DHARMAKIRTI: HETUBINDU Input by Motoi Ono Text used: E. STEINKELLNER, Dharmakirti's Hetubinduh. Teil I. Tibetischer Text und rekonstruierter Sanskrit-Text. Wien 1967. 旼컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴커 � THIS TEXT FILE IS FOR REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY! � � COPYRIGHT AND TERMS OF USAGE AS FOR SOURCE FILE. � � � � Text converted to Classical Sanskrit Extended � � (CSX) encoding: � � � � description character = ASCII � � � � long a � 224 � � long A � 226 � � long i � 227 � � long I � 228 � � long u � 229 � � long U � 230 � � vocalic r � 231 � � vocalic R � 232 � � long vocalic r � 233 � � vocalic l � 235 � � long vocalic l � 237 � � velar n � 239 � � velar N � 240 � � palatal n � 164 � � palatal N � 165 � � retroflex t � 241 � � retroflex T � 242 � � retroflex d � 243 � � retroflex D � 244 � � retroflex n � 245 � � retroflex N � 246 � � palatal s � 247 � � palatal S � 248 � � retroflex s � 249 � � retroflex S � 250 � � anusvara � 252 � � anusvara (overdot) � 167 � � capital anusvara � 253 � � visarga � 254 � � (capital visarga 255) � � � � Other characters of the CSX encoding table are � � not included. Accents have been dropped in order � � to facilitate word search. � 읕컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴컴켸 Explanatory Remarks A number of five figures at the left side indicates the location of the key word in the basic texts. In the case of the SV, the HB and the VN, the first three figures indicate the page number, and the last two indicate the line number (for example, SV16026=SV 160,26; HB02314=HB 23,14; VN06110=VN 61,10). In the case of the PV and the NB, the second figure indicates the chapter number and the last three figures indicate the karika or sutra number (for example, PV02232=PV, the Pramanasiddhi-chapter v.232; NB03015=NB, the Pararthanumana-chapter sutra 15. In the case of the SP, the last two figures indicate the karika number (for example, SP00015=SP, v.15). 3. In this database, sentences are artificially divided into word-units, although they involve a phonetic fusion or union in the basic texts. Further, compound words are divided into their shortest constitutive elements (we use a hyphen to indicate that hyphenated elements originally form a compound word) with the following exceptions: 3.1. The prefixes a-, dur-, nih- remain undivided, irrespective of attachment to words or compound words. 3.2. Suffixes making an adverb, for example -vat, -vasa, are divided. But suffixes making a possessive adjective, for example -vat, -mat, remain undivided, and terms such as a numeral+ -dha/-vidha/-prakara remain also undivided. 3.3. Compound words with the suffixes -ta/-tva or -bhava/-bhuta fundamentally remain undivided. For example: karyakaranabhava/-bhuta/-ta. 3.4. Compound words with evam-, tat-, tatha-, para-, yatha-, su-, sva- in the wordhead fundamentally remain undivided. For example: evamjatiya, tadutpatti, tathakrta, paratantra, yathartha, yathasvam, sujnanatva, svabhava. 3.5. Some compound words which are regarded as terminology remain also undivided. For example: agnihotra, ayogavyavaccheda, arthapatti, padartha, paramartha, prasajyapratisedha, viruddhavyabhicarin, samanantarapratyaya, samtanaparinama, samanyalaksana, svabhavapratibandha. 4. Those terms whose wordhead is subject to the Sandhi rules (for example, -d dhetu-) are cited in their original form (for example, -d *hetu-) for the sake of using this database to make an KWIC index. 1. August. 1997 / Tsukuba Motoi ONO Note: This database is quite a tentative one, and I must admit that there are a lot of errors and defects in this version. I would appreciate it very much if the user would point out any errors in this version so that we can make a better new version in the future. E-mail: ono@logos.tsukuba.ac.jp ***************************************************************************** 00104 namo buddh�ya. 00105 parok�a-artha-pratipatter anum�na-成rayatv�t tad-vyutp�dana- 00106 artha� sa�k�epata idam �rabhyate. 00108 pak�a-dharmas tad-a嚆ena vy�pto hetus tridh� eva sa� / 00109 avin�bh�va-niyam�d hetv�bh�s�s tato apare // 00110 pak�o dharm�, avayave samud�ya-upac�r�t. prayojana-abh�v�d 00111 anupac�ra iti cet, na, sarva-dharmi-dharma-prati�edha-arthatv�d 00112 upac�rasya. eva� hi c�k�u�atva-�di-parih�ta� bhavati. 00113 dharma-vacanena api dharmasya par成rayatv�d dharmy-成raya- 00114 siddhau dharmi-graha鎚t praty�satte� s�dhya-dharmi-siddhir iti 00115 cet, na, d敖焌nta-dharmi�o api praty�satte�. tad-a嚆a-vy�pty� 00116 d敖焌nta-dharmi�i sattva-siddher dharmi-vacan�t s�dhya-dharmi- 00117 parigraha�. siddhe api punar-vacana� niyama-artham 成a�kyeta. 00118 saj�t�ya eva sattvam iti siddhe api tad-abh�ve vyatireke 00119 s�dhya-abh�ve asattva-vacana-vat tad-a嚆a-vy�pti-vacan�t siddhe 00120 api d敖焌nta-dharmi�i sattve dharmi-vacana� tatra eva bh�va- 00121 niyama-artham 成a�kyeta. tasm�t s�marthy�d artha-gat�v apy 00201 upac�ra-m�tr�t sam�na-nirde妬t pratipatti-gaurava� ca parih�ta� 00202 bhavati. pak�asya dharmatve tad-vi�e�a�a-apek�asya anyatra ananuv�tter 00203 as�dh�ra�at� iti cet, na, ayogavyavacchedena vi�e�a鎚d 00204 yath� caitro dhanurdhara iti na anyayogavyavacchedena yath� 00205 p�rtho dhanurdhara iti. 00206 tad-a嚆as tad-dharma�. 00207 vy�ptir vy�pakasya tatra bh�va eva vy�pyasya v� 00208 tatra eva bh�va�. 00209 etena anvayo vyatireko v� pak�a-dharma� ca yath�sva� 00210 pram性ena ni�cita ukta�, sarvatra hetau s�dhya-dharma-abh�ve 00211 vy�pty-asiddher vy�paka-niv�ttau v� vyatireka-abh�v�t anvaya-vyatirek�bhy盛 00212 ni�cit�bhy盛 tad-a嚆a-vy�ptir ni�cit�. 00213 tatra pak�a-dharmasya s�dhya-dharmi�i pratyak�ato anum�nato 00214 v� prasiddhir ni�caya�, yath� prade�e dh�masya �abde 00215 v� k�takatvasya. sadh�ma� hi prade�am arth�ntara-vivikta-r�pam 00216 as�dh�ra�a-�tman� d敖�avata� pratyak�e�a yath�-d敖�a-bheda-vi�aya� 00217 sm�rta� li�ga-vijㅰnam utpadyate. 00218 tatra yad �dyam as�dh�ra�a-vi�aya� dar�ana� tad 00219 eva pram性am. 