�marthy�t. na 02406 prativ�dino apy atra, bh�vato mithy�-pratipatter iti. 02407 ida� ny�yya� nigrahasth�na-lak�a�am uktam asm�bhi�. 02501 anyat tu na yuktam iti na i�yate. 02502 yatra ida� yathokta� nigrahasth�na-lak�a�a� na asti tasya 02503 nigrahasth�natvam ayuktam iti na uktam asm�bhi�. 02504 pratid敖焌nta-dharma-abhyanujㅰ-sva-d敖焌nte pratijㅰh�nir 02505 nigrahasth�nam iti atra bh晟yak�ra-mata� d余ayitv� v�rttikak�ro 02506 aya� sthita-pak�am �ha. tam eva br�ma�. 02507 pratid敖焌ntasya yo dharmas ta� yad� sva-d敖焌nte 02508 abhyanuj�n�ti nig�h�to veditavya�. tatra d敖�a� ca as�v ante ca 02509 vyavasthita iti d敖焌nta�. sva-d敖焌nta� sva-pak�a�, pratid敖焌nta� 02510 pratipak�a�. pratipak�asya dharma� sva-pak�e 02511 abhyanuj�nan par�jita�, yath� anitya� �abda aindriyakatv�d 02512 iti br�van pratipak�a-v�dini s�m�nyena pratyavasthite �ha 02513 yadi s�m�nyam aindriyaka� nitya� �abdo apy evam astv iti 02514 e咸 pratijㅰh�ni� pr�k-pratijㅰtasya �abda-anityatvasya ty�g�d 02515 iti. 02516 atra upagata-pratijㅰ-ty�g�t pratijㅰh�nau vi�e�a-pratiniyama� 02517 ki� k�to anena prak�re�a pratijㅰ� tyajata� pratijㅰh�nir 02518 iti. sambhavati hy anyena api prak�re�a hetu-do�a-udbh�vana- 02519 �din� pratipak�a-s�dhana-abhidh�nena ca sva-pak�a-parity�ga� 02520 para-pak�a-upagama� ca. idam eva ca pratijㅰh�ne� 02521 pradh�na� nimittam eva� pratip�ditena pratijㅰ h�tavy� 02522 h�nau ca par�jaya iti. 02601 ida� punar asambaddham eva s�m�nya� nityam aindriyakam 02602 ity ukte �abdo apy evam astv iti. ka� svastha-�tm� svayam 02603 aindriyakatv�d anitya� �abdo gha�avad iti bruvan s�m�nyena 02604 upadar�ana-m�tre�a nitya� �abda� pratipadyate. 02605 s�m�nyasya api nityasya aindriyakatve apy anitye gha�e dar�an�t 02606 sa嚆ayita� sy�t. 02607 j姓y�t pratipadyeta api iti cet, tath� api ki� s�m�nyasya upadar�anena. 02608 evam eva nitya� �abda iti vaktavya� ja�asya 02609 pratipattau vic�ra-abh�v�t. 02610 na ca nitya-s�m�nya-upadar�anena tad-dharma� �abde pratipadyam�ne 02611 pratipak�a-dharma-abhyanujㅰto bhavati, anitya� 02612 �abda iti ca vadato nitya� �abda ity 西jasa� pratipak�a� 02613 sy�t, na nitya� s�m�nyam iti. 02614 tasm�d aindriyakatvasya nitya-anitya-pak�a-v�tter vyabhic�r�d 02615 as�dhana-a�gasya up�d�n�n nigraha-arha�, na pratipak�a- 02616 dharma-anuj쨅y� anena prak�re�a pratijㅰh�ne�. 02617 pratijㅰ-artha-prati�edhe dharma-vikalp�t tad-artha-nirde�a� 02618 pratijㅰ-antaram pratijㅰto artho anitya� �abda aindriyakatv�d 02619 ity eva, tasya hetu-vyabhic�ra-upadar�anena prati�edhe 02620 k�te dharma-bheda-vikalp�t s�m�nya-gha�ayo� sarvagatatva- 02701 asarvagatatva-dharma-vikalpena pratijㅰ-antara� karoti, yath� 02702 gha�o asarvagato anitya eva �abdo apy asarvagato anitya 02703 iti. etat pratijㅰ-antara� n�ma nigrahasth�na� s�dhana-s�marthye 02704 apy aparijㅰn�t. sa hi p�rvasy� anitya� �abda iti 02705 pratijㅰy筬 s�dhan�ya uttar�m asarvagata� �abda iti pratijㅰm 02706 �ha. tad-dar�an�ya tad-artha-nirde�a ity �ha. tad-artha� 02707 p�rva-ukta-s�dhya-siddhy-artha uttara-pratijㅰ-nirde�as tad-artha- 02708 nirde�a�. na ca pratijㅰ pratijㅰ-antara-s�dhane samarth� 02709 iti nigrahasth�nam. 02710 atra api na evam-bruvat� pratijㅰ-antara� p�rva-pratijㅰ-s�dhan�ya 02711 ukta� bhavati, ki� tarhi vi�e�a�am aindriyakatvasya 02712 heto� s�m�nye v�tty� vyabhic�ra udbh�vite asarvagatatve 02713 saty aindriyakatvasya hetor vi�e�a�a-up�d�ne vyabhic�ra� 02714 pariharati. na puna� pratijㅰ-antaram �ha, asarvagatatvasya 02715 �abde siddhatv�t pratijㅰy成 ca s�dhya-nirde�a-lak�a�atv�t. 02717 yad apy ukta� p�rva-pratijㅰ-s�dhan�ya uttar盛 pratijㅰm 02718 �ha iti tad apy ayuktam. na hi pratijㅰ pratijㅰ-s�dhan�ya 02719 ucyam�n� pratijㅰ-antara� bhavati, ki� tarhi hetv-�der ananyatama�. 02720 s�dhya-s�dhan�ya up�d�n�t s�dhana-nirde�a� sa 02801 sy�n na s�dhya-nirde�a�. ud�hara�a-s�dharmya-�de� ca hetu-lak�a�asya 02802 asarvagatve bh�v�t pratijㅰ-lak�a�asya ca abh�v�t, hetutvam 02803 asarvagatve prayukta� na pratijㅰ-antaratvam. atyanta- 02804 asambaddha� ca ida� pratijㅰ� pratijㅰ-s�dhan�ya �ha iti. 02805 yo hi pr�k pratijㅰm uktv� hetu-ud�hara�a-�dika� vaktu� 02806 j�n�ti, sa ki�cid anukrama� s�dhanasya j�n�ty eva hi, j�nan 02807 katham avikala-anta�kara�a� pratijㅰm eva pratijㅰ-s�dhan�ya 02808 up�dad�ta. up�dadat� ca anena pratijㅰ-m�tre�a siddhir 02809 i亢� bhavati, tata� ca na pr�g api hetu� br�y�t. 02810 eva�prak�ra鎚m asambaddh�n盛 parisa�khy�tum 02811 a�akyatv�t, lak�a�a-niyamo apy asambaddha eva pratijㅰ- 02812 antara-abhidh�ne pratijㅰ-antara� n�ma nigrahasth�nam iti. 02813 asambaddha-abhidh�na� nigrahasth�nam iti eva�prak�r性�m 02814 ekam eva lak�a�a� v�cya� sy�t. na ca eva�vidha� 02815 ka�cid viv�de�u d敖�a-p�rvo vyavah�ro yena tad-artha� 02816 yatna� kriyate. na ca b�la-pral�pa-anudi�ya 妬stra� pravartate 02817 prav�ttau ca k� ni亢h� te咸m ani亢�n�t. d惡yate ca 02818 vidu咸m api na atinir�pa鎚d asiddha-abhidh�nam iti. vyavah�ra- 02819 dar�an�t t�d惡a� par�jaya-adhikara�a� vyavasth�pyate. 02901 tasm�d iha api yadi niv�tta-�k涉k�e v�dini paro anaik�ntikat�m 02902 udbh�vayet, as�dhana-a�gasya anaik�ntikasya abhidh�n�n 02903 nigrahasth�na� v�dina�, eva� yadi prativ�d� sat s�m�nyam 02904 aindriyaka� nitya� ca pram性ena pratip�dayitu� 02905 �aknuy�t. anudi�ya-apram性aka� 妬stra-upagama� pram性ena 02906 e咸m arth�n�m apratip�dane na bh�ta-do�a-udbh�vanam iti 02907 na ka�cit par�jayo abhyupagama-m�tre�a vastu-siddher abh�v�t 02908 prativ�din� do�asya apratip�ditatv�t. pram性air asamarthita- 02909 s�dhana-abhidh�n�t tu jet� api na bhavati iti. 02910 anitya-�k涉k�e punar v�dini na ka�cid do�o vi�e�a�a-abhidh�nena 02911 heto� samarthana-upakram�t. 02912 pratijㅰ-hetvor virodha� pratijㅰ-virodha�. yath� gu�a-vyatirikta� 02913 dravyam iti pratijㅰ, r�pa-�dibhyo artha-antarasya anupalabdher 02914 iti hetu�, so aya� pratijㅰ-hetvor virodha�. etena 02915 eva pratijㅰ-virodho apy ukto yatra pratijㅰ sva-vacanena 02916 virudhyate, yath� �rama鎚 garbhi鰍, na asty �tm� iti v�, hetu- 02917 virodho api yatra pratij쨅y� hetur virudhyate, yath� sarva� 02918 p�thak sam�he bh�va-�abda-prayog�d iti. etena pratij쨅y� 02919 d敖焌nta-virodho api vy�khy�ta�. heto� ca d敖焌nta-�dibhir 02920 virodha� pram性a-virodha� ca pratijㅰ-hetvor vaktavya�. 