00220 tasmin tath�bh�te d敖�e sati sa yena yena as�dh�ra�as 00221 tad-as�dh�ra�at盛 tato bhedam abhilapanty atad-vy�v�tti-vi�ay� 00222 sm�tir utpann� pratyak�a-balena yath�d敖�a-�k�ra-graha鎚n na 00223 pram性am, pr�g as�dh�ra�a� d敖�v� as�dh�ra�a ity abhilapato 00224 ap�rva-artha-adhigama-abh�v�d arthakriy�-s�dhanasya dar�an�d 00225 ad敖�asya punas tat-s�dhana-svabh�vasya vikalpena apratipatte� 00301 ca anum�na-vat. arthakriy�-arth� hi sarva� pram性am apram性a� 00302 v� anve�ate prek咸v�n, na ca s�m�nya� k盛cid arthakriy�m 00303 upakalpayati svalak�a�a-pratipatter �rdhva� tat-s�marthya-utpanna- 00304 vikalpa-vijㅰna-gr�hya� yath� n�la� d敖�v� n�lam iti 00305 jㅰne. tad eva hi n�la-svalak�a�a� tath�vidha-s�dhya-arthakriy�k�ri, 00306 tac ca tena �tman� d敖�am eva pratyak�e�a. na ca 00307 tat-svalak�a�a-graha�a-uttarak�labh�vi-n�la-vikalpasya vi�aye�a n�la- 00308 artha-s�dhya-arthakriy� kriyate. tasm�d anadhigata-artha-vi�aya� 00309 pram性am ity apy anadhigate svalak�a�a iti vi�e�an�yam. 00310 adhigate tu svalak�a�e tat-s�marthya-janm� vikalpas tad-anuk�r� 00311 k�ryatas tad-vi�ayatv�t sm�tir eva na pram性am, anadhigata- 00312 vastu-r�pa-anadhigate�, vastv-adhi亢h�natv�t pram性a-vyavasth�y筬, 00313 arthakriy�-yogya-vi�ayatv�t tad-arthin盛 prav�tte�, 00314 arthakriy�-yogya-lak�a�a� hi vastu; tato api vikalp�d vastuny 00315 eva tad-adhyavas�yena prav�tte�, prav�ttau vikalpasya pratyak�e�a 00316 abhinna-yogak�ematv�t. 00317 p�rva-pratyak�a-k�a�ena upayoga-abhed�d uttare�u kasyacid 00318 apr�m性ya-prasa�ga iti cet, na, k�a�a-vi�e�a-s�dhya-artha-v西ch�y盛 00319 n�n�-yogak�ematv�t. s�dh�ra�e hi k�rye na te咸� s�marthya-bheda�, 00320 apar�para-dh�ma-pramita-sa�nik敖�a-agni�v iva agni-m�tra-s�dhye 00401 arthe. etena dharma-dharmi-li�ga-�di-vikalpasya pram性a-p敖�ha- 00402 bh�vina� pr�m性ya� pratyuktam. 00403 anvaya-ni�cayo api svabh�vahetau s�dhya-dharmasya vastutas 00404 tad-bh�vatay� s�dhana-dharma-bh�va-m�tra-anubandha- 00405 siddhi�. s� s�dhya-viparyaye hetor b�dhaka-pram性a-v�tti�. 00406 yath� yat sat tat k�a�ikam eva, ak�a�ikatve arthakriy�-virodh�t 00407 tal-lak�a�a� vastutva� h�yate. k�ryahetau k�ryak�ra�abh�va- 00408 siddhi�, yath� idam asya upalambha upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pta� 00409 pr�g anupalabdham upalabhyate, satsv apy anye�u hetu�v 00410 asya abh�ve na bhavati iti yas tad-bh�ve bh�vas tad-abh�ve 00411 abh�va� ca pratyak�a-anupalambha-s�dhana� k�ryak�ra�abh�vas 00412 tasya siddhi�. k�ryak�ra�abh�va eva hy arth�ntarasya eva� 00413 sy�t yatra dh�mas tatra ava�yam agni�, agner bh�va 00414 eva hi bh�vo dh�masya tat-k�ryatvam. anupalabdh�v apy 00415 anvaya-ni�cayo asad-vyavah�rasya upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pta-anupalabdhi- 00416 m�tre v�tti-s�dhana� nimitta-antara-abh�va-upadar�an�t. 00417 vyatireka-ni�cayo api k�rya-svabh�vaheto� k�ryak�ra�a- 00418 vy�pyavy�pakabh�va-siddhau d惡ya-vi�ay�bhy盛 k�ra�a-vy�paka- 00419 anupalabdhibhy盛 s�dhya-abh�ve hetv-abh�va-siddhir uddi亢a- 00420 vi�ayasya abh�vasya upadar�ane, anyath� anupalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya 00421 kvacid abh�va-asiddhe�. anuddi亢a-vi�aya� s�dhya-abh�ve 00422 abh�va-khy�pana� apratibandha-m�tra-siddhau sidhyati iti na tatra 00501 vyatireka-s�dhane anupalabdhyor d惡ya-vi�ayat� apek�yate. vyatireka- 00502 ni�cayo anupalabdh�v upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pt�t sato anupalambha- 00503 abh�va-dar�anam. 00504 etal-lak�a�as tridh� eva so hetus triprak�ra eva, svabh�va� 00505 k�ryam anupalabdhi� ca iti yath� anitye kasmi嚆cit s�dhye sattvam 00506 agnimati prade�e dh�mo abh�ve ca upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya anupalabdhir 00507 ity atra eva trividhe avin�bh�va-niyam�t. pak�a-dharmasya 00508 yathokt� vy�ptir avin�bh�va�; sa trividh�d hetor 00509 anyatra na asti ity atra eva niyata ucyate. 00510 tatra s�dhana-dharma-bh�va-m�tra-anvayini s�dhya-dharme 00511 svabh�vo hetu�. apar�para-vy�v�tti-bhedena dharma-bhede api 00512 vastuto li�gi-svabh�va eva hetu-svabh�ve anvaya-vyabhic�ra-abh�v�l 00513 lak�a�e tan-m�tra-anvayena vi�e�a�a� para-mata-apek�am. 00514 pare hy arth�ntara-nimittam atad-bh�va-m�tra-anvayinam api 00515 dharma� svabh�vam icchanti. vi�e�a�ena tath�vidhasya atat- 00516 svabh�vat盛 tasmin s�dhye hetor vyabhic�ra� ca �ha, yath� 00517 hetumati vin成e k�takatvasya. 00518 tasya dvidh� prayoga�; s�dharmye�a vaidharmye�a ca, 00519 yath� yat sat tat sarva� k�a�ika� yath� gha�a-�daya� sa嚆 00520 ca �abda iti, tath� k�a�ikatva-abh�ve sattva-abh�va�, sa嚆 ca 00521 �abda ity anvaya-vyatirek�bhy盛 sarva-upasa�h�re�a vy�pti-pradar�ana 00522 lak�a�au s�dharmya-vaidharmya-prayogau. 00523 atra s�marthy�d eva pratijㅰ-arthasya prat�ter na pratijㅰy筬 00524 prayoga�. apradar�ite prameye arthe katha� tat-prat�tir iti cet. 00601 svaya� pratipattau prameyasya ka upadar�ayit�. prade�a-stha� 00602 dh�mam upalabdhavatas tasya agnin� vy�pte� smara�e tat-s�marthy�d 00603 eva agnir atra iti prat�tir bhavati. na ca tatra ka�cid 00604 agnir atra ity asmai nivedayati. na api pr�g eva pratipadyate 00605 ki�cit, pram性am antare�a eva� prat�ter nimitta-abh�v�t. 00606 prat�tau li�gasya vaiyarthya�. svayam eva akasm�d 00607 agnir atra iti prameya� vyavasth�pya pa�c�t tat-pratipattaye 00608 li�gam anusarati iti ko aya� pratipatte� krama�. pare�a api 00609 tad ucyam�na� plavata eva, upayoga-abh�v�t. vi�aya-upadar�anam 00610 upayoga iti cet, tena eva t�vad dar�itena ko artha�. yadi 00611 prat�tir anyath� na sy�t, sarva� �obheta. tasm�d e�a� svaya� 00612 prat�tau vin� api kenacid vi�aya-upasth�pakena pratiyan asm�n 00613 k�ryi�o d敖�v� parvabr�hma�a iva vyakta� m�lya� m�gayate. 00614 asmad-vacan�d api svaya� siddham eva li�gam anus�tya 00615 pratyeti iti ko anayor avasthayor vi�e�a�. d敖焌 ca pak�a-dharma- 00616 sambandha-vacana-m�tr�d pratijㅰ-vacanam antare�a api prat�tir 00617 iti kas tasya upayoga�. sva-ni�caya-vad anye咸m api ni�caya-utp�dan�ya 00618 ca s�dhanam ucyate, tatra svayam aya� prameyasya upadar�anam 00619 antare�a api pratipadya para� pratip�dayan ap�rvam 00620 artha-kramam 成rayata iti kim atra k�ra�am. tasm�n na prameya- 00621 vacanena ki�cit prayojanam, anyath� api pratipatter 00622 utpatte�. 00623 etena upanaya-nigamana-�dikam api pratyuktam, et�vat� eva 00624 s�dhya-prat�ter bh�v�t. �i出ika-r�ga� parityajya-�k�i鰍- 00625 nim�lya cintaya t�vat kim iyat� prat�ti� sy�n na v�. bh�ve 00701 ki� prapa쨇a-m�lay�, iti iy�n eva s�dhana-v�kye prayogo 00702 jy�y�n. 00703 atra pak�a-dharma-sambandha-vacanayo� krama-niyamo api na 00704 ka�cit, sarvath� gamakatv�t. 00705 sambandha-vacane api kevala� prayogo bhinna�, ubhayath� api 00706 dharma-bhede tath� api tad-bh�vasya eva khy�pan�t. na hy 00707 atat-svabh�vasya bh�va ek�ntena anyabh�va� k�takatvasya bh�ve 00708 prayatn�nantar�yakatva-vat, na apy atat-svabh�vasya niv�tt�v ak�ryasya 00709 tasya niv�ttir yath� anayor eva dharmayor niv�tti�. tasm�d 00710 anvaya-vyatirekayor yath�-lak�a�am eko api prayukto dvit�yam 00711 �k�ipati iti na ekatra s�dhana-v�kye dvayo� prayoga i�yate, 00712 vaiyarthy�t, tat-svabh�vatay� anvaya-siddhau tad-abh�ve abh�va-siddhe�, 00713 tad-abh�ve abh�va-siddhau ca anvayasya api siddhe�. 