03001 para-pak�e sva-siddhena gotva-�din� anaik�ntika-codan�d 03002 virodha�, ya� para-pak�a� sva-siddhena gotva-�din� vyabhic�rayati, 03003 tad viruddham uttara� veditavyam sva-pak�a-anapek�a� 03004 ca, ya� ca sva-pak�a-anapek�a� hetu� prayu�kte 03005 anitya� �abda aindriyakatv�d iti, tasya sva-siddhasya gotva-�der 03006 anityatva-virodh�d viruddha�. ubhaya-pak�a-sampratipannas 03007 tv anaik�ntika�, yad ubhaya-pak�a-pratipanna� vastu, 03008 tena anaik�ntika-codan� iti. 03009 atra api pratijㅰy筬 s�dhana-v�kye prayoga-prati�edh�t 03010 tad-成rayas tat-k�to v� hetu-d敖焌ntayor na virodha iti na pratijㅰ- 03011 virodho n�ma ki�cit nigrahasth�nam. 03012 sy�d etat, asaty api pratijㅰ-prayoge gamyam�no api pratijㅰ- 03013 hetvor virodho bhavati, yath� r�pa-�dibhyo artha-antarasya anupalabdhi� 03014 tad gu�a-vyatiriktam, na upalabhyate ca r�pa-�dibhyo 03015 artha-antara� dravyam ity ukte api gamyata eva s�dhya- 03016 s�dhanayor virodha�; katha� tato artha-antarasya-anupalabdhis 03017 tad-vyatireka� ca iti. 03018 satyam, sy�d aya� virodha�, yadi hetu� s�dhya-dharma- 03101 viparyaya� s�dhayet. yadi hy upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptatvena 03102 upagatasya sato dravyasya r�pa-�di-pratibh�sa-vivekena sva- 03103 pratibh�sa-anupalabdhi�, tat tad-vyatireke�a na asti iti i亢a-vyatireka- 03104 viparyaya-s�dhan�d viruddho hetur asm�bhir ukta eva iti 03105 bhavaty eva ida� nigraha-adhikara�am, yady eva�vidha� pratijㅰ- 03106 hetvor virodha i亢a�. atha punar asya upalabdhi-lak�a�a- 03107 pr�ptir lupyate, tad� na ka�cit pratijㅰ-hetvor virodha�, 03108 vyatirikt�n�m api bh�v�n盛 kuta�cid viprakar�i鎚� tad- 03109 vyatireke�a anupalabdh�v api vyatirekasya bh�v�t. 03110 yad ukta� pratijㅰy筬 sva-vacana-virodhe pratijㅰ-virodha 03111 iti tatra idam eva nigraha-adhikara�am as�dhana-a�ga- 03112 bh�t�y筬 pratijㅰy筬 s�dhana-v�kye prayoga�; na virodha� 03113 tad-adhikara�atv�t. yadi pratijㅰ-anapek�o virodha� sy�t, sy�t 03114 par�jaya-成raya�. pratijㅰ-adhikara�atve punas tat-prayogak�ta 03115 eva par�jayo asya prast�va-upasa�h�ra-avas�natv�t. vyartha� 03116 virodha-udbh�vana� par�jita-par�jaya-abh�v�d bhasm�k�ta-prajvalana-vat. 03117 ye tu kecid vic�ra-prasa�ge�v ekatra s�dhye bahavo 03118 hetava ucyante, te咸� vikalpena tat-s�dhya-s�dhan�ya 03119 v�tte� s�marthyam anyath� dvit�yasya vaiyarthy�t. yadi hi 03120 tatra apy eka-prayogam antare�a aparasya prayogo na sambhavet, 03121 na tad� dvit�yasya ka�cit s�dhana-artha� prat�ta-pratip�dana- 03122 abh�v�t. tasm�n na pratijㅰy筬 sva-vacana-virodho n�ma 03123 ki�cit nigrahasth�nam. 03201 na ca na asty �tm� ity atra ka�cit pratijㅰ-virodha� na asty �tma- 03202 �abd�rthasya bh�va-up�d�natva-ni�edh�t. �abd�rtha-ni�edhe 03203 hi virodha� sy�t. na ca sva-lak�a�a� �abd�rtha iti. 03204 ya� puna� pratij쨅y� b�dhan�d hetu-virodha ukta�, yath� 03205 sarva� p�thak sam�he bh�va-�abda-prayog�d iti, na atra 03206 pratijㅰy筬 prayoga�, na api hetor, yena virodha� sy�t, ki� 03207 tarhi pratip�dita-artha-upadar�anena upasa�h�ra-vacanam etasm�t. 03209 anyair eva hetubhi� �abdasya eka-vi�e�a-anabhidh�nam 03210 aneka-artha-s�m�nya-abhidh�na� ca pratip�dya sarvasya �abd�rthasya 03211 n�n�-artha-r�patay� eka-vastu-vi�e�a-svabh�vat�-bh�vam 03212 upadar�ayan �abd�rtham adhik�tya sarva� p�thag 03213 iti br�y�t. etena tad-virodha� pratyukta�. d敖焌nta-upadar�ana� 03214 ca etad anitya� �abda� k�taka-anityatv�d iti yath�. kvacid 03215 arthe vipratipattau prasiddham aneka-artha-s�m�nye �abda- 03216 prayogam upadar�ya pratip�dita-vipratipatti-sth�na� s�m�nyena 03217 upasa�harati sarva� p�thag iti. 03218 yadi d敖焌nta-prayoga� ki� �jun� eva tat-prayoga-krame�a 03219 na prayukto vipratipatti-vi�aya� ca ki� na dar�ita iti cet, na, 03220 sam�sa-nirde妬t, evam api prayoga-dar�an�d as�dhana-v�kyatv�c 03221 ca. ata eva na pratij쨅y� hetor b�dhanam. na ca ekam 03222 eva ki�cin na asti iti bruv性a� ka�cit tat-samuccaya-r�pam 03223 eka� sam�ham icchati yena virodha� sy�t. 03301 yo api yugapat �a�kena yog�d ity �din� param性or 03302 bhedam �ha, na tasya apy eka� samuccaya-r�pa� s�dhayitum 03303 i亢a�, ki� tarhy abh�va eva eka-aneka-prati�edh�t. ata� so api 03304 na sam�has tasya i亢a�, na tatra �abda iti na virodha�. 03305 na virodho aya� p�rvak�t pratijㅰ-hetu-virodh�t bhidyate 03306 yena p�thag ucyeta. tatra hetu-pratijㅰyor b�dhanam, iha 03307 pratij쨅y� hetor ity asti bheda iti cet, artha-virodhe hi hetu- 03308 pratij쨅yor b�dhyab�dakabh�va� sy�t. sarvo artha-virodho 03309 dvi�v ity api paraspara� b�dhakam eka-artha-sa�nidh�v apara- 03310 arth�-sambhav�t. tatra hetu-pratijㅰyo� p�thag b�dha-ud�hara�ayor 03311 na ka�cid artha-bheda�. 03312 api ca aya� viruddho aviruddho v� sati hetu-prayoge vyadhikara�atv�d 03313 asiddha ity asiddhat� hetor nigrahasth�nam. 03314 sa khalu ucyam�na eva atad-dharmatay� prat�to vaktu� par�jayam 03315 �nayati. par�jite tasmi�s tad-artha-virodha-cintay� na 03316 ki�cit. 03317 api ca sarvatra aya� pratijㅰ-hetvor virodha� sambhavan 03318 na dvay尋 hetu-do�a-j�tim atipatati viruddhat�m asiddhat盛 03319 ca iti. viruddhat� siddhe hetor dharmi�i bh�ve s�dhya-dharma- 03320 viparyaya eva bh�vena pratijㅰ-artha-virodh�t. asiddhat� 03401 punar dharmi�i pratijㅰt�-artha-siddhau viruddhayo� svabh�vayor 03402 ekatra asambhav�t. na ca anyath� virodha�. 