00714 tad-abh�va eva abh�va-khy�tir yath� sy�n na anyatra viruddhe 00715 v� iti niyama-khy�pana-artho api vyatireka-prayogo na yukta�, 00716 anya-viruddhayor api vipak�atv�t. 00717 katham idam avagamyate sad ava�ya� na�vara-svabh�vam iti 00718 yena anvaya-vyatireka-sambhava iti cet, vin成a-hetv-ayog�t. svabh�vata 00719 eva na�var� bh�v筬; na e咸� ni�pann�n�m anyato 00720 vin成a-utpatti�, tasya as�marthy�t; na hi vin成a-hetur bh�va-svabh�vam 00721 eva karoti, tasya niv�tte�. na api bh�va-antaram eva, 00722 bh�va-antara-kara�e bh�ve tad-avasthe na ki�cit karoti iti tath�-upalabdhy- 00801 �di-prasa�ga�. na api bh�va-antaram asya �vara�am, tad-avasthe 00802 tasminn �vara�asya apy ayog�t. na api vin成a-hetun� bh�va-abh�va� 00803 kriyate, abh�vasya vidhin� upagame vyatireka-avyatireka- 00804 vikalpa-anatikram�t. bh�va-prati�edha-ekar�patve bh�va� na 00805 karoti iti sy�t, eva� ca akartur ahetutvam iti na vin成a-hetu� 00806 ka�cit. 00807 vaiyarthy�c ca. yadi svabh�vato na�vara� sv�tmany anavasth�y�- 00808 bh�va�, tasya na ki�cin n成a-k�ra�ai�, tat-svabh�vatay� 00809 eva svaya� n成�t. yo hi yat svabh�va� sa sva-hetor 00810 eva utpadyam�nas t�d惡o bhavati, na punas tad-bh�ve hetv-antaram 00811 apek�ate, prak成a-drava-u巷a-ka�hina-�di-dravya-vat. na hi prak成a-�dayas 00812 tad-�tm�na utpann� puna� prak成a-�di-bh�ve hetv-antaram 00813 apek�ante, tad-�tmanas t�d�tmya-abh�ve nair�tmya-pr�sa�g�t. 00814 tadvad asthiti-dharm� cet svabh�vato ni�panno na punas 00815 tad-�tmat�y盛 hetv-antaram apek�ate. 00816 b�ja-�di-vad anek�nta iti cet, sy�d etat: b�ja-�d�n�m a�kura-�di- 00817 janana-svabh�v�n�m api salila-�di-hetv-antara-apek�a鎚t keval� na 00818 janayanti, tadvad bh�vo api vin成e sy�d iti. na tat-svabh�vasya 00819 janan�d ajanakasya ca atat-svabh�vatv�t. ata eva 00820 tayor avasthayor vastu-bhedo ni�ceya�, bh�v�n盛 svabh�va 00821 anyath�tva-abh�v�t tat-svabh�vasya pa�c�d iva pr�g api 00822 janana-prasa�g�t. tasm�d yo antyo avasth�-vi�e�a� sa eva a�kura-�di- 00901 janana-svabh�va�. p�rva-bh�vinas tv avasth�-vi�e咸� k�ra�asya 00902 k�ra鎚ni iti na anek�nta�, k�a�ike�u bh�ve�v apar�para-utpatter 00903 aikya-abh�v�t. 00904 te anty筬 samarth筬 ki� na janayanti iti, janayanty 00905 eva, na atra anyath�bh�va� svabh�vasya avaipar�ty�t. te�u sarve�u 00906 sahak�ri�u samartha-svabh�ve�u ko aparasya upayoga iti cet, na vai 00907 bh�v�n盛 k�cit prek咸-p�rva-k�rit� yato ayam eko api samartha� 00908 kim asm�bhir ity apare nivarteran. nirabhipr�ya-vy�p�r� 00909 hi sva-hetu-pari鎚ma-upanidhi-dharm�s tat-prak�tes tath�bhavanto 00910 na up�lambham arhanti. samarth筬 ki� na apar�para� janayanti 00911 iti cet, na, tatra eva s�marthy�t. tasya eva ekasya janane 00912 samarth� na anyasya iti na apar�para-jananam. 00913 bhinna-svabh�vebhya� cak�ur-�dibhya� sahak�ribhya eka- 00914 k�rya-utpattau na k�ra�a-bhed�t k�rya-bheda� sy�d iti cet, 00915 na, yath�sva� svabh�va-bhedena tad-vi�e�a-upayogatas tad-upayoga- 00916 k�rya-svabh�va-vi�e�a-asa�kar�t, yath� m�t-pi出a-kul�la 00917 s�tra-�dibhyo bhavato gha�asya m�t-pi出�d am�t-svabh�vebhyo 00918 v�k�a-�dibhyo bhinna� svabh�va� kul�l�t tasya eva m�d-�tmana� 00919 sata� sa�sth�na-vi�e�a-�tmatay� tad-anyebhyo bhinna� s�tr�t 00920 tasya eva m�t-sa�sth�na-vi�e�a-�tmana� cakra-�der vibhakta� svabh�vo 00921 bhavati; tad eva� na kul�l�n m�t-svabh�vat�, na 01001 m�da� sa�sth�na-vi�e�a�; na ca tayo� �akti-vi�e�a-vi�aya- 01002 bhedo api taj-janita-vi�e�a-bhedasya k�ryasya svabh�va-bheda�, 01003 m�t-sa�sth�nayor aparaspara-�tmatay� sa�sth�na-m�d-r�p�bhy盛 01004 tayor apratibh�sana-prasa�g�t. 01005 anyad eva sa�sth�na� gu�o m�d-dravy�t, tena bhinna- 01006 svabh�va� kul�la-m�t-pi出ayor upayoga-vi�aya iti cet, uktam 01007 atra. api ca yadi sa�sth�na� bhinna� m�da�, kul�la� ki� 01008 na p�thak karoti. gu�asya dravya-paratantratvam iti na p�thak 01009 karoti. tat-sa�sth�na-�dh�ra-�tmaka� yadi svabh�vena tad dravya� 01010 tat-sa�sth�na� v� tad-�dheya-�tmakam, ki� kul�la-apek�ay� iti cet, 01011 na, tata� paraspara-sambandha-yogyat�-pratilambh�t; anyath� 01012 vastuna eva yogyat� dharmat� iti pr�g api m�t-pi出asya sa�sth�na- 01013 vi�e�a-sambandha-yogyatve sati sa�sth�na-vi�e�e�a sambandha- 01014 prasa�ga�. eva� tarhi s� yogyat� m�d-dravyasya kul�l�d 01015 bhavati iti na anayo� svabh�va-bheda�, bhede hi pr�g-vat prasajyeta. 01016 asti t�vad eka-svabh�vatve api kasyacid aneka-pratyaya-upadheya- 01017 vi�e�at� iti na m�t-sa�sth�nayor eka-svabh�vatva-s�dhan�ya 01018 nirbandha�. 01019 tena sahak�ri�a� pratyay� na eka-upayoga-vi�ay筬 k�rya- 01020 svabh�vasya ekatve api vastuta iti yath� iha k�ra�a-bhedo bhinna- 01021 vi�e�a-upayog�n na eka-k�ryas tath� cak�ur-�dibhyo vijㅰna-utpatt�v 01022 unneya�. tath� hi samanantarapratyay�d vijㅰn�c 01101 cak�urvijㅰnasya upalambha-�tmat� tasya eva upalambha-�tmana� 01102 sata� cak�ur-indriy�d r�pa-graha�a-yogyat�-pratiniyamo vi�ay�t 01103 tat tulya-r�pat� ity abhinnatve api vastuta� k�ryasya k�ra鎚n盛 01104 bhinnebhya� svabh�vebhyo bhinn� eva vi�e咸 bhavanti iti na 01105 k�ra�a-bhede apy abhedas tat-k�rya-vi�e�asya. ta eva ete k�ra�a- 01106 �akti-bhed� yath�sva� prativi�i亢a-k�rya-janane avyavadheya- 01107 �aktitay� pratyupasthit筬 k�a�ikatv�t s�magr�-k�ryasya svabh�va- 01108 sthity-成raya ity ucyante. tath� hi tat tebhya� samastebhya 01109 upalambha-�tmaka� r�pa-graha�a-pratiniyata� vi�aya- 01110 r�pa� ca iti prativi�i亢a-svabh�vam eka� j�tam. 01111 apratirodha-�aktike�v anantara-k�rye�v an�dheyavi�e�e�u k�a�ike�u 01112 pratyaye�u paraspara� ka� sahak�ra-artha iti cet, na vai 01113 sarvatra ati�aya-utp�dana� sahakriy�. ki� tarhi. bah�n盛 yad 01114 eka-artha-kara�am api, yath� antyasya k�ra�a-kal�pasya. tad 01115 eva mukhya� sahak�ritva� sahak�r辰�m, tasya eva antyasya 01116 k�ra�atv�t tatra ca k�a�a ekasya svabh�vasya avivek�d vi�e�asya 01117 kartum a�akyatv�t, svabh�va-antara-utpatti-lak�a�atv�d vi�e�a- 01118 utpatte�. bh�va-antara-utpatt�v antya� na sy�t, tata� ca na 01119 s�k咸t k�ra�a� sy�t. tasm�n na k�ra�asya sahak�ribhyo vi�e�a- 01120 utpatti�. te samarth筬 svabh�vato anty筬 pratyay筬 01121 saha j�yante k�a�ik� ye咸� pr�g-pa�c�t-p�thag-bh�vo na asti 01122 yebhya� ca anantara� k�ryam utpadyate, tatra eka-arthakriy� 01123 eva sahak�ritvam. 01201 samartha� kuto j�yata iti cet, sva-k�ra�ebhya�. 01202 t�ny enam apara-pratyaya-sa�nidh�na ki� janayanti, 01203 kad�cid anyath� api syu�, tata� ca eko api kvacid janayed iti 01204 cet, apar�para-pratyaya-yogena pratik�a�a� bhinna-�aktaya� 01205 sa�sk�r筬 santanvanto yady api kuta�cit s�my�t sar�p筬 01206 prat�yante, tath� api bhinna eva e咸� svabh�va�; tena ki�cid 01207 eva kasyacit k�ra�am. 01208 tatra yo avyavadh�na-�di-de�o r�pa-indriya-�di-kal�pa� sa vijㅰna- 01209 janane samartho hetu�. yas te咸� paraspara-upasarpa�a- 01210 �dy-成raya� pratyaya-vi�e�a� sa tad-hetu-janane samartha�. 01211 te咸� ca na p�rva� na pa�c�n na p�thag bh�va iti samarth�n 01212 api p�rva-apara-p�thag-bh�va-bh�vino do咸 na upal�yante. tena yas 01213 te咸� paraspara-upasarpa�a-�di-hetu� sa samarthasya hetur iti tatra 01214 na kad�cid anyath�bh�va�. anena ny�yena sarvatra hetu-phala- 01215 bh�va-pratiniyamo boddhavya� pratik�a�am any�nya-svabh�va- 01216 bheda-anvayin實u bh�va-�akti�u, na tu sthira-eka-svabh�ve�u bh�ve�u, 01217 svabh�vasya anyath�tva-asambhav�t samartha-asamartha-svabh�v�n盛 01218 kriy�-akriy�-anupapatte�. 01219 anya-sahita� karoti na kevala iti cet, ki� kevalasya k�rya- 01220 janane samartha� svabh�vo asamartho v� samartha iti cet, ki� 01221 na karoti, akurvan katha� samartha�. kuvinda-�daya� pa�a-�di- 01222 kriy�y盛 samarth� api na sarvad� kurvanti iti cet, kr身ana-鬪lo 01301 dev�n盛priyo 01301 m�rkha� sukhaidhita� k�tam api puna� puna� 01302 k�rayati, tath� hy etad b�ja-�dy-upany�se nirlo�hitam. tasm�t 01303 svabh�vasya anyath�tva-asambhav�t tad-dharma�as tath�bh�vo 01304 antya-avasth�-vad aniv�rya�. 01305 antya-avasth�y盛 pr�g asamarthasya s�marthya-utpattau 01306 s�marthyasya tat-svabh�vatve ap�rva-utpattir eva s�, atat-svabh�vatve 01307 so ak�raka eva, s�marthya-�khy�d bh�v�t k�rya-utpatte�. 01308 api ca sa eva t�vat sakala-sahak�ri-sahita� k�rya� kasm�t 01309 karoti kurvan d敖�a�, tena karoti iti br�ma�. aho mah�-s�marthya� 01310 mah�-prabh�vasya dar�anam atat-svabh�v�n api bh�v�n 01311 svabh�va-m�tre�a n�n�-vy�p�re�u niyu쨓anam. yadi n�ma 01312 kad�cit ki�cit katha�cit atra-bhavanto dar�ana-patham atikr�met, 01313 hanta-aprasava-dharmakam apeta-sant�na� sy�d iti iya� 01314 cint� citta� dunoti. na vai vayam atat-svabh�v�n�m asmad-dar�ana- 01315 va妬t k�rya-kriy盛 br�ma�. ki� tarhi. svabh�vena eva te 01316 tat-kara�a-dharm筬, t�n pa�yanta� kevala� j�n�mahe ta ete 01317 k�rak� iti. satyam, idam apy asti, svabh�vas te咸� k�rya-kriy�- 01318 dharm�, tena samasta-pratyayavat�m ak�tv� na upek咸 �pattir iti. 01319 so ak�epa-kriy�-dharm� svabh�va� ki� te咸� tad� eva antya- 01320 avasth�y�m utpanna �hosvit pr�g apy �s�t. �s�t, apracyuta-utpanna- 01321 sthira-eka-svabh�v�n盛 kad�cana kasyacit svabh�vasya abh�va- 01401 virodh�t. tat kim id�n尋 m�t� ca vandhy� ca; ko v� asya 01402 bh晟itasya artho ak�epa-kriy�-dharm� ca svabh�vo na ca karoti iti. 01403 sahitas tat-svabh�vo na kevala iti cet, anyas tarhi kevalo 01404 anya� ca sahitas, svabh�va-bhedo hi bh�va-bhedasya lak�a�am. 01405 na hi sa s�hitye api parar�pe�a kart�; svar�pa� ca asya pr�g 01406 api tad eva iti katha� kad�cit kriy�-vir�ma�. yasya api bh�va� 01407 k�a�ikas tasya api kasm�t kevalo na karoti, yadi bhavet, kury�d eva. 01408 katha� na bhavati. k�a�ikatv�t. ukta� y�d惡asya kriy�. sa katham 01409 eka-k�a�a-bh�vy anyath� bhavet. ya� ca bhavati, sa eva na 01410 bhavati iti na aya� prasa�ga�, k�raka-ak�rakayo� svabh�va-tad- 01411 hetor virodh�t. 01412 yo api manyate ak�epa-kriy�-dharm� eva sa tasya svabh�va�, 01413 na sa s�hityam apek�ate, k�rya� tu pratyaya-antara-apek�am 01414 iti sahitebhya eva j�yate na kevalebhya iti, tasya api 01415 katha� sa kevalo api karoty eva k�rya� ca tasm�n na utpadyate 01416 iti tad-avastho virodha�. na kevala� karoty eva iti cet, katham 01417 id�n�m ak�epa-kriy�-svabh�va�. nanv etad eva parid�pita� 01418 bhavati karoty eva iti; k�rya� ca aya� kevalo api samartha� 01419 san param apek�am�na� katham upek�eta. param an�d�tya etad 01420 prasahya kury�t, eva� hy anena �tmana� s�marthya� dar�ita� 01421 bhavati. k�rya� param apek�ata iti tata� keval�d anutpattir 01501 ukt� bhavati, sa kevalo api samartha-svabh�va iti tata utpatti� 01502 br余e, ete ca ekatra katha� sy�t�m. tad ayam �r�y�-�alya-vitudyam�na- 01503 marm� viklava� vikro�ati ity upek咸m arhati. 01504 tasm�d idam eka-arthakriy�-lak�a�a� sahak�ritva� k�a�ik�n盛 01505 eva bh�v�n�m, na tv ak�a�ik�n盛 p�thagbh�va-sambhav�n�m, 01506 p�thak-kriy�-sambhavena sahak�ritva-niyama-ayog�t. 01507 yatra tu sant�na-upak�re�a bh�v� hetut盛 pratipadyante 01508 yath� ta出ula-b�ja-�dibhya odana-a�kura-�di-janmani dahana-udaka- 01509 p�thivy-�daya�, tatra sant�na-成raye�a vi�e�a-utp�dana� pratyay�n盛 01510 sahakriy� ucyate, na dravya-成raye�a, k�a�ike dravye vi�e�a- 01511 anutpatte�; na hi ta出ula-�d�n盛 dahana-�dau krame�a svabh�va- 01512 ati�aya-anutpatt�v odana-�di-siddhi� prabh�svar�d v� apavaraka- 01513 pravi亢a-indriyasya sva-upak�ribhya� sant�na-vi�e�a-anutpatt�v artha- 01514 pratipatti-janma. 01515 ak�epa-k�ri�u tv indriya-�di�u na vi�e�a-utpatti� parasparata�. 01516 tatra yath�sva� pratyayai� paraspara-upasarpa�a-�dy-成rayair ye 01517 yogya-de�a-�dy-avasth� j�t筬, te saha svabh�va-ni�patty� jㅰna- 01518 hetut盛 pratipadyanta iti tatra eka-arthakriy� eva sahak�ritvam. 01519 yatra vi�e�a-utp�danena sahak�ri�a� pratyay�s tatra hetu- 01520 sant�na� pratyay�n apek�ata iti tata� svabh�va-antara-pratilambha- 01521 ucyate. tatra sva-rasato hetu-pratyay�n盛 p�rva-k�a�a-niv�ttau 01522 tebhya eva vi�i亢a-k�a�a-utp�d�t krame�a y�vad ati�ayavato 01523 antya-k�ra�a-kal�p�t k�ryasya utpatti�. 01601 sahak�ri�a� samutpanna-vi�e咸t k�ra鎚t k�rya-utpattau vi�e�asya 01602 eva utpattir na yukt�. avi�i亢�d vi�e�a-utpattau k�ryasya api 01603 sy�t; paraspara-vi�e�a-utp�d�n apek�i�o api sahak�ri�a� k�rya� 01604 kurv�ran. tena ak�a�ik�n�m api sahak�ry-anapek咸鎚� k�ra�at� 01605 sy�t, apek�a鰍yebhya� svabh�va-ati�aya-utpatti� ca na sy�t. atha 01606 sahak�ri鎚 k�ta-vi�e�a eva vi�e�a-utp�d�v apy upati亢heta; evam 01607 anavasth� sy�t. na ca sahak�ri�a� paraspara-k�rya-utp�da-anugu�a 01608 vi�e�a-utp�dane nitya� yogya-avasth� yena e咸� paraspara- 01609 k�ta-vi�e�o nitya-anu�akta� sy�t, tad-up�ya-ap�yayo� k�rya-vyakti- 01610 viraha-dar�an�t. tena �dyo vi�e�a� sahak�ribhyo nirupak�rasya 01611 na utpadyata iti cet, na asm�ka� puna� punar vacane ka�cid 01612 udvego bhavati; yady evam api lokasya ny�ya-prat�tir bhavati, 01613 hanta tarhy ucyat�m. na vi�e�a-utp�dan�d eva sahak�ri鎚� 01614 sahak�ritv盛 yatas tad-abh�v�d vi�e�a-janane sahak�ri�o na 01615 syu�. ki� tarhi. eka-arthakriy�y� api. sa api bhavet parasparato 01616 vi�e�a-rahit�n�m. atha bhavet, p�thag api bhavet; tath� ca tad 01617 vi�e�a-bh�vi k�ryam api keval�d bhavet iti cet, pratik�a�am 01618 apar�parai� pratyayair