03403 asiddhe dharmi-svabh�ve abhihitayor hetu-pratijㅰ-arthayor 03404 virodh�d virodha-sambhava iti cet, apram性a-yoge tu ubhayor 03405 dharmi�i sa嚆aya�. tath� sati hetor dharmi�i bh�va-sa嚆aye 03406 asiddhat� eva hetu-do�a ity asiddha-viruddh�bhy�m anyo 03407 na pratij쨅y� virodho n�ma par�jaya-hetu�. asiddha-viruddhe 03408 ca hetv-�bh�sa-vacan�d eva ukta iti na p�thak pratijㅰ-virodho 03409 vaktavya iti. 03410 ubhaya-成ritatv�d virodhasya vivak咸to anyatara-nirde�a iti 03411 cet, sy�d etat pratijㅰ-hetvor virodha iti pratijㅰ-het� 成ritya 03412 ubhaya-成rayo bhavati. tatra yad� pratijㅰ-virodho vivak�itas 03413 tad� pratijㅰ-virodha iti ucyate, yad� pratijㅰy� hetor v� 03414 virodhas tad� viruddho hetur iti. ata� pratijㅰ-virodho hetu-virodho 03415 v� ity ado�a�. tatra hetor ud�hara�a� nitya� �abda 03416 utpatti-dharmakatv�d iti, pratijㅰ-virodhasya na asty �tm� iti, 03417 pratijㅰ-hetvo� paraspara-viruddha-ud�hara�a� gu�a-vyatiriktam 03418 ity �di, pratij쨅y� hetu-virodha-ud�hara�a� na asty eko 03419 bh�va ity �dikam iti. 03420 na, sarvatra hetv-apek�asya virodhasya hetv-�bh�sa-anatikram�t, 03421 yathokta� pr�k. anapek�e ca kevale svata� pratijㅰ- 03422 virodhe vivak�ite pratijㅰ-hetvor virodha iti hetu-graha�am 03501 asambaddham. na ca utpatti-dharmakatv�n nityam ity 03502 atra api hetu-virodho yukta�, pratij쨅y� hi hetor b�dhane 03503 hetu-virodha�. iha tu hetun� pratijㅰ b�dhyata iti pratijㅰ-virodho 03504 yukta�, ubhaya-成raye api virodhe b�dhyam�na-vivak�ay� 03505 tad-virodha-vyavasth�pan�t. 03506 yad apy uktam etena pratij쨅y� d敖焌nta-virodha-�dayo api 03507 vaktavy� bha出�lekhyany�yena iti tatra api pak檻k�ta-dharma- 03508 viparyayavati d敖焌nte virodha� sy�t. viruddhe ca d敖焌nte 03509 yadi pak�a-dharmasya v�ttir ananya-s�dh�ra鎚 pras�dhyate, 03510 viruddhas tad� hetv-�bh�sa� s�dh�ra鎚y�m apras�dhite v� 03511 tad-v�tti-niyame anaik�ntika� av�ttau v� as�dh�ra�a�. 03512 viruddha-d敖焌nt�-v�ttau viparyaya-v�ttau ca hetor na 03513 ka�cid hetu-do�o d敖焌nta-virodha� ca pratij쨅y� iti cet, na, 03514 tad api sa嚆aya-hetutva-anativ�tter d敖焌nta-virodho hi pratijㅰy筬 03515 s�dharmye do�a�, na vaidharmye, abhimatatv�t. 03516 s�dharmya-d敖焌nte ca vipar�ta-dharmavati vastuta� s�dhy�-avyabhic�re 03517 api hetor na avyabhic�ra-dharmat� �aky� dar�ayitum 03518 iti na apradar�ita-avin�bh�va-sambaddh�d hetor ni�caya�. 03519 tan na pratij쨅y� d敖焌nta-virodho hetv-�bh�s�n ativartate. 03601 ubhayath� api do�o astv iti cet, na na hetu-do�asya pr�k 03602 prasa�gena par�jitasya do�a-antara-anapek�a鎚t. vi�e�e�a s�dhana- 03603 avayava-anukrama-niyama-v�dina ud�hara�a-s�dharmya� 03604 hetu-lak�a�a� viruddhe d敖焌nte na sambhavati iti pr�k 03605 prayuktasya hetor do�e�a par�jaya iti na uttara-d敖焌nta-apek�ay� 03606 virodha� cint�m arhati. hetor api d敖焌nta-virodhe as�dh�ra�atva� 03607 viruddhatva� v� vaidharmye yadi v�tti� sy�t. 03608 pram性a-virodhe tu heto�, yath� na dahano agni� �aity�d 03609 ity �di hy asiddho hetv-�bh�sa�. 03610 pratijㅰy筬 pram性a-virodha� sva-vacana-virodhena vy�khy�ta 03611 iti. 03612 sarva ete s�dhana-virodh� hetv-�bh�se�v eva antarbhavanti 03613 iti hetv-�bh�sa-vacanena eva ukt筬. 03614 yat tu viruddham uttara� para-pak�e sva-siddhena gotva-�din� 03615 anaik�ntika-codan� iti, tad asambaddham eva. yadi hi sva-siddhena 03616 gotva-�din� parasya vyabhic�ra-siddhim �k涉k�eta, 03617 tasya tat sva-pak�a-viruddha� na abhimatam iti virodha 03618 yujyeta. sa hi svaya� pratipanne gotve hetu-v�tte� sa嚆ay�no 03619 apratipattim �tmanas tath� khy�payati. sa ca hetu� 03620 saty asati gotve apras�dhita-s�dhana-s�marthya� sa嚆aya-hetutv�d 03701 anaik�ntika eva pras�dhite tu s�marthye gotve 03702 av�tty� hetor na sa嚆aya eva sarva-sa嚆aya-prak�r性盛 03703 parih�re�a samarthan�t. etena sva-pak�a-anapek�a-hetu-prayogasya 03704 anaik�ntikat� vy�khy�t�, so api sva-abhimata-nitya-gotva- 03705 v�tti� hetum anityatve bruv性o asamarthita-s�dhana-a�gatay� 03706 sa嚆aya-hetum eva �ha iti. yat punar uktam ubhaya-pak�a-sampratipannena 03707 vastun� anaik�ntika-codan� iti, tatra apy ava�ya� 03708 sa嚆aya-hetutva-mukhena eva anaik�ntiko vaktavya�. tad 03709 asamarthite anyatra api tulyam iti na ubhaya-siddha-itarayor anaik�ntikatvair 03710 vi�e�a�. 03711 yad apy uktam, d敖焌nta-�bh�sa-hetv-�bh�sa-p�rvakatv�t 03712 tad-abhidh�nena eva ukt� iti na p�thag nigrahasth�ne�u ukt� iti, 03713 tad apy avayava-antara-v�dino ayuktam. yo avayava-antara� 03714 d敖焌nta� hetor �ha, tasya na hetv-�bh�sa-ukty� d敖焌nta-�bh�sa- 03715 uktir vy�py� tad-vacanena gamyam�nasya tasm�t s�dhana-antara- 03716 abh�va-prasa�g�t. d敖焌nta-�bh�s�n盛 hetv-�bh�se�v 03717 antarbh�v�d d敖焌ntasya api het�v antarbh�va i亢o bhavati, 03718 tath� ca na d敖焌nta� p�thak s�dhana-avayava� sy�d ap�thag-v�tte�. 03719 yo d敖焌nta-s�dhyo arthas tasya het�v antarbh�v�d 03720 hetun� eva s�dhita iti na d敖焌ntasya p�thak ki�cit s�marthyam. 03801 api ca na ki�cit p�rva-pak�a-v�dino hetv-�bh�sa-asa�spar�e 03802 ny�yya� nigrahasth�nam asti iti tat-sambandh�ni sarv性y 03803 eva hetv-�bh�sa-vacanena eva ukt�ni iti na p�thag v�cy�ni 03804 syu�. artha-antara-gamana-�der api hetor as�marthya eva sambhav�t. 03805 na hi samarthe hetau s�dhye ca siddhe artha-antara- 03806 gamana� ka�cid �rabhate asamarthasya mithy�-prav�tter iti. 03807 pak�a-prati�edhe pratijㅰt�-artha-apanayana� pratijㅰ-sa�ny�sa�. 03808 ya� pratijㅰtam artham anitya� �abda aindriyakatv�d 03809 iti s�m�nya-v�tty� hetor vyabhic�ra-pradar�anena 03810 prati�edhe k�te ka evam �ha anitya� �abda iti parityajati, 03811 tasya pratijㅰ-sa�ny�so n�ma nigrahasth�nam iti. 03812 atra api yady udbh�vite api hetor vyabhic�re na sa pak�a� 03813 parityajati, ki� na g�hyeta. nig�h�ta eva hetv-�bh�sa-abhidh�n�d 03814 iti cet, kim id�n�m uttara-pratijㅰ-s盛ny�sa-apek�ay�, 03815 tasya tad eva adya� nigrahasth�nam iti kim anyair 03816 a�akya-paricchedai� kl�ba-pral�pa-ce亢itair. upanyastair eva� 03817 hy atiprasa�ga� sy�t. pak�a-prati�edhe t余鰍�bhavatas 03818 t余鰍�bh�vo n�ma nigrahasth�nam prapal�yam�nasya 03901 prapal�yitva� n�ma nigrahasth�nam ity evam �dy api v�cya� 03902 sy�t, tasm�d etad apy asambaddham iti. 03903 avi�e�a-ukte hetau prati�iddhe vi�e�am icchato hetv-antaram. 