yath� bh�va-sant�ne vi�e�a-utpattir yogya- 01619 de�at�-�dy-avasth�-vi�e咸鎚� ca k�rya-kara�a� te咸� ca yata 01620 utpatti� pratyeka� ca s�marthye api yath� keval�n�m akriy�- 01701 kart�-vi�e�asya p�thagbh�va-abh�v�t k�rya-dvaividhya� ca sahak�ri- 01702 sa쨓anita-vi�e�a-para�para-utpatti-dharmakam anyac ca a�kura-�di- 01703 vad ak�epa-k�ri-indriya-vijㅰna-vac ca k�rya-k�ra�ayo� svabh�va- 01704 bhed�d iti sarvam uktam. tatra sahak�ribhya� sant�na-upak�ra- 01705 apek�a-k�rya-k�ra�a-janmani sahak�ri鎚m �dyo vi�e�a� sahak�ri- 01706 k�ta-vi�e�a-janm� na bhavati anantara-k�rya-vat, tat-prabh�ti ye 01707 vi�e咸s te taj-janm�na�, tasya te咸� ca tat-prak�titv�d iti 01708 na anavasth�. tath� yady ak�a�iko api bh�va �dya-vi�e�a-k�ra�a-vad 01709 ajanita-ati�aya� k�rya� kury�t, karotu n�ma; so asya svabh�vo 01710 yady ak�epa-kart�-dharm�, p�thagbh�vasya sambhav�t kevalo 01711 api tath� sy�d ity uktam atat-svabh�vas tu tad� apy ak�raka eva. 01712 tasm�d ak�a�ik�n盛 k�ra鎚n盛 na eka-arthakriyay� ka�cit 01713 sahak�ritva-niyamo na api sant�na-upak�re�a iti na tasya ka�cit sahak�r�; 01714 tasm�t kevalo api kury�t. pr�yas tu sa�gh�ta-sth�y� bh�va- 01715 sant�na� sahak�ri-pratyayair upajanita-vi�e�a� sva-k�rya� kurvan 01716 d敖�a�, b�ja-�di-vat. sthirahetuv�dino pratyaya-apek咸y盛 k�rakasya 01717 svabh�va-antarasya utpattir iti vyaktam; k�ryasya apek咸 ity 01718 ucyate. k�rakasya svabh�vasya pr�g api bh�vo akriy� na yujyate. 01801 tasm�d yo yad-�tm� sa satt�-m�tre�a t�d惡o bhavati; 01802 na bh�tv� tad-bh�ve para-abhisa�sk�ram apek�ate. svabh�vato 01803 asthiti-dharma�o bh�vasya na ki�cin n成a-k�ra�ai�; sthiti-dharma�o 01804 api bh�vasya n成a-k�ra�ai� kim, svabh�vasya kenacid anyath� 01805 kartum a�akyatv�t. anyath�tva-pratipattau v� tat-svabh�va eva 01806 na sy�d iti p�rva eva vikalpa�, tatra ca uktam. ya� ca parasm�d 01807 anyath�bh�va� so apara� svabh�va� ya� ca apara� sa katha� 01808 tasya, svabh�va-bheda-lak�a�atv�d bh�va-bhedasya. tath� ca p�rvako 01809 bh�vo acyuti-dharme sthita iti na tasya anyath�bh�va�. 01810 etena ka�hina-�d�n盛 t�mra-�d�n�m agny-�dibhyo drava-�di- 01811 svabh�va-antara-utpatti� pratyukt�. tatra api p�rvakasya sva-rasa-nirodhitv�d 01812 vin成e agny-�der up�d�n�c ca apara eva drava-�di-svabh�va- 01813 utpanna�. 01814 sa svaya� sthiti-dharm� eva, vin成a-hetv-asambhave avasth�n�t. 01815 tasya parasm�d vin成a�, na ca vin成o n�ma apara� svabh�va�, 01816 bh�va-cyutir eva vin成a iti cet, na idam uttara� vikalpa- 01817 dvayam atikr�mati. ki� nityo bh�va� svabh�vena �hosvid anityo iti 01818 vikalpe pr涉 nityo bh�tv� pa�c�d anityo bhavati iti bruv性a� 01819 pr�ktanasya nitya-abhimatasya sarvad� nitya-anitya-svabh�va-bheda� 01820 bh�va-dvaya� ca svaya� ca n成am an成a� ca pr�ha iti 01821 p�rvasmin vin成a-hetur asamartha�. na pr涉 nityo bh�tv� pa�c�d 01822 anityo bhavati. ki� tarhi. pa�c�d api nityo eva, eka-svabh�vatv�t. 01823 sa tarhi bh�va� svabh�vena n成am an�vi�an katha� na亢o 01901 n�ma, tat-svabh�va-vin成ayor aparaspara-r�patv�t. 01902 tasm�t saty asya vin成e vin成a-svabh�vena anena bhavitavyam. 01903 tath� api vyartho vin成a-hetur ity uktam. tena svabh�vato 01904 na�vare ana�vare v� bh�ve na vin成a-hetor upayoga�. 01905 tasm�d vin成e anapek�o bh�vas tad-bh�va-niyata iti ya� 01906 san sa vin成�, n成varat�y� niv�ttau ca sattva-niv�ttir ity 01907 anvaya-vyatireka-siddhi�. 01908 svabh�vato na�varatve api ka�cid atat-svabh�vo api sy�t, na 01909 hi sarva� sarvasya svabh�va iti na anvaya-vyatireka-siddhir iti cet, 01910 na, ak�a�ikatve avastutva-prasa�g�t. �aktir hi bh�va-lak�a�am, 01911 sarva-�akti-viraho abh�va-lak�a�am. na ca ak�a�ya kvacit k�cic 01912 �akti�, kramayaugapady�bhy�m arthakriy�-virah�t. tasm�d yat 01913 sat tat k�a�ikam eva iti vy�pti-siddhi�. 01914 arth�ntare gamye k�rye k�rya� hetu�, avyabhic�r�t. 01915 k�ryak�ra�abh�vena yadi li�gasya gamakatvam, sarvath� 01916 gamyagamakabh�va�. sarvath� janyajanakabh�v�d iti cet, 01917 na, tad-abh�ve bhavata� tadupatti-niyama-abh�v�t. tasm�t 01918 k�rya� svabh�vair y�vadbhir avin�bh�vi k�ra�e, te咸� 01919 hetu�, tat-k�ryatva-niyam�t, tair eva ca dharmair ye tair 01920 vin� na bhavanti. a嚆ena janyajanakatva-prasa�ga iti cet, na, 01921 taj-janya-vi�e�a-graha�e abhimatatv�l li�ga-vi�e�a-up�dh�n盛 ca s�m�ny�n�m. 02001 avi�i亢a-s�m�nya-vivak咸y盛 vyabhic�r�n na i�yate. 02002 kasyacit kad�cit kuta�cit bh�ve api sarvas t�d惡as tath�vidha- 02003 janm� iti kuto avasitam. tath� ca na anvaya-vyatirek�v iti cet, 02004 na, atad-bh�vinas tasya sak�d api tato abh�v�t. paraspara-apek�ay� 02005 janya-janaka-svabh�va-lak�a�e k�rya-k�ra�e. tatra yadi 02006 dh�mo agny-�di-s�magry� anyato api bhavet, tasya taj-janya� 02007 svabh�vo na bhavati iti sak�d api tato na bhaved arth�ntara-vat, 02008 na api s�magr� ta� janayet, ataj-janana-svabh�vatv�t s�magry-antara- 02009 vat. na ca dh�masya tad-ataj-janya-svabh�vo yukta�, 02010 eka-svabh�vatv�t. dh�ma-adh�ma-janana-svabh�v�d bhavato dh�ma- 02011 adh�ma-svabh�va� sy�t, k�rya-svabh�v�n盛 k�ra�a-svabh�va-k�tatv�d 02012 ak�ra�a-apek�a�e ca ahetutva-prasa�g�t. tasm�d yo 02013 dh�ma-janana�, so agny-�di-s�magr�-vi�e�a� yo agny-�dy-s�magr�- 02014 vi�e�a-janita� so dh�ma iti k�rya-k�ra�ayor eva� svabh�va-niyam�t 02015 tad vij�t�y�d utpattir na bhavati. tat k�rya� k�ra�a� 02016 na vyabhicarati. tena siddhe k�ryak�ra�abh�ve k�ryasya 02017 k�ra�ena vy�pti� siddh� bhavati. 02018 nanu vij�t�y�d api ki�cid bhavad d敖�am, tad yath� 02019 gomaya-�de� 妬l�ka-�di�. na vij�t�y�d utpatti�. tath�vidham 02020 eva hi t�d惡�m �di-nimittam iti na k�ra�a-bheda�. prabandhena 02101 v�ttau tu �ar�d bhavati. asti ca gomaya-itara-janman-svabh�va- 02102 bhedo r�pasya abhede api, na hy �k�ra-tulyat� eva bh�v�n盛 02103 tattve nimittam, abhinna-�k�r性�m api ke咸�cid anyato vi�e咸j 02104 j�ti-bheda-dar�an�t. anyath� hi vilak�a鎚y� api s�magry� 02105 avilak�a�a-k�rya-utpattau ca k�ra�a-bheda-abhed�bhy盛 k�rya-bheda- 02106 abhed�v ity ahetukau vi�vasya bheda-abhedau sy�t�m. tath� 02107 hi na bhed�d bheda ity abhed�d api na abheda�, tad-vyatirikta� 02108 ca na ka�cid bh�va-svabh�va ity ahetukatv�d bh�v�n盛 nitya� 02109 sattvam asattva� v� sy�t, apek�yasya abh�v�t. apek�ay� hi 02110 bh�v筬 k�d�citk� bhavanti vyavasth�v盛� ca s�dhye�u 02111 s�dhana-niyogo na sy�t. k�ra�a-�akti-pratiniyame hi ki�cid eva 02112 kasyacit s�dhan�ya up�d�yeta, na aparam, tasya eva tatra �akter 02113 anyasya ca a�akte�, tayos taj-janana-itara-svabh�vatvena bhed�t. 02114 taj-janana-svabh�va-vilak�a鎚d api tasya utpattau na taj-janana- 02115 �akti-niyame iti yat-yata�-kuta�cit sy�t, taj-janana- 02116 �akti-s�mye tu tad eva iti na k�rya� d敖�a� k�ra�a� vyabhicarati. 02118 upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya anupalabdhir abh�va-hetur abh�va- 02119 vyavah�ra-hetur v�. 02120 atra upalabdher upalabham�na-dharmatve taj-jㅰnam upalabdhi�. 02121 tasm�d anya-upalabdhir anupalabdhi�, vivak�ita-upalabdher 02122 anyatv�d abhak�ya-aspar�an�ya-vat paryud�sa-v�tty�. upalabhyam�na- 02123 dharmatve sva-vi�aya-vijㅰna-janana-yogyat�-lak�a�o vi�aya- 02201 svabh�va upalabdhi�, yogyat�y� bh�va-r�patv�t. tasm�d anya-upalabdhi- 02202 yogyat� eva anupalabdhi� p�rvavat. yatra yasminn upalabhyam�ne 02203 niyamena yasya upalabdhir bhavati yogyat�y� avi�e咸t, 02204 sa tat-sa�s敖�a�, eka-jㅰna-sa�sarg�t. tayo� sator na eka-r�pa- 02205 niyat� pratipatti�, asambhav�t. tasm�d avi�i亢a-yogyat�-r�payor 02206 eka-jㅰna-sa�sargi�o� paraspara-apek�am eva anyatvam iha abhipretam, 02207 praty�satter 成raya鎚t. sa kevala� tad-apek�ay� 02208 tad-anya iti taj-jㅰna� tat-svabh�vo v� jㅰt�-j쨎ya-dharma- 02209 lak�a�a-anupalabdhi�. s� abh�va� pratiyogino abh�va-vyavah�ra� 02210 v� s�dhayati. 02211 katham anyabh�vas tad-abh�va�, yena abh�va-r�pa-anupalabdhir 02212 abh�va-vyavah�ra� s�dhayed iti cet, uktam atra yath� paryud�sa- 02213 v�tty� apek咸to abh�vo anupalabdhi� ca anupalabdhi�. na prati�edha- 02214 m�tram, tasya s�dhana-asiddher abh�va-vyavah�ra-asiddhi- 02215 prasa�g�t. tasya asa�s敖�a-r�pasya bh�va-siddhir eva aparasya abh�va- 02216 siddhir ity anyabh�vo api tad-abh�va iti vyapade�yate. 02217 anyabh�va-lak�a�o bh�va� svaya� pram性a-siddhas tad-abh�va- 02218 vyavah�ra� s�dhayet tat-siddhi-siddho v� tad-abh�va iti 02219 na ka�cid vi�e�a�, yena anupalabdhy� abh�va-vyavah�ra-siddher virodha� 02301 sy�t. sa eva anyabh�vas tad-vi�ay� ca upalabdhis tad-abh�vasya 02302 ki� na s�dhanam, ki� punar anyabh�vasya siddhir eva 02303 tad-abh�va-siddhir iti cet, ap�thak-siddhi� sambandha-abh�v�c ca. 02304 anyabh�vas t�van na s�dhanam. 02305 yat-siddhau yasya na siddhi�, tat tasya li�ga� bhavati, dh�ma- 02306 agni-vat. anyabh�va-siddhy� eva tad-abh�va� prasidhyati, tasya 02307 tad-anya-asa�s敖�a-r�pasya tattva-vyavasth�pakena pram性ena eva anya- 02308 vyavaccheda-siddhe�. 02309 sambandha-abh�v�c ca. tac ca tasya li�ga� yadi sy�t, tasya 02310 tena ka�cit sambandho bhavet, yath� k�takatva-anityatvayor eka-artha- 02311 samav�yo dh�masya li�gina� ca eka-artha-samav�yo v� �dh�r�dheyabh�vo 02312 v� janyajanakabh�vo v�. na eva� ka�cid bh�va-abh�vayo� 02313 sambandha�, yena asya s�dhana� sy�t. 02314 asti vi�ayavi�ayibh�va� �abda-artha-sambandha-vad iti cet, �abda- 02315 arthayos tat-pratip�dana-abhipr�ye sati tat-prayog�t tena saha 02316 k�rya-k�ra�a-lak�a�o avin�bh�va-lak�a�o v� sambandha� sy�t. 02317 aya� ca atra na sambhavati iti katha� vi�ayavi�ayibh�va� sy�t. 02318 siddhe hi tayo� s�dhyas�dhanabh�ve tan-mukhena vi�ayavi�ayibh�va� 02319 sy�t; sa eva asati sambandhe na sidhyati; tad-asiddhau 02320 vi�ayavi�ayibh�vo api na. anyath� itaretara-成rayam ida� sy�t. 02321 anyabh�v�c ca abh�va-siddh�v asamud�ya� ca s�dhya� 02322 sy�t. tath� ca gha�a-abh�vas tad-anyabh�v�d iti gha�asya sarvatra 02323 sarvad� ca abh�va� sy�t. na, prade�a-�di-dharmy-abh�va-s�dhan�d iti 02401 cet; prade�a-�di-dharmi-vi�e�a�a-bh�to abh�va� s�dhyate, na tu 02402 kevala�; tato na asamud�yasya s�dhyat�. na ca li�ga-li�ginor 02403 asambandho anyabh�vasya prade�a-�din� dharmi鎚 sambandh�d 02404 iti manyate. na, prade�a-�der eva anyabh�vatv�t. yatra eva hi 02405 prade�e yan na asti ity ucyate sa eva tena asa�s敖�o anyabh�va�. 02406 tad-dar�an�d eva asya gha�o na asti iti vikalpa iti katha� tasya eva 02407 li�gali�gibh�va�. 02408 na ca atra s�m�nya-vi�e�a-bh�va-kalpan� sambhavati, yena 02409 s�m�nya� hetur bhavet vi�e�o dharm� iti, tad-vi�e�a-pratipatter eva 02410 tad-abh�vasya prat�tes tasya ca anyatra anya-abh�v�t. pratijㅰrthaikade�atv�c 02411 ca na hetutvam. na ca yatra prade�a-m�tra� 02412 tatra gha�a-abh�va�. t�d惡e kevale prade�e abh�va eva iti cet, 02413 nanu tasya eva kevala iti gha�a-viraha iti. sa ca li�gabh�ta- 02414 prade�a-pratipatt�v eva siddha�. kasya id�n尋 tal li�gam. anvayasya 02415 anugamana� ca nirarthakam. tasm�d anyabh�vo na s�dhanam 02416 abh�vasya. 02417 asti virodha� sambandha�, tato anyabh�v�d abh�vasya 02418 siddhir iti cet, kena kasya virodha�. anyabh�vena pratiyogina�. 02419 ki� nu vai pratiyog� pram�tum i亢o, yena li�ga-li�ginor virodha� 02420 sambandha� sy�t. abh�vas tu pratiyogino gha�asya anyabh�vena aviruddha�, 02421 saha-avasth�n�t. tasmin prameye li�ga-li�gino� katha� 02422 virodha�. tasm�t sambandha-abh�va�. atra apy asamud�ya-s�dhyatva� 02423 tad-avastham. 02424 nanv anyabh�va-tadbh�vayor asati sambandhe anyabh�va- 02425 gaty� api tad-abh�va-gatir na sy�d iti cet, na vai kuta�cit sambandh�d 02501 anyabh�vas tad-abh�va-gamaka i亢a�, ki� tv anyabh�va- 02502 eva tad-abh�va�, yathokta� pr�k. tasya anya-asa�s敖�a-r�pasya kevalasya 02503 ek�tma-vyavasthitasya tad�tman� paricchedasya eva anya-vyavacchedatv�t 02504 tasya kaivalyam aparasya vaikalyam iti tad-anyabh�va 02505 eva tad-abh�va�, tad-anya-pratipattir eva ca tad-apratipattir 02506 iti. anyath� tasya paricchedena tato anyasya avyavacchede 02507 tat-pariccheda eva na sy�t, tad-atadr�payor avivek�t. ya e�a 02508 vyavah�ra� kasyacid dar�an�t kvacit pr�pti-parih�ra-artha�, sa 02509 na sy�t. na hy ayam anala� pa�yann api kevalam analam 02510 eva pa�yati, yena salila-arth� na pravarteta. 02511 anupalambhena salila-abh�va� prat�yata iti cet, ko ayam anupalambho 02512 n�ma. yadi salila-upalambha-abh�va iti, katha� so abh�va� 02513 kasyacit pratipatti� pratipatti-hetur v�; tasya api katha� 02514 pratipatti�. tasya tato v� anyasya kasyacid apy apratipatt�v 02515 apy abh�va-pratipattau saty盛 sv�pa-mada-m�rch�-vyavadh�na- 02516 p敖�h�bhava-�dy-avasth�sv apy abh�va� ki� na prat�yate. bh�yo api 02517 vic�rita� pram性avini�caye. tasm�d ayam anala� pa�yann apy 02518 analo aya� na salilam ity anadhyavasyan na ti亢hen na api 02519 prati亢heta iti dustara� vyasana� pratipanna� sy�t. 02520 tata eva ekasya dar�an�d anya-abh�va-gatir bhavati iti cet, 02521 katham eka� d敖�am anyan na asti iti praty�yayati. kevalasya 02601 dar�an�d iti cet, idam eva asm�bhir abhihitam, kasm�t tava atra 02602 paru�am iva �bh�ti. tasm�t t�ra-adar�in� eva �akunin� parya焌 02603 api praty�gantavyam ity alam avidyam�na-prati亢h�nay� di�a� 02604 pratipatty�. 