03904 nidar�anam eka-prak�ti ida� vyakta� parim性�t, m�t-p�rvak性盛 03905 �ar�va-prabh�t�n盛 d敖�a� parim性am iti. asya 03906 vyabhic�re�a pratyavasth�na� n�n�-pr�k�t�n�m eka-prak�t�n盛 03907 ca d敖�a� parim性am iti eva� pratyavasthita �ha 03908 eka-prak�ti-samanvaya-vik�r性盛 parim性a-dar�an�t sukha- 03909 du�kha-moha-samanvita� hi ida� sarva� vyakta� parimita� 03910 g�hyate. tasya prak�ty-antara-r�pa-samanvaya-abh�ve saty eka- 04001 prak�tikatvam iti. tad idam avi�e�a-ukte hetau prati�iddhe vi�e�a� 04002 bruvato hetv-antara� bhavati. sati ca hetv-antara-bh�ve 04003 p�rvasya hetor as�dhakatv�n nigrahasth�nam. 04004 atra api p�rvasya eva hetor anaik�ntikasya abhidh�n�n nig�h�te 04005 hetv-antara-cint� kva upayujyate. yadi pr�k-s�dhana-v�d� 04006 hetum anaik�ntikam uktv� datta-uttara-avasara�, tena eva nig�hyate 04007 adatta-uttara-avasara�, hetv-antara-abhidh�ne api na nigraham 04008 arhaty avir�m�t. 04009 prak�t�d arth�d apratibaddha-artham artha-antaram. yathokta- 04010 lak�a�e pak�a-pratipak�a-parigrahe hetuta� s�dhya-siddhau 04011 prak�ty�y盛 kury�n nitya� �abdo aspar�atv�d iti hetu�, 04012 hetu� ca n�ma hinoter dh�tos tu-�abde pratyaye k�d-anta� 04013 padam. pada� ca n�ma-�khy�ta-upasarga-nip�t� iti prastutya 04014 n�ma-�d�ni vy�ca亢e, idam artha-antara� n�ma nigrahasth�nam 04015 abhyupagata-artha-asa�gatatv�d iti. 04016 ny�yyam etan nigrahasth�nam, p�rva-uttara-pak�a-v�dino� 04017 pratip�dite do�e prak�ta� parityajy�-s�dhana-a�ga-vacanam 04018 ado�a-udbh�vana� ca. s�dhana-v�dino hy upanyasta-s�dhanasya 04101 samarthane kartavye tad ak�tv� aparasya prasa�gena aprasa�gena 04102 v� atan-n�ntar�yakasya apy abhidh�na� par�jaya- 04103 sth�nam uttara-v�dino api do�a-udbh�vana-m�tr�d aparasya upak�epa 04104 iti. 04105 var�a-krama-nirde�avan nirarthakam. yath� nitya� �abdo 04106 jabaga�ada�atv�t jhabha쨐ha�hadha�avad iti. s�dhana-anup�d�n�n 04107 nig�hyata iti. 04108 idam apy asambaddham, na hi var�a-krama-nirde妬d eva i亢a- 04109 artha-siddh�v �narthakyam. yad eva ki�cid as�dhana-a�gasya 04110 vacanam, tad eva anarthaka� s�dhya-siddhy-upayogino 04111 abhidheyasya abh�v�t ni�prayojanatv�c ca iti, prak�ra-vi�e�a-up�d�nam 04112 asambaddham. 04113 vater up�d�n�d ado�a iti cet, sy�d etat, var�a-krama-nirde�avad 04114 iti vatir atra up�tta� so anyad� apy ananur�pa� g�hnati ity 04115 ado�a iti. na, artha-antara-�der nigrahasth�nasya avacana-prasa�g�t, 04116 eva� hi t� na p�thag v�cy� nirarthakena eva abhidh�n�t. 04201 na s�dhya-siddh�v anarthaka� nirarthakam, yasya na eva 04202 ka�cid artha�, tan nirarthakam i亢am iti cet, yasya kasyacid 04203 av�dino api hi nirarthaka-abhidh�ne ki� na nigraho nigraha- 04204 nimitta-avi�e咸t. 04205 na, tasya iha aprast�v�d iti cet, �y�tam iha yo nirarthaka� 04206 brav�ti, tasya tena eva nigraha iti. tat tulya� sarvasya as�dhana- 04207 a�ga-v�dina iti. sa sarvo nirarthaka-abhidh�yy anena eva 04208 nigrahasth�nena nigraha-arha�. 04209 na ca var�a-krama-nirde�a� sarvatra nirarthaka� kvacit- 04210 prakara�e tasya api arthavattv�t. tasm�d atra eva asya �narthaky�t 04211 nigrahasth�natvam. 04212 api ca atyalpam idam ucyate var�a-krama-nirde�o nigrahasth�nam 04213 iti kapola-v�dita-kak�a-gha葺itakam ity evam-�d�n�m 04214 api v�cyatv�t. 04215 par�at-prativ�dibhy盛 trir-abhihitam apy avijㅰtam 04216 avijㅰta-artham. yad v�kya� par�ad� prativ�din� ca trir-abhihita� 04217 na vijㅰyate �li亢a-�abdam aprat�ta-prayogam atidruta- 04218 ucc�ritam ity evam �din� k�ra�ena, tad avijㅰta-artham, as�marthya- 04301 sa�vara鎚ya prayukta� nigrahasth�nam iti. 04302 na ida� nirarthak�d bhidyate. sa yadi prak�ta-artha-sambaddha� 04303 gamakam eva kury�t, na asya-as�marthyam, tatra 04304 j姓y�t par�ad-�dayo na pratipadyanta iti na vidv�n nigraham 04305 arhati. 04306 par�at-prajㅰm aparikalpya vacan�n nigraha-arha eva iti cet, 04307 ny�yav�dino j姓y�d uktam aj�nan ki� na prativ�d� nig�hyate. 04308 j姓y�t par�ad-�der avijㅰta-pratip�dana-as�marthya iti vijet� na 04309 sy�n na nigraha-arha�. asambaddha-abhidh�ne nirarthakam 04310 eva iti na p�thag avijㅰta-artha� n�ma nigrahasth�nam iti. 04311 paurv�parya-ayog�d apratibaddha-artham ap�rthakam. yatra 04312 anekasya padasya v�kyasya v� paurv�parye�a yogo 04313 na asti ity asambaddha-arthat� g�hyate, tat samud�ya-arthasya ap�y�d 04314 ap�rthakam, da�a-d姓ima-�di-v�kya-vat. 04401 ida� kila pad�n�m asambandh�d asambaddha-var鎚n 04402 nirarthak�t p�thag uktam nanv evam asambaddha-v�kyam 04403 api p�thag v�cya� sy�t. na ubhaya-sa�grah�t ap�rthakam, 04404 nirarthakasya api sa�graha-prasa�g�t. eva�vidh�c ca vi�e�a- 04405 sam成ray�t p�thag-nigrahasth�na-lak�a�a-pralapane atiprasa�go 04406 apy ukta�. na ca sa�graha-nirde�e ki�cid do�a� pa�y�ma� 04407 prabhede v� gu�a-antaram iti yat ki�cid etat. 04408 avayava-vipary�sa-vacanam apr�ptak�lam. pratijㅰ-�d�n盛 04409 yath�lak�a�am artha-va妬t krama�, tatra avayav�n盛 viparyaye�a 04410 abhidh�na� nigrahasth�nam. 04411 na, evam api siddher iti cet, na prayoga-apeta-�abda-tulyatv�t. 04412 yath� gaur ity asya padasya arthe go鰍 iti prayujyam�na� 04413 pada� kakuda-�dimantam artha� pratip�dyati iti. na �abda-anv�khy�na� 04414 vyartham, anena padena go-�abdam eva pratipadyate, 04415 go-�abd�t kakuda-�dimantam artham; tath� pratijㅰ-�dy- 04416 avayava-viparyaye�a anup�rv尋 pratipadyate, �nup�rvy� 04501 ca artham iti, tath� hi p�rva� karma-up�d�yate tata� kara�a� 04502 m�t-pi出a-�dika� loka iti. 04503 tad etad unmattasya unmatta-sa�var�anam iva prayoga-apeta- 04504 �abda-vad etad iti. yadi go鰍-�abd�t kakuda-�dimaty 04505 arthe prat�ti�, �abda-anv�khy�na-prayatnena artha� na pa�y�ma�. 04507 go鰍-�abdasya artha-pratip�dane as�marthy�t pratip�daka- 04508 vyutpatty-artham anv�khy�nam iti cet, nanu go鰍-�abd�d api 04509 loke prat�tir d敖焌. satya� d敖焌, na tu s�k咸d ity uktam. 04510 uktam etan na punar yuktam, str�-特dr性�m ubhaya-prat�ter 04511 abh�v�t. ya� khalu ubhaya� vetti �abdam apa�abda� ca, sa 04512 eva� pratipadyate. yas tu nakka-�abda� mukka-�abdam eva 04513 v� vetti, na n�s�-�abdam, sa katham apa�abd�c �abda� pratipadya 04514 tato artha� pratipadyeta. d敖焌 ca anubhaya-vedino api 04515 prat�tir iti na para�paray� prat�ti�. 04516 arthe asamarthasya �abde api prat�ti-janana-as�marthy�c ca. 04517 na hy arthe api v�cakatva� n�ma anyad eva tad-vi�aya-prat�ti- 04518 janan�t. apa�abda� cec �abde prat�ti� janayet, artha eva 04519 ki� na janayati. na hy etasya arth�t ki�cid bhaya� pa�y�mo 04520 yena ta� pariharet. 