02605 yady eka-paricched�d eva anya-vyavaccheda� sidhyati, sarvasya 02606 anyasya avi�e�e�a tatra abh�va-siddhir bhavet, na tulya-yogya-avasthasya 02607 eva; upalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�ptasya anupalabdhir abh�va-s�dhan� 02608 iti vi�e�a�a� ca na vaktavyam, anupalabdhi-lak�a�a-pr�pt�n�m 02609 api tatra vyavacched�t. ek�tma-paricched�t tad-anya-�tma- 02610 vyavaccheda�, tad-�tma-niyata-pratibh�sa-jㅰn�t na hi tad�tm� 02611 tad-anyasya �tm� bhavati. anya-�tmano avyavacchede prav�tti- 02612 niv�ttyor abh�va iti p�rva� prasa�ga�. ta� ca de�a-k�la-svabh�va- 02613 avasth�-niyata� tad�tman� upalambham�n� buddhis tath�tva- 02614 pracyutim asya vyavacchinatti. eva� hi sa tay� paricchinno 02615 yady anyath�bh�vo vyavacchinno bhavati tath�tva� ca 02616 tasya eva bhavati na anyasya ity anyath�bh�t�d vyavacchindaty 02617 eva tat paricchinatti. evam ekasya pram性asya v�tti� sarva- 02618 bh�v�n dvair成ye vyavasth�payati, tasya anvaya-vyatireka-buddhi- 02619 hetutvena eva s�phaly�t. 02620 tad-vyatiriktasya a�e�asya vyavacchedena vy�pti-s�dhan�d eva 02621 prak�ra-antara-abh�va� sidhyati, tasya tad-anyatay� vy�pty-abh�ve 02622 tena tad-artha-avyavacched�t punar bh�vasya apariccheda-prasa�g�t. 02623 tasm�t kvacit pram性a� prav�tta� tat paricchinatti 02624 tad-anyad vyavacchinatti t�t�ya-prak�ra-antara-abh�va� ca 02701 s�cayati iti eka-pram性a-vy�p�ra e�a�. tath� hi kvacit pram性a� 02702 prav�tta� tad eva tad-anyasm�d vyavacchinatti, 02703 tasya eva paricched�t, tad-anyad eva ca tasm�d vyavacchinatti, 02704 tatra aparicched�t. atas tad eva pram性a� prak�ra-antara-abh�va� 02705 s�dhayati, tasmin d惡yam�ne ad敖�asya tad-anyatvena sarvasya 02706 vyavasth�pan�d atad-anyasya eva ca tattvena vyavasth�pan�t. 02707 etena krama-akrama-�dayo apy anyonya-vyavaccheda-r�p� vy�khy�t筬. 02709 tad eva� ekasya upalambh�t tasya tad-anya-�tmano vyavaccheda�, 02710 na tad-de�a-k�layo� sarvasya anyasya bh�vasya vyavaccheda�. 02711 tasm�d atad�tm� ca sy�t tad-de�a-k�la� ca, rasa-r�pa-�di- 02712 vat. tasm�d yathokt�d eva anupalambh�t kvacit kad�cit 02713 kasyacid abh�va-siddhi�. 02714 anyabh�va-vi�aya-upalabdhir api tad-abh�vasya s�dhik� i亢� eva, 02715 na tu li�gatvena, tatra apy abh�vasya p�thak s�dhyatve 02716 sambandha-abh�vasya tulyatv�t. li�ga-�virbh�va-k�la eva tad-abh�va- 02717 siddhe�. na hy anyabh�va� pratipadya tat-pratipatter anvaya- 02718 vyatirekau pras�dhya tad-abh�va� pratipadyate. ki� tarhi. 02719 tad-anya� pratipadyam�na eva tad-abh�va� pratipadyate, 02720 dar�ana-anantara� vyavadh�nena vin� idam asti ida� tu na asti iti 02721 vyavasth�pan�t, d敖焌nta-asiddhe�. tac ca tasya li�ga� yad 02722 yasya anvayi vyatireki ca. na hy eva� �akya� dar�ayitu� yatra anya- 02723 bh�va-upalabdhis tatra tad-abh�va iti, tad-eka-upalabdhe� kvacid apy 02724 abh�v�t. s�m�nyena pradar�ane d敖焌nte api pram性a-antara-abh�v�t 02725 s� eva tad-anyabh�va-upalabdhi� s�dhya-dharmasya s�dhik� iti 02726 d敖焌nta-anavasthitv�d apratipatti�. 02801 tasm�n na kuta�cil li�g�d abh�va-siddhi�. so anyabh�va� 02802 pratyak�a-lak�a�ena anupalambhena siddho m掩ha-pratipatt�v 02803 abh�va-vyavah�ra� s�dhayed ity ala� prasa�gena. 02804 s� iya� tridh� anupalabdhi�. siddhe k�ryak�ra�abh�ve 02805 bh�vasya k�ra�asya anupalabdhir vy�pyavy�pakabh�va-siddhau 02806 siddha-abh�vasya vy�pakasya anupalabdhi� svabh�va-anupalabdhi� ca. 02807 tatra k�ra�a-vy�pakayor api svabh�vasya asad-vyavah�ra-siddhir 02808 anyabh�va-siddher eva. sa tatra asiddha� k�rya-vy�pyayor abh�vam 02809 abh�va-vyavah�ra� v� s�dhayati. svabh�va-anupalabdhau tv anupalabdhy� 02810 li�gabh�tay� abh�va-vyavah�ra eva s�dhyate. 02811 yadi k�ra�a-vy�pakau tad-anyabh�va-siddhi-r�pay� anupalabdhy� 02812 siddha-asad-vyavah�r�v anyasya abh�vam abh�va-vyavah�ra� 02813 ca s�dhayata� s� ca anupalabdhis tayor upalabdhi-lak�a�a- 02814 pr�pt�v eva asad-vyavah�rasya s�dhik�, katha� tayo� parok�e 02815 arthe prayoga�. na eva prayoga� pram性atay�, li�gasya ani�cay�t. 02816 kevala� k�ra�a-vy�pakayo� siddha-sambandhayor yady abh�va� 02817 parasya ava�yam abh�va-ni�caya iti dar�ana-artham ete prayujyete. 02818 ity e�a pak�a-dharmo anvaya-vyatirekav�n iti tad-a嚆ena 02819 vy�ptas tri-lak�a�as trir�pa eva hetur gamaka�, sva-s�dhya- 02820 dharma-avyabhic�r�t. 02821 �a�-lak�a�o hetur ity apare. tr辰i ca et�ny ab�dhita-vi�ayatvam 02901 vivak�ita-eka-sa�khyatva� jㅰtatva� ca iti. 02902 tatra ab�dhita-vi�ayatva� t�vat p�thag lak�a�a� na bhavati, 02903 b�dha-avin�bh�vayor virodh�t. avin�bh�vo hi saty eva s�dhya- 02904 dharme bh�vo heto�. sa hetus tal-lak�a�o dharmi�i sy�t, atra 02905 ca s�dhya-dharma� katha� na bhavet. pratyak�a-anum�ne hi 02906 s�dhya-dharma� b�dham�ne ta� dharmi�o ni�k�sayata�, 02907 tasmin saty eva hetur bhava�s ta� tatra eva dharmi�y avasth�payati 02908 iti para� bata bh�v�n�m asv�sthyam. anyatra 02909 s�dhya-dharme�a avin�bh�v� hetur na dharmi�y eva iti cet, tat 02910 kim aya� tapasv� �a出ham udv�hya putra� m�gyate. yasya 02911 dharmi�y asaty api s�dhya-dharme bh�vas tam upadar�ya 02912 katha� sa dharm� s�dhya-dharmav�n ity ucyate. ata eva b�dh� 02913 bh�va ukta�; sy�d etat: yata eva hetur anyath� api bhavet, ata 02914 eva pram性�bhy�m ab�dhita-dharm� dharm� ity ucyate iti tat 02915 kim id�n尋 heto� s�marthyam ab�dhay� eva s�dhya-siddhe�. 02916 yadi s�dhya-abh�vo b�dhaka-pram性a-v�ttau niyata�. ab�dh�y盛 02917 s�dhya-siddhir iti vyartho hetu�; b�dh�y�m api, s�dhana-s�marthya 02918 abh�v�t. aniyame na ca b�dhaka� pram性a� sy�t s�dhya-abh�vasya 02919 ca sambhava iti na s�marthyam ab�dh�y筬. 02920 na b�dh�y� abh�vo ab�dh�. ki� tarhi. b�dh�y� anupalabdhi�. 02921 s� ca puru�asya kvacid b�dha-asambhave api sy�d iti sa 02922 hetu-prayogasya vi�aya�. ki� nu vai hetur b�dha-upalabdher api 02923 bibheti, na punar b�dh�y筬, yena b�dh�m an�d�tya apy anupalabdhau 02924 prayoktavya i亢a�. sa tarhi hetu� param�rthena 03001 b�dh� kim asti na asti ity anapek�ya b�dh�-anupalabdhau prayoktavya� 03002 kim artha� prayujyate. s�dhya-siddhy-artham. sa ki� 03003 kvacit saty�m api b�dh�y盛 s�dhya� s�dhayet, yena asy� abh�va 03004 ni�caya� prati yatno na kriyate hetu� ca prayujyate. tath� 03005 ca ab�dhita-vi�ayatva� hetu-lak�a�a� na bhavati, b�dh�y�m 03006 api saty�m asya s�marthy�t; tath� ca anabhyupagamye sa嚆ayitasya 03007 prav�tty-ayog�d yath� anupalabdhau b�dh�-sadbh�va-sambhave 03008 apy abhyupagamya prayujyate, tath� b�dha-upalabdh�v api 03009 prayujyat�m, abhyupagame vi�e�a-abh�v�t. 03010 na b�dh�y盛 saty盛 s�marthyam iti cet, yady eva� 03011 prayuktasya apy as�marthya-pr�ptir ity anir鰍ta-b�dh�-sambhava� 03012 prayoga� na arhati. b�dh�-anupalambhe s�marthyam iti cet, kim 03013 upalambho b�dh盛 vy�pnoti, yata eva� hetor b�dh�-sambhava- 03014 k�tam as�marthya� na sambhavet. atha tan-niv�ttau b�dh� 03015 nivartate, tath� api b�dh�-anupalambh�d eva s�dhya-siddher vyartho 03016 hetu�, anupalambhe b�dh�y� asambhav�t. upalambhasya niv�tt�v 03017 api b�dh�y� aniv�ttau tad-avastha� hetor as�marthyam 03018 ity aprayoga�. tasm�t sva-s�dhya-bh�va-abh�v�bhy�m anyath� api 03019 bhavan hetur dharmi�i ki�cin na bh�vayati na vibh�vayati ity 03020 upak�epo na samartha�. tan na b�dh�-avin�bh�vau sah�vasthitau; 03021 tena ab�dh� r�pa-antara� na bhavati. 