04601 ak�ta-samayasya �abde apy aprat�ti-janan�c ca. na hy 04602 ayam apa�abda� �abde api svabh�vata� prat�ti� janayaty 04603 adar�an�t, samayata eva tu janayet. samaya-va妬d vartam�no 04604 artha eva ki� na pravartate. eva� hi pratipatti-para�par�- 04605 pari�rama� parih�to bhavati. 04606 viparyaya-dar�an�c ca. �abd�d artham apratipadyam�n筬 04607 apa�abdair eva bahula� vyutpadyam�n� loke d惡yante 04608 iti vyartha� �abda-anu妬sanam. 04609 na vyartha� sa�sk�ta-�abda-vyutpatty-arthatv�d iti cet, 04610 ko aya� �abd�n盛 sa�sk�ra�. na hy e咸� prajㅰ-b�hu-�ruty- 04611 �dika� sa�sk�ra� pa�y�ma�, na apy e咸m ek�ntena 04612 �ravyat�, na apy artha-praty�yane ka�cid ati�aya�. na 04613 dharma-s�dhanat� mithy�-v�tti-codanebhya� sa�sk�tebhyo 04614 apy adharma-utpatte�, anyebhyo api viparyaye dharma-utpatte�. 04615 �abdasya suprayog�d eva svarga-modana-gho�a鎚 vacana-m�tram. 04616 na ca eva�vidh�n �gam�n �driyante yuktijㅰ�. na ca 04617 d�na-�di-dharma-s�dhana-codan�-特nya-kevala-�abda-suprayog�n 04618 naraka-p�tam iti bruv性asya kasyacin mukha� vakr�bhavati. 04619 tasm�n na sa�sk�to n�ma ka�cic �abda�. 04701 �i亢a-prayoga� sa�sk�ra iti cet, ke �i亢筬. ye vidita-vedyat�- 04702 �di-gu�a-yukt筬. ka� punar e咸� gu�a-utkar�a-anapek�o al�ka-nirbandha�, 04703 yat te am�n eva �abd�n prayu쨓ate, na apar�n. na 04704 ca atra ka�cic �abde parok�a� s�k檻, yata idam eva� ni�cinuma� 04705 prayu쨓ate n�ma �i亢筬. nanv eva� vaya� gu�a-ati�ayam 04706 apa�yanta� sa�sk�ra� ke咸�cic �abd�n�m 04707 anumany�mahe, tad-anv�khy�na-yatna� v�, gu�a-ati�aya-abh�v�t. 04708 veda-rak�a-�dika� ca aprayojanam eva atat-samaya-sth�yina�. 04709 saty api gu�a ati�aye na kara鰍ya eva anv�khy�ne yatna� 04710 tat-svabh�vasya anyato api siddhe�, pr�k�ta-apabhra嚆a- 04711 drami�a-andhra-�di-bh晟�-vat. na hi pratide�a� bh晟性盛 04712 ki�cil lak�a�am asti, atha ca samprad�ya-va妬t t� lokas 04713 tath� eva pratipadyate t�s盛 ca prayoga-bhra嚆am tath� 04714 sa�sk�t�n盛 �abd�n盛 prat�tir bhavi�yati iti. ja�a-prav�ttir 04715 eva e咸, y� �abd�n盛 lak�a�e prav�tti�. 04801 avayava-viparyaye api yadi te咸� vacan�n盛 sambandha-prat�tir, na 04802 viparyayo na apy artha-aprat�ti� s�marthy�t. na hy atra ka�cit 04803 samaya� praty�yana-avi�e�e apy evam eva avayav筬 prayoktavy� 04804 iti. 04805 sa eva te咸� kramo yath�vasthitebhyo artha-prat�tir bhavati iti 04806 na viparyay�t prat�ti�, tata �nup�rv�-pratipatty� prat�tir 04807 iti cet, na aprat�yam�na-sambandhebhya �nup�rv�-pratipatti�. 04808 ye咸� �abd�n盛 ka�cit sambandho j�yate, idam iha 04809 sambadhyata iti te�u vidita-sambandhe�u ka� kasya p�rvo 04810 aparo v� krama�, yena krame�a vyavasth�pyeran. sambandha- 04811 pratipattau sa eva te咸� krama�, yo yath�vasthit�n盛 04812 sambandha� prat�yate. na hi v�kye�u pad�n盛 krama-niyama� 04813 ka�cit, yath� r�j쨅� puru�a�, puru�o raj쨅 iti. y�vadbhi� 04814 padair artha-parisam�pti� tad� eka� v�kyam, yath� 04815 devadatta g�m �naya k敖鎚m iti. atra pad�n盛 yath�k�ma� 04816 prayoge api na artha-prat�tau vi�e�a iti ka�cit krama-abhinive�a�. 04818 pratip�dita� ca pratijㅰ-vacana-antare�a api yath�rtha� 04819 prat�tir bhavi�yati iti prat�yam�na-arthasya ca �abdasya prayoge 04820 atiprasa�ga�. pari�i亢e�u ca sambandha� pradar�ya 04901 dharmi�i bh�va� pradar�yeta, dharmi�i bh�va� pradar�ya 04902 sambandha� pradar�yeta iti na niyama� ka�cid ubhayath� api 04903 prat�ty-utpatter ity uktam. aprat�yam�na-sambandhe�u ca pade�u 04904 na tebhya �nup�rvy� api prat�tir iti na idam ap�rthak�d 04905 bhidyata iti; na apr�ptak�la� p�thag v�cya� sy�d iti. 04906 h�nam anyatamena apy avayavena ny�nam. yasmin v�kye 04907 pratijㅰ-�d�n�m anyatamo avayavo na bhavati, tad v�kya� 04908 h�na� s�dhana-abh�ve s�dhy�-siddhe�. 04909 na pratijㅰ-ny�na� h�na� tad-abh�ve prat�ti-bh�v�d iti 04910 pratip�ditam. h�nam eva tat ny�nat�y�m api nigrah�d ity 04911 apara�. ya� prat�yam�na-artham anarthaka� �abda� prayu�kte, 04912 sa nigraham arhet. na artha-upasa�hitasya abhidh�t� ity 04913 asam�k�ita-abhidh�nam etat. ata eva ca pratijㅰy� na s�dhana- 04914 a�ga-bh�va iti. 04915 hetu-ud�hara�a-adhikam adhikam. ekena k�tatv�d anyatarasya 04916 �narthakyam iti tad etan niyama-abhyupagame veditavyam. 04918 yatra eka-s�dhana-v�kya-prayoga-p�rvako vic�ra�, tatra adhika- 04919 abhidh�nam anarthakam iti nigrahasth�nam. prapa쨇a-kath�y盛 04920 tu na ka�cid do�o niyama-abh�v�d iti. 05001 �abd�rthayo� punarvacana� punaruktam anyatra anuv�d�t. 05002 �abda-punaruktam anitya� �abdo anitya� �abda iti. 05003 artha-punaruktam anitya� �abdo nirodha-dharmako dhv�na 05004 iti. 05005 atra na �abda-punarukta� p�thag v�cyam artha-punarukta- 05006 vacanena eva gatatv�t. na hy artha-bhede �abda-s�mye api 05007 ka�cid do�a�, yath� 05008 hasati hasati sv�miny uccai rudaty atiroditi / 05009 k�ta-parikara� sveda-udg�ra� pradh�vati dh�vati / 05010 gu�a-samudita� do�a-apeta� pra�indati nindati / 05011 dhana-lava-parikr�ta� yantra� pran�tyati n�tyati //2// 05012 yath� v� yad yasmin bhavati bhavati, na bhavati na bhavati, 05013 tat tasya k�ryam, itarat k�ra�am iti. 05014 gamyam�na-artha� punarvacanam api punarukta� niyata- 05015 pada-prayoge s�dhana-v�kye yath� pratijㅰ-vacanam iti. 05016 artha-punaruktena eva gata-arthatv�t na p�thag v�cyam. ayam 05017 api niyata-s�dhana v�kya eva do�o vaktavya�, na vistara-kath�y�m, 05018 vy�cak咸�o hi kad�cid asamyak-�rava�a-pratipatti- 05019 �a�kay� s�k�i-prabh�t�n盛 puna� punar br�y�t, api na tatra 05020 ki�cic chalam. 05021 na avi�ayatv�d iti cet, na aya� gurur na �i�ya iti na yatnata� 05101 pratip�daniya�, yena puna� punar ucyata iti punarvacane 05102 nigraha eva iti cet, na, s�k�i鎚� yatnena pratip�dyatv�t, 05103 tad-apratip�dane do�a-abhidh�n�t, pratip�dyasya �i�yatv�t, 05104 vijig實u-v�da-prati�edhatv�t, trir-abhidh�na-vacan�t, punarvacana- 05105 prasa�ge samaya-niyama-abh�v�c ca. 05106 na ca idam adhik�d bhidyata iti na p�thag v�cyam. viniyata- 05107 pada-prayoge hi s�dhana-v�kye �dhikya-do�a iti punarvacane 05108 api gata-arthasya-�dhikyam eva padasya iti. 05109 prapa쨇a-kath�y�m apy akathita-eka-artha-s�dhana-adhikara鎚y盛 05110 n�n�-artha-s�dhana-�ps�y盛 n�n�-s�dhana-�ps�y盛 v� 05111 �rotur hetv-�di-b�hulasya punarvacanasya ado�atv�t prat�ta- 05112 pratyaya-abh�v�d hetv-�di-b�hulya� vacana-b�hulya� ca s�dhana- 05113 do�a iti �dhikya-punarvacanayos tulya-do�a iti sa�graha- 05114 vacana� ny�yyam, do�a-abh�v�d eva gu�a-abh�v�t, eva�prak�r�n盛 05115 bhed�n盛 vacane ca atiprasa�g�d ity uktam. 05116 pary�ya-�abda-kalpo hy aparo hetur eka-hetu-pratip�dite vi�aye 05117 vartam�na� pratip�dyasya vi�e�a-abh�v�t. artha� puna�- 05118 pratip�dan�n na bhidyate. 05201 yat punar uktam, anuv�de tv apunarukta� �abda-abhy�s�d 05202 artha-vi�e�a-upapatte�, yath� hetv-apade妬t pratijㅰy筬 05203 punarvacana� nigamanam iti, pratijㅰy� eva gamyam�na-arth�y� 05204 vacana� punarvacanam, ki� punar asy筬 punarvacanam 05205 ity ayukta� nigamanam. 05206 vijㅰtasya par�ad� trir-abhihitasya apratyucc�ra�am ananubh晟a�am. 05207 vijㅰta-v�kya-arthasya par�ad� prativ�din� 05208 trir-abhihitasya yad apratyucc�ra�am, tad ananubh晟a�a� 05209 n�ma nigrahasth�nam. apratyucc�rayan kim-成raya� para- 05210 pak�a-prati�edha� kury�d iti. 05211 uttare�a avas�n�n na ida� nigrahasth�nam iti cet, sy�d 05212 etat, uttare�a gu�a-do�avat� m掩ha-am掩hatva� gamyata iti 05213 ki� punar-ucc�ritena. asti hi ka�cid uttare samartho na pratyucc�ra�e, 05214 na asau t�vat� nigraham arhed iti. 05215 na, uttara-vi�aya-aparijㅰn�t. yady aya� na pratyucc�rayati, 05216 nirvi�ayam uttara� prasajyeta. atha uttara� brav�ti, 05217 katha� na ucc�rayati. tad ida� vy�hatam ucyate, na ucc�rayaty 05301 uttara� ca brav�ti iti. apratijㅰn�c ca. na ca ida� pratijㅰyate, 05302 p�rva� sarvam ucc�rayitavyam, pa�c�d uttaram 05303 abhidh�tavyam iti, api tu yath�katha�cid uttara� v�cyam, 05304 uttara� ca 成raya-abh�ve ayuktam iti, yuktam apratyucc�ra�a� 05305 nigrahasth�nam iti. 05306 yadi n�ma v�d� sva-s�dhana-artha-vivara�a-vy�jena prasa�g�d 05307 apar�para� gho�ayet, viv�da-�spada� ca jijㅰsitam 05308 artha-m�tram uktv� pratijㅰ-�di�v artha-vi�e�a-para�paray� apar�n 05309 arth�n upak�ipya kath盛 vist�rayet, tac ca sarva� yad� 05310 na anuvaktu� �aknuy�t, kas tasya viv�da-成raya-artha-m�tra-uttara- 05311 vacane s�marthya-vigh�ta�, yena v�di-vacana-ananubh晟a�a� 05312 nigrahasth�nam ucyate. tasm�d sarv盛 v�di-kath�m 05313 ananubh晟am性o na uttare asamartha�. 05314 yad-vacana-n�ntar�yak� jijㅰsita-artha-siddhi� yath� pak�adharmat�- 05315 vy�pti-pras�dhana-m�tra� na tatra api prasa�ga-antara- 05316 upak�epa�, tad ava�ya� s�dhana-a�ga-vi�ayatv�d d余a�ena upadar�yata 05317 eva. tatra api na sarva� pr�g anukrame�a ucc�ritavyam, 05318 pa�c�d d余a�a� v�cya� dvir ucc�ra�a-prasa�g�t. d余a�a- 05401 vi�aya-upadar�ana-arthe anubh晟a�e v�di-vacana-anukrama- 05402 gho�a�a� vyartham iti, na k�ryam eva d余ayat� asya aya� do�a 05403 iti n�ntar�yatv�t pratido�a-vacana� vi�aya-upadar�ana� 05404 kriyata eva. na hi sarva-vi�aya-upadar�ana� k�tv� yugapad 05405 do�a� �akyate abhidh�tum, pratyartha� do�a-bhed�t. tasm�d 05406 ya� pad�rtha� d余ayati, sa eva tad-d余a�a-vi�ayas tad� 05407 pradar�an�yo na apara�, tad-d余a�e apara-upadar�anasya asambhav�t. 05408 tasmin d余ite punar anyo artho apara-do�a-vi�aya ity 05409 ayam anubh晟a�e d余a�e ca ny�ya�. sak�t-sarva-anubh晟a�e 05410 api do�a-vacana-k�le punar vi�aya� pradar�an�ya eva, apradar�ite 05411 do�asya vaktum a�akyatv�t. tath� ca dvir-anubh晟a�a� 05412 k�ta� sy�t. tatra prathama� sarva-anukrama-anubh晟a�a� ni�prayojanam. 05413 d余a�a-v�din� d余a�e vaktavye yan na tatra upayujyate, 05414 tasya abhidh�nam ado�a-udbh�vana� dvir-ukti� ca iti 05415 sak�t-sarva-anubh晟a�a� par�jaya-adhikara�a� v�cyam. 05416 tath� astv iti cet, sy�d etat, ukta� etad artha-antara� nigrahasth�nam 05417 iti. tatra s�dhane yata� kuta�cit prasa�ga-�din� 05418 an�ntar�yak�-abhidh�na� v�dino artha-antara-gamanam eva iti 05419 sa nigrah�-arha�. na ka�cit tat-kathita-kriyam性a-prasa�go 05420 na prasajyate. na api tat tasya anubh晟a鰍yam, na ca idam apy 05421 asm�bhir anujㅰyate, sarva� pr�k sak�d vaktavya� pa�c�d 05422 d余a�am iti, ki� tu d余ayat� ava�ya� vi�ayo dar�an�yo 05423 anyath� d余a鎚-v�tter iti. 05501 eva� tarhi na ananubh晟a�a� p�thag nigrahasth�na� 05502 v�cyam apratibhay� gatatv�t, uttarasya hy apratipattir 05503 apratibh�. na ca uttara-vi�ayam apradar�ayann uttara� pratipattu� 05504 samartha�. na hy an�k�ipta-anuttara-pratipattikam 05505 ananubh晟a�am. tena ananubh晟a�asya vy�pik�y�m apratibh�y盛 05506 vihita� nigrahasth�natvam ananubh晟a�e labdham 05507 eva, gavi vihitam iva s�sn�-�dimattva� b�huleye api. tasm�d 05508 apratibh� eva nigraha-adhikara�atvena v�cy�, na ananubh晟a�am. 05510 ka� ca aya� samaya-niyamas trir-abhihitasya ananubh晟a�am 05511 iti. yadi t�vat para-pratip�dana-arth� prav�tti�, ki� 05512 trir abhidh�yeta. tath� tath� sa gr�ha鰍ya�, yath� asya pratipattir 05513 bhavati. atha para-upat�pana-arth�, tad� api ki� trir 05514 abhidh�yate, s�k�i鎚� kar�e nivedya prativ�d� ka亢a-prat�ta- 05515 druta-sa�k�ipta-�dibhir upadrotavya�, yath�-uttara-pratipatti- 05601 vim掩has t余鰍�bhavati. na hi para-upat�pana-krame ka�cin 05602 ny�ya�, yena ka亢a-prat�ta-prayoga-druta-ucc�rit�ni niv�ryante 05603 trir-abhidh�na� v� vidh�yate. na ca para-upat�p�ya santa� pravartante 05604 妬str性i v� pra鰍yante ity ado vaktavyam. tasm�t 05605 t�vad vaktavyam, y�vad anena na g�h�tam, na trir eva. agraha�a- 05606 s�marthye pr�g eva paricchinna-s�marthyena parihartavya� 05607 par�n anupratibodhyeti. 