03022 tan n�ma tasm�d vi�e�a�a-antara� lak�a�a-antara-up�d�na-artha� 03023 v� bhavet, yasya bh�ve api yasya anyasya abh�va�. tad yath� 03024 pak�adharmatva� sapak�e ca bh�va iti. na ca etad b�dh�y� avin�bh�ve 03101 sati sambhavati iti na s�dhya-viparyaya-avibh�vinor hetu-viruddhayor 03102 vi�aye b�dh� sambhavati iti na tad-abh�va� p�thag 03103 anayor lak�a�a-antaratvena v�cya�. tasm�d heto� prayoge 03104 pratijㅰy� do咸鎚� sambhavo na asti. na api keval� pratijㅰ 03105 prayujyata iti na pratijㅰ-do咸 v�cy筬. 03106 etena eka-sa�khy�-vivak咸 api pratyukt�. katham. eko hi sva- 03107 s�dhya-bh�va eva bh�v�t tad-avyabhic�r�. tatra eva tasm�d anyas 03108 tad-b�dhakasya eva bh�v�t tad-viruddha ity atra b�dhay� 03109 sam�nam. 03110 api ca ki� vastuto asambhavat-pratihetu� sa samyag-jㅰna- 03111 viparyaya-hetur �hosvid apradar�ita-pratihetu� ki� ca ata�. 03112 yady asambhavat-pratihetu�, a�akya-ni�cayatv�d alak�a�am 03113 etat. hetv-abh�vo v�. na hy ani�cita-�tmana� pratip�daka-dharmasya 03114 tal-lak�a�atva� bhavati yath� sandigdha-pak�adharmatvasya, 03115 na api sandigdha-lak�a�o hetur bhavati iti na ka�cid hetur 03116 bhavet. tulya-lak�a�e hi d敖�a� pratiyogi-sambhavo ad敖�a- 03117 pratiyogi�v api �a�k�m utp�dayati, vi�e�a-abh�v�t; sati v� 03118 vi�e�e hetor lak�a�am; tato hi hetur ek�ntena nirasta-pratipak�a� 03119 sva-s�dhya� ni�c�yayati ity atal-lak�a�o na hetu� sy�t. tath� ca 03120 vyartha-eka-sa�khy�-vivak咸. ato viruddh�vyabhic�ri�o lak�a�a� 03121 h�yeta svalak�a�a-yuktayor hetvor ekatra dharmi�i virodhena upanip�te 03122 viruddh�vyabhic�r� iti. na ca tasya vi�e�asya svar�pa� 03123 nirdi�yate, yat prat�tya pratiyogina� sambhava-asambhav�v 03124 utpa�y�ma�. tasm�n na asty eva vi�e�a iti sarvatra �a�kay� 03201 bhavitavyam; d敖�a-pratihetor api heto� pr�g itare�a na ka�cid 03202 vi�e�o lak�yate. na ca sambhavat-pratihet�n�m api sarvad� 03203 tasya upalabdhi�; ati�ayavat� tu prajㅰ-utprek�i鰍 d敖焌. tena ani�caya� 03204 sambhava-asambhavayor iti lak�a�asya ani�citatv�n na 03205 ka�cid hetu� sy�t. 03206 atha apradar�ita-pratihetu�, yath� �ha: yad� tarhi �abdatva� 03207 nityam abhyupagacchati, tad� aya� hetur eva sy�t, yady atra anityatva 03208 hetu� k�takatva-�di ka�cin na dar�ayed iti. idam aprak成yam 03209 apy asa�vara鰍yam api iti ka亢hatara� vyasanam �y�ta� 03210 katha� nirvo�hu� �akyeta. sa t�vad aya� hetur vast�ni 03211 sva-s�dhya-tattva-prak�t�ni k�tv� tat-pram性ak�n puru咸n abhyudaya 03212 ni��reyas�bhy盛 sa�yojayitv� puna� pratibh�vat� 03213 puru�e�a hetv-antara-nidar�anena utk�lita-s�dhana-s�marthyas t�ni 03214 vast�ni t盛� ca puru咸n tadbh�va-sampada� pracy�vya- 03215 bhra亢a-r�jya iva r�j� tapovana� gacchati iti ki� atra br�ma�. 03216 puru�a-pratibh�k�ta� ca s�dhanatvam. tat ki� vastuta� 03217 s�dhanam as�dhana� v�. sa ca hetu� svabh�vatas tad-dharma-bh�v� 03218 yadi katham anyath� kriyeta, vast�n盛 svabh�va-anyath�bh�vasya 03219 ubhayo� ca viruddha-svabh�vayor abh�v�t. atad-dharma-bh�v� 03220 ca katham anyad� api s�dhana� kasyacit. 03221 tasm�t svabh�vata� sva-s�dhya-avin�bh�vinor ukta-lak�a�ayo� 03222 k�rya-svabh�vayos tal-lak�a�asya pratihetor asambhav�d alak�a�am 03301 eka-sa�khy�-vivak咸, vyavacchedya-abh�v�t. 03302 jㅰna� punar ali�ga-dharmatve katha� li�ga-lak�a�a� 03303 bhavi�yati. ki�-r�p�l li�g�d artho jㅰtavya iti cint�y盛 pratipattur 03304 avisa�v�dakasya r�pam abhidh�yate, yasya dar�an�d 03305 aya� s�dhana-as�dhane pravibhajya tasya i亢a-artha-sa�nidh�na 03306 pratyay�t prav�ttim avalambate. tath� yad asya �tma-r�pa� tal 03307 lak�a�am, na tu parar�pam. pratipatti-janmany upayoga-m�tr�t 03308 tal-lak�a�atve atiprasa�ga�. eva� prameya-puru�a-�d�n�m api 03309 tal-lak�a�atva� bhavet, na hi te�v asatsu li�gini jㅰna� bhavati. 03310 ni�cita-graha�a� tarhi na kartavyam. na na kartavyam, 03311 tasya anya-arthatv�t. sapak�a-vipak�ayor dar�ana-adar�an�bhy盛 gamaka� 03312 hetum icchat盛 na eva samartho hetur bhavati, sator api 03313 dar�ana-adar�anayor agamakatva-dar�an�t. tena bh�va-abh�v�bhy盛 03314 gamaka iti jㅰpana-artha� ni�cita-graha�am. tena parar�pa� 03315 lak�a�a� na bhavati, tena li�gasya r�pa-vi�e�a-anabhidh�n�t, tau 03316 hi bh�va-abh�vau tad-bh�va-s�dhaka-v�tty� boddhavyau, up�ya-antara- 03317 abh�v�t. tena, yady api bh�va-abh�va-vacana-m�tre�a tat-s�dhana- 03318 pram性am �k�ipyate, tayo� pratip�dan�ya ni�cita-�abda� 03319 prayukto lak�a�e, anyath� jㅰna-satt�-nibandhanatv�j j쨎ya- 03320 satt�-vyavasth�y�s tayor eva satt�-prasiddher iti sarvatra 03401 satt�-vyavasth� eva tat-s�dhana� pram性am �kar�ati. par�rthatv�c 03402 ca 妬stra-pra�ayanasya. trir�pa� li�ga� sa�v�dakam 03403 arthasya iti tad r�pa� ye na vidanti, na te咸� tata� prav�ttir iti 03404 para-upalak�a�atv�d yady api jㅰna� siddham, tath� api t�v eva 03405 bh�va-abh�vau kecid dar�ana-adar�ana-m�tre�a vyavasth�payanti iti 03406 tan-ni�edha-artho ni�cita-�abda ukta�, sator api bh�va-abh�vayor 03407 anvaya-vyatirekayo� satt�y盛 sa嚆ay�t. tasm�d yata� satt�- 03408 pras�dhaka-pram性�d anayor ni�cayas tad-adh�n� iti jㅰpana-artham 03409 asm�bhir graha�a� k�tam. 03410 yato api bh�va-abh�va-vacana-m�tre�a tat-s�dhana-pram性a-�k�epa-siddhi�, 03411 p�thag ato jㅰna� lak�a�a� na bhavati, tena eva arthasya avagatatv�d 03412 upanaya-artha-vat pak�adharmatv�t. anvaya-vyatirekayor 03413 api tarhi na p�thaktvam, ekasya prayog�d ubhaya-gater 03414 iti cet, na, heto� sapak�a-asapak�ayor bh�va-abh�vayor aparaspara- 03415 �k�ep�t; eka� v�kyam ubhaya� gamayati ity ucyate, 03416 na eko artho dvit�yasya. nanu tatra eva bh�vo tad-abh�ve 03417 ca abh�va iti v�kye paraspara-�k�epa iti cet, vacanam etad ekasya 03418 api niyama-khy�pakasya dvit�ya-�k�epa-n�ntar�yakatv�t s�marthy�d 03419 ubhayam �k�ipati na puna� kevalau bh�va-abh�v�v �k�ipata�; 03420 niyamavantau ca na kevalau, niyamasya ubhaya-r�patv�t. 03421 tasm�t tatra eva bh�va iti na bh�va eva ucyate, itare�a api na abh�va 03501 eva, yena bh�vo abh�vo v� dvit�yam �k�ipet. na eva� jㅰna� 03502 para-upalak�a鎚t trailak�a�y�d vyatirekitam iti na lak�a�a-antaram. 03503 tasm�n na hetu� �a�-lak�a�a�. 03504 hetubindur �c�rya-dharmak�rti-k�ta� sam�pta�.