05608 avijㅰta� ca ajㅰnam. vijㅰta� par�ad� prativ�din� yad 05609 avijㅰtam, tad ajㅰna� n�ma nigrahasth�nam. arthe khalv 05610 avijㅰte na tasya prati�edha� br�y�d iti. 05611 etad apy ananubh晟a�a-vad apratibhay� eva gamyatv�d 05612 av�cyam. yath� ananubh晟a�e apradar�ita-vi�ayatv�d uttara- 05613 pratipattir a�aky� iti anuttara-pratipatty� eva nigrahasth�natvam 05614 uttara-vi�aya-pradar�ana-prasa�gam antare�a anubh晟a�asya 05615 vaiyarthy�t, tath�-jㅰne apy uttara-apratipatty� eva 05616 nigrahasth�natvam, aj�n�na� katham uttaram uttara-vi�aya� 05701 ca uttara� br�y�d iti vi�aya-ajㅰnam uttara-jㅰna� 05702 ca nigrahasth�nam, anyath�-pratibh�y� nirvi�ayatv�t. anavadh�rita- 05703 artho hi na anubh晟et. ananubh晟am性o vi�ayam 05704 apradar�ya-uttara� pratipattu� na �aknuy�d iti uttara� 05705 na pratipadyeta jㅰta-uttara-tad-vi�ayasya uttara-apratipatter asambhav�t. 05706 ubhayam etad uttara-apratipatte� k�ra�am iti. 05707 tad-abh�ve pratipattir bhavaty eva iti tayo� p�thag vacane 05708 apratibh�y筬 ko vi�aya iti vaktavyam, nirvi�ayatv�d av�cy� 05709 eva sy�t. 05710 na uttara-ajㅰnam ajㅰna� ki� tarhi vi�aya-ajㅰnam, ajㅰte 05711 hi vi�aye uttara-ajㅰn�t tan na pratipadyeta iti asti vi�ayo apratibh�y� 05712 iti cet, eva� tarhy ananubh晟a�a� nirvi�ayam, 05713 ajㅰnena �k�ep�t. na hi vi�aya� samyak pratipadyam�na� 05714 ka�cin na anubh晟eta iti na ananubh晟a�a� p�thag v�cyam. 05715 uttara-ajㅰnasya ca �k�ep�t. vi�aya-ajㅰnena uttara-ajㅰnam apy 05716 �k�iptam eva. na hi vi�ayam aj�nann uttara� j�n�ti iti na eva apratibh�y� 05717 vi�ayo asti. 05801 jㅰte api vi�aye punar uttara-ajㅰnam apratibh�y� vi�aya 05802 iti cet, eva� tarhi vi�aya-uttara-ajㅰnayor api prabhed�n nigrahasth�na- 05803 antar性i v�cy�ni. yath� ajㅰnasya vi�aya-ajㅰnam uttara- 05804 ajㅰnam iti prabhed�d asaty api gu�a-ati�aye nigrahasth�na- 05805 antara-vyavasth� kriyate, tath� ajㅰnayor api sarv�-jㅰna-ardha- 05806 ajㅰnam ity �di-prabhed�n nigrahasth�na-antar性i ki� na ucyante. 05807 na ca ubhayasya apy ajㅰnasya sa�graha-vacane ka�cid 05808 do�a�, gu�as tu sy�d iti sa�graha-vacana� ny�yyam. 05809 tasm�d ananubh晟a�a-jㅰnayor apratibh�-vi�ayatv�n na 05810 p�thag-vacanam. api ca na p�rva-uttara-v�dino hetv-�bh�s�-pratibh�bhy�m 05811 anyan nigrahasth�na� ny�yyam asti tad-ubhaya- 05812 vacanena eva sarvam uktam iti. tad-ubhaya-�k�ipte�u prabhede�u 05813 gu�a-ati�ayam antare�a vacana-�der atiprasa�g�d vyartha� 05814 prapa쨇a iti. 05815 uttarasya apratipattir apratibh�. para-pak�a-prati�edha 05816 uttara� yad� na pratipadyate, tad� nig�h�to vaktavya�. 05817 s�dhana-vacana-anantara� prativi�ayam uttare vyartha� 05818 tad-ajㅰna-krama-gho�a�a-�loka-p葉ha-�din� k�la� gamayan kartavya- 05819 apratipatty� nigraha-arha iti ny�yya� nigrahasth�nam 05820 iti. 05901 k�rya-vy�sa�g�t kath�-vicchedo vik�epa�. yat ki�cit kartavya� 05902 vy�sajya kath盛 vicchinatti, ida� me kara鰍ya� 05903 parih�yate, asminn avasite pa�c�t kari�y�mi, prati�y�yakal� 05904 me ka椿ha� k�i�oty evam-�din� kath盛 vicchinatti, sa vik�epo 05905 n�ma nigrahasth�nam. ekatara-nigraha-ant�y盛 kath�y盛 05906 svayam eva kath�-anta� pratipadyata iti. 05907 idam apy yadi p�rvapak�a-v�d� kury�d vy�ja-upak�epa-m�tre�a, 05908 na punar bh�tasya tath�vidha-kath�-uparodhina� k�ryasya 05909 bh�ve, tasya sva-s�dhana-as�marthya-paricched�d eva 05910 vik�epa� sy�t. tath� ca idam artha-antara-gamana eva antarbhaved 05911 asamartha-s�dhana-abhidh�n�d hetv-�bh�se�u v�. prak�ta- 05912 s�dhana-asambaddha-pratipatte� ca nirarthaka-ap�rthak�bhy盛 05913 na bhidyate. atiprasa�ga� ca eva�prak�r性�m asambaddha- 06001 s�dhana-v�kya-pratipatti-bhed�n盛 p�thag-nigrahasth�na- 06002 vyavasth�pane prokta�. atha uttarapak�a-v�dy eva� vik�ipet, 06003 tasya api s�dhana-anantaram uttare pratipattavye tad-apratipatty� 06004 vik�epa-pratipattir apratibh�y�m artha-antare v� antarbhavati. 06006 nanu na ava�ya� s�dhana-d余a鎚bhy�m eva sarvasya pratipattir, 06007 yena sarv� v�di-prativ�dinor na asamyak-pratipattir 06008 hetv-�bh�se�v apratibh�y盛 v� antarbhavet. bhavati hi anibaddhena 06009 api kath�-prapa쨇ena viv�da iti, na, asambhav�t. 06010 ekatra adhikara�e viruddha-abhyupagamayor viv�da� sy�t, aviruddha- 06011 abhyupagamayor anabhyupagamayor v� viv�d�-abh�v�t. 06012 tatra ava�yam ekasya pr�g-vacana-prav�tti�, yugapat-prav�ttau 06013 paraspara-vacana-�rava�a-avadh�ra�a-uttar性�m asambhavena 06014 prav�tti-vaiphaly�t svastha-�tman�m aprav�tte�. tena 06015 ca sva-upagama-upany�se ava�ya� s�dhana� vaktavyam, 06016 anyath� pare咸m apratipatte�, apare�a ca tat-sambandhi d余a�am. 06017 ubhayor asamyak-pratipattau hetv-�bh�sa-apratibhayo� 06018 prasa�ga iti. sarvo ny�ya-prav�tta� p�rva-uttarapak�a-upany�so 06101 dvaya� na atipatati. etena eva vita出� pratyukta-abhyupagama- 06102 abh�ve viv�da-abh�v�t. 06103 yad� tarhy abhyupagamya v�da� viphalatay� na ki�cid 06104 vakti, anyad v� yat ki�cit pralapati, tad� katha� hetv-�bh�sa- 06105 antarbh�va�. asamarthita-s�dhana-abhidh�na evam uktam, 06106 anabhidh�na anya-abhidh�nayor api par�jaya eva ity uktam 06107 abhyupagamya v�dam as�dhana-a�ga-vacan�t. etena adhikasya 06108 punaruktasya ca pratijㅰ-�der vacanasya ca nigrahasth�natva� 06109 vy�khy�tam, tad api hi pratip�dita-artha-viparyayatv�t 06110 s�dhana-s�marthya-anabhidh�nam. aprat�ta-pratyayatay� lak�a鎚t 06111 s�dhanasya as�dhana-a�ga-vacanam iti nigrahasth�nam 06112 iti. 06113 sva-pak�a-do�a-abhyupagam�t para-pak�e do�a-prasa�go mata-anujㅰ. 06114 ya� pare�a codita� do�am anuddh�tya, bhavato 06115 apy aya� do�a iti brav�ti, yath� bhav盛� caura� puru�atv�d 06116 ity ukte sa ta� pratibr�y�d, bhav�n api iti, sa sva-pak�e do�a-abhyupagam�t 06117 para-pak�e ta� do�a� prasa쨓ayan para-matam 06118 anuj�n�ti iti mata-anujㅰ nigrahasth�nam iti. 06201 atra api yadi puru�atv�c cauro bhav�n api sy�t, na ca bhavat� 06202 �tm� evam i亢a�, tasm�n na aya� caurya-hetur iti yady 06203 ayam abhipr�ya�, tad� na ka�cid do�a�, anabhimate tad-�tmani 06204 cauratvena hetu-dar�anena d余a鎚t. 06205 prasa�gam antare�a 西jasena eva ki� na vyabhic�rita iti 06206 cet, yat ki�cid etat, santi hy eva�prak�r� api vyavah�r� loka 06207 iti. atha tad upak�epam abhyupagacchaty eva, tad� apy 06208 as�v uttara-apratipatty� eva tat-s�dhane nigraha-arha�, na aparatra 06209 sva-do�a-upak�ep�t, tat-s�dhana-nirdo�at�y盛 hi tad-abhyupagama 06210 eva uttara-apratipattir iti t�vat� eva p�rvam �panna-nigrahasya 06211 para-do�a-upak�epasya anapek�a鰍yatv�d iti. 06212 nigraha-pr�ptasya anigraha� paryanuyojya-upek�a�am. paryanuyojyo 06213 n�ma nigraha-upapatty� codan�ya�, tasya upek�a�a� 06214 nigraha-pr�pto asi ity ananuyoga�. etac ca kasya par�jaya 06215 ity anuyuktay� par�ad� vaktavyam, na khalu nigraha-pr�pta� 06216 sva-kaup�na� viv寤uy�d iti. 06301 atra api yadi s�dhana-v�dina� nigraha-pr�ptam uttara-v�d� 06302 na paryanuyu�kte, apratibh� eva asya uttara-apratipatter iti na 06303 paryanuyojya-upek�a�a� p�thag nigrahasth�nam. ny�ya-cint�y盛 06304 punar na dvayor ekasya api atra jaya-par�jayau, s�dhana- 06305 �bh�sena artha-apratip�dan�d bh�ta-do�a-anabhidh�n�c ca. 06306 atha ka�cid do�am udbh�vayati, ka�cin na, na tad� 06307 nigraham arhati uttara-pratipatte�. 06308 arhati eva, sarvasya sato do�asya anudbh�van�d iti cet, na 06309 santa iti k�tv� sarve do咸 ava�ya� vaktavy� avacane v� 06310 nigraha�, ekena api tat-s�dhana-vigh�t�d, eka-s�dhana-vacana-vat. 06311 yath� ekasya artha-asya aneka-s�dhana-sadbh�ve apy ekena eva 06312 tat-siddher na sarva-up�d�nam iti na do�am udbh�vayann eva aparasya 06313 anudbh�van�n nigraha-arha�. 06401 atha p�rva-pak�a-v�d� uttara-pak�a-v�dina� nigraha-pr�pta� 06402 na nig�h鎚ti, tad� tayor ny�yena na ekasya api p�rvavaj 06403 jaya-par�jayau. do�a-�bh�sa� br�v�nam uttara-v�dina� sva- 06404 s�dhan�d anuts�rayato asamarthita-s�dhana-a�gatv�n na jayo 06405 v�dina�, sarva-do�a-asambhava-pradar�anena s�dhana-a�ga-samarthan�t. 06406 na apy uttara-v�dino bh�ta-do�a-apratip�dan�t. tasm�d 06407 evam api na paryanuyojya-upek�a�a� n�ma par�jaya-adhikara�am 06408 iti. 06409 asth�ne nigrahasth�na-anuyogo niranuyojya-anuyoga�. nigrahasth�na- 06410 lak�a�asya mithy�-avas�y�d anigrahasth�ne nig�h�to 06411 asi iti bruvan niranuyojya-anuyog�n nig�h�to vaktavya�. 06412 atra api yadi tat-s�dhana-v�dinam abh�tair do�air uttara- 06413 v�dy abhiyu쨓�ta, so asth�ne nirdo�e nigrahasth�nasya abhiyokta- 06414 udbh�vayit� na bhavati. tath� ca bh�ta-do�a-udbh�vana-lak�a�asya 06415 uttarasya apratipatter itare�a uttara-�bh�satve pratip�dite 06501 apratibhay� eva nig�h�ta iti na idam ato nigrahasth�na-antaram. 06503 atha uttara-v�dina� bh�ta� s�dhana-do�am udbh�vayantam 06504 aparo do�a-�bh�sa-vacanena abhiyu쨓�ta, tasya tena bh�ta- 06505 do�atve pratip�dite s�dhana-�bh�sa-vacanena eva nig�h�ta iti. 06506 evam api na ida� hetv-�bh�sebhyo bhidyate. ava�ya� hi 06507 vi�aya-antara-vy�pty-artha� hetv-�bh�s� nigrahasth�natvena 06508 vaktavy筬, tad-ukt�v apara-uktir anarthak� iti. 06509 siddh�ntam abhyupety�-niyam�t kath�-prasa�go apasiddh�nta�. 06510 kasyacid arthasya tath�bh�va� pratijㅰya pratijㅰt�- 06511 artha-viparyay�t kath�-prasa�ga� kurvato apasiddh�nto 06512 vij쨎ya�. yath� na sato vin成a�, na asad utpadyata iti siddh�ntam 06513 abhyupetya pak�am avasth�payati ek� prak�tir 06514 vyaktasya, vik�r性�m anvaya-dar�an�t. m�d-anvay�n盛 �ar�va- 06515 �d�n盛 d敖�am eka-prak�tikatvam, tath� ca aya� vyakta- 06601 bhedas sukha-du�kha-moha-samanvito g�hyate. tat sukha-�dibhir 06602 eka-prak�tir iti. sa evam uktav�n paryanuyujyate. 06603 atha prak�tir vik�ra iti katha� lak�ayitavyam iti. yasya avasthitasya 06604 dharma-antara-niv�ttau dharma-antara� pravartate, 06605 s� prak�ti�. yat tad dharma-antaram, sa vik�ra iti. so aya� 06606 prak�ta-artha-viparyay�d aniyam�t kath盛 prasa쨓ayati. pratijㅰta� 06607 khalv anena na asad �virbhavati, na sat tirobhavati iti. 06608 sad-asato� ca tirobh�va-�virbh�v�v antare�a na kasyacit prav�tty- 06609 uparama� prav�ttir v� iti eva� pratyavasthito yadi sata 06610 �tma-h�nam asata� ca �tma-l�bham abhyupaiti, apasiddh�nto 06611 bhavati atha na abhyupaiti, pak�o asya na sidhyati iti. 06612 iha api na ka�cid aniyam�t kath�-prasa�ga� yat tena upagatan 06613 na asad utpadyate, na sad vina�yati iti tasya samarthan�ya 06614 idam uktam eka-prak�tikam ida� vyaktam anvaya-dar�an�d 06615 iti. tatra ek� prak�ti� sukha-du�kha-moha�. tad-avibhakta- 06616 yonikam ida� vyakta� tad-anvaya-dar�an�t. vyaktasya 06701 tat-svabh�vat�-bheda-upalabdher iti sukha-�d�n�m utpatti- 06702 vin成a-abhyupagama-abh�v�t sarvasya tad-�tmakasya na utpatti- 06703 vin成�v iti siddha� bhavati. atra tad-uktasya hetor do�am 06704 anudbh�vya vik�ra-prak�ti-lak�a�a� p�cchan svayam aya� 06705 prak�ta-asambandhena aniyam�t kath盛 pravartayati. 06706 tatra ida� sy�d v�cyam, vyakta� n�ma prav�tti-niv�tti- 06707 dharmakam, na tath� sukha-�daya�. vyaktasya sukha-�dy-anvaye 06708 sukha-�di-svabh�vat�y盛 prav�tti-niv�tti-dharmat�-lak�a�am 06701 avah�yata iti. na tad-rahita-sukha-�di-svabh�vat� vyakta-lak�a�a- 06709 virodh�d iti. sukha-�dy-anvaya-dar�an�d ity asiddho hetur 06711 iti. eva� hi tasya s�dhana-do�a-udbh�vanena pak�o d余ito 06712 bhavati. so anupasa�h�tya s�dhana-do�a� kath盛 prat�nayan 06713 sva-do�a� paratra upak�ipati. 06714 ayam eva do�o anena prakara�ena ucyata iti cet, e�a naimittik性盛 06715 vi�aya�, na loka� �abdair apratip�ditam artha� 06716 pratipattu� samartha iti. sa eva aya� bha出�lekhyany�yo 06717 atra api. yathoktena ny�yena p�rvakasya as�dhana-a�gasya asiddhasya 06718 hetor abhidh�n�d eva nigraha�, na api aniyam�t 06719 kath�-prasa�g�d iti. idam api hetv-�bh�se�v antarbh�v�n na 06720 p�thag v�cyam. 06801 hetv-�bh�s成 ca yathokt筬. hetv-�bh�s成 ca nigrahasth�n�ni. 06802 ki� punar lak�a�a-antara-yog�d hetv-�bh�s� nigrahasth�na- 06803 bh�vam �padyante, yath� pram性�ni prameyatvam 06804 ity ata �ha yathokta-hetv-�bh�sa-lak�a�ena eva nigrahasth�na- 06805 bh�va iti. 06806 atra api yathokta� k�tv� cintyam eva, ki� te yath�lak�ita-prabhed�s 06807 tath� eva, �hosvid anyath� iti. tat tu cintyam�nam 06808 iha atiprasajyata iti na pratanyate. hetv-�bh�s成 ca yath�ny�ya� 06809 nigrahasth�nam iti et�van-m�tram i亢am iti. 06810 loke avidy�-timira-pa�ala-ullekhanas tattva-d敖�er 06811 v�dany�ya� parahita-ratair e�a sadbhi� pra鰍ta� / 06812 tattva-�loka� timirayati ta� durvidagdho jano aya� 06813 tasm�d yatna� k�ta iha may� tat-samujjv�lan�ya //3// 06814 v�dany�yo n�ma prakara